Comparison of Relationships Among Team Cohesion Scores and Measures of Team Success in Male Varsity Basketball Teams

Abstract

This study explores several methodological areas that may account for in consistency in basketball study findings concerning the cohesion-performance relationship. An average team score for each item and factor appearing on a cohesion questionnaire was calculated for 18 youth teams (ages 10-16) and 17 teams composed of college men (ages 19—22). Both univariate and multivariate relationships between 2 measures of team success and team scores for cohesion items were identified and compared in each age level of competition. The study findings indicate (a) measures of team success, affiliation cohesion, and satisfac tion with team achievements are interrelated in both levels of competition; (b) the magnitude of relationships increased significantly in both the youth and mens teams when moving from simple to multiple correlational techniques; (c) the magnitude of multiple relationships did not differ among each measure of team succcess separately; (d) the magnitude of multiple correlations did not increase when computing canonical correlations in either level of competition; and (e) the magnitude of relationships were not a function of the number of teams in each level of competition.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alderman R. and Wood N. , 1976, An Analysis of Incentive Motivation in Young Canadian Athletes, "Canadian Journal of Applied Sport Sciences", 1, pp. 169—176.

Arnold G.E. and Straub W.F. , 1973, Personality and Group Cohesiveness as Determinants of Success among Interscholastic Basketball Teams In: I. Williams and L. Wankel (eds.), Proceedings of Fourth Canadian Psychomotor Learning and Sport Psychology Symposium, Department of National Health and Welfare, Ottawa.

Carron A. , 1980, Social Psychology of Sport, Mouvement Publications, Ithaca, N. Y., pp. 233—257.

Cotter, L. , 1979, Group Cohesiveness and Team Success among Women's Intercollegiate Basketball Teams. Paper presented at the Research Section of the annual meeting of the American Alliance for Health, Physical Education, Recreation and Dance, New Orleans.

Eitzen, D. , 1975, Group Structure and Group Performance. In: D. Landers (ed.), Psychology of Sport and Motor Behavior II, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, Pa., pp. 41-45.

Festinger, L. , 1968, Informal Social Communication. In: D. Cartwright and A. Zander (eds.), Group Dynamics, Harper and Row, New York, pp. 182-191.

Fiedler, F. , 1954, Assumed Similarity Measures as Predictors of Team Effectiveness , "Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology", 49, pp. 381—388.

Fiedler F. , Hartman W. and Rudin S. , 1952, The Relationship of Interpersonal Perception to Effectiveness in Basketball Teams (Suppl. Tech. Rep. No. 3, Contract N60T1-07/35), Bureau of Records and Service, University of Illinois, Urbana.

Grace H. , 1954, Conformance and Performance, "Journal of Social Psychology", 40, pp. 233—237.

10.

Gruber J. and Gray G. , 1981, Factor Patterns of Variables Influencing Cohesiveness at Various Levels of Basketball Competition, "Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport", accepted publication due March 1981 .

11.

Helwig J. and Council K. (eds.), 1979, SAS Users Guide, 1979 Fdition, SAS Institute, Inc., Raliegh, North Carolina.

12.

Klein M. and Christiansen G. , 1969, Group Composition, Group Structure, and Group Effectiveness of Basketball Teams. In: J. Loy, Jr. and G. Kenyon (eds.), Sport, Culture and Society: A Reader on the Sociology of Sport, MacMillan , pp. 397-407.

13.

Martens R. , 1970, Influence of Participation Motivation on Success and Satisfaction in Team Performance, "Research Quarterly", 41, pp. 510-518.

14.

Martens R. and Petersen J. , 1971, Group Cohesiveness as a Determinant of Success and Member Satisfaction in Team Performance, "International Review of Sport Sociology", 6, pp. 49—61.

15.

Melnick M. and Chemers M. , 1974, Effects of Group Social Structure of the Success of Basketball Teams, "Research Quarterly", 45, pp. 1-8.

16.

Seagrave J. , 1972, Comparison of Group Cohesiveness in Club and Varsity Athletic Teams for Men. Unpublished M.S. thesis, Pullman: Washington State University, 1972.

17.

Shepard C. , 1964, Small Groups - Some Sociological Perspectives, Chandler Publishing Company, Scranton, Pa.

18.

Vander Velden L. , 1971, Relationships among Members, Team and Situational Variables, and Basketball Team Success: A Social-Psychological Inquiry. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Wisconsin, Madison.

19.

Widmeyer W. and Martens R. , 1978, When Cohesion Predicts Performance Outcome in Sport, "Research Quarterly", 49, pp. 372—380.