The authors reanalyze Claessen’s data set on the “Early States.” Though Claessen’s Early State typology is largely justified, we suggest some corrections and amendments to his typologization and his model of Early State evolution. We show that the development of personal ownership of land correlates rather weakly with the political development of the Early State, and that political development might be accompanied by the strengthening of communal ownership. We also examine the correlation between Early State political development and ruler sacralization. Though this correlation is insignificant for the whole sample, its insignificance is accounted for by two distinct evolutionary patterns. The pattern observed in the “axial age” zone is characterized by a strong negative correlation between political development and ruler sacralization, while the pattern observed throughout the rest of the world is characterized by a strong positive correlation between the two variables. The authors discuss possible causes of this difference.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alaev, L. B. (1999). Chastnaja sobstvennost’ na zemlju v drevnej i srednevekovoj Indii [Private ownership of land in ancient and medieval India]. In L. S. Vasil’ev (Ed.), Chastnaja sobstvennost’ na Vostoke (pp. 94-119). Moskva, Russia: Institut ekonomicheskikh problem perekhodnogo perioda.
2.
Alaev, L. B. (2000). Problema sel’skoj obshchiny v klassovyh obshchestvakh [Village community in class societies]. In O. V. Volkova (Ed.), L. B. Alaev: obshchina v ego zhizni (pp. 168-181). Moskva, Russia: Vostochnaja literatura.
3.
Bargatzky, T. (1987). Upward evolution, suprasystem dominance, and the Mature State. In H. J. M. Claessen & P. van de Velde (Eds.), Early state dynamics (pp. 24-38). Leiden, the Netherlands: Brill
4.
Belkov, P. L. (1993). Problema genezisa gosudarstva: pererastaet li vozhdestvo v gosudarstvo? [The problem of state origin: Does chiefdom transform into state?] In I. V. Sledzevski (Ed.), Tsivilizatsii Tropicheskoj Afriki: obshchestva, kul’tury, jazyki (pp. 29-40). Moskva, Russia: Institut Afriki.
5.
Belkov, P. L. (1995). Rannee gosudarstvo, predgosudarstvo, protogosudarstvo: igra v terminy? [Early state, prastate, protostate: A notions game?] In V. A. Popov (Ed.), Rannie formy politicheskoj organizatsii: ot pervobytnosti k gosudarstvennosti (pp. 165-187). Moskva, Russia: Vostochnaja literatura.
6.
Berezkin, Yu. E. (1994). Apatani i drevneyshiy Vostok: al’ternativnaja model’ slozhnogo obshchestva [Apa Tanis and the ancient near east: Alternative model of complex society]. Kunstkamera: etnograficheskie tetradi, 4, 5-19.
7.
Berezkin, Yu. E. (1995a). Alternative models of middle range society. “Individualistic” Asia vs. “collectivistic” America? In N. N. Kradin & V. A. Lynsha (Eds.), Alternative pathways to early state (pp. 75-83). Vladivostok, Russia: Dal’nauka.
8.
Berezkin, Yu. E. (1995b). Vozhdestva i akefalnye sloznye obshchestva: arkheologicheskie dannye i ethnografichestke paralleli [Chiefdoms and acephalic complex societies: archaeological data and ethnographic parallels]. In V. A. Popov (Ed.), Rannie formy politicheskoj organizatsii: ot pervobytnosti k gosudarstvennosti (pp. 62-78). Moskva, Russia: Vostochnaja literatura.
9.
Berezkin, Yu. E. (1997). Amerika i Blizhniy Vostok: formy sotsiopoliticheskoi organizatsii v dogosudarstvennuiu epokhu [America and the Middle East. Forms of sociopolitical organization in the pre-state period]. Vestnik drevnej istorii, 2, 3-24.
10.
Berezkin, Yu. E. (2000). Once again on horizontal and vertical links in structure of the middle range societies. In N. N. Kradin, A. V. Korotayev, D. M. Bondarenko, V. de Munck, & P. K. Wason (Eds.), Alternatives of social evolution (pp. 220-224). Vladivostok, Russia: Far Eastern Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences.
11.
Bessmertnyj, Ju. L. (1969). Feofal’naja derevnja i rynok v Zapadnoj Evrope v XII-XIII vekakh [Feudal village and market in western Europe in the 12th and 13th centuries]. Moskva, Russia: Nauka.
12.
Bondarenko, D. M. (1995). Benin nakanune pervykh kontaktov s evropejtsami: Chelovek. Obshchestvo. Vlast’ [Benin on the eve of the first contacts with Europeans: Man. Society. Authority]. Moskva, Russia: Institut Afriki.
13.
Bondarenko, D. M. (1998). Kontseptsija “rannego gosudarstva”: osnovnye polozhenija i popytka ikh otsenki [The “early state” concept: Basic tenets and an attempt of their assessment]. In I. V. Sledzevski & D. M. Bondarenko (Eds.), Afrika: obshchestva, kul’tury, jazyki (pp. 16-26). Moskva, Russia: Institut Afriki.
14.
Burton, M. L., Moore, C. C., Whiting, J. W. M., & Romney, A. K. (1996). Regions based on social structure. Current Anthropology, 37, 87-123.
15.
Burton, M. L., & White, D. R. (1987). Cross-cultural surveys today. Annual Review of Anthropology, 16, 143-160.
16.
Burton, M. L., & White, D. R. (1991). Regional comparisons, replications, and historical network analysis. Behavioral Science Research, 25, 55-78.
17.
Carneiro, R. L. (1987). Cross-currents in the theory of state formation. American Ethnologist, 14, 756-770.
18.
Carneiro, R. L. (2000). The muse of history and the science of culture. New York: Kluwer Academic.
19.
Chase-Dunn, C., & Hall, T. D. (1997). Rise and demise. Comparing worldsystems. Boulder, CO: Westview.
20.
Claessen, H. J. M. (1984). The internal dynamics of the early state. Current Anthropology, 25, 365-370.
21.
Claessen, H. J. M. (1986). Kingship in the early state. Bijdragen tot de taal-, land-, en volkenkunde. Antropologica, 142(28), 113-127.
22.
Claessen, H. J. M.(1987). Kings, chiefs and officials: The political organization of Dahomey and Buganda compared. Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law, 25(26), 203-241.
23.
Claessen, H. J. M. (1996). State. In D. Levinson & M. Ember (Eds.), Encyclopedia of cultural anthropology (Vol. 4, pp. 1253-1257). New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
24.
Claessen, H. J. M. (2000). Structural change. Evolution and evolutionism in cultural anthropology. Leiden, the Netherlands: Universiteit Leiden.
25.
Claessen, H. J. M., & Oosten, J. G. (Eds.). (1996). Ideology and the formation of early states. Leiden, the Netherlands: Brill.
26.
Claessen, H. J. M., & Skalník, P. (Eds.). (1978). The early state. The Hague, the Netherlands: Mouton.
27.
Claessen, H. J. M., & Skalník, P. (Eds.). (1981). The study of the state. The Hague, the Netherlands: Mouton.
28.
Claessen, H. J. M., & van de Velde, P. (Eds.). (1987). Early state dynamics. Leiden, the Netherlands: Brill.
29.
Diakonoff, I. M., Neronova, V. D., & Sventsitskaja, V. A. (Eds.). (1989). Istorija drevnego mira [Ancient history] (Vol. 2). Moscow, Russia: Nauka.
30.
Dow, M. M., Burton, M. L., & White, D. R. (1981). Multivariate modeling with interdependent network data. Behavioral Science Research, 17, 216-245.
31.
Dow, M. M., Burton, M. L., & White, D. R. (1982). Network autocorrelation. Social Networks, 4, 169-200.
32.
Dow, M. M., Burton, M. L., White, D. R., & Reitz, K. (1984). Galton’s problem as network autocorrelation. American Ethnologist, 11, 754-770.
33.
Dumézil, G. (1958). L’idéologie tripartite des Indo-Européens (Vol. 31). Brussels, Belgium: Collection Latomus.
34.
Earle, T. K. (1978). Economic and social organization of a complex chiefdom: The Halelea district, Kaua’i, Hawaii. Ann Arbor: Michigan University Press.
35.
Earle, T. K. (1997). How chiefs come to power. The political economy in prehistory. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
36.
Earle, T. K. (2000). Hawaii (800-1824). In D. M. Bondarenko & A. V. Korotayev (Eds.), Civilizational models of politogenesis (pp. 73-86). Moscow, Russia: Institute for African Studies.
37.
Eisenstadt, S. N. (1982). The Axial Age: The emergence of transcendental visions and the rise of clerics. Archives Européennes de Sociologie, 2, 294-314.
38.
Eisenstadt, S. N. (Ed.). (1986). The origins and diversity of Axial Age civilizations. Albany: State University of New York Press.
39.
Ember, C. R., & Ember, M. (1998). Cross-cultural research. In H. R. Bernard (Ed.), Handbook of methods in cultural anthropology (pp. 647-690). Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira.
40.
Ember, M. (1971). An empirical test of Galton’s problem. Ethnology, 10, 98-106.
41.
Frantsouzoff, S. A. (1995). The inscriptions from the temples of Dhat Himyam at Raybun (tables I-II). Proceedings of the Seminar for Arabian Studies, 25, 15-27.
42.
Frantsouzoff, S. A. (1997). Regulation of conjugal relations in Ancient Raybun. Proceedings of the Seminar for Arabian Studies, 27, 47-62.
43.
Frantsouzoff, S. A. (2000). The society of Rayburn. In N. N. Kradin, A. V. Korotayev, D. M. Bondarenko, V. de Munck, & P. K. Wason (Eds.), Alternatives of social evolution (pp. 220-224). Vladivostok: Far Eastern Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences.
44.
Frazer, J. G. (1922). The golden bough (Vol. 1, abridged ed.). New York: Macmillan.
45.
Freud, S. (1923). Totem i tabu [Totem and taboo]. Petrograd, Russia.
46.
Fried, M. (1967). The evolution of political society: An essay in political anthropology. New York: Random House.
47.
Gellner, E. (1988). Plough, sword and book. London: Collins Harvill.
48.
Genicot, L. (1990). Rural communities in the medieval west. London: Harvard University Press.
49.
Geschiere, P. (1995). The complex interaction of state and society in postcolonial Africa. In M. A. van Bakel & J. G. Oosten (Eds.), The dynamics of the early state paradigm (pp. 7-22). Utrecht, the Netherlands: ISOR.
50.
Godiner, E. S. (1991). Politicheskaja antropologija o proiskhozhdenii gosudarstva [Political anthropology on the origin of the state]. In S. Ja. Kozlov & P. I. Puchkov (Eds.), Etnologicheskaja nauka za rubezhom: problemy, poiski, reshenija (pp. 51-77). Moscow, Russia: Nauka.
51.
Grinin, L. E. (1997). Formatsii i tsivilizatsii. Glava 4. Sotsial’nopoliticheskie, etnicheskie i dukhovnye aspekty sotsiologii istorii [Formations and civilizations. Chapter 4. Socio-political, ethnic, and spiritual aspects of sociology of history]. Filosofija i obshchestvo, 5, 5-64.
52.
Haas, J. (1982). The evolution of the prehistoric state. New York: Columbia University Press.
53.
Heusch, L. de. (1987). Ecrits sur la royauté sacreé. Bruxelles, Belgium: Editions de l’Université de Bruxelles.
54.
Jakobson, V. A. (1997). Gosudarstvo kak sotsial’naja organizatsija (teoreticheskie problemy) [State as social organization (theoretical aspects)]. Vostok/Oriens, 1, 5-15.
55.
Jaspers, K. (1953). The origin and goal of history. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
56.
Kochakova, N. B. (1996). Dvadtsatiletie issledovatel’skogo proekta “Rannee gosudarstvo” [The twentieth anniversary of “the early state” scholarly project]. Vostok/Oriens, 4, 191-199.
57.
Kochakova, N. B. (1999). Rannee gosudarstvo i Afrika (analiticheskij obzor publikatsij Mezhdunarodnogo issledovatel’skogo proekta “Rannee gosudarstvo”) [The early state and Africa (an analytic review of publications of “the early state” international scholarly project)]. Moscow, Russia: Institut Afriki.
58.
Kradin, N. N. (1998). “Rannee gosudarstvo”: kljuchevye aspekty kontseptsii i nekotorye momenty ejo istorii [“The early state”: Key aspects of the concept and some episodes of its history”]. In I. V. Sledzevski & D. M. Bondarenko (Eds.), Afrika: obshchestva, kul’tury, jazyki (pp. 4-15). Moscow, Russia: Institut Afriki.
59.
Kubbel’, L. E. (1988). Ocherki potestarno-politicheskoj etnografii [Essays of potestal and political ethnography]. Moscow, Russia: Nauka.
60.
Kullanda, S. (2002). Indo-European “kinship terms” revisited. Or does history begin where linguistics ends? Current Anthropology, 43, 103-104.
61.
Kullanda, S. V. (1995). Tsar’ bogov Indra: junosha - voin - vozhd’ [Indra, the tsar of gods: Youth - warrior - chief]. In V. A. Popov (Ed.), Rannie formy politicheskoj organizatsii: ot pervobytnosti k gosudarstvennosti (pp. 104-125). Moscow, Russia: Vostochnaja literatura.
62.
Lüdtke A. (Ed.). (1991). Herrschaft als soziale Praxis (Historische und sozialanthropologische Studien) [Dominance as social practice (Historical and social anthropological studies)]. Göttingen, Germany: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.
63.
Militarjov, A. Ju., & Shnirelman, V. A. (1984). K probleme lokalizatsii drevnejshikh afrazijtsev (opyt lingvo-arkheologicheskoj rekonstruktsii) [Localization of the most ancient Afrasians (A linguistic-archaeological reconstruction)]. In I. F. Vardul’, V. A. Dybo, P. M. Kozhin, A. Ju. Militarjov, & S. A. Starostin (Eds.), Lingvisticheskaja reconstruktsija i drevnejshaja istorija Vostoka (Vol. 2, pp. 35-53). Moskva, Russia: Nauka.
64.
Murdock, G. P. (1967). Ethnographic atlas: A summary. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
65.
Murdock, G. P., Ford, C. S., Hudson, A. E., Kennedy, R., Simmons, L. W., & Whiting, J. W. M. (1987). Outline of cultural materials. New Haven, CT: HRAF.
66.
Oosten, J. G., & van de Velde, P. (1994). Constructing the early state: The rise of a research programme. In M. van Bakel, R. Hagesteijn, & P. van de Velde (Eds.), Pivot politics. Changing cultural identities in early state formation processes (pp. 7-21). Amsterdam: Het Spinhuis.
67.
Pugach’jov, V. P., & Solov’jov, A. I. (2000). Vvedenie v politologiju [Introduction to political science]. Moskva, Russia: Aspekt.
68.
Shifferd, P. A. (1987). Aztecs and Africans: Political processes in twenty-two early states. In H. J. M. Claessen & P. van de Velde (Eds.), Early state dynamics (pp. 39-53). Leiden, the Netherlands: Brill.
69.
Smith, M. E. (1985). An aspectual analysis of polity formations. In H. J. M. Claessen, P. van de Velde, & M. E. Smith (Eds.), Development and decline. The evolution of sociopolitical organization (pp. 97-125). South Hadley, MA: Bergin & Garvey.
70.
Tokarev, S. A. (1990). Rannie formy religii [Early forms of religion]. Moskva, Russia: Politizdat.
71.
Vitkin, M. A. (1981). Marx and Weber on the primary state. In H. J. M. Claessen & P. Skalník (Eds.), The study of the state (pp. 443-454). The Hague, the Netherlands: Mouton.
72.
Webb, M. C. (1984). The state of the art on state origins? Reviews in Anthropology, 11, 270-281.
73.
White, D. R., Burton, M. L., & Dow, M. (1981). Sexual division of labor in African agriculture. American Anthropologist, 83, 824-849.
74.
Wikander, S. (1938). Der arische Männerbund. Studien zur Indo-Iranischen Sprach- und Religionsgeschichte [Arian men secret society. Studies of Indo-Iranian linguistic and religious history]. Lund, Sweden: Håkan Ohlssons Buchdruckerei.
