From Large Villages to Small Towns: A Study of Rural Transformation in New Census Towns,India

Abstract

Since the release of the census 2011 data, much has been written about the ‘unprecedented’ emergence of new census towns (CTs), their spatial distribution, their role in urban growth and possible reasons for their emergence. However, little has been talked about the process of transformation of the concerned settlements from ‘rural’ to ‘urban’ using field information. The current study is an attempt to bridge this gap. Taking the case of Sehara, a new CT in the state of West Bengal, the article argues that the process of structural transformation of economy in such settlements is not necessarily unidirectional and agriculture plays a strong role in this process. Fluctuation of non-farm employment makes such towns an ‘undecidable category’. The study also reveals that the towns like Sehara have little regional importance when the concerned region is dotted by several big villages.

Keywords

New census towns rural transformation rural non-farm employment agrarian distress agricultural labourers

References

Abraham

2009. ‘Employment Growth in Rural India: Distress-driven?’ Economic and Political Weekly 44 (16): 97–104.

Angeles-Reyes

1994. ‘Nonfarm Work in the Philippine Rural Economy: An Omen of Change or a Change of Omens?’ In Development or Deterioration? Work in Rural Asia, edited by Koppel

Hawkins

James

, 100–33. London: Lynne Rienner Publishers.

Basu

D. N.

Kashyap

S. P.

1992. ‘Rural Non-Agriculture Employment in India: Role of Development Process and Rural–Urban Employment Linkages’. Economic and Political Weekly 27 (51 & 52): 178–89.

Bhalla

G. S.

2007. Indian Agriculture since Independence. New Delhi: National Book Trust.

Bhattacharyya

2007. ‘Agrarian Impasse in West Bengal in the Liberalisation Era’. Economic and Political Weekly 42 (52): 65–71.

Bijapurkar

2013. We Are Like That Only: Understanding the Logic of Consumer India. New Delhi: Portfolio Penguin.

Binswanger-Mkhize

H. P.

2013. ‘The Stunted Structural Transformation of the Indian Economy: Agriculture, Manufacturing and Rural Non-Farm Sector’. Economic and Political Weekly 48 (26 & 27): 5–13.

Brenner

Schmid

2015. ‘Towards a New Epistemology of the Urban?’ City 19 (2 & 3): 151–82.

Cavalcante

2016. ‘Feeling Rich on an Empty Stomach: Agrarian Crisis and Rural Consumption Choices’. In Middle India and Rural–Urban Development: Four Decades of Change, edited by Harriss-White

, 251–74. New Delhi: Springer.

10.

Chakrabarty

2013. ‘Decentralisation and the Politics of Water Allocation in West Bengal’. Journal of South Asian Development 8 (1): 1–26.

11.

Chand

Parappurathu

2012. ‘Temporal and Spatial Variations in Agricultural Growth and Its Determinants’. Economic and Political Weekly 47 (26 & 27): 55–64.

12.

Chand

Srivastava

S. K.

2014. ‘Changes in the Rural Labour Market and Their Implications for Agriculture’. Economic and Political Weekly 49 (10): 47–54.

13.

Chandrasekhar

2011. ‘Workers Commuting between the Rural and Urban: Estimates from NSSO Data’. Economic and Political Weekly 46 (46): 22–25.

14.

Chung

2014. ‘Rural Transformation and Persistence of Rurality in China’. Eurasian Geography and Economics 54 (5 & 6): 594–610.

15.

Deokar

B. K.

Shetty

S. L.

2014. ‘Growth in Indian Agriculture: Responding to Policy Initiatives since 2004–05’. Economic and Political Weekly 49 (26 & 27): 101–05.

16.

Gibson

Cahill

McKay

2010. ‘Rethinking the Dynamics of Rural Transformation: Performing Different Development Pathways in a Philippine Municipality’. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 35 (2): 237–55.

17.

GoI. 2007. Report of the Expert Group on Agricultural Indebtedness. New Delhi: Ministry of Finance, Government of India.

18.

Guin

2017. ‘Urban Transition in West Bengal, India’. Journal of Asian and African Studies 52 (8): 1258–76.

19.

Guin

Das

D. N.

2015a. ‘New Census Towns in West Bengal: “Census Activism” or Sectoral Diversification?’ Economic and Political Weekly 50 (14): 68–72.

20.

Guin

Das

D. N.

2015b. ‘Spatial Perspectives of the New Census Towns: A Case Study of West Bengal’. Environment and Urbanization ASIA 6 (2): 109–24.

21.

Gulati

Jain

Satija

2014. ‘Rising Farm Wages in India: The ‘Pull’ and ‘Push’ Factors’. Journal of Land and Rural Studies 2 (2): 261–86.

22.

Gupta

2005. ‘Wither the Indian Villages: Culture and Agriculture in ‘Rural’ India’. Economic and Political Weekly 40 (8): 751–58.

23.

Gupta

2009. The Caged Phoenix: Can India Fly? New Delhi: Penguin Viking.

24.

Gupta

2013. Revolution from Above: India’s Future and Citizen Elite. New Delhi: Rainlight Rupa.

25.

Gupta

2015. ‘The Importance of Being “Rurban”: Tracking Changes in a Traditional Setting’. Economic and Political Weekly 50 (24): 37–43.

26.

Hinderink

Titus

2002. ‘Small Towns and Regional Development: Major Findings and Policy Implications from Comparative Research’. Urban Studies 39 (3): 379–91.

27.

Jayaraj

2004. ‘Social Institutions and Structural Transformation of the Non-Farm Economy’. In Rural India Facing the 21st Century: Essays on Long Term Village Change and Recent Development Policy (pp. 175–91), edited by Harriss-White

Janakarajan . London: Wimbledon Publishing Company.

28.

Jatav

Sen

2013. ‘Drivers of Non-Farm Employment in Rural India: Evidence from 2009-10 NSS Round’. Economic and Political Weekly 48 (26 & 27): 14–21.

29.

Jodhka

S. S.

2006. ‘Beyond “Crisis”: Rethinking Contemporary Punjab Agriculture’. Economic and Political Weekly 41 (16): 1530–37.

30.

Jodhka

S. S.

2010. ‘Dalits in Business: Self Employed Scheduled Castes in North-West India’. Economic and Political Weekly 45 (11): 41–48.

31.

Khasnabis

2008. ‘The Economy of West Bengal’. Economic and Political Weekly 43 (52): 103–15.

32.

Koppel

Hawkins

1994. ‘Rural Transformation and the Future of Work in Rural Asia’. In Development or Deterioration? Work in Rural Asia, edited by Koppel

Hawkins

James

, 1–46. London: Lynne Rienner Publishers.

33.

Kumar

2016. ‘Agrarian Transformation and the New Rurality in Western Uttar Pradesh’. Economic and Political Weekly 51 (26 & 27): 61–71.

34.

Kundu

2003. ‘Urbanisation and Urban Governance: Search for a Perspective beyond Neo-Liberalism’. Economic and Political Weekly 38 (29): 3079–87.

35.

Kundu

2011. ‘Method in Madness: Urban Data from 2011 Census’. Economic and Political Weekly 46 (40): 13–16.

36.

Kundu

2013. ‘Who Are the Emerging Middle Classes? The Indian Example’. Available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=thmS-QjEi_E (accessed on 11 February 2014).

37.

Lanjouw

Proctor

2003. ‘Rural Non-Farm Economy: Latin American Experience’. In Rural Transformation in India: The Role of Non-farm Sector, edited by Nayyar

Sharma

A. N.

, 49–53. New Delhi: Institute for Human Development.

38.

L. J. C.

Fan

1994. ‘Urbanisation from Below: The Growth of Towns in Jiangsu, China’. Urban Studies 31 (10): 1625–45.

39.

Mellor

J. W.

1976. The New Economy of Growth: A Strategy for India and the Developing World. New York, NY: Cornell University Press.

40.

Mitra

Kumar

2015. ‘New Patterns in Indian Urbanization: Emergence of Census Towns’. Environment and Urbanization ASIA 6 (1): 18–27.

41.

Nayyar

Sharma

A. N.

2003. ‘Introduction and Overview’. In Rural Transformation in India: The Role of Non-Farm Sector, edited by Nayyar

Sharma

A. N.

, 11–28. New Delhi: Institute for Human Development.

42.

NSSO. 2014. Employment and Unemployment Situation in India: NSS 68th Round. NSS Report No. 554 (68/10/1). New Delhi: National Sample Survey Office, Government of India.

43.

Pradhan

K. C.

2013. ‘Unacknowledged Urbanisation: New Census Towns of India’. Economic and Political Weekly 48 (36): 43–51.

44.

Rao

G. N.

Nair

K. N.

2003. ‘Change and Transformation in Rural South India: Findings from Village Studies’. Economic and Political Weekly 38 (32): 3349–54.

45.

Rawal

Swaminathan

1998. ‘Changing Trajectories: Agricultural Growth in West Bengal, 1950–1996’. Economic and Political Weekly 33 (40): 2595–602.

46.

Reddy

D. N.

Reddy

A. A.

Nagaraj

Bantilan

2014. ‘Rural Non-Farm Employment and Rural Transformation in India’. Working Paper Series No. 57, Patancheru, Telangana: International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics.

47.

Redfield

Singer

M. B.

1954. ‘The Cultural Role of Cities’. Economic Development and Cultural Change 3 (1): 53–73.

48.

Reissman

1964. The Urban Process. New York, NY: Free Press.

49.

Rigg

1998. ‘Rural–Urban Interactions, Agriculture and Wealth: A South East Asian Perspective’. Progress in Human Geography 22 (4): 497–522.

50.

Roy

2015. ‘What is Urban About Critical Urban Theory?’ Urban Geography 2015, 1–14. DOI: 10.1080/02723638.2015.1105485

51.

Sarkar

2007. ‘Development and Displacement: Land Acquisition in West Bengal’. Economic and Political Weekly 42 (16): 1435–42.

52.

Sjoberg

1965. ‘Theory and Research in Urban Sociology’. In The Study of Urbanization (pp. 157–90), edited by Hauser

P. H.

Schnore

L. F.

New York, NY: John Wiley.

53.

Shen

2006. ‘Estimating Urbanisation Level in Chinese Provinces in 1982–2000’. International Statistical Review 74 (1): 89–107.

54.

Shrinivasan

2013. ‘Farmer Population Falls by 9 Million in 10 Years’. The Times of India, Available at http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Farmer-population-falls-by-9-million-in-10-years/articleshow/19813617.cms (accessed on 24 June 2014).

55.

Singh

S. K.

2016. ‘De-Ploughing the “Rural”: Urban Myths About Rural Consumptions”. Economic and Political Weekly (Web Exclusives) 51 (25). Available at http://www.epw.in/journal/2016/25/web-exclusives/de-ploughing-%E2%80%9Crural.html (accessed on 18 June 2016).

56.

Sircar

2017. ‘Placing the Urban in Its Rural Context: A Mixed Methods Case Study of a “Census Town” in India’. Urbanization 2 (2): 98–115.

57.

Sood

2013. ‘Farmers Have Decreased, Farm Labourers Increased: Census Report’. Down to Earth. Available at http://www.downtoearth.org.in/content/farmers-have-decreased-farm-labourers-increased-census-report (accessed on 24 June 2014).

58.

White

1976. ‘Population, Employment and Involution in a Javanese Village’. Development and Change 7, 267–90.

59.

Wirth

1938. ‘Urbanism as a Way of Life’. American Journal of Sociology 44 (1): 1–24.