Using an interpretative research approach to ethical and legal literature, it is argued that nursing in the battlefield is distinctly different to civilian nursing, even in an emergency, and that the environment is so different that a duty of care owed by military nurses to wounded soldiers should not apply. Such distinct differences in wartime can override normal peacetime professional ethics to the extent that the duty of care owed by military nurses to their patients on the battlefield should not exist. It is also argued that as military nurses have legal and professional obligations to care for wounded soldiers on the battlefield, this obligation conflicts with following military orders, causing a dual loyalty conflict. This is because soldiers are part of the ‘fighting force’ and must be fit to fight and win the battle. This makes them more of a commodity rather than individual persons with distinct health care needs.
Southby JRNursing ethics and the military. In: Beam TE, Sparacino LR (eds). Military medical ethics, vol. 2. Washington, DC: Borden Institute, 2003, p.661-86.
2.
Fry S., Harvey RM, Hurley AC, Foley BJDevelopment of a model of moral distress in military nursing. Nurs Ethics2002; 9: 373-87.
3.
Kligman A., Kupermintz H.Response style and self-control under SCUD missile attacks: the case of the sealed room situation during the Gulf War. J Trauma Stress1994; 7: 415-26.
4.
US Department of the Army.Combat health support in stability operations and support operations [Field manual]. Washington DC: DA, 1997, p.8-42.
5.
Nursing and Midwifery Council.The code: standards of conduct, performance and ethics for nurses and midwives. London: NMC, 2008.
6.
R v. Bateman [1925] All ER Rep 45 at 49
7.
Nursing and Midwifery Council.Duty of care [Advice sheet]. London: NMC, 2008.
8.
Cassidy v. Ministry of Health [1951] 1 All ER 574 at 586
9.
Green S.Coherence of medical negligence case. Med Law Rev2006; 14(1): 1-14.
10.
Tschudin V. , Schmitz C.The impact of conflict and war on international nursing and ethics. Nurs Ethics2003; 10: 354-67.
11.
Williams PTTo kill or not to kill: a question of wartime ethics. Nurs Ethics1996; 3: 150-6.
12.
Tschudin V.Ethics in nursing: the caring relationship, second edition. Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann, 1992 .
13.
Armed Forces Act 2006. Norwich: The Stationery Office, 2006, s. 2 (3).
14.
Bajec I.Post Gulf War explosive injuries in liberated Kuwait. Injury1993; 24: 517-20.
15.
International Council of Nurses.Code of ethics for nurses. Geneva: ICN, 2000.
16.
Altun I.Innovation in behaviour patterns that characterize nurses. Nurs Ethics2008; 15: 838-40.
17.
Armed Forces Act 2006. Norwich: The Stationery Office, 2006, s. 12 (1) (a) and (b).
18.
Beam TEMedical ethics on the battlefield: the crucible of military medical ethics . In: Beam TE, Sparacino LR (eds). Military medical ethics, vol. 2. Washington, DC: Borden Institute, 2003, 369-402.
19.
Gross MLBioethics and armed conflict: moral dilemmas of medicine and war. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2006.
20.
Kottow MHShould medical ethics justify violence?J Med Ethics2006; 32: 464-7.
21.
Gross MLWhy treat the wounded? Warrior care, military salvage, and national health . Am J Bioethics2008; 8(2): 3-12.
22.
Griffiths L., Jasper M.Warrior nurse: duality and complementarity of role in the operational environment . J Adv Nurs2007; 61: 92-9.
23.
Enemark C.Triage, treatment, and torture: ethical challenges for US military medicine in Iraq. J Military Ethics2008; 7: 187-201.
24.
Sandin P.Collective military virtues. J Military Ethics2007; 6: 303-14.
25.
Rossow-Kimball B., Goodwin D.Self-determination and leisure experiences of women living in two group homes. Adapt Phys Activ Q2009; 26: 1-20.
26.
Rubin GRUnited Kingdom military law: autonomy, civilisation, juridification. Mod Law Rev2002; 64: 36-57.
27.
Tripodi P.Peacekeepers, moral autonomy and the use of force. J Military Ethics2006; 5: 214-32.
28.
Re Post Traumatic Stress Disorder Group Litigation. Multiple Claimants v. Ministry of Defence [2003] EWHC 1134 at 2.c.12
29.
Westhusing TSEquality within military organizations. J Military Ethics2006; 5: 5-11.
30.
Crowe C., Hardil K.Nursing and war: transforming our legacy. Can Nurse1991; 87: 291-302.
31.
SO1 Leadership and Development.Soldier management: a guide for commanders. Sandhurst: Royal Military Academy, 2004, p.50.
32.
National Health ServiceAct 2006. Norwich: The Stationery Office, 2006.
33.
Harper P.Different skills, different attitude, same duty of care. Br J Nurs2006; 15: 537-9.
34.
Bassett A.Guns and brooches: Australian Army nursing from the Boer War to the Gulf War . Oxford: Oxford University Press , 1997.
35.
Moore BA, Reger GMClinician to frontline soldier: a look at the roles and challenges of army clinical psychologists in Iraq. J Clin Psychol2006; 62: 395-403.
36.
Ministry of Defence.Queen’s regulations for the Army (Part 8: Medical, dental and health - Part 9: Dress) . London: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office, 1975, J5.362.
37.
Yeo M.Integration of nursing theory and nursing ethics. ANS Adv Nurs Sci1989; 11(3): 33-42.
38.
Armed Forces Act 2006. Norwich: The Stationery Office, 2006, parts 11-13.
39.
Toner C.Military service as a practice: integrating the sword and the shield approaches to military ethics. J Military Ethics2006 ; 3: 183-200.
40.
Bureau of Medicine and Surgery, under the authority of the Secretary of the Navy.Manual for the Medical Department of the United States Navy. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1914, paras 2085, 3413.
41.
St Georges’s Healthcare NHS Trust v. S, R v. Collins and others, ex parte S, [1998] 3 All ER 673
42.
Armed Forces Act 2006, Part 1 (Offences), s. 16 - Malingering (1) c).
43.
Ministry of Defence.Joint medical doctrine (Joint Warfare Publication 4-03). Shrivenham : Joint Doctrine and Concepts Centre, 2007, paras 120, 122.
44.
MacFarlane C.Emergency thoracotomy and the military surgeon . Aust N Z J Surg2004; 74: 280-4.
45.
Haworth M.Motorsport rescue. The golden hour. http://www.haworth21.karoo.net/The%20Golden%20Hour.htm (2006 , accessed May 2010).
46.
Bukowski CWThe Platinum 10: 2nd BCT, 101st Airborne improves medical training to help save lives. Infantry Magazine2006; (July-August). http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0IAV/is_4_95/ai_n17154164/ (2006, accessed May 2010).
47.
Callan v. Extrication of the seriously injured road crash victim. Emerg Med J2005; 22: 817-21.
48.
Murdock DBTrauma: where’s there no time to count. AORN J2008; 87: 322-32.
49.
Hess JR, Holcomb JBTransfusion practice in military trauma. Transfus Med2008; 18: 143-50.
50.
Hodgetts TJ , Mahoney PF, Russell MQ, Byers M.ABC to <C> ABC: redefining the military trauma paradigm. Emerg Med J2006; 23: 745-6.
51.
Kraemer LAA military twist to the profession of nursing. Medsurg Nurs2008; 17: 275-7.
Hodgetts TJPersonal view: a day in the life of an emergency physician at war. Emerg Med J2004; 21: 129-30.
54.
Coleman S.The problems of duty and loyalty. J Military Ethics2009; 8: 105-15.
55.
Ministry of Defence.Medical support joint operations, second edition. Shrivenham: Joint Doctrine and Concepts Centre, 2007, para. 112.
56.
Kennedy TE, Hill E., Adams NR, Jennings B.A conceptual model of army nursing practice. Nurs Manage1996; 27: 33-6.
57.
Best R.Military medical care: questions and answers. Congressional Research Service. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/nation/documents/walter-reed/RL33537.pdf (2007, accessed May 2010).
58.
Tricarico DJReadiness - meeting the air force mission. Todays Surg Nurse1998; 20: 41-6.
59.
Matthews RSIndecent medicine: in defense of the absolute prohibition against physician participation in torture. Am J Bioethics2006 ; 6(3): W34-W44.
60.
Hedahl M.Blood and blackwaters: a call to arms for the profession of arms. J Military Ethics2009; 8(1): 19-33.
61.
Witting C.Duty of care: an analytical approach. Oxf J Legal Stud2005; 25(1): 33-63.
62.
London AJThreats to the common good. Hastings Cent Rep2003; 33(5): 17-25.
63.
Hallgarth MWBioethics and armed conflict: moral dilemmas of medicine and war [Book review] . J Military Ethics2007; 6: 83-4.
