We argue that a more complete picture of the International Olympic Committee (IOC) in the emerging globalized world is possible by considering the IOC as a transnational organization. In this paper, we demonstrate the importance of paying attention to a non- governmental entity (the IOC) in its interactions with a national government (South Africa) as well as the fragile and often paradoxical nature of transnational behavior. We illustrate how both the internal and external forces that were brought to bear on the IOC forced it to reconsider whether the South African Olympic and National Games Association (SAONGA) could actually deliver on the mandate required of all National Olympic Committees. From an initial position of confidence in SAONGA, the IOC slowly moved to one in which it was clear that the South Africans would have to be expelled from the Olympic movement. The re instatement of South Africa only came with the guarantee that the transnational goal of Olympism could be met in that country.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Brundage, A., n.d.: "Report of the events leading up to the withdrawal of recognition from the South African NOC by the IOC at its Amsterdam Session". In: Avery Brundage Collection, University of Western Ontario (hereafter referred to as A.B.C.), Box 144.
2.
Christie, J., March 14th, 1991: "Sport world set to embrace South Africa ". In: Globe and Mail. Toronto.
3.
Christie, J., July 6th, 1991: "Welcome mat out for South Africa". In: Globe and Mail. Toronto.
4.
Christie, J. and Van Niekerk, P., July 10th, 1991: "South African athletes to return to world stage". In: Globe and Mail. Toronto .
5.
COMMONWEALTH COMMITTEE OF FOREIGN MINISTERS (on Southern Africa), September 13-14th, 1991: "Commonwealth news release". London, Commonwealth Secretariat.
6.
Commonwealth Heads Of Government, October 21st, 1991: "The Harare communiqué". Harare.
7.
Cunningham, D., Slack, T., and Hinings, B., 1987: "Changing design archetypes in amateur sport organizations ". In: T. Slack and C.R. Hinings (eds.): The Organization and Adminstration of Sport. London, ON, Sports Dynamics Publishers.
8.
Defrantz, A., May 28th, 1991: "Apartheid just one of the issues to be settled". In: USA Today. Arlington, VA.
9.
Degras, J., 1951: Soviet Documents on Foreign Policy, Volume I - 1917-1924 . London, Oxford University Press .
10.
Department Of External Affairs8DEA9, 1962-76, 1984: Department of External Affairs Files. Ottawa. For files located in the National Archives of Canada (NAC), the citation used is DEA Files, NAC.
11.
Edwards, H., 1970: The Revolt of the Black Athlete. New York, The Free Press.
12.
Espy, R., 1979: The Politics of the Olympic Games. Berkeley, University of California Press.
13.
Globe And Mail, Ocotber 21st, 1989). "De Klerk takes a big step and a big risk". Toronto .
14.
Globe And Mail, April 10th, 1991: "Bill to end pillar of apartheid formally proposed in South Africa". Toronto.
15.
Globe And Mail, April 24th, 1991: "Another segregation law to die". Toronto.
16.
Globe And Mail, April 25th, 1991: "S. Africa broadens amnesty". Toronto.
17.
Guelke, A., 1986: " The politicisation of South African sport". In: L. Allison (ed.): The Politics of Sport. Manchester,Manchester University Press.
18.
Guttman, A., 1984: The Games Must Go On: Avery Brundage and the Olympic Movement. New York, Columbia University Press.
19.
Hain, P., 1982: " The politics of sport and apartheid". In: J. Hargreaves (ed.): Sport, Culture and Ideology. London, Routledge and Kegan Paul.
20.
Hinings, B., and Slack, T., 1987: " The dynamics of quadennial plan implementation in national sport organizations ". In: T. Slack and C.R. Hinings (eds.): The Organization and Administration of Sport. London, ON, Sports Dynamics Publishers.
21.
Hoberman, J., 1986: The Olympic Crisis: Sport, Politics and the Moral Order . New Rochelle, NY, Aristide D. Caratzas.
22.
Hoy, D., 1979: "The proposed African boycott of the XI Commonwealth Games ". MA Thesis, University of Alberta, Edmonton.
23.
Huntington, S., 1981: "Transgovernmental organizations in world politics". In: M. Smith, R. Little, and M. Shackelton (eds.): Perspectives on World Politics. London, Croom Helm Limited.
24.
International Olympic Committee (Ioc), 1967 : "Report of the IOC commission on South Africa". In: A.B.C., Box 85.
25.
International Olympic Committee (Ioc), April 1968: "Minutes of the IOC Executive Board". In: A.B.C., Box 87.
26.
International Olympic Committee (Ioc), July 1976: "Minutes of the Meeting of the 78th Session of the IOC-Montreal ". Lausanne, International Olympic Committee.
27.
International Olympic Committee (Ioc), 1984 : The Olympic Movement. Lausanne, International Olympic Committee.
28.
Kanin, D., 1976: "The role of sport in the international system". A paper presented at the Annual Convention of the International Studies Association, Toronto.
29.
Kanin, D., 1978: "The Olympic system: Transnational sport organization and the politics of cultural exchange". In: B. Lowe, D. Kanin, and A. Strenk (eds.): Sport and International Relations. Champaign, Ill., Stipes Publishing Company.
30.
Kidd, B., 1991: "From quarantine to cure: The new phase of the struggle against apartheid sport". In: Sociology of Sport Journal8, 33-46.
31.
Killanin, Lord, 1983: My Olympic Years. New York, William Morrow and Company, Inc.
32.
Lapchick, R., 1975: The Politics of Race and International Sport: The Case of South Africa. London, Greenwood Press.
33.
Lapchick, R., 1976: "Apartheid sport: South Africa's use of sport in its foreign policy". In: Journal of Sport and Social Issues1 (1), 52-79.
34.
Leiper, J., 1988: "Politics and Nationalism in the Olympic Games". In: J.O. Seagrave and D. Chu (eds.): The Olympic Games in Transition. Champaign, IL, Human Kinetics Press.
35.
LETTER FROM IRA EMERY TO AVERY BRUNDAGE, January 25th, 1961: A.C.., Box 145.
36.
LETTER FROM L.M. FRANCEY TO OTTO MEYER, April 30th, 1962: A.B.C., Box 144.
37.
LETTER FROM G.K. RANGASAMY TO ALL NATIONAL SPORTING BODIES AFRICA, August 7th, 1962: A.A.B., Box 144.
38.
LETTER FROM AVERY BRUNDAGE TO LORD KILLANIN, August 31st, 1967: A.B.C., Box 87.
39.
LETTER FROM AVERY BRUNDAGE TO LORD BURGHLEY, May 28th, 1970), A.B.C., Box 55.
40.
LETTER FROM REGINALD HONEY TO AVERY BRUNDAGE, July 30th, Box 58.
41.
LETTER FROM RUDOLPH OPPERMAN TO AVERY BRUNDAGE, November 4th, 1971: A.B.C., Box 144.
42.
LETTER FROM AVERY BRUNDAGE TO RUDOLPH OPPERMAN, August 9th, Box 144.
43.
Lyberg, W., 1988-89: The IOC Sessions: 1956-88. Stockholm, National Olympic Committee of Sweden.
44.
Lyberg, W., n.d.: IOC Executive Committee Minutes - Volume II - 1948-1969. Unpublished manuscript located at the Swedish National Olympic Committee.
45.
Macaloon, JJ, 1981: The Great Symbol: Pierre de Coubertin and the Origins of the Modern Olympic Games. Chicago, The University of Chicago Press.
46.
Macintosh, D., Greenhorn, D., and Black, D., 1992: "Canadian diplomacy and the 1978 Edmonton Commonwealth Games". In: Journal of Sport History19 (1), 26-55.
47.
Macintosh, D., and Hawes, M., 1992: "The IOC and the World of interdependence". In: Olympika: The International Journal of Olympic Studies1, 29-45.
48.
Macintosh, D., and Hawes, M., forthcoming: Sport and Canadian Diplomacy. Montreal -Kingston, McGill Queen's University Press.
49.
Morse, E., 1970: "The transformation of foreign policies". In: World Politics22 (3), 371-92.
50.
Nafziger, J.A.R., 1978: "The regulation of transnational sports competition: Down from Mount Olympus". In: Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law8, 180-212.
51.
Quick, S., 1990: "'Black knight checks white king.' The conflict between Avery Brundage and the African Nations over South African membership in the IOC". In: Canadian Journal of History of Sport21 (2), 20-32.
52.
Ramsamy, S., 1984: "Apartheid, boycotts and the Games". In: A. Tomlinson and G. Whannel (eds.): Five-Ring Circus: Money, Power and Politics at the Olympic Games. London, Pluto Press.
53.
Ramsamy, S., 1991: "Apartheid and Olympism: On the abolishment of institutionalized discrimination in international sport". In: F. Landry, M. Landry and M. Yerles (eds.): Sport ... The Third Millennium . Sainte-Foy, Que., Les Presses de L'Universite Laval,pp. 537-47.
54.
Shaw, S., 1976: "Sport and politics: The case for South Africa". In: CAHPER Journal43(1), 30-8.
55.
Shaw, T., and Shaw, S., 1977: "Sport as transnational politics: analysis of Africa". In: Journal of Sport and Social Issues1 (2), 54-79.
56.
Sklair, L., 1991: Sociology of the Global System. New York, Harvester-Wheatsheaf. Smith, C., January 1992: "Inside Track". Athletics.
57.
Strenk, A., 1978: "Back to the very first day: Eighty years of politics in the Olympic Games". In: Journal of Sport and Social Issues2 (1), 24-36.
58.
Taylor, T., 1988: "Politics and the Seoul Olympics". In: The Pacific Review1 (2), 190-95.
59.
Triesman, D., 1984: "The Olympic Games as a political forum". In: A. Tomlinson and G. Whannel (eds.): Five-Ring Circus: Money, Power and Politics at the Olympic Games. London, Pluto Press.
60.
Weber, M., 1947: The Theory of Social and Economic New York, The Free Press.
61.
Wren, C., 24 March 1991: "Olympic panel in South Africa, weighing a return to Games". In: New York Times.
62.
Zakus, D.H., 1992: "The International Olympic Committee: Tragedy, farce and hypocrisy". In: Sociology of Sport Journal9 (4), 340-53.
