This paper investigates the internationalization of the commercial real estate markets of France and Germany, markets typically ignored in comparative political economy. Although both markets are embedded in Continental European capitalism, their trajectories of internationalization are variegated. After exploring how processes of internationalization are processed within each country, we show how these processes have played out in the commercial real estate markets of France and Germany. The French state played a key role in guiding processes of internationalization: the introduction of new tax regimes allowed French property companies to raise capital at the stock exchange. The case of Germany demonstrates the continued importance of the banking sector for real estate investment markets. Although the typical characteristics of the French and German political economies are strengthened in this process, agents also feel the need to respond to the interests of international investors by creating Real Estate Investment Trust-like systems to absorb domestic and foreign capital.
AlbertM (1991) Capitalisme Contre Capitalisme, Paris: Seuil.
2.
Amable B (2003) The Diversity of Modern Capitalism. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
3.
AMF (2003) La Création de L’autorité des Marchés Financiers. Report Annuel 2003. Paris: L’Autorité des Marchés Financiers.
4.
BallM (1994) The 1980s property boom. Environment and Planning A26(5): 671–695.
5.
BastardC (2011) Les Investissements en Immobilier D’entreprise des SCPI, Paris: CBRE Research.
6.
BaumA (2001) Evidence of cycles in European commercial real estate markets and some hypotheses. In: StephenJBrownCHL (eds) A Global Perspective on Real Estate Cycles, New York: SpringerAvailable at: http://centaur.reading.ac.uk/27213/.
7.
BerryJMcgrealSSoteloR (1999) An assessment of property investment vehicles with particular reference to German funds. Journal of Property Investment and Finance17(5): 430–443.
8.
BittererNHeegS (2012) Implementing transparency in an Eastern European office market: Preparing Warsaw for global investments. Articulo – Journal of Urban Research9: 1–15.
9.
BoisnierC (2011) Les sociétés immobilières d’investissement cotées (SIIC) ou French REITs: Foncière des régions et Unibail-Rodamco. Flux3(85–86): 89–104.
10.
BoyerR (1997) French statism at the crossroads. In: CrouchCStreeckW (eds) Political Economy of Modern Capitalism. Mapping Convergence and Diversity, London: Sage Publications, pp. 71–101.
11.
CBRE Research (2011) Market View Investment France. Paris: CBRE 4th quarter, 2011.
12.
CliftB (2012) Comparative capitalisms, ideational political economy and French post-dirigiste responses to the global financial crisis. New Political Economy17(5): 565–590.
13.
CoakleyJ (1994) The integration of property and financial markets. Environment and Planning A26: 697–713.
14.
Crouch C (2005) Capitalist Diversity and Change. Recombinant Governance and Institutional Entrepreneurs. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
15.
CrouchCLe GalèsP (2012) Cities as national champions?Journal of European Public Policy19(3): 405–419.
16.
CrouchCStreeckW (1997) Political Economy of Modern Capitalism. Mapping Convergence and Diversity, London: Sage Publications.
17.
CulpepperPD (2005) Institutional change in contemporary capitalism: Coordinated financial systems since 1990. World Politics57(2): 173–199.
18.
DeegRJacksonG (2007) The state of the art: Towards a more dynamic theory of capitalist variety. Socio-economic Review5: 149–179.
19.
De Vignet de VendeuilCLangenbachMSimonA (2007) Le Passage des SCPI aux OPCI: Quel Supplement de Rendement?, Paris: Université Paris Dauphine.
20.
DixonAD (2010) Variegated capitalism and the geography of finance: Towards a common agenda. Progress in Human Geography35(2): 193–210.
21.
EngelenEKoningsMFernandezR (2010) Geographies of financialization in disarray: The Dutch case in comparative perspective. Economic Geography86(1): 53–73.
22.
EnrightTE (2012) Building a Grand Paris: French Neoliberalism and the Politics of Urban Spatial Production, Santa Cruz: University of California, Santa Cruz.
23.
FernandezRAalbersMB (2016) Housing and the variations of financialized capitalism. Competition & Change20(2): 71–88.
24.
FernandezRHofmanAAalbersMB (2016) London and New York as a safe deposit box for the transnational wealth elite. Environment and Planning A48(12): 2443–2461.
25.
FichtnerJ (2014) Privateers of the Caribbean: The hedge funds – US–UK – offshore nexus. Competition & Change18(1): 37–53.
26.
FichtnerJ (2015) Rhenish capitalism meets activist hedge funds: Blockholders and the impact of impatient capital. Competition & Change19(4): 336–352.
27.
FSIF (2010) Les Sociétés D’investissement Immobilier Côtées: Une Réussite Française. Paris: Editions l’Abécédaire des Institutions.
28.
Garcia-Bernardo J, Fichtner J, Heemskerk EM, et al. (2017) Uncovering Offshore Financial Centers: Conduits and Sinks in the Global Corporate Ownership Network. Working paper. Available at: https://arxiv.org/abs/1703.03016 (accessed 26 April 2017).
29.
GlockBHäußermannH (2004) New trends in urban development and public policy in eastern Germany: Dealing with the vacant housing problem at the local level. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research28(4): 919–929.
30.
GothamKF (2012) Creating liquidity out of spatial fixity: The secondary circuit of capital and the restructuring of the US housing finance system. In: AalbersMB (ed.) Subprime Cities: The Political Economy of Mortgage Markets, Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, pp. 23–52.
31.
GuironnetAAttuyerKHalbertL (2015) Building cities on financial assets: The financialisation of property markets and its implications for city governments in the Paris city-region. Urban Studies53(7): 1442–1464.
32.
HaberlyDWójcikD (2015) Tax havens and the production of offshore FDI: An empirical analysis. Journal of Economic Geography15(1): 75–101.
Hall P and Soskice D (eds) (2001) Varieties of Capitalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
35.
Hancké B (1999) Revisiting the French Model: Coordination and Restructuring in French Industry in the 1980s. Leibniz: WZB Discussion Paper No. FS | 99-301.
36.
HardieIHowarthD (2009) Die krise but not la crise? The financial crisis and the transformation of German and French banking systems. Journal of Common Market Studies47(5): 1017–1039.
37.
HayC (2004) Common trajectories, variable paces, divergent outcomes? Models of European capitalism under conditions of complex economic interdependence. Review of International Political Economy11(2): 231–262.
38.
HeegSDörryS (2009) Leerstände und Bauboom – Büroimmobilien nur noch ein Anlageprodukt?Forschung Frankfurt26(3): 30–36.
39.
Hendrikse R (2015) The long arm of finance. Exploring the unlikely financialization of governments and public institutions. PhD Thesis, Universiteit van Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Offpage.
40.
HendrikseRPSidawayJD (2014) Financial wizardry and the Golden City: Tracking the financialc crisis through Pforzheim, Germany. Transactions39(2): 195–208.
41.
HimbertE (2014) Analysis of German Real Estate Funds: Selection Criteria for Investment Opportunities Perspective, Stockholm: KTH Architecture and the Built Environment.
42.
Höpner M (2007) Coordination and Organization The Two Dimensions of Nonliberal Capitalism. Cologne: MPiFG Discussion Paper 07/12.
43.
HöpnerMJacksonG (2006) Revisiting the Mannesmann takeover: How markets for corporate control emerge. European Management Review3: 142–155.
44.
HöpnerMKrempelL (2004) The politics of the German company network. Competition & Change8(4): 339–356.
45.
HowarthD (2013) France and the international financial crisis: The legacy of state-led finance. Governance: An International Journal of Policy, Administration, and Institutions26(3): 369–395.
46.
HowarthDQuagliaL (2013a) Banking on stability: The political economy of new capital requirements in the European union. European Integration35(3): 333–346.
47.
HowarthDQuagliaL (2013b) Banking union as Holy Grail: Rebuilding the single market in financial services, stabilizing Europe’s banks and ‘completing’ economic and monetary union. Journal of Common Market Studies51: 103–123.
48.
HowellC (2009) The transformation of French industrial relations: Labor representation and the state in a post-dirigiste era. Politics and Society37(2): 1–28.
49.
IEIF (2014) Annuaire des Sociétés Immobilières Cotées Européennes. SIIC, REITs et Foncières, Paris: IEIF les publications.
50.
JacksonGDeegR (2012) The long-term trajectories of institutional change in European capitalism. Journal of European Public Policy19(8): 1109–1125.
51.
JohalSLeaverA (2007) Is the stock market a disciplinary institution? French giant firms and the regime of accumulation. New Political Economy12(3): 349–368.
52.
JustT (2010) Internationalisierung des deutschen Büroimmobilienmarkts. Informationen zur Raumentwicklung. Heft 5/6/2010: 341–350.
53.
Kofner S (2012) Aktuelle Geschäftsmodelle von Finanzinvestoren im Themenfeld Wohnungswirtschaftlicher Wandel und neue Finanzinvestoren. Düsseldorf: Gutachten im Auftrag der Enquetekommission Wohnungswirtschaftlicher Wandel und Neue Finanzinvestoren auf den Wohnungsmärkten in NRW.
LapavitsasCPowellJ (2013) Financialisation varied: A comparative analysis of advanced economies. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society6(3): 359–379.
56.
Lehrer M and Celo S (2016) German family capitalism in the 21st century: patient capital between bifurcation and symbiosis. Socio-Economic Review 14(4): 729–750.
57.
LeitnerH (1994) Capital markets, the development industry, and urban office market dynamics: Rethinking building cycles. Environment and Planning A26(5): 779–802.
58.
LizieriC (2009) Towers of Capital. Office Markets & International Financial Services, Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.
59.
LizieriCMcAllisterPWardC (2003) Continental shift? An analysis of convergence trends in European real estate equities. Journal of Real Estate Research16(3): 339–356.
60.
LützS (2000) From managed to market capitalism? German finance in transition. German Politics9(2): 149–171.
61.
MertensD (2014) Privatverschulding in Deutschland. Institutionalistische und Vergleichende Perspektiven auf die Finanzialisierung Privater Haushalte, Köln: Max Planck Institute Köln.
62.
MertensD (2017) Putting ‘merchants of debt’ in their place: The political economy of retail banking and credit-based financialisation in Germany. New Political Economy22(1): 12–30.
63.
MichelsenCWeißD (2010) What happened to the East German housing market? A historical perspective on the role of public funding. Post-communist Economies22(3): 387–409.
64.
Morin F (2000) A transformation in the French model of shareholding and management. Economy and Society 29(1): 36–53.
65.
Nappi-Choulet I (1998) The Paris Office Market Crisis. Working Paper #293. Paris: ESSEC.
66.
Nappi-ChouletI (2012) Stratégies immobilières des fonds d’investissement opportunistes: La financiarisation du marché immobilier français. BSGlg58: 83–94.
67.
Nappi-ChouletI (2013) La financiarisation du marché immobilier francais: De la crise des années 1990 à la crise des subprimes de 2008. Revue D’Économie Financière2(110): 189–206.
68.
NölkeAHeiresMBielingH-J (2013) Editorial: The politics of financialization. Competition & Change17(3): 209–218.
69.
NölkeAVliegenthartA (2009) Enlarging the varieties of capitalism: The emergence of dependent market economies in East Central Europe. World Politics61(4): 670–702.
70.
O’SullivanM (2007) Acting out institutional change: Understanding the recent transformation of the French financial system. Socio-economic Review5: 389–436.
71.
PfnürA (2013) Economic Relevance of Corporate Real Estate in Germany, Darmstadt: Expert Opinion Commissioned by the Client Consortium BASF SE.
72.
PloegerR (2004) Regulating Urban Office Provision: A Study of the Ebb and Flow of Regimes of Urbanisation in Amsterdam and Frankfurt am Main, 1945–2000, Amsterdam: Amsterdam Institute for Social Science Research (AISSR).
73.
PrykeM (1994) Looking back on the space of a boom: (Re)developing spatial matrices in the City of London. Environment and Planning A26: 235–264.
SaviniFAalbersMB (2016) The de-contextualisation of land use planning through financialisation: Urban redevelopment in Milan. European Urban and Regional Studies23(4): 878–894.
77.
ScharmanskiA (2012) Im Sog der Euroschuldenkrise. Auswirkungen der Euroschuldenkrise auf den deutschen Immobilienmarkt, Hamburg: Quantum Fokus.
78.
SchmidtVA (2003) French capitalism transformed, yet still a third variety of capitalism. Economy and Society32(4): 526–554.
79.
ShonfieldA (1965) Modern Capitalism. The Changing Balance of Public and Private Power, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
80.
StockhammerE (2008) Some stylized facts on the finance-dominated accumulation regime. Competition & Change12(2): 184–202.
81.
StreeckW (1997) German capitalism: Does it exist? Can it survive?New Political Economy2(2): 237–256.
82.
StreeckW (2009) Re-forming Capitalism. Institutional Change in the German Political Economy, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
83.
StreeckW (2013) Gekaufte Zeit. Die Vertagte Krise des Demokratischen Kapitalismus, Berlin: Suhrkamp Verlag.
84.
Streeck W and Thelen K (eds) (2005) Beyond Continuity: Institutional Change in Advanced Political Economies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
85.
TheurillatTCorpatauxJCrevoisierO (2008) The impact of institutional investors on corporate governance: A view of Swiss pension funds in a changing financial environment. Competition & Change12(4): 307–327.
86.
TheurillatTRératPCrevoisierO (2014) The real estate markets: Players, institutions and territories. Urban Studies1(20): 1414–1433.
87.
UfferS (2011) The Uneven Development of Berlin’s Housing Provision, London: London School of Economics and Political Science.
88.
Van LoonJAalbersMB (2017) How real estate became ‘just another asset class’: The financialization of the investment strategies of Dutch institutional investors. European Planning Studies25(2): 221–240.
89.
VitolsS (2004) Negotiated shareholder value: The German variant of an Anglo-American practice. Competition & Change8(4): 357–374.
90.
VoigtländerM (2010) Der Immobilienmarkt in Deutschland. Struktur und Funktionsweise, Berlin: Verband deutscher Pfandbriefbanken.
91.
Wijburg G (2017) Privatised Keynesianism and the state-enhanced diversification of credit: the case of the French housing market. Leuven: REFCOM working paper.
92.
Wijburg G and Aalbers MB (2017) The alternative financialization of the German housing market. Housing Studies, DOI: 10.1080/02673037.2017.1291917.
93.
WissokerPFieldsDWeberRet al. (2014) Rethinking real estate finance in the wake of a boom: A celebration of the twentieth anniversary of the publication of the double issue on property and finance in Environment and Planning A. Environment and Planning A46(2): 697–713.
94.
ZysmanJ (1983) Governments, Markets, and Growth. Financial Systems and Politics of Industrial Change, Oxford: Martin Robertson.
