The practice of routine medical circumcision of newborn male infants remains the norm in the United States, occurring to more than one million baby boys annually. This article examines the history and continuing debate surrounding this surgery, and places it within the context of gender identity. The rise of the activist anti-circumcision movement is described, as medical, moral, psychological, and legal issues surrounding this controversy are identified. The continuing practice of male circumcision is framed as an abusive wounding of males, which holds lifelong implications. A differentiation is made between the conventional medical amputation of the foreskin, from that which is solely ritual, religious-based. Further, a societal double standard is noted between the moral outcry against female circumcision and the relative silence toward male circumcision.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
SahliehAldeeb Abu S. A. (1994). To mutilate in the name of Jehovah or Allah: Legitimation of male and female circumcision. Medicine and Law, 13, 575–622.
2.
American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), Committee on the fetus and newborn. (1971). Standards and recommendations for hospital care of newborn infants (5th ed.), 110, Evanston, IL: AAP.
3.
American Academy of Pediatrics. (1984). Care of the uncircumcised penis. [Brochure].
4.
American Academy of Pediatrics. (1989). Report of the ad hoc task force on circumcision. Pediatrics, 84, 388–391.
5.
American College of Obstetricians & Gynecologists (ACOG). (1983). Guidelines for perinatal care. Washington, D.C.: Committee on Obstetrics, Maternal and Fetal Medicine.
6.
AnandK. J. S., & HickeyP. R. (1987). Pain and its effects in the human neonate. New England Journal of Medicine, 317, 1321–1329.
7.
BengstonB., & BaldwinC. (1993). The international student: Female circumcision issues. Journal of Multicultural Counseling and Development, 21(3), 168–173. [Special issue: Multicultural health issues].
8.
BigelowJ. (1992). The joy of uncircumcising: Restore your birthright and maximize sexual pleasure. Aptos, CA: Hourglass Book Publishing.
9.
BeniniF.JohnstonC.FaucherD., & ArandaJ. V. (1993, August 18). Topical anesthesia during circumcision in newborn infants. Journal of the American Medical Association, 270, 850–853.
10.
BitschaiJ. (1956). A history of urology in Egypt. Cambridge, MA: River-side Press.
11.
BoydB. R. (1990). Circumcision: What it does. San Francisco: Taterhill Press.
12.
BrietzkeC. E. (Ed.). (1996). Circumcision uncut. Men's Confidential, 12(3), 10–11.
13.
BriggsA. (1985). Circumcision: What every parent should know. Earlysville, VA: Birth & Parenting Publishers.
14.
BrigmanW. (1985). Circumcision as child abuse: The legal and constitutional issues. Journal of Family Law, 23(3), 337–357.
15.
BrownE. R. (1979). Rockefeller medicine men: Medicine and capitalism in America. Berkeley: University of California Press.
16.
CalderoneM. (1983, May-July). Fetal erection and its message to us. SEICUS Report, 9–10.
17.
CampbellJ. (with MoyersB.). (1988). The power of myth. New York: Doubleday.
Canadian Pediatric Society. (1996, March 15). Neonatal circumcision revisited. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 154(6), 769–780.
20.
CendronM.ElderJ. S., & DuckettJ. W. (1996). Perinatal urology. In GillenwaterJ. Y.GrayhackJ. T.HowardsS. S., & DuckettJ. W. (Eds.), Adult & pediatric urology (3rd ed., pp. 2149–2152). St. Louis: Mosley Yearbook.
21.
CohenM. S. (1992). Circumcision. In FowlerJ. F. (Ed.), Urologic surgery (pp. 422–428). Boston: Little, Brown.
22.
ColmanW. (1994). The scenes themselves which lie at the bottom of the story: Julius, circumcision, and the castration complex. Psychoanalytic Review, 81, 603–625.
23.
CoulterH. (1994). Divided legacy: A history of the schism in medical thought (4 volume series). Washington, D.C.: Wehawken.
24.
deMausseL. (1974). The history of childhood. New York: Peter Bedrick Books.
25.
DeMeoJ. (1990). Desertification and the origins of armoring: The Sahasasian connection. Journal of Orgonomy, 24, 99–110.
26.
FarrellW. (1986). Why men are the way they are. New York: McGraw-Hill.
27.
FarrellW. (1993). The myth of male power: Why men are the disposable sex. New York: Simon & Schuster.
28.
FreudS. (1913). Totem and taboo. Standard Edition, (13), 1–161.
29.
FrostN. (1992). Ethics, ethics everywhere. Current Problems in Pediatrics, 22(10), 422–423.
30.
GardinerD. (1949). The fate of the foreskin: A study of circumcision. British Medical Journal, 2, 1433.
31.
GelbaumI. (1993, Supplement. March/April). Circumcision: Refining a traditional technique. Journal of Mid-Wifery, 38, 18S–30S.
32.
GellisS. S. (1978). Circumcision. American Journal of Diseases of Childhood, 132, 1168.
33.
GluckmanG. R.StollerM. I.JacobsM. M., & KoganB. A. (1995). Newborn penile glans amputation during circumcision and successful reattachment. Journal of Urology, 153, 778–779.
34.
GoldbergH. (1976). The hazards of being male: Surviving the myth of masculine privilege. New York: Signet Book.
35.
GoldbergK. (1993). How men can live as long as women. Fort Worth, TX: The Summit Group.
36.
GoldmanR. F. (1997). Circumcision: The hidden trauma. Boston: Vanguard Publishing.
37.
GoldmanR. F. (1997). Questioning circumcision: A Jewish perspective (2nd ed.). Boston: Vanguard Publishing.
38.
GravesE. J. (1995). Detailed diagnoses and procedures: National hospital discharge survey, 1993, from the National Center for Health Statistics, Vital Health Statistics, 13, 122–128.
39.
GreenJ. (1991). The herbal male. City: The Crossing Press.
HicksE. K. (1993). Infibulation: Female mutilation in Islamic northeastern Africa. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publication.
42.
HoskenF. (1982). The Hosken report: Genital and sexual mutilation of females (Revised). Lexington, MA: Women's International Network News.
43.
HowardC. R.HowardF. M., & WeitzmanM. L. (1994). Acetaminophen analgesia in neonatal circumcision: The effect on pain. Pediatrics, 93, 624–628.
44.
International Conference on Population and Development. (1994, September 17). Knight-Ridder News Service.
45.
K., A. (1995). [Letter to the editor]. Mentor, 7(1), 6.
46.
KeenS. (1991). Fire in the belly. New York: Bantam Books.
47.
KennedyH. (1989). Sadomasochistic perversion in adolescence: A developmental-historical observation. Journal of Psychoanalytic Theory and Practice, 4, 348–360.
48.
KipnisA. (1991). Knights without armor. New York: Perigee Books.
49.
Lightfoot-KleinH. (Ed). (1989). Prisoners of ritual: An odyssey into female genital circumcision in Africa. Binghamton, NY: Haworth Press.
50.
MazisG. (1993). The trickster, magician and grieving man: Reconnecting men with earth. Santa FE, NM: Bear and Company.
51.
MillerA. (1991). Breaking down the wall of silence. New York: Dutton.
52.
MilosM., & MacRiD. (1992a, April 19). Body ownership rights of children: The circumcision question, [Speech at 22nd Annual Convention of American Atheists]. American Atheist, 50–59.
53.
MilosM., & MacRiD. (1992b, Supplement. March/April). Circumcision: A medical or a human rights issue?Journal of Mid-Wifery, 37(2), 87S–96S.
54.
MiyaP. (1994). Botched circumcisions. [Ethical dilemmas column] American Journal of Nursing, 94(3), 56.
55.
MoneyJ. (1989). Circumcision: Power and politics—2420 BC to 1989 AD. Zeitschrift fur Sexualforschung, 2(2), 171–176.
56.
MoneyJ. (1991). Sexology, body image, foreskin restoration, and bisexual status. Journal of Sex Research, 28(1), 145–156.
57.
MonickE. (1987). Phallos: Sacred images of the masculine. Toronto: Inner City Books.
58.
MorganW. (1965, July 19). The rape of the phallus [Commentary], Journal of the American Medical Association, 193(3), 123–124.
59.
MorrisD. (1973). Intimate behavior. New York: Bantam Books.
60.
MorrisD. (1985). Body watching. New York: Crown.
61.
NewmanR. (1991). Circumcision: The false initiation. Changing Men, 23, 19–21.
62.
NikuS. D.StockJ. A., & KaplanG. W. (1995). Neonatal circumcision. Urologic Clinics of North America, 22(1), 57–65.
63.
PeiM. (1965). The story of language. New York: Lippincott.
64.
PharisM., & EislerA. (1990). Psychological implications of childhood meatotomies. Child & Adolescent Social Work, 7, 461–474.
65.
PolandR. L. (1990). The question of routine neonatal circumcision. New England Journal of Medicine, 322, 1312.
66.
PurvisK. (1992). The male sexual machine: An owner's manual. New York: St. Martin's Press.
67.
RemondinoP. C. (1974). History of circumcision from the earliest times to the present. New York: AMS Press. (Original work published 1891).
68.
RitterT. (1992). Say no to circumcision!Aptos, CA: Hourglass Book Publishing.
69.
RodrickS. (1995, May 29). Unkindest cut: Anti-circumcision and penile restoration activism. The New Republic, 212.
70.
RombergR. (1985). Circumcision: The painful dilemma. South Hadley, MA: Bergen & Garvey Publishers.
71.
SchoenE. J. (1990). The status of circumcision of newborns. New England Journal of Medicine, 322, 1308–1312.
72.
SperlichB. K., & ConantM. (1994, June). Circumcision: Quality isn't the only dilemma [Letter to the editor]. American Journal of Nursing, 94, 16.
73.
StangH. J.GunnerM. R.SnellmanL.CondonL. M., & KesterbaumR. (1988). Local anesthesia for neonatal circumcision: Effects on distress and cortisol response. Journal of the American Medical Association, 259, 1507–1511.
74.
TaddioA.GoldbachM.IppM.StevensB., & KorenG. (1995, February 4). Effects of neonatal circumcision on pain responses during vaccination in boys. Lancet, 345, 291–292.
75.
TaylorJ. R.LockwoodA. P., & TaylorA. J. (1996, February). The prepuce: Specialized mucosa of the penis and its loss to circumcision, British Journal of Urology, 77, 291–295.
76.
ThompsonH. C.KingL. R.KnoxE., & KoronesS. B. (1975). Report of the ad hoc task force on circumcision. Pediatrics, 56, 610–611.
77.
ToubiaN. (1994). Female circumcision as a public health issue. New England Journal of Medicine, 331, 712–716.
78.
Van der KwaakA. (1992). Female circumcision and gender identity: A questionable alliance?Social Science and Medicine, 35, 777–787.
79.
WallersteinE. (1980). Circumcision: An American health fallacy. New York: Springer Publishing Company.
80.
WallersteinE. (1985). Circumcision: The uniquely American medial enigma. Urology Clinics of North America, 12, 123–132.
81.
WebbE., & HartleyB. (1994). Female genital mutilation: A dilemma in child protection. Archives of Disease in Childhood, 70, 441–444.
82.
WhippleJ. (1987). Circumcision: A conspiracy of silence. In AbbottF. (Ed.), New men, new minds (pp. 110–113) Freedom, CA: The Crossing Press.
83.
WilliamsN.ChellJ., & KapilaL. (1993). Why are children referred for circumcision?British Medical Journal, 306, 28–30.
84.
WilkesM. S., & BlumS. (1990). Current trends in routine newborn male circumcision in New York State. New York State Journal of Medicine, 90, 243–246.
85.
WiswellT. (1992). Circumcision: An update. Current Problems in Pediatrics, 22, 424–431.
86.
WiswellT., & HacheyD. O. (1993). Urinary tract infections and the uncircumcised state: An update. Clinical Pediatrics, 32, 130–134.
87.
WorthP. (1995, Fall). Beyond harm: The politics of circumcision. Man, Alive!: Journal of Men's Wellness, 8(3), 6–7.
88.
WranaP. (1939). Historical review: Circumcision. Archives of Pediatrics, 6, 385–392.
89.
ZindlerF. R. (1990, February). Circumcision: The stone age in the steel age. American Atheist, 34–40.
90.
ZoskeJ. (1996). Rethinking men's health and wellness. Wellness Management, 12(2), 1–6.
