Compulsory treatment in psychiatry is controversial and its use has been increasingly critiqued following the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities in 2006. This essay seeks to explore whether the restriction of personal liberty and autonomy that compulsory treatment requires can be justified on ethical or medical grounds.
Conclusions:
Compulsory treatment is not without potential harms to the doctor–patient therapeutic relationship and patient engagement with mental health services. However, we contend that the clinical and societal benefits of compulsory treatment justify its practice and that, paradoxically, compulsory treatment is necessary for the restoration of a patient’s autonomy rather than its dispossession.
The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists. Powers and duties of psychiatrists in Australian and New Zealand Mental Health Acts: a literature review. Australas Psychiatry2017; 25: 426–426.
4.
TännsjöT.Coercive Care: The Ethics of Choice in Health and Medicine. London: Routledge, 1999.
5.
FreemanMKolappaKde AlmeidaJ, et al. Reversing hard won victories in the name of human rights: a critique of the General Comment on Article 12 of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. Lancet2015; 2: 844–850.
6.
De BhailísCFlynnE. Recognising legal capacity: commentary and analysis of Article 12 CRPD. Int J Law Context2017; 13: 6–21.
7.
MatthewsE.Autonomy and the psychiatric patient. J Appl Philos2000; 17: 59–70.
8.
De JongMKampermanAOorschotM, et al. Interventions to reduce compulsory psychiatric admissions: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Psychiatry2016; 73: 657–664.
9.
FazelSGulatiGLinsellL, et al. Schizophrenia and violence: systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS Med2009; 6: e1000120.
10.
KatsakouCPriebeS.Outcomes of involuntary hospital admission: a review. Acta Psychiatr Scand2006; 114: 232–241.
11.
GiaccoDPriebeS.Suicidality and hostility following involuntary hospital treatment. PLoS One2016; 11: 1–13.
12.
KortrijkHStaringAVan BaarsA, et al. Involuntary admission may support treatment outcome and motivation in patients receiving assertive community treatment. Soc Psych Psych Epid2010; 45: 245–252.
13.
LargeMSharmaSCannonE, et al. Risk factors for suicide within a year of discharge from psychiatric hospital: a systematic meta-analysis. Aust N Z J Psychiat2011; 45: 619–628.
14.
BarnettPMatthewsHLloyd-EvansB, et al. Compulsory community treatment to reduce readmission to hospital and increase engagement with community care in people with mental illness: a systematic review and meta-anlysis. Lancet Psychiatry2018; 5: 1013–1022.
15.
SweeneyAFilsonBKennedyA, et al. A paradigm shift: relationships in trauma-informed mental health services. BJPsych Adv2018; 24: 319–333.
16.
HöferFHabermeyerEMokrosA, et al. The impact of legal coercion on the therapeutic relationship in adult schizophrenia patients. PLoS One2015; 10: 1–11.
17.
GilburtHRoseDSladeM.The importance of relationships in mental health care: a qualitative study of service users’ experiences of psychiatric hospital admission in the UK. Health Serv Res2008; 8: 92–93.
18.
SheehanKBurnsT.Perceived coercion and the therapuetic relationship: a neglected association?Am J Psychiatry2011; 62: 471.
19.
PandarakalamJ.Formal psychiatric treatment: advantages and disadvantages. Br J Medical Pract2015; 8: 37–41.
20.
GrayB.Psychiatry and oppression: a personal account of compulsory admission and medical treatment. Schizophrenia Bulletin2009; 35: 661–663.
21.
BainbridgeEHallahanBMc GuinnessD, et al. Predictors of involuntary patients’ satisfaction with care: prospective study. BJPsych Open2018; 4: 452–500.
22.
DrewNFunkMTangS, et al. Human rights violations of people with mental and psychosocial disabilities: an unresolved global crisis. Lancet2011; 378: 1664–1675.
