A novel unmanned aircraft with solid-state control surfaces: Analysis and flight demonstration

Abstract

This article presents a completely servo-less, piezoelectric controlled, wind tunnel and flight tested, remotely piloted aircraft that has been developed by the 2010 Virginia Tech Wing Morphing Design Team (a senior design project between the Departments of Mechanical Engineering and Aerospace and Ocean Engineering). A type of piezocomposite actuator, the Macro-Fiber Composite, is used for changing the camber of all control surfaces on the aircraft. The aircraft is analyzed theoretically for its aerodynamic characteristics to aid the design of the piezoelectric control surfaces. A vortex lattice analysis complemented the database of aerodynamic derivatives used to analyze control response. Steady-state roll rates were measured in a wind tunnel and were compared to a similar aircraft with servomotor actuated control surfaces. The theoretical analysis and wind tunnel testing demonstrated the stability and control authority of the concept, culminating in the first flight of the completely Macro-Fiber Composite controlled aircraft on 29 April 2010. An electric motor-driven propulsion system is used to generate thrust, and all systems are powered with a single lithium polymer battery. This vehicle became the first completely Macro-Fiber Composite controlled, flight tested aircraft. It is also known to be the first fully solid-state piezoelectric material controlled, nontethered, flight tested fixed-wing aircraft.

Keywords

Solid-state control surfaces morphing variable camber piezoelectric material Macro-Fiber Composite

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

AM Power Systems Website. Available at: http://www.ampowersystems.net/thunder.htm

Barrett

(1990) Intelligent rotor blade actuation through directionally attached piezoelectric crystals. In: 46th American Helicopter Society national conference and forum, 21–23 May, Washington, DC.

Barrett

(1992) Actuation strain decoupling trough enhanced directional attachment in plates and aerodynamic surfaces. In: First European conference on smart structures and material, 12–14 May, Glasgow, UK.

Barrett

(1996) Active aeroelastic tailoring of an adaptive Flexspar stabilator. Smart Materials and Structures 5(6): 723–730.

Barrett

(2002) Convertible vertical take-off and landing miniature aerial vehicle. US Patent 6,502,787,22.

Barrett

(2004) Adaptive aerostructures: the first decade of flight on uninhabited aerial vehicles. In: Anderson

(ed.) Proceedings of SPIE, Smart Structures and Materials 2004: Industrial and Commercial Applications of Smart Structures, vol. 5388, pp. 190–201.

Barrett

Howard

(2000) Adaptive aerostructures for subscale aircraft. In: 20th Southeastern conference on theoretical and applied mechanics, 16–18 April, Pine Mountain, GA.

Barrett

Law

(1998) Design, fabrication and testing of a new twist-active wing design. In: Regelbrugge

(ed.) Proceedings of SPIE, Smart Structures and Integrated Systems, San Diego, CA, vol. 3329, pp. 33–41.

Barrett

Lee

(2000) Design criteria, aircraft design, fabrication and testing of sub-canopy and urban micro-aerial vehicles. In: AIAA/AHS international powered lift conference, November 2000, Alexandria, VA.

10.

Barrett

Stutts

(1997) Design and testing of a 1/12th scale solid state adaptive rotor. Smart Materials and Structures 6(4): 491–497.

11.

Barrett

Stutts

(1998) Development of a piezoceramic flight control surface actuator for highly compressed munitions. In: 39th structures, structural dynamics and materials conference, AIAA-98-2034, 20–23 April, Long Beach, CA.

12.

Barrett

Tiso

(2004) PBP adaptive actuators and embodiments. International Patent Filing from the Faculty of Aerospace Engineering, Technical University of Delft, International Patent Number PCT/NL2005/000054, 18 February 2005, The Netherlands.

13.

Barrett

Brozoski

Gross

(1997) Design and testing of a subsonic all-moving adaptive flight control surface. AIAA Journal 35(7): 1217–1219.

14.

Barrett

Burger

Melian

(2001) Recent advances in uninhabited aerial vehicle (UAV) flight control with adaptive aerostructures. In: 4th European demonstrators conference, December 2001, Edinburgh, UK.

15.

Barrett

Frye

Schliesman

(1998) Design, construction and characterization of a flightworthy piezoelectric solid state adaptive rotor. Smart Materials and Structures 7(3): 422–431.

16.

Barrett

Vos

Tiso

. (2005) Post-buckled precompressed (PBP) actuators: enhancing VTOL autonomous high speed MAVs. In: 46th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC structure, structural dynamics & materials conference, AIAA 2005-2113, 18–21 April, Austin, TX.

17.

Bernhard

APF

Chopra

(2001) Analysis of a bending-torsion coupled actuator for a smart rotor with active blade tips. Smart Materials and Structures 10(1): 35–52.

18.

Bilgen

(2010) Aerodynamic and electromechanical design, modeling and implementation of piezocomposite airfoils. PhD Dissertation, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA. Available at: http://scholar.lib.vt.edu/theses/available/etd-08142010-142319/

19.

Bilgen

Kochersberger

Inman

(2009) Macro-fiber composite actuators for a swept wing unmanned aircraft. Aeronautical Journal (Special issue on Flight Structures Fundamental Research in the USA) 113(1144): 385–395.

20.

Bilgen

Kochersberger

Inman

. (2010a) Macro-Fiber Composite actuated simply-supported thin morphing airfoils. Smart Materials and Structures 19: 055010.

21.

Bilgen

Kochersberger

Inman

. (2010b) Novel, bi-directional, variable camber airfoil via Macro-Fiber Composite actuators. Journal of Aircraft 47(1): 303–314.

22.

Bilgen

Kochersberger

Diggs

. (2007) Morphing wing micro-air-vehicles via Macro-Fiber-Composite actuators. In: 48th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC structures, structural dynamics and materials conference, AIAA-2007-1785, 23–26 April, Honolulu, HI.

23.

Bilgen

Kochersberger

Inman

. (2010c) Lightweight high voltage electronic circuits for piezoelectric composite actuators. Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures 21(14): 1417–1426.

24.

Cesnik

CES

Shin

(2001) On the twist performance of a multiple-cell active helicopter blade. Smart Materials and Structures 10(1): 53–61.

25.

Cesnik

CES

Shin

Wilbur

(2001) Dynamic response of active twist rotor blades. Smart Materials and Structures 10(1): 62–76.

26.

Crawley

Lazarus

Warkentin

(1989) Embedded actuation and processing in intelligent materials. In: 2nd international workshop on composite materials and structure for Rotorcraft, 14–15 September, Troy, NY.

27.

Derham

Hagood

(1996) Rotor design using smart materials to actively twist blades. In: Proceedings of the American Helicopter Society 52nd annual forum, 4–6 June, vol. 2, pp. 1242–1252, Washington, DC.

28.

Drela

(1989) XFOIL: an analysis and design system for low Reynolds number airfoils. In: Mueller

(ed.) Low Reynolds Number Aerodynamics (Lecture Notes in Engineering No. 54). Springer-Verlag.

29.

Drela

(2001) XFOIL 6.9 User Primer, XFOIL: Subsonic Airfoil Development System. Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Available at: http://web.mit.edu/drela/Public/web/xfoil/xfoil_doc.txt

30.

Drela

. AVL 3.26 User Primer. Available at: http://web.mit.edu/drela/Public/web/avl/avl_doc.txt

31.

Eggleston

Hutchison

Johnston

. (2002) Morphing aircraft design team. Virginia Tech Aerospace and Ocean Engineering Senior Design Project.

32.

Ehlers

Weisshaar

(1990) Static aeroelastic behavior of an adaptive laminated piezoelectric composite wing. AIAA Journal 28: 1611–1623.

33.

Ehlers

Weisshaar

(1992) Adaptive wing flexural axis control. In: Third international conference on adaptive structures, 9–11 November, San Diego, CA.

34.

Gault

(1949) Boundary-layer and stalling characteristics of the NACA 63-009 airfoil section. NACA TN no. 1984. Moffett Field, CA: Ames Aeronautical Laboratory, June 1949.

35.

Geissler

Sobieczky

Trenker

(2000) New rotor airfoil design procedure for unsteady flow control. In: 26th European rotorcraft forum, paper no. 31, 26–29 September, The Hague, The Netherlands.

36.

Giurgiutiu

(2000) Review of smart-materials actuation solutions for aeroelastic and vibration control. Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures 11: 525–544.

37.

Giurgiutiu

Chaudhry

Rogers

(1994) Engineering feasibility of induced-strain actuators for rotor blade active vibration control. In: Hagood

(eds) Proceedings of SPIE, Smart structures and materials ’94 conference, paper no. 2190-11, 13 February, Orlando, FL, pp. 107–122.

38.

Grohmann

Maucher

Jänker

(2006) Actuation concepts for morphing helicopter rotor blades. In: 25th international congress of the aeronautical sciences, 3–8 September, Hamburg, Germany.

39.

Grohmann

Maucher

Janker

. (2008) Embedded piezoceramic actuators for smart helicopter rotor blades. In: 49th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC structures, structural dynamics and materials, AIAA-2008-1702, 7–10 April, Schaumburg, IL.

40.

Hagood

Kindel

Ghandi

. (1993) Improving transverse actuation using interdigitated surface electrodes. In: Hagood

Knowles

(eds) Proceedings of SPIE, 1993 North American conference on smart structures and materials, SPIE paper no. 1917-25, 1 February, Albuquerque, NM, pp. 341–352.

41.

High

Wilkie

(2003) Method of fabricating NASA-standard Macro-Fiber Composite piezoelectric actuators. NASA/TM-2003-212427, ARL-TR-2833, June 2003.

42.

Janker

Kloppel

Hermle

. (1999) Development and evaluation of a hybrid piezoelectric actuator for advanced flap control technology. In: 25th European rotorcraft forum (ERF 1999), 14–16 September, Rome, Italy.

43.

Kim

Han

(2006) Smart flapping wing using Macro-Fiber Composite actuators. In: Matsuzaki

(ed.) Proceedings of SPIE, Smart Structures and Materials 2006: Smart Structures and Integrated Systems, 26 February, San Diego, CA, vol. 6173. pp. 1–9.

44.

Kim

Han

Kwon

(2009) Wind tunnel tests for a flapping wing model with a changeable camber using Macro-Fiber Composite actuators. Smart Materials and Structures 18 (2009) 024008 (8pp).

45.

Koratkar

Chopra

(2000) Development of a Mach-scaled model with piezoelectric bender actuated trailing-edge flaps for helicopter individual blade control (IBC). AIAA Journal 38(7): 1113–1124.

46.

Koratkar

Chopra

(2001) Wind tunnel testing of a Mach-scaled rotor model with trailing-edge flaps. Smart Materials and Structures 10(1): 1–14.

47.

Kovalovs

Barkanov

Gluhihs

(2007) Active twist of model rotor blades with D-Spar design. Transport 22(1): 38–44.

48.

Lazarus

Crawley

Bohlmann

(1991) Static aeroelastic control using strain actuated adaptive structures. Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures 2: 386–410.

49.

Lee

(1997) Design and testing of the kolibri vertical take-off and landing micro aerial vehicle. Final report for the Department of Defense Counterdrug Technology Office, November 1997.

50.

Lee

(1999) Design of high displacement smart trailing edge flap actuator incorporating dual-stage mechanical stroke amplifiers for rotors. PhD Dissertation, Department of Aerospace Engineering, University of Maryland, College Park, MD.

51.

Lee

Chopra

(2001a) Design of piezostack-driven trailing-edge flap actuator for helicopter rotors. Smart Materials and Structures 10(1): 15–24.

52.

Lee

Chopra

(2001b) Wind tunnel test of blade sections with piezoelectric trailing-edge flap mechanism. In: Proceedings of the 57th annual forum of the American Helicopter Society, 9–11 May 2001, Washington, DC, vol. 2, pp. 1912–1923.

53.

Munday

Jacob

(2001) Active control of separation on a wing with conformal camber. In: 39th aerospace sciences meeting and exhibit, AIAA-2001-293, 8–11 January, Reno, NV.

54.

Nelson

(1998) Flight Stability and Automatic Control. 2nd ed. Boston, MA: McGraw-Hill.

55.

Paradies

Ciresa

(2009) Active wing design with integrated flight control using piezoelectric macro fiber composites. Smart Materials and Structures 18 (2009) 035010 (9pp).

56.

Park

Kim

(2005) Analytical development of single crystal macro fiber composite actuators for active twist rotor blades. Smart Materials and Structures 14: 745–753.

57.

PBS NOVA, Making Stuff: Smarter (2011) Website for the show. Available at: http://video.pbs.org/video/1786635771/

58.

Pinkerton

Moses

(1997) A Feasibility Study to Control Airfoil Shape Using THUNDER. Hampton, VA: NASA Langley Research Center Technical Memorandum.

59.

Product sheet for SP5L type high-voltage diode. Available at: http://www.deantechnology.com/pdf/download/Diodes.pdf

60.

Product sheet for the MFC actuator. Available at: http://www.smartmaterial.us/media/Datasheet/MFC_ENG_WEB.pdf

61.

Raymer

(2006) Aircraft Design: A Conceptual Approach. Reston, VA: AIAA.

62.

Rodgers

Hagood

Weems

(1997) Design and manufacture of an integral twist-actuated rotor blade. In: Proceedings of the 38th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC structures, structural dynamics and exhibit, and AIAA/ASME/AHS materials conference and adaptive structures forum, AIAA-1997-1264, 7–10 April 1997, Kissimmee, FL.

63.

Shin

(2001) Integral twist actuation of helicopter rotor blades for vibration reduction. PhD Thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA.

64.

Shin

Cesnik

CES

Hall

(2002) Control of integral twist-actuated helicopter blades for vibration reduction. In: Proceedings of the 58th American Helicopter Society annual forum, 11–13 June, Montreal, Canada, vol. 2, pp. 2122–2134.

65.

Spangler

Hall

(1990) Piezoelectric actuators for helicopter rotor control. In: 31st AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC structures, structural dynamics and materials conference, AIAA-1990-1076, 2–4 April, Long Beach, CA.

66.

Steadman

Griffin

Hanagud

(1994) Structure-control interaction and the design of piezoceramic actuated adaptive airfoils. AIAA/ASME Adaptive Structures Forum, AIAA-1994-1747, 21–22 April, Hilton Head, SC.

67.

Straub

Anand

Birchette

. (2009) SMART rotor development and wind tunnel test. In: 35th European Rotorcraft Forum 2009 (ERF 2009), Article 1200, 22–25 September, Hamburg, Germany.

68.

Straub

Ngo

Anand

. (2001) Development of a piezoelectric actuator for trailing-edge flap control for full scale rotor system. Smart Materials and Structures 10(1): 25–34.

69.

TowerHobbies. R/C airplane kits. Available at: http://towerhobbies.com

70.

Vos

Barrett

Zehr

(2008) Magnification of work output in PBP class actuators using buckling/converse buckling techniques. In: 49th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC structures, structural dynamics and materials conference, AIAA 2008-1705, 7–10 April, Schaumburg, IL.

71.

Vos

De Breuker

Barrett

. (2007) Morphing wing flight control via postbuckled precompressed piezoelectric actuators. Journal of Aircraft 44(4): 1060–1068.

72.

VTWMD YouTube Link (2010a) Flight videos. Available at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQVG8FNK6es

73.

VTWMD YouTube Link (2010b) Operation and flight videos. Available at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v= KxTJBp53nO0

74.

Wang

Bartley-Cho

Martin

. (2001) Development of high-rate, large deflection, hingeless trailing edge control surface for the smart wing wind tunnel model. In: McGowan

(eds) Proceedings of SPIE, Smart Structures and Materials 2001: Industrial and Commercial Applications of Smart Structures Technologies, 4 March, Newport Beach, CA, vol. 4332.

75.

Wickramasinghe

Chen

Martinez

. (2009) Design and verification of a smart wing for an extremely-agile micro-air-vehicle. In: 50th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC structures, structural dynamics and materials conference, AIAA 2009-2132, 4–7 May, Palm Springs, CA.

76.

Wilkie

Bryant

High

. (2000) Low-cost piezocomposite actuator for structural control applications. In: SPIE 7th annual international symposium on smart structures and materials, 6 March, Newport Beach, CA.

77.

Wilkie

Inman

Lloyd

. (2006) Anisotropic laminar piezocomposite actuator incorporating machined PMN-PT single-crystal fibers. Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures 17(1): 15–28.

78.

Williams

(2004) Nonlinear mechanical and actuation characterization of piezoceramic fiber composites. PhD Dissertation, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA.