The Key to Quality Nursing Care: towards a model of personal and professional development

Abstract

Quality of nursing cannot be assessed in terms of performance referenced criteria, but only in terms of the personal qualities displayed in the performance. The key to improvement in practice may be the improvement of emotional and motivational tendencies. In essence, professional development implies personal development. Harré makes a distinction between ‘powers to do’ and ‘powers to be’ (a state of being). The former are the capacities that individuals acquire to perform their tasks and roles. Professional development therefore involves, first, the acquisition of the capacities necessary for the successful completion of a set of professional tasks (the powers to do). Secondly, it involves the acquisition of the appropriate emotions and motivations, and the theories about human nature and the conduct that underpins them (the powers to be). Therefore, these capacities cannot be derived from an analysis of tasks, since what are defined as tasks in the first place are determined by the exercise of such powers. The acquisition of attitudes constitutes a source of competent practice. Harré’s model of ‘personal identity’ provides a conceptual framework for thinking about the process of the acquisition of nursing competence and its relationship to differing views of nursing. Considerations relating to different priorities within Harré’s model make it possible to raise questions about the objectives of competence at different stages.

Keywords

dialogue quality self-monitoring social relations

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Glen S.

Emotional and motivational tendencies: the key to quality nursing care?

Nurs Ethics 1998; 5: 36-42 .

Harré R. Personal being. Oxford: Basil Blackwell , 1983.

Gould C. Rethinking democracy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press , 1988.

Taylor W. The ethics of authenticity. London: Harvard , 1991.

Barnett R. The limits of competence. Buckingham: Society for Research in Higher Education/Open University Press , 1994.

Toulmin SE. Self-knowledge and knowledge of the self. In: Mischel T ed. The self. Oxford: Blackwell , 1977.

Hamlyn DL. Self-knowledge. In: Mischel T ed. The self. Oxford: Blackwell , 1977: 195-195.

Gee JP. Literacy, discourse and linguistics . J Educ, 1989; 17(1): 5-17 .

Wise AE , Darling-Hamond I , McLaughlin MW , Bernstein MT. Evaluation: a study of effective practice. Santa Monica, CA: California Rail Corporation , 1984.

10.

Kaufe D , Geisler C. Novelling in academic writing . Written Commun 1991; 8: 289-289 .

11.

Bakintin MA. The dialogic imagination. Austin, CA: University of California Press , 1981.

12.

Kelly G. The psychology of personal constructs. New York: Norton , 1955.