Impact of Caring for Terminally Ill Children on Physicians: A Systematic Scoping Review

Abstract

Introduction:

Caring for terminally ill children influences nurses’ and allied health provider’s quality of life, ability to provide personalized, dignified and empathetic care and even their concepts of personhood. In the absence of data this review utilizes the Ring Theory of Personhood (RToP) to evaluate how a physician’s concept of personhood is affected caring for terminally ill children in order to better support them holistically.

Methods:

Using PRISMA Guidelines, 14 researchers carried out independent searches of PubMed, CINAHL, PsycINFO, Cochrane Library and gray literature databases for articles published between 2000 to 2019. Concurrent and independent employment of content and thematic analysis (Split Approach) was used to enhance the trustworthiness of the analysis.

Results:

13,424 titles and abstracts were retrieved, 188 full texts were evaluated, and 39 articles were included and analyzed. Identical categories and themes identified using the Split Approach suggest that caring for dying children in PPC impacts the physician’s professional identity, clinical decision making, personal well-being and relationships. The data also suggests that the magnitude of these effects depends on the presence of protective and risk factors.

Conclusion:

Aside from providing a novel insight into the upon the physician, this review proffers a unique approach to accounting for the presence, magnitude and influence of incoming catalysts, resultant conflicts, and protective and risk factors upon the physician’s personhood. Further studies into the changes in personhood are required. Design of a personalized assessment tool based on the RToP will help direct timely, appropriate and personalized support to these physicians.

Keywords

personhood pediatric palliative care terminal ill physicians the ring theory of personhood selfhood burnout

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

WHO. Burn-out an “occupational phenomenon”: International Classification of Diseases. Published 2019. Accessed May 28, 2019. https://www.who.int/mental_health/evidence/burn-out/en/

Kitwood

TM.

Dementia Reconsidered: The Person Comes First. Open University Press; 1997.

Penrod

Kolanowski

Fick

Loeb

Hupcey

. Reframing person-centered nursing care for persons with dementia. Res Theory Nurs Pract. 2007;21(1):57–72.

Radha Krishna

Alsuwaigh

. Understanding the fluid nature of personhood—the ring theory of personhood. Bioethics. 2015;29(3):171–181.

Shanafelt

Boone

Tan

, et al. Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among US physicians relative to the general US population. Arch Intern Med. 2012;172(18):1377–1385.

Lancet. Physician burnout: a global crisis. Lancet. 2019;394(10193):93.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Information for Pediatric Healthcare Providers. Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-2019). Published 2020. Accessed 6 June 2020. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/pediatric-hcp.html

Vos

Craig

Cooper

. Existential therapies: a meta-analysis of their effects on psychological outcomes. J Consult Clin Psychol. 2015;83(1):115–128.

Alfried

. The search for meaning in life and the existential fundamental motivations. Existential Analysis. 2003;10(1):22–27.

10.

Zilboorg

. Fear of death. Psychoanal Quart. 1943;12(4):465–475.

11.

William

. The Varieties of Religion Experience. Longmans, Gren, Co. 1902;12:2014.

12.

Becker

. The Denial of Death. The Free Press; 1973.

13.

Ariès

. Western Attitudes Toward Death: from the Middle Ages to the Present. JHU Press; 1975:3.

14.

Barnard

. Attending to mystery in a world of problems: psychology, religion, and the personhood of physicians. J Med Human. 1990;11(3):129–134.

15.

Chochinov

McClement

Hack

Thompson

Dufault

Harlos

. Eliciting personhood within clinical practice: effects on patients, families, and health care providers. J Pain Symptom Manag. 2015;49(6):974–980.e972.

16.

Soh

TLGB

Krishna

LKR

Sim

Yee

ACP

. Distancing sedation in end-of-life care from physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia. Singapore Med J. 2016;57(5):220–227.

17.

Speraw

. “Talk to me—I’m human”: The story of a girl, her personhood, and the failures of health care. Qual Health Res. 2009;19(6):732–743.

18.

Tsai

DF-C

. How should doctors approach patients? A Confucian reflection on personhood. J Med Ethics. 2001;27(1):44–50.

19.

Mann

Cowburn

. Emotional labour and stress within mental health nursing. J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs. 2005;12(2):154–162.

20.

Bailey

Murphy

Porock

. Professional tears: developing emotional intelligence around death and dying in emergency work. J Clin Nurs. 2011;20(23-24):3364–3372.

21.

Entwistle

Watt

. Treating patients as persons: a capabilities approach to support delivery of person-centered care. Am J Bioeth. 2013;13(8):29–39.

22.

Fan

. Which care? Whose responsibility? And why family? A Confucian account of long-term care for the elderly. J Med Philos. 2007;32(5):495–517.

23.

Buron

Levels of personhood: a model for dementia care. Geriatr Nurs. 2008;29(5):324–332.

24.

Dennett

. Brainstorms: Philosophical Essays on Mind and Psychology. 1978. MIT Press; 1981.

25.

Locke

. An Essay Concerning Principles of Human Understanding. T Tegg and Son; 1836.

26.

Kant

. Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals. Riga, J.F. Hartknoch; 1785.

27.

Jowett

. The republic of Plato. Macmillan; 1888.

28.

Singer

. rethinking Life and Death. Oxford University Press; 1994.

29.

Fletcher

. Humanhood: Essays in Biomedical Ethics. Prometheus Books; 1979.

30.

Taylor

Sources of the Self: The Making of the Modern Identity. Harvard University Press; 1989.

31.

Clissett

Porock

Harwood

Gladman

. The responses of healthcare professionals to the admission of people with cognitive impairment to acute hospital settings: an observational and interview study. J Clin Nurs. 2014;23(13-14):1820–1829.

32.

Feinberg

Abortion. In: Matters of Life and Death. Temple University Press; 1980:256–294.

33.

Cranford

Smith

. Consciousness: the most critical moral (constitutional) standard for human personhood. AmJ Law Med. 1987;13(2-3):233–248.

34.

Radha Krishna

. Accounting for personhood in palliative sedation: the ring theory of personhood. Med Humanit. 2014;40(1):17–21.

35.

Radha Krishna

. Personhood within the context of sedation at the end of life in Singapore. BMJ Case Rep. 2013;2013. bcr2013009264-bcr2013009264.

36.

Krishna

. Palliative care imperative: a framework for holistic and inclusive palliative care. Ethics Med. 2013;29(1).

37.

Krishna

LKR

Alsuwaigh

Miti

Wei

Ling

Manoharan

. The influence of the family in conceptions of personhood in the palliative care setting in Singapore and its influence upon decision making. Am J Hosp Palliat Med. 2014;31(6):645–654.

38.

Krishna

LKR

Kwek

. The changing face of personhood at the end of life: the ring theory of personhood. Palliat Support Care. 2015;13(4):1123–1129.

39.

Krishna

LKR

. Addressing the concerns surrounding continuous deep sedation in Singapore and southeast Asia: a palliative care approach. J Bioeth Inq. 2015;12(3):461–475.

40.

Radha Krishna

Murugam

Quah

DSC

. The practice of terminal discharge: is it euthanasia by stealth? Nurs Ethics. 2018;25(8):1030–1040.

41.

ZJM

Krishna

LKR

Yee

CPA

. Chinese familial tradition and Western influence: a case study in Singapore on decision making at the end of life. J Pain Symptom Manage. 2010;40(6):932–937.

42.

Krishna

Yong

Koh

. The role of palliative rehabilitation in the preservation of personhood at the end of life. BMJ Case Rep. 2014;2014:bcr2014204780.

43.

Alsuwaigh

Krishna

. The compensatory nature of personhood. Asian Bioeth Rev. 2014;6(4):332–342.

44.

Krishna

Te Tay

Watkinson

Yee

ACP

. Advancing a welfare-based model in medical decision. Asian Bioeth Rev. 2015;7(3):306–320.

45.

Alsuwaigh

. How do English-speaking cancer patients conceptualise personhood? Ann Acad Med Singapore. 2015;44(6):207–217.

46.

Wei

Krishna

Kumar

. Respecting the wishes of incapacitated patients at the end of life. Ethics Med. 2016;32(1).

47.

Chang

Lim

Tay

, et al. The influence of evolving Confucian beliefs in the selection of proxy decision-makers at the end of life in Singapore. Asian Bioeth Rev. 2017;9(1-2):117–128.

48.

Darling

. Ecological systems theory: the person in the center of the circles. Res Hum Dev. 2007;4(3-4):203–217.

49.

Hobfoll

. The influence of culture, community, and the nested-self in the stress process: advancing conservation of resources theory. Appl Psychol. 2001;50(3):337–421.

50.

Lemonidou

Papathanassoglou

Giannakopoulou

Patiraki

Papadatou

. Moral professional personhood: ethical reflections during initial clinical encounters in nursing education. Nurs Ethics. 2004;11(2):122–137.

51.

Davey

Singh

. Metanarrative review: current status and opportunities for public health research. Int J Health Syst Dis Manage. 2013;1(2):59–63.

52.

Greenhalgh

Wong

. Training Materials for Meta-Narrative Reviews. Global Health Innovation and Policy Unit Centre for Primary Care and Public Health Blizard Institute, Queen Mary University of London; 2013.

53.

Osama

Brindley

Majeed

, et al. Teaching the relationship between health and climate change: a systematic scoping review protocol. BMJ Open. 2018;8(5):e020330.

54.

Wong

Greenhalgh

Westhorp

Buckingham

Pawson

. RAMESES publication standards: meta-narrative reviews. BMC Med. 2013;11(1):20.

55.

Pring

. The ‘false dualism’ of educational research. J Philos Educ. 2000;34(2):247–260.

56.

Crotty

The Foundations of Social Research: Meaning and Perspective in the Research Process. SAGE; 1998.

57.

Ford

. Taking a narrative turn: possibilities, challenges and potential outcomes. OnCUE J. 2012;6(1):23–36.

58.

Schick-Makaroff

MacDonald

Plummer

Burgess

Neander

. What synthesis methodology should I use? A review and analysis of approaches to research synthesis. AIMS Public Health. 2016;3(1):172–215.

59.

Peters

Godfrey

McInerney

Soares

Khalil

Parker

. The Joanna Briggs Institute reviewers’ manual 2015: methodology for JBI scoping reviews. Published 2015. Accessed April 29, 2019. http://joannabriggs.org/assets/docs/sumari/Reviewers-Manual_Methodology-for-JBI-Scoping-Reviews_2015_v1.pdf

60.

Peters

Godfrey

Khalil

McInerney

Parker

Soares

. Guidance for conducting systematic scoping reviews. Int J Evid Based Healthc. 2015;13(3):141–146.

61.

Pham

Rajić

Greig

Sargeant

Papadopoulos

McEwen

. A scoping review of scoping reviews: advancing the approach and enhancing the consistency. Res Synth Methods. 2014;5(4):371–385.

62.

Sambunjak

Straus

Marusic

. A systematic review of qualitative research on the meaning and characteristics of mentoring in academic medicine. J Gen Intern Med. 2010;25(1):72–78.

63.

Koh

ZYK

Yap

, et al. Assessing mentoring: a scoping review of mentoring assessment tools in internal medicine between 1990 and 2019. PloS One. 2020;15(5):e0232511.

64.

Hsieh

H-F

Shannon

. Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qual Health Res. 2005;15(9):1277–1288.

65.

Braun

Clarke

. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual Res Psychol. 2006;3(2):77–101.

66.

Sawatsky

Parekh

Muula

Mbata

Bui

. Cultural implications of mentoring in sub-Saharan Africa: a qualitative study. Med Educ. 2016;50(6):657–669.

67.

Popay

Roberts

Sowden

, et al. Guidance on the conduct of narrative synthesis in systematic reviews. A product from the ESRC Methods Programme Version. 2006;1:b92.

68.

Boyatzis

RE.

Transforming Qualitative Information: Thematic Analysis and Code Development. Sage; 1998.

69.

Voloch

K-A

Judd

Sakamoto

. An innovative mentoring program for Imi Ho’ola Post-Baccalaureate students at the University of Hawai’i John A. Burns School of Medicine. Hawaii Med J. 2007;66(4):102–103.

70.

Cassol

Pétré

Degrange

, et al. Qualitative thematic analysis of the phenomenology of near-death experiences. PloS One. 2018;13(2):e0193001.

71.

Stenfors-Hayes

Kalén

Hult

Dahlgren

Hindbeck

Ponzer

. Being a mentor for undergraduate medical students enhances personal and professional development. Med Teach. 2010;32(2):148–153.

72.

Neal

Lawlor

, et al.

What makes research useful for public school educators?

Adm Policy Ment Health. 2018;45(3):432–446.

73.

Wagner-Menghin

de Bruin

van Merriënboer

. Monitoring communication with patients: analyzing judgments of satisfaction (JOS). Adv Health Sci Educ. 2016;21(3):523–540.

74.

Elo

Kyngäs

. The qualitative content analysis process. J Adv Nurs. 2008;62(1):107–115.

75.

Mayring

. Qualitative content analysis. Companion Qualitative Res. 2004;1(2004):159–176.

76.

Humble

ÁM

. Technique triangulation for validation in directed content analysis. Int J Qual Methods. 2009;8(3):34–51.

77.

Sambunjak

Straus

Marušić

. Mentoring in academic medicine: a systematic review. JAMA. 2006;296(9):1103–1115.

78.

Boss

Geller

Donohue

. Conflicts in learning to care for critically ill newborns: “it makes me question my own morals”. J Bioeth Inq. 2015;12(3):437–448.

79.

Fanos

. “Coming through the fog, coming over the moors”: the impact on pediatric oncologists of caring for seriously ill children. J Cancer Educ. 2007;22(2):119–123.

80.

Shenoi

Kalyanaraman

Pillai

Raghava

Day

. Burnout and psychological distress among pediatric critical care physicians in the United States. Crit Care Med. 2018;46(1):116–122.

81.

Fields

Cuerdon

Brasseux

, et al. Physician burnout in pediatric critical care medicine. Crit Care Med. 1995;23(8):1425–1429.

82.

Weintraub

Geithner

Stroustrup

Waldman

. Compassion fatigue, burnout and compassion satisfaction in neonatologists in the US. J Perinatol. 2016;36(11):1021–1026.

83.

Profit

Sharek

Amspoker

, et al. Burnout in the NICU setting and its relation to safety culture. BMJ Qual Saf. 2014;23(10):806–813.

84.

Wolfe

Unti

. Critical care rotation impact on pediatric resident mental health and burnout. BMC Med Educ. 2017;17(1):181.

85.

Roth

Morrone

Moody

, et al. Career burnout among pediatric oncologists. Pediatr Blood Cancer. 2011;57(7):1168–1173.

86.

Garcia

Molon

, et al. Prevalence of burnout in pediatric intensivists: an observational comparison with general pediatricians. Pediatr Crit Care Med. 2014;15(8):e347–353.

87.

Crowe

Sullivant

Miller-Smith

Lantos

. Grief and burnout in the PICU. Pediatrics. 2017;139(5):e20164041.

88.

Hollingsworth

Wesley

Huckridge

Finn

Griksaitis

. Impact of child death on paediatric trainees. Arch Dis Child. 2018;103(1):14–18.

89.

Ffrench-O’Carroll

Feeley

Crowe

Doherty

. Grief reactions and coping strategies of trainee doctors working in paediatric intensive care. Br J Anaesth. 2019;123(1):74–80.

90.

de Boer

van Rosmalen

Bakker

van Dijk

. Appropriateness of care and moral distress among neonatal intensive care unit staff: repeated measurements. Nurs Crit Care. 2016;21(3):e19–27.

91.

Larson

Dryden-Palmer

Gibbons

Parshuram

. Moral distress in PICU and neonatal ICU practitioners: a cross-sectional evaluation. Pediatr Crit Care Med. 2017;18(8):e318–e326.

92.

Duncan

Arnon

DiPietrantonio

, et al. Pediatric liver transplant teams coping with patient death. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr. 2018;67(2):169–172.

93.

Papadatou

Bellali

Papazoglou

Petraki

. Greek nurse and physician grief as a result of caring for children dying of cancer. Pediatr Nurs. 2002;28(4):345–354.

94.

Twohig

Reulbach

Figuerdo

McCarthy

McNicholas

Molloy

. Supporting preterm infant attachment and socioemotional development in the neonatal intensive care unit: staff perceptions. Infant Ment Health J. 2016;37(2):160–171.

95.

Taubman-Ben-Ari

Weintroub

. Meaning in life and personal growth among pediatric physicians and nurses. Death Stud. 2008;32(7):621–645.

96.

Stenmarker

Palmerus

Marky

. Life satisfaction of Swedish pediatric oncologists: the role of personality, work-related aspects, and emotional distress. Pediatr Blood Cancer. 2009;53(7):1308–1314.

97.

Oates

. Stress and mental health in neonatal intensive care units. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed. 1995;72(2):F107–110.

98.

Bartel

Engler

Natale

Misra

Lewin

Joseph

. Working with families of suddenly and critically ill children: physician experiences. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2000;154(11):1127–1133.

99.

Lee

Dupree

. Staff experiences with end-of-life care in the pediatric intensive care unit. J Palliat Med. 2008;11(7):986–990.

100.

Serwint

Rutherford

Hutton

. Personal and professional experiences of pediatric residents concerning death. J Palliat Med. 2006;9(1):70–82.

101.

Fogaça

MDC

Carvalho

WBD

Nogueira-Martins

. Preliminary study about qualify of life of physicians and nurses working in pediatric and neonatal intensive care units. Revista da Escola de Enfermagem da USP. 2010;44(3):708–712.

102.

Klein

Bucher

Hendriks

, et al. Sources of distress for physicians and nurses working in Swiss neonatal intensive care units. Swiss Med Wkly. 2017;147:w14477.

103.

Stenmarker

Hallberg

Palmerus

Marky

. Being a messenger of life-threatening conditions: experiences of pediatric oncologists. Pediatr Blood Cancer. 2010;55(3):478–484.

104.

Fischer

Calame

Dettling

Zeier

Fanconi

. Experience and endocrine stress responses in neonatal and pediatric critical care nurses and physicians. Crit Care Med. 2000;28(9):3281–3288.

105.

Setou

Takada

. Associated factors of psychological distress among Japanese pediatricians in supporting the bereaved family who has lost a child. Kobe J Med Sci. 2012;58(4):E119–127.

106.

Gribben

Kase

Waldman

Weintraub

. A cross-sectional analysis of compassion fatigue, burnout, and compassion satisfaction in pediatric critical care physicians in the United States. Pediatr Crit Care Med. 2019;20(3):213–222.

107.

Granek

Barrera

Scheinemann

Bartels

. Pediatric oncologists coping strategies for dealing with patient death. J Psychosoc Oncol. 2016;34(1-2):39–59.

108.

Kirsch

Coronado

Roeleveld

Tweddell

Mott

Roth

. The burdens of offering: ethical and practical considerations. World J Pediatr Congenit Heart Surg. 2017;8(6):715–720.

109.

Epstein

. End-of-life experiences of nurses and physicians in the newborn intensive care unit. J Perinatol. 2008;28(11):771–778.

110.

Wocial

Ackerman

Leland

, et al. Pediatric ethics and communication excellence (PEACE) rounds: decreasing moral distress and patient length of stay in the PICU. HEC Forum. 2017;29(1):75–91.

111.

Kpassagou

Soedje

KMA

. Health practitioners’ emotional reactions to caring for hospitalized children in Lome, Togo: a qualitative study. BMC Health Serv Res. 2017;17(suppl 2):700.

112.

Kase

Waldman

Weintraub

. A cross-sectional pilot study of compassion fatigue, burnout, and compassion satisfaction in pediatric palliative care providers in the United States. Palliat Support Care. 2019;17(3):269–275.

113.

Tawfik

Phibbs

Sexton

, et al. Factors associated with provider burnout in the NICU. Pediatrics. 2017;139(5):e20164134.

114.

Genevro

Marshall

Miller

. Report on bereavement and grief research. Death Stud. 2004;28(6):491–575.

115.

DeSpelder

, Strickland AL. The Last Dance: Encountering Death and dying. Mayfield Publishing Co; 1996.

116.

DuBose

. The phenomenology of bereavement, grief, and mourning. J Relig Health. 1997;36(4):367–374.

117.

Letendre

. Organizational ethics. In: ten Have

HAMJ

Gordijn

(eds) Encyclopedia of Global Bioethics. Springer; 2015:1–10.

118.

Silva

Gibson

Sibbald

Connolly

Singer

. Clinical ethicists’ perspectives on organisational ethics in healthcare organisations. J Med Ethics. 2008;34(5):320–323.

119.

Hartman

. Moral philosophy, political philosophy, and organizational ethics: a response to Phillips and Margolis. Bus Ethics Q. 2001;11(4):673–685.

120.

Firth-Cozens

. Interventions to improve physicians’ well-being and patient care. Soc Sci Med. 2001;52(2):215–222.

121.

Bovier

Arigoni

Schneider

Gallacchi

. Relationships between work satisfaction, emotional exhaustion and mental health among Swiss primary care physicians. Eur J Public Health. 2009;19(6):611–617.

122.

Keeton

Fenner

Johnson

Hayward

. Predictors of physician career satisfaction, work–life balance, and burnout. Obstet Gynecol. 2007;109(4):949–955.

123.

Kwok

Calder

Barlow-Krelina

, et al. Implementation of a structured hospital-wide morbidity and mortality rounds model. BMJ Qual Saf. 2017;26(6):439–448.

124.

Benassi

MacGillivray

Silver

Sockalingam

. The role of morbidity and mortality rounds in medical education: a scoping review. Med Educ. 2017;51(5):469–479.

125.

Sikstrom

Saikaly

Ferguson

Mosher

Bonato

Soklaridis

. Being there: a scoping review of grief support training in medical education. PLoS One. 2019;14(11):e0224325.

126.

Fallek

Tattelman

Browne

Kaplan

Selwyn

PA. CE

: Original research: helping health care providers and staff process grief through a hospital-based program. Am J Nurs. 2019;119(7):24–33.

127.

Van Mol

Kompanje

Benoit

Bakker

Nijkamp

. The prevalence of compassion fatigue and burnout among healthcare professionals in intensive care units: a systematic review. PloS One. 2015;10(8):e0136955.

128.

Geurts

Schaufeli

De Jonge

. Burnout and intention to leave among mental health-care professionals: a social psychological approach. J Soc Clin Psychol. 1998;17(3):341–362.

129.

Ben-Dror

. Employee turnover in community mental health organization: a developmental stages study. Community Ment Health J. 1994;30(3):243–257.

130.

Razza

. Determinants of direct-care staff turnover in group homes for individuals with mental retardation. Ment Retard. 1993;31(5):284.

131.

Acker

. Burnout among mental health care providers. J Soc Work. 2012;12(5):475–490.

132.

Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. Impact of the DSM-IV to DSM-5 Changes on the National Survey on Drug Use and Health [Internet]. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (US); 2016.

133.

Weathers

Litz

Keane

Palmieri

Marx

Schnurr

. The PTSD checklist for DSM-5 (pcl-5). Scale available from the National Center for PTSD at www ptsd va gov. 2013;10.