Analogical Reasoning and the Content of Creation Stories

Abstract

A long-standing question in sociology concerns preindustrial societies and the relationship between their subsistence technology and ideas about god. This article proposes a shift from questions regarding gods who now and then create to questions about creations that sometimes involve a god. For preindustrial societies, it addresses the relation between their subsistence technology and the content of their creation stories. This article's answer combines Hume's general hypothesis that people reason by analogy with Topitsch's specification that invokes vital, technical, and social analogies. This conjunction yields concrete hypotheses about the substance of creation stories in societies with varying levels of subsistence technology according to Lenski's typology. To test these hypotheses, the authors used Murdock's Standard Cross-Cultural Sample and the Human Relations Area Files. Field reports were coded for 116 preindustrial societies. The findings show that people use different thought models to explain the unknown, depending on the society's level of subsistence technology.

Keywords

creation stories creators religion evolution analogical thinking

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Albert, H. (2000). Kritischer rationalismus. [Critical Rationalism] . Tubingen, Germany: Mohr.

Bachofen, J.J. (1861). Das Mutterrecht. [Mother Right]. Stuttgart, Germany: Krais & Hoffmann.

Boas, F. (1911). The mind of primitive man. New York: Macmillan.

Cobb, M. (2006). The egg and sperm race. New York: Free Press.

Dawkins, R. (2006). The god delusion. London: Bantam .

Diamond, J. (1997). Guns, germs and steel. London: Cape.

Dow, J.W. (2006). The evolution of religion. Method and Theory in the Study of Religion, 18, 67-91.

Durkheim, E. (1897). Le suicide. Paris: Alcan.

Durkheim, E. (1912). Les formes élémentaires de la vie religieuse. [The Elementary Forms of Religious Life]. Paris: Alcan.

10.

Ember, C.R. , & Ember, M. (1988). Guide to cross-cultural research using the HRAF archive. New Haven, CT: HRAF Press .

11.

Evans-Pritchard, E.E. (1956). Nuer religion. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

12.

Frazer, J.G. (1890). The golden bough. New York : Macmillan.

13.

Gray, J.P. (1987). Do women have higher social status in hunting societies without high gods? Social Forces, 65, 1121-1131.

14.

Hewes, G.W. (1948). The rubric fishing and fisheries. American Anthropologist, 50, 238-246.

15.

Hope, C.A. , & Stover, R.G. (1984). Monotheism and gender status. Social Forces, 63, 335-348.

16.

Horton, R. (1967). African traditional thought and western science . Africa, 37, 50-71 and 155-187.

17.

Hume, D. (1757). Four dissertations. London : Millar.

18.

Jensen, A.E. (1939). Hainuwele. [Hainuwele]. Frankfurt am Main: Klostermann.

19.

Kaberry, P.M. (1939). Aboriginal women. London: Routledge.

20.

Knight, N. , Sousa, P. , Barrett, J.L. , & Atran, S. (2004). Children's attributions of beliefs to humans and God. Cognitive Science, 28, 117-126.

21.

Leach, E. (1966). Virgin birth. Proceedings of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 1966, 39-49.

22.

Leeming, D. , & Leeming, M. (1994). A dictionary of creation myths. New York: Oxford University Press.

23.

Lenski, G. (1970). Human societies. New York: McGraw-Hill.

24.

Lenski, G. (2005). Ecological-evolutionary theory. Boulder, CO: Paradigm.

25.

Levenstein, A. (1912). Die Arbeiterfrage. [The Workers' Question]. München: Reinhardt.

26.

Lukas, F. (1894). Das Ei als kosmogonische vorstellung. [The Egg as Cosmogonic Idea]. Zeitschrift des Vereins für Volkskunde , 4, 227-245.

27.

Makris, N. , & Pnevmatikos, D. (2007). Children's understanding of human and super-human mind. Cognitive Development, 22, 365-375.

28.

Malinowski, B. (1929). The sexual life of savages. London: Routledge.

29.

Meggers, B.J. (1952). Environmental limitation on the development of culture. American Anthropologist, 56, 801-824.

30.

Miller, J.D. , Scott, E.C. , & Okamoto, S. (2006). Public acceptance of evolution. Science, 313, 765-766.

31.

Monberg, T. (1975). Fathers were not genitors. Man , 10, 34-40.

32.

Montagu, A. (1937). Coming into being among the Australian Aborigines . London: Routledge.

33.

Moor, N. , Ultee, W. , & Need, A. (2007). Analogien, Subsistenztechnologien und (nicht-) moralische allmächtige Schöpfergötter in vorindustriellen Gesellschaften. [Analogies, Subsistence Technologies, and (Non-) Moral High Creator Gods in Pre-Industrial Societies]. Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie, 59, 383-409.

34.

Murdock, G.P. (1962). Ethnographic atlas. Ethnology , 1, 113-134.

35.

Murdock, G.P. , & White, D.R. (1969). Standard cross-cultural sample. Ethnology, 8, 329-369.

36.

Nolan, P. , & Lenski, G.E. (2006). Human societies (10th ed.). Boulder, CO: Paradigm.

37.

Norris, P. , & Inglehart, R. (2004). Sacred and secular: Religion and politics worldwide . Cambridge, UK; New York: Cambridge University Press.

38.

Peregrine, P. (1996). The birth of the gods revisited. Cross-Cultural Research, 30, 84-112.

39.

Pinker, S. (2002). The blank slate: The modern denial of human nature . New York: Viking.

40.

Roes, F.L. , & Raymond, M. (2003). Belief in moralizing gods. Evolution and Human Behavior, 24, 126-35.

41.

Sanday, P.R. (1981). Female power and male dominance: On the origins of sexual inequality. Cambridge, UK; New York: Cambridge University Press.

42.

Sheils, D. (1975). Toward a unified theory of ancestor worship: A cross-cultural theory. Social Forces, 54, 275.

43.

Snouck Hurgronje, C. (1889). Mekka. [Mecca]. Den Haag: Nijhoff.

44.

Sullerot, E. (1970). La femme dans le monde moderne. [Woman in the Modern World]. Paris: Hachette.

45.

Swanson, G.E. (1960). The birth of the gods: The origin of primitive beliefs. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

46.

Topitsch, E. (1954). Society, technology, and philosophical reasoning . Philosophy of Science, 21, 275-96.

47.

Topitsch, E. (1958). Vom Ursprung und Ende der Metaphysik. [On the Origin and End of Metaphysics]. New York: Springer.

48.

Topitsch, E. (1988). Erkenntnis und Illusion. [Knowledge and Illusion] Tubingen, Germany: Mohr.

49.

Tylor, E.B. (1871). Primitive culture. London: Murray.

50.

Underhill, R. (1974). Economic and political antecedents of monotheism . American Journal of Sociology, 80, 841-61.

51.

Weber, M. (1920). Gesammelte Aufsätze zur Religionssoziologie. [Collected Writings on the Sociology of Religion]. Tubingen, Germany: Mohr.

52.

Weber, M. (1921). Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft. [Economy and Society] . Tubingen, Germany: Mohr.

53.

Wilson, D.S. (2002). Darwin's cathedral. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.

54.

Wilson, D.S. (2005). Testing major evolutionary hypotheses about religion with a random sample. Human Nature, 16, 419-446.

55.

Wilson, E.O. (1975). Sociobiology. Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press.