The debate continues about whether people have a duty to pass on the positive results of their genetic tests to relatives who are at risk from the same disease, and, should they refuse, whether physicians and genetic counselors then have the duty to do so. To date, the role and views of nurses in this debate have not been investigated. In our study, a sample of Israeli nurses, untrained in genetics, were asked for their theoretical opinions and what practical steps they would take in the case of patients' refusal to disclose. The nurses were very sure that patients should inform their families but were equally sure that nurses must respect their decision to disclose or not. Few said they would take practical steps to disclose information if the patient objected. The authors believe that the most useful and appropriate role for nurses in this field is in working to bring about co-operation between patients and family members.
Kent A.Consent and confidentiality in genetics: whose information is it anyway ? J Med Ethics2003; 29: 16—18 .
2.
Bradley ANUtility and limitations of genetic testing and information . Nurs Standard2005; 20(5): 52—55 .
3.
Genetic Information Act, 25.12. 2000. (Official Gazette and Book of Amendments, 14a.) (in Hebrew).
4.
Engelhardt HTThe foundation of bioethics. Oxford University Press , 1996.
5.
Tabak N.Ethical dilemmas in human experimentation [Thesis]. Tel Aviv University , 1989 (in Hebrew).
6.
Yishay R.The patient's autonomy: a privilege or a responsibility . Harefuah1991; 121: 339—42 (in Hebrew).
7.
Tabak N.Informed consent form; a dream or reality ? Med Law1993; 9: 9—12 (in Hebrew).
8.
Hakimian R.Disclosure of Huntington's disease to family members: the dilemma of known but unknowing parties . Genet Test2000; 4: 359—64 .
9.
Carmi A.Health ethics in medicine . Nero Publishers, 2004 (in Hebrew).
10.
Ethical dilemmas in medicine: medical confidentiality. Introduction. n.d. Retrieved 12 December, 2006 from: http://www.daat.ac.il/daat/refua/Sodiyut1.htm (in Hebrew).
11.
Canterbury v. Spence, D.C. 464F. 2d 722 United States Court of Appeals, 1972.
12.
Tarasoff et al. v. Regents of the University of California. Supreme Court of California, 17.cal.3d 425, 551 p.2d 334, 1976.
13.
Safer v. Estate of Pack. 677 A 2d 1188 [NJ Super AD 1996] Cited in: American Society of Human Genetics. Social Issues Sub-Committee on Familial Disclosure, ASHG statement: professional disclosure of familial genetic information. Am J Hum Genet 1998; 62: 474—83.
14.
American Society of Human Genetics.Social Issues Sub-Committee on Familial Disclosure, ASHG statement: professional disclosure of familial genetic information . Am J Hum Genet1998; 62: 474—83 .
15.
Kessler S.Psychological aspects of genetic counseling. VII: Thoughts on directiveness . J Genet Counsel1992; 1: 9—18 .
16.
Mahon SMGenetic counseling and disclosure of results [Letter] . J Nurs Scholarsh2006; 38: 4—5 .
17.
Plantinga L. , Natowicz MR , Kass NE , Null SC , Gostin LQ , Faden R.Disclosure, confidentiality and families: experiences and attitudes of those with genetic versus non-genetic medical conditions . Am J Med Genet2003; 119c: 51—59 .
18.
Forrest K. , Simpson SA , Wilson BJ et al. To tell or not to tell: barriers and facilitators in family communication about genetic risk . Clin Genet2003; 64: 317—26 .
19.
Lehmann LS , Weeks JC , Klar N. , Biener L. , Garber JEDisclosure of familial genetic information: perceptions of the duty to inform . Am J Med2000; 109: 705—11 .
20.
Julian-Reynier C. , Eisinger F. , Chabal F. et al. Disclosure to the family of breast/ovarian cancer genetic test results: patients' willingness and associated factors . Am J Med Genet2000; 94: 13—18 .
21.
Clarke A. , Richards M. , Kerzin-Storrar L. et al. Genetic professionals' reports of nondisclosure of genetic risk information within families . Eur J Hum Genet2005; 13: 556—62 .
22.
Dugan BR , Wiesner GL , Juengst ET , O'Riordan M. , Matthews AL , Robin NHDuty to warn at-risk relatives for genetic disease: genetic counselors' clinical experience . Am J Med Genet2003; 119C: 27—34 .
23.
Falk MJ , Dugan RB , O'Riordan MA , Matthew AL , Robin NHMedical geneticists' duty to warn at risk relatives for genetic disease . Am J Med Genet2003; 120A: 374—80 .
24.
Genetic Interest Group.Confidentiality guidelines . Genetic Interest Group , 1998.
25.
Campbell E. , Friedman Ross L.Professional and personal attitudes about access and confidentiality in the genetic testing of children: a pilot study . Genet Test2003; 7: 123—30 .
26.
Terzioglu F. , Dinç L.Nurses' views on their role in genetics . J Obstet Gynecol Neonatal Nurs2004; 33: 756—64 .
27.
Jenkins JF , Prows L. , Dimond E. , Mosess R. , Williams J.Recommendations for educating nurses in genetics . J Prof Nurs2001; 17: 283—90 .
28.
Jenkins J.Ethical implications of genetic information . Online J Issues Nurs2001 Retrieved 6 June, 2006, from: http://www.nursingworld.org/ojin/ethicol/ethics_5.htm
29.
Barnoy S. , Appel D. , Peretz C. , Meiraz H. , Ehrenfeld M.Genetic testing, genetic information and the role of maternal-child health nurses in Israel . J Nurs Scholarsh2006; 38: 219—24 .
30.
Ludwick R. , Silva MCNursing around the world: cultural values and ethical conflicts . Online J Issues Nurs2000 Retrieved 6 June, 2006 , from: http://www.nursingworld.org/ojin/ethics_4htm
31.
Kotkis D. , Tabak N.When the physician is an HIV carrier; there are two sides to the coin . Med Law2003, 27: 185—93 (in Hebrew).
32.
Code of ethics for Israeli nurses. Israel Nurses Association , 2004.
33.
Patient's Rights Act, 1.15.1996. (Book of Amendments, 1591) (in Hebrew).
34.
Coulter A.Paternalism or partnership . BMJ1999; 319: 719—20 .
35.
Henson RM , Wyatt SW , Lee NCThe National Breast and Cervical Cancer Early Detection Program: a comprehensive public health response to two major health issues for women . J Public Health Manage Pract1996; 2(2): 36—47 .
36.
Tobin AJ , Singer ERHuntington's disease: the challenge for cell biologists . Trends Cell Biol2000; 10: 531—36 .
37.
Shiloh S. , Patel Y. , Papa M. , Goldman B.Motivations, perceptions and interpersonal differences associated with interest in genetic testing for breast cancer susceptibility among women at high and average risk . Psychol Health1998; 13: 1071—86 .
