This analysis examines the practice of care providers in residential aged care lying to residents with dementia. Qualitative data were collected through multiple methods. Data here represents perceptions from registered and enrolled nurses, personal care assistants, and allied health professionals from five residential aged care facilities located in Queensland, Australia. Care providers in residential aged care facilities (RACFs) lie to residents with dementia. Lying is conceptualized as therapeutic whereby the care provider’s intent is to eliminate harm and also control behaviour. Care providers of residents with dementia in RACFs need guidance around lying. An ethical framework cognisant of an ethical theory of good and ethical theory of right supplemented by a theory of virtue is proposed. A complimentary four stage communication strategy that promotes truth telling as a first option while also recommending the lie as a suitable strategy is also promoted.
TuckettA.Truth-telling in clinical practice and the arguments for and against: a review of the literature. Nurs Ethics2004; 11(5): 500–13.
2.
TuckettA.Truth-telling in aged care: a qualitative study(Thesis). Queensland: Queensland University of Technology, 2004. http://eprints.qut.edu.au/15862/(2008, accessed August 2011).
3.
Wood-MitchellACunninghamJMackenzieLJamesI.Can a lie ever be therapeutic? The debate continues. J Dem Care2007; 15(2): 24–8.
4.
RyanCJde MooreGPatfieldM.Becoming none but tradesmen: lies, deception and psychotic patients. J Med Ethics1995; 21(2): 72–6.
5.
HertoghCTheBMiesenBEefstingJ.Truth-telling and truthfulness in the care for patients with advanced dementia: an ethnographic study in Dutch nursing homes. Soc Sci Med2004; 59: 1685–93.
6.
DavisNContemporary deontology. In: SingerP. (ed.). A companion to ethics. Oxford: Blackwell, 1991, p.205–18.
7.
BonhoefferD.Ethics. London: SCM Press, 1955.
8.
TuckettA.Stepping across the line: information sharing, truth-telling and the role of the personal carer in the Australian nursing-home. Qual Health Res2007; 17(4): 489–500.
9.
BlumN.Deceptive practices in managing a family member with Alzheimer’s disease. Sym Interac1994; 17(1): 21–36.
10.
ElvishRJamesIMilneD.Lying in dementia care: an example of a culture that deceives in people’s best interests. Aging Ment Health2010: 14(3): 255–62.
11.
JamesIWood-MitchellAWaterworthAMackenzieLCunninghamJ.Lying to people with dementia: developing ethical guidelines for care settings. Int J Ger Psychiatry2006; 21: 800–1.
12.
Wood-MitchellAWaterworthAStephensonMJamesI.Lying to people with dementia: sparking the debate. J Dementia Care2006; 14(6): 30–1.
13.
TuckettA.An ethic of the fitting: a conceptual framework for nursing practice. Nurs Inquiry1998; 5: 220–7.
14.
HiggsR.On telling patients the truth. Paper presented at The 11th National Bioethics Conference, Wahroonga, Australia, 11–13October1998.
15.
RosenerFBergerJKarkPPotashJBennettA.Disclosure and prevention of medical errors. Arch Intern Med2000; 160(14): 2089–92.
16.
DownsM.How to tell? Disclosing a diagnosis of dementia. Generations1999; 23(3): 30–4.
17.
BrewinT.The cancer patient: communication and morale. BMJ1977; 2: 1627.
18.
BokS.Lying: moral choices in public and private life. New York: Quartet, 1973.
19.
SheldonM.Truth-telling in medicine. JAMA1982; 247(5): 651–4.
20.
MoutsopoulusL.Medicine and law. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1984.
21.
LavittG.Truth-telling to patients with a terminal diagnosis. J Halacha Contemporary Soc1988; 15: 95–196.
22.
HebertP.Truth-telling in clinical practice. Canadian Fam Physic1994; 40: 2105–13.
23.
WrightLMacRaeSGordonDElliotEDixonDAbbeyS.Disclosure of misattributed paternity: issues involved in the discovery of unsought information. Seminars in Dialysis2002; 15(3): 202–6.
24.
HasselkusB.Everyday ethics in dementia day care: narratives of crossing the line. The Gerontologist1997; 37(5): 640–9.
BenderM.Lying: in the real world, context is all-important. J Dementia Care2007; 15(6): 12–14.
27.
TuckettA.The meaning of nursing-home: ‘Waiting to go up to St. Peter, OK! Waiting house, sad but true’ – an Australian perspective. J Aging Stud2007; 21(4): 119–33.
28.
TuckettA.Registered nurses’ understanding of truth-telling as practiced in the residential aged care: an Australian perspective. Health Soc Rev2006; 15(2): 179–91.
29.
BergerPLuckmannT.The social construction of reality: a treatise in the sociology of knowledge. London: Penguin, 1996.
30.
CrottyM.the foundations of social research: meanings and perspectives in the research process. St. Leonards, Australia: Allen & Unwin, 1998.
MeadG.Mind, self, and society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1934.
33.
TuckettAStewartD.Part I: journals as method: experience, rationales and limitations. Contemporary Nurs2003/4; 16(1/2): 104–13.
34.
TuckettAStewartD.Part II: group discussion as method: experience, rationales and limitations. Contemporary Nurs2004; 16(3): 240–51.
35.
StraussACorbinJ.Basics of qualitative research: techniques and procedures for developing grounded theory. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 1998.
36.
EzzyD.Qualitative analysis: practice and innovation. Crows Nest, Australia: Allen & Unwin, 2002.
37.
HigginbothamNAlbrechtGConnorL.Health social science: a transdisciplinary and complexity perspective. South Melbourne, Australia: Oxford University Press, 2001.
38.
MorseJ.Strategies for sampling. In: MorseJ (ed.). Qualitative nursing research: a contemporary dialogue. London: SAGE, 1991, p.127–45.
39.
MorseJ.Qualitative generalizability. Qual Health Res1999; 9: 5–6.
40.
KeithJ.Consequences for research procedures. In: GubriumJSankarA (eds). Qualitative methods in aging research. London: SAGE, 1994, p.105–19.
CutcliffeJMcKennaH.When do we know what we know? Considering the truth of research findings and the craft of qualitative research. Inter J Nurs Stud2002; 39: 611–18.
43.
TuckettA.Qualitative research sampling – the very real complexities. Nurs Researcher2004; 12(1): 47–61.
44.
GlasserB.The future of grounded theory. Qual Health Res1999; 9: 836–45.
45.
TuckettA.Applying thematic analysis theory to practice: a researcher’s experience. Contemporary Nurs2005; 19(1/2): 75–87.
CharmazK.Qualitative interviewing and grounded theory analysis. In: HolsteinJGubriumJ (eds). Inside interviewing: new lenses, new concerns. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 2003, p.311–30.
48.
FarmerTRobinsonKElliottSEylesJ.Developing and implementing a triangulation protocol for qualitative health research. Qual Health Res2006; 16: 377–94.
49.
TuckettA.Part II: rigour in qualitative research – complexities and solutions. Nurs Researcher2005; 13(1): 29–42.
50.
WalkerB.Communication: building up a toolkit of helpful responses. J Dementia Care2007; 15(1): 28–31.
51.
MayW.The virtues in a professional setting. In: FulfordKGillettGSoskiceJ. (eds). Medicine and moral reasoning. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994, p.75–90.
52.
KerridgeILoweMMcPheeJ.Ethics and law for the health professions. Katoomba, NSW: Social Science Press, 2005.
53.
JohnstoneM-J.Bioethics: a nursing perspective. Sydney: Churchill Livingston, 2004.
54.
NealMBarton WrightP.Validation therapy for dementia. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews2003; 3. Art. No: CD001394.
55.
BeauchampTChildressJ.Principles of biomedical ethics. New York: Oxford University Press, 2001.
