Lean as ideology and practice: A comparative study of the impact of lean production on working life in automotive manufacturing in the United Kingdom and Poland
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online June, 2016
Lean as ideology and practice: A comparative study of the impact of lean production on working life in automotive manufacturing in the United Kingdom and Poland
This article reports on research conducted at General Motors UK and Poland, BMW-UK and VW-Motor Poland. The development of a range of managerial practices at the workplace, often described as lean production techniques, is discussed. The focus is on the impact of the latter on employees’ quality of work-life. While advocates of lean, so-called leanistas, argue that the ‘right’ management cadre will allow the positive effects of lean to prevail, evidence confirming this assumption remains limited. In contrast to ‘lean ideology’, findings here highlight the deleterious effects of systems so defined on the quality of life at work and to workers’ health beyond employment.
Adler P (1995) Democratic taylorism: The toyota production system at NUMMI. In Babson S (ed.) Lean Work, Empowerment and Exploitation in the Global Auto Industry. Detroit: Wayne State University Press.
2.
Adler P (1998) Time and motion regained. Harvard Business Review January-February: 97–108.
3.
BrennerMDFairrisDRuserJ (2004) Flexible work practices and occupational safety and health: Exploring the relationship between cumulative trauma disorders and workplace transformation. Industrial Relations43(1): 242–266.
4.
CarterBDanfordAHowcroftD (2011) ‘All They Lack is a Chain': Lean and the new performance management in the British Civil Service. New Technology, Work and Employment26(2): 83–97.
5.
CarterBDanfordAHowcroftD (2012) ‘Nothing gets done and no one knows why’: PCS and workplace control of Lean in HM Revenue and Customs. Industrial Relations Journal43(5): 416–432.
6.
CarterBDanfordAHowcroftD (2013) ‘Stressed out of my box’: employee experience of lean working and occupational ill-health in clerical work in the UK public sector. Work, Employment & Society27(5): 747–767.
7.
CzarzastyJ (2014) Rokowania zbiorowe w cieniu globalizacji. Rola i miejsce związków zawodowych w korporacjach ponadnarodowych, Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Naukowe Scholar.
8.
ElgerTSmithC (2005) Assembling Work. Remaking Factory Regimes in Japanese Multinationals in Britain, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
9.
GarrahanPStewartP (1992) The Nissan Enigma: Flexibility at Work in a Local Economy, London: Mansell.
10.
HarleyB (1999) The myth of empowerment: work organisation, hierarchy and employee autonomy in contemporary Australian workplaces. Work, Employment and Society13(1): 41–66.
11.
HeadS (2003) The New Ruthless Economy: Work and Power in the Digital Age, Oxford: OUP.
12.
KochanTLansburyRMacDuffieJP (1997) After Lean Production, New York: Cornell University Press.
13.
LandsbergisPALessinNAdlerP (1998) Lean production and worker health: A discussion. New Solutions8(4): 499–523.
14.
LandsbergisPACahillJSchnallP (1999) The impact of lean production and related new systems of work organisation on worker health. Journal of Occupational health Psychology4(2): 108–130.
15.
LewchukWYatesCStewartP (2001) Quality of working life in the automobile industry: A Canada-UK comparative study. New Technology Work & Employment16: 72–87.
16.
MacDuffieJP (1988) The Japanese auto transplants: Challenges to conventional wisdom. ILR Report26(1): 12–18.
17.
MillerCCCardinalLBGlickWH (1997) Retrospective reports in organizational research: a re-examination of recent evidence. Academy of Management Journal40(1): 189–204.
18.
MooneyGLawA (2007) New labour/hard labour? Restructuring and resistance inside the welfare industry, Bristol: Policy Press, University of Bristol.
19.
MrozowickiAMaciejewskaM (2013) Conflicts at work in Poland's new capitalism: Worker resistance in a flexible work regime. In: GallG (ed.) New Forms and Expressions of Conflict at Work, Houndmills: Palgrave, pp. 191–211.
20.
Pernicka S, Glassner V, Dittmar N, et al. (2015) When does solidarity end? Transnational labour cooperation during and after the crisis – the GM/Opel case revisited. Economic and Industrial Democracy. Epub ahead of print 7 May 2015. DOI: 10.1177/0143831X15577840.
21.
PrabhuswamyMNageshPRavikumarK (2013) Statistical analysis and reliability estimation of total productive maintenance. IUP Journal of Operations Management12(1): 7–20.
22.
RinehartJHuxleyCRobertsonD (1997) Just Another Car Factory? Lean Production and its Discontents, Ithaca and London: ILR Press.
23.
Seddon J (2008) Systems Thinking in the Public Sector. The Failure of the Reform Regime and a Manifesto for a Better Way. Triarchy Press.
24.
SeddonJCaulkinS (2007) Systems thinking, lean production and action learning. Action Learning: Research and Practice4(1): 9–24.
25.
StewartP (2014) Lean Production and Globalisation: a “revolutionary” management agenda and the remaking of labour intensification? In: Martinez LucioM (ed.) International Human Resource Management: An Employee Relations Perspective, Los Angeles, London: Sage, pp. 137–158.
26.
StewartPMurphyK (2012) Cómo sobrevivir al posfordismo: despido y jubilación en la sociedad posfordista. Sociologia del Trabajo74: 31–46.
27.
Stewart P, Richardson M, Danford A, et al. (2009) We Sell Our Time No More. Workers’ Struggles Against Lean Production in the British Car Industry. London: Pluto Press.
28.
Taylor P, Carter R, Danford A, et al. (2010) Occupational Ill-Health and Absence Management Under a Lean Regime in the UK Civil Service. In: Work, Employment and Society Conference 2010, Brighton, UK.
