Musical Character and the Performance and Perception of Dotting,Articulation and Tempo in 34 Recordings of Variation 7 from J.S. Bach's Goldberg Variations (BWV 988)
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online July, 2008
Musical Character and the Performance and Perception of Dotting,Articulation and Tempo in 34 Recordings of Variation 7 from J.S. Bach's Goldberg Variations (BWV 988)
The performance of dotted rhythms has received considerable scholarly attention in the recent past. Historical musicologists mostly examined it in the context of baroque performance practice while music psychologists studied it primarily in relation to rhythm perception or emotion in music. This paper builds on our previous work that examined the perception of dotting in 34 commercial recordings of Bach's Goldberg Variations and its role in defining perceived musical character. In this study we compare this earlier data of perceived dotting, articulation and tempo with newly measured performed dotting, articulation and tempo in the same 34 recordings. We also investigate the relationship between performed parameters and judged musical character. Correlation analysis indicates a difference between performed and perceived dotting. It also shows that in a baroque piece of music where dotted rhythms are prevalent, performed dotting contributes less to judged musical character than do performed articulation and tempo. The results demonstrate that perceived dotting and judged character are at least as dependent on articulation and tempo as on performed dotting. On the basis of these findings the paper posits that the “dottedness” of an interpretation is more a judgment of musical character than an assessment of rhythmic execution.
AbravayaI. (1997). A French overture revisited. Early Music, 25 (1), 47–61.
2.
BachC. P. E. (1753). Versuch über die wahre Art das Clavier zu spielen. Berlin. Trans. by MitchellW. as: Essay on the True Art of Playing Keyboard Instruments. London: Eulenburg, 1974.
3.
BrosbolJ.SchubertE. (2006). Calculating articulation in solo music performances. Proceedings of the 9th International Conference of Music Perception and Cognition. Mario Baroni (ed). University of Bologna, Italy, August 22–26.
4.
CabreraD. (1999) “PsySound”: A computer program for the psychoacoustical analysis of music, MikroPolyphonie 5, Retrieved 28 February 2007, from http://www.mikropol.net.
5.
CollinsM. (1969). A reconsideration of French over-dotting. Music and Letters, 50 (1), 111–23.
6.
DartT. (1954). The interpretation of music. London: Hutchinson.
7.
DirstM. (1991). Bach's French overtures and the politics of overdotting. Early Music, 25 (1), 35–44.
8.
DolmetschA. (1949/1915). The interpretation of the music of the 17–18th centuries. London: Novello.
9.
DoningtonR. (1989/1963). The interpretation of early music. London: Faber.
10.
FabianD. (2003). Bach performance practice 1945–1975: A comprebensive review of sound recordings and literature. Aldershot: Ashgate (esp. chapter 6).
11.
FabianD.SchubertE. (2003–2004). Expressive devices and perceived musical character in 34 performances of Variation 7 from Bach's Goldberg Variations. Musicœ Scientiœ, Special issue 2003–2004, 49–68.
12.
FribergA.SundbergJ. (1995). Time discrimination in a monotonic, isochronous sequence, Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 98 (5), 2524–31.
13.
FribergA.SundströmA. (2002). Swing ratios and ensemble timing in jazz performance: Evidence for a common rhythmic pattern. Music Perception, 19 (3), 333–49.
14.
FullerD. (1977). Dotting, the “French style” and Frederick Neumanns Counter-Reformation. Early Music, 5 (4), 517–43.
15.
GabrielssonA. (1987). Once again: The theme from Mozart's Piano Sonata in A Major (K331). Action and Perception in Rhythm and Music (pp. 81–102). GabrielssonA. (ed), Stockholm: Royal Swedish Academy of Music No. 55.
16.
GabrielssonA.JuslinP. (1996). Emotional expression in music performance: Between the performer's intention and the listener's experience. Psychology of Music, 24 (1), 68–91.
17.
GabrielssonA.LindströmE. (2001). The influence of musical structure on emotional expression. In JuslinP. N.SlobodaJ. A. (eds), Music and emotion: Theory and research (pp. 223–48). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
18.
GoeblW.ParncuttR. (2001). Perception of onset asynchronies: Acoustic piano versus synthesized complex versus pure tones. Proceedings of the Meeting of the Society for Music Perception and Cognition (pp. 21–2). SMPC2001, Kingston, Ontario.
19.
GotliebH.KonečniVl. J. (1985). The effects of instrumentation, playing style, and structure in the Goldberg Variations of Johann Sebastian Bach. Music Perception, 3 (1), 87–102.
20.
HeflingS. (1993). Rhythmic alteration in seventeenth-and eighteenth-century music. New York: Schirmer.
21.
HevnerK. (1936). Experimental studies of the elements of expression in music. American Journal of Psychology, 48, 246–68.
22.
JuslinP.FribergA.BresinR. (2001–2002). Toward a computational model of expression in music performance: The GERM model. Musica Scientia, Special issue 2001–2002, 63–122.
Leech-WilkinsonD. (2001). Using recordings to study musical performances. In LinehaE. (ed), Aural history: Essays on recorded sound (pp. 1–12). London: British Library, National Sound Archive.
25.
LittleM. E. (2006a). Gigue. Grove Music Online, ed. MacyL. Retrieved 21 September 2006, from http://www.grovemusic.com.
26.
LittleM. E. (2006b). Siciliana [siciliano]. Grove Music Online, MacyL. (ed). Retrieved 21 September 2006, from http://www.grovemusic.com.
27.
LondonJ. (2004). Hearing in time: Psychological aspects of musical meter. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
28.
LoulieÉ. (1696). Éléments ou principes de musique. Paris: N. p.
29.
MallochW. (1997). Bach and the French ouverture. Musical Quarterly, 75 (2), 174–201.
30.
MendelA. (ed) 1952. Bach: St john Passion-Vocal Score. New York: Schirmer.
31.
NeumannF. (1965). La note pointée et la soi-disant « Manière Française ». Revue de Musicologie, 51, 66–92. Trans. as: The dotted note and the so-called French Style. Early Music, 5(3), 310–24.
32.
NeumannF. (1982). Essays in performance practice. Ann Arbor, Mich: UMI Research Press.
33.
NeumannF. (1993). Performance practices of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. New York: Schirmer.
34.
O'DonnellJ. (1979). The French Style and the overtures of Bach. Early Music, 7(2-3), 190–96, 336–45.
35.
OhgushiK. (2002). Comparison of dotted rhythm expression between Japanese and Western pianist. Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Music Perception and Cognition 17–21 July 2002 (pp. 250–53).
PontG. (1983). Handel's Overtures for harpsichord and organ. Early Music, 11 (3), 309–22.
38.
QuantzJ. J. (1752). Versuch einer Anweisung die Flöte traversiere zu spielen. Berlin. Trans. by ReillyE. as: On playing the flute. New York: Schirmer, 1975.
39.
Rellstab, (1790). C. P. E. Bach's Anfangstücke mit einer Anleitung für den Gebrauch dieser Stücke. Berlin, n. p.
40.
ReppB.WindsorL.DesainP (2002). Effects of tempo on the timing of simple musical rhythms. Music Perception, 19 (4), 565–93.
41.
SadakataM.OhgushiK.DesainP. (2004). A cross-cultural comparison study of the production of simple rhythmic pattern. Psychology of Music, 32 (4), 389–403.
42.
SchubertE. (2003). Update of the Hevner adjective checklist. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 96, 1117–22.
43.
SchubertE. (2004). Research in expressing continuous emotional response to music as a function of its acoustic parameters: Current and future directions. Paper presented at the 18th International Congress on Acoustics ICA 2004, April 4–9 (Kyoto: International Conference Hall).
44.
SchubertE.FabianD. (2001). Preference and perception in dotted 6/8 patterns by experienced and less experienced baroque music listeners. Journal of Music Perception and Cognition, 7(2), 113–32.
45.
SchubertE.FabianD. (2005). An experimental investigation of musical character portrayed by piano versus harpsichord performances of a J. S. Bach excerpt. Aesthetics and Experience in Music Performance (pp. 77–94).
SchwandtE. (1990). Questions concerning the Edition of the “Goldberg Variations” in the Neue Bach Ausgabe. Performance Practice Review, 3(1), 58–69.
48.
ShermanB. (1997). Inside early music. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press.
49.
TaruskinR. (1995). Text and act. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press.
50.
TürkD. G. (1789). Klavierschule, oder Anweisung zum Klavierspielen für Lehrer und Lernende. Leipzig-Halle. Trans, by HagghR. as: School of clavier playing. Lincoln-London: University of Nebraska Press, 1982.
51.
WallsP. (2003). History, imagination and the performance of music. Woodbridge: The Boydell Press.
WolffC. (ed) 1977. Bach: Goldberg Variations-Fourth Part of the Clavier Übung BWV988. Urtext of the New Bach Edition Kassel: Bärenreiter. Kritischer Bericht, NBA Series V, Bd. 2, Kassel: Bärenreiter.
