Creating a supranational institution: the role of the individual and the mood of the times

Abstract

This study notes that, while the research literature which addresses accounting change in different countries is preoccupied with issues such as economic and legal environment, culture and consensus, research in accounting history recognizes, in biographical studies, the role sometimes played by individuals in influencing the outcomes in moments where change takes place. The article looks at the case of the creation of the International Accounting Standards Committee and analyses the evidence concerning the roles of the central individuals, Henry Benson, Douglas Morpeth and Wally Olson. It concludes that while it is difficult to disentangle the strands of institutional politics and responses to prevailing policy issues, the individuals concerned did play major roles and there is a case for the intervention of individuals to be considered in the international accounting literature as one of the issues that helps build accounting infrastructure.

Keywords

accounting change accounting standards International Accounting Standards Committee

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Accountancy (1973), “International Accountancy: A Beginning”,Vol.85, No.963, pp. 4–5 .

Accountancy (1975), “Sir Henry Benson moves on from Coopers”, Vol.87, No.982, pp. 46–50 .

American Accounting Association (1977), “ Report of the AAA Committee on International Accounting Operations and Education ”, The Accounting Review, Vol.52, Supplement, pp. 65–101 .

Benson, H. (1981), “Establishing Standards Through a Voluntary Professional Process Across National Boundaries”, in Burton, J.C. (ed.), Arthur Young Professors Round Table, London: Arthur Young , pp.27–48.

Benson, H. (1989), Accounting for Life, London: Kogan Page .

Brennan, W.J. (ed.), (1979), The Internationalization of the Accountancy Profession, Toronto: Canadian Institute of Chartered Accountants .

Butterfield, H. (1955), “ The Role of the Individual in History ”, History, Vol.XL, No.138–9, pp. 1–17 .

Carlyle, T. (1840 [1993]), On Heroes, Hero-worship and the Heroic in History, Berkeley: University of California Press .

Carnegie, G.D. and Napier C.J. (1996), “ Critical and Interpretative Histories: Insights into Accounting's Present and Future through its Past ”, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, Vol.9, No.3, pp. 7–39 .

10.

Choi, F.D.S and Mueller, G.G. (1978), An Introduction to Multinational Accounting, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall .

11.

Defliese, P.L. (1981), “British Standards in a World Setting”, in Leach, R. and Stamp, E. (eds.), British Accounting Standards: The First Ten Years, Cambridge: Woodhead Faulkner , pp.105–118.

12.

Edwards, J.R. (1994), Twentieth Century Accounting Thinkers, London: Routledge .

13.

Forrester, D.A.R. (1993), Eugen Schmalenbach and German Business Economics, New York: Garland Publishing .

14.

Giddens, A. (1984), The Constitution of Society, Cambridge: Polity Press .

15.

Gray, S.J. (1988), “ Towards a Theory of Cultural Influence on the Development of Accounting Systems Internationally ”, Abacus, Vol.24, No.1, pp. 1–15 .

16.

Hofstede, G. (1980), Culture's Consequences, London: Sage .

17.

Lee, T. (1996),”Preface”, in Lee,T. (ed.), Shaping the Accountancy Profession: The Story of Three Scottish Pioneers, New York: Garland Publishing , pp.ix–xv.

18.

Lemarchand, Y. (1993), Du Déperissement à l'amortissement: Enquête sur l'histoire d'un Concept et de sa Traduction Comptable [From Dilapidation to Depreciation: An Enquiry into the History of a Concept and its Translation in Accounting], Nantes: Editions Ouest.

19.

Meek, G. (2002), “Accounting in the United States”, in Walton, P. , Haller, A. and Raffournier, B. (eds.), International Accounting, second edition, London: Thomson Business Press , pp.66–90.

20.

Mueller, G.G. (1968), “ Accounting Principles Generally Accepted in the United States versus those Generally Accepted Elsewhere ”, International Journal of Accounting Education and Research, Vol.3, Spring, pp. 91–103 .

21.

Napier, C. (1995), “The History of Financial Reporting in the UK”, in Walton, P.J. (ed.), European Financial Reporting: A History, London: Academic Press , pp.259–283.

22.

Nikitin, M. (1996), “ The Birth of Industrial Accounting in France: The Role of PierreAntoine Godard-Demarest (1767–1850) as Strategist, Industrialist and Accountant at the Baccarat Crystalworks ”, Accounting, Business and Financial History, Vol.6, No.1, pp. 93–110 .

23.

Nobes, C.N. (1984), International Classification of Financial Reporting, London: Croom Helm .

24.

Olson, W.E. (1982), The Accounting Profession, Years of Trial: 1969–1980, New York: AICPA .

25.

Standish, P.E.M. (1990), “ Origins of the Plan Comptable Général: A Study in Cultural Intrusion and Reaction ”, Accounting and Business Research, Vol.20, No.80, pp. 337–351 .

26.

Walton, P.J. (1998), “Accountancy: The Most Exciting Profession in the World”, Accounting & Business, June, pp.12–13.

27.

Walton, P.J. (2002), “Henry Benson”, in Warner, M. (ed.), International Encyclopedia of Business and Management, second edition, London: Thomson , pp.482–486.

28.

Who's Who (2006), 156th Edition, London: A&C Black .