An orthogonal factor analysis was applied to a phi coefficient matrix
composed of 78 cultural characteristics related to warfare. The first un-
rotated, the first two and the first six rotated factors were examined. A
clear bipolar warfare factor emerged in all three of these groups of factors,
which was also related to both crime and theft. Other characteristics re
lated to warfare were nonindulgent child-raising practices, emphasis on
achievement, narcissism (sensitivity to insult, boastfulness, display of wealth),
social anxiety, and punishment of pre- and extramarital sexuality. Techno
logical development, social complexity, and lineage were only minimally
related to warfare. Consequently, psychocultural dynamics evidently are
the primary factors related to aggression in cultures. Warlike cultures are
more restrictive and more punitive toward children and adults, and their
members are evidently less well adjusted than those in peaceful cultures.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ardrey, Robert1961African genesis, New York, Atheneum.
2.
1966The territorial imperative, New York, Atheneum.
3.
Bacon, Margaret K., Irvin L. Child, and Herbert Barry, Iii1963 "A cross-cultural study of correlates of crime," Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology66: 291-300.
4.
Bakan, David1966The duality of human existence, Chicago , Rand McNally.
5.
Barry, Herbert, III, Margaret K. Bacon , and Irvin L. Child1967 "Definitions, ratings, and bibliographic sources for child training practices of 110 cultures," in Cross-Cultural Approaches, Clellan S. Ford, ed., New Haven, HRAF Press: 293-331.
6.
Barry, Herbert, III, Irvin L. Child , and Margaret K. Bacon1959 "Relation of child training to subsistence economy," American Anthropologist61: 51-63.
7.
Becker, Wesley C.1964 "Consequences of different kinds of parental discipline," in Review of Child Development Research, Martin L. Hoffman and Lois W. Hoffman, eds., New York, Russell Sage Foundation: 1, 169-208.
8.
Berger, Bennett M.1967 "Hippie morality more old than new," Trans-Action5: 19-27.
9.
Bloombach, Milton1968 "Tribes and traits: a smallest space analysis of cross-cultural data," American Anthropologist70: 328-30.
10.
Bowden, Edgar1969 "An index of sociocultural development applicable to precivilized societies," American Anthropologist71: 454-61.
11.
Broch, Tom, and Johan Caltung1966 "Belligerence among the primitives: a reanalysis of Quincy Wright's data," Journal of Peace Research3: 33-45.
12.
Chagnon, Napoleon A.1968 "Yanomamö social organization and warfare," in War—The Anthropology of Armed Conflict and Aggression, Morton Fried, Marvin Harris , and Robert Murphy, eds., Garden City, National History Press: 109-59.
13.
Dollard, John, Leonard Doob, Neal Miller, Orval Mowrer, and Robert Sears1939Frustration and aggression, New Haven , Yale University Press.
14.
Driver, Harold E., and Karl F. Schuessler1967 "Correlational analysis of Murdock's 1957 ethnographic sample," American Anthropologist69: 332-52.
15.
Fesbach, Seymour1970 "Aggression," in Carmichael's Manual of Child Psychology, 3d ed., Paul H. Mussen, ed., New York, John Wiley: 2, 159-259.
16.
Ford, Clellan S., ed. 1967Cross-cultural approaches: readings in comparatice research, New Haven , HRAF Press.
17.
Ford, Clellan S., and Frank A. Beach1951Patterns of sexual behavior, New York , Harper & Brothers.
18.
Freud, Sigmund1924Beyond the pleasure principle (translated by C. J. M. Hub-back) , New York, Boni & Liveright .
19.
1930Civilization and its discontents, New York , J. Cape and H. Smith.
20.
Fried, Morton, Marvin Harris , and Robert Murphy, eds. 1968War-the anthropology of armed conflict and aggression, Garden City, Natural History Press.
21.
Galtung, Johan1968 "Peace," in International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, David L. Sills, ed., New York, Macmillan: 11, 487-96.
22.
Gay, Peter1966The Enlightenment: an interpretation, vol. 1, New York, Alfred A. Knopf.
23.
1969The Enlightenment: an interpretation, vol. 2, New York, Alfred A. Knopf.
24.
Gouldner, Alvin W., and Richard A. Peterson1962Notes on technology and the moral order, New York, Bobbs-Merrill .
25.
Graham, Hugh D., and Ted R. Gurr, eds. 1969Violence in America, historical and comparative perspectives, vols. I and 2, Washington, D.C., U.S. Government Printing Office.
26.
Guilford, Joy P.1965Fundamental statistics in psychology and education, 4th ed., New York, McGraw-Hill.
27.
Harley, John K.1963Adolescent youths in peer groups: a cross-cultural study, unpublished doctoral dissertation, Cambridge, Harvard University.
28.
Hickman, John M.1962 "Dimensions of a complex concept: a method exemplified ," Human Organization21: 214-18.
29.
Horton, Donald1943 "The functions of alcohol in primitive societies: a cross-cultural study," Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol4: 199-320.
30.
Köbben, André J. F.1967 "Why exceptions? The logic of cross-cultural comparison ," Current Anthropology8: 3-34.
31.
Lagacé, Robert O.1966 "Psychocultural analysis, cultural theory, and ethnographic research," Behavior Science Notes1: 165-99.
32.
Lambert, William W., Leigh Minturn Triandis, and Margery Wolf1959 "Some correlates of beliefs in the malevolence and benevolence of supernatural beings—a cross-cultural study," Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology58: 162-69.
33.
Lorenz, Konrad Z.1966On aggression, New York, Harcourt, Brace & World.
34.
McClelland, David C.1961The achieving society, Princeton, D. Van Nostrand.
35.
McClelland, David C., et al. 1953The achievement motive, New York, Appleton-Century-Crofts.
36.
Moore, Frank W., ed. 1966Readings in cross-cultural methodology (2d printing, reset), New Haven, HRAF Press.
37.
Murdock, George Peter1957 "World ethnographic sample," American Anthropologist59: 664-87.
38.
1966 "The Cross-Cultural Survey," in Readings in Cross-Cultural Methodology, Frank W. Moore , ed., New Haven, HRAF Press : 40-49.
39.
1967Ethnographic atlas: a summary, Pittsburgh , University of Pittsburgh Press.
40.
Murdock, George Peter, et al. 1962- "Ethnographic Atlas," Ethnology1 to date.
41.
Murphy, Robert F.1957 "Intergroup hostility and social cohesion," American Anthropologist n.s. 59: 1018-35.
42.
Nader, Laura1968"[Conflict:] IV. Anthropological aspects," in International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, David L. Sills, ed., New York, Macmillan : 3, 236-42.
43.
Naroll, Raoul1966 "Does military deterrence deter?" Trans-Action3, no. 2: 14-20.
44.
1968 "Some thoughts on comparative method in cultural anthropology ," in Methodology in Social Research, Hubert M. Blalock and Ann B. Blalock, eds., New York, McGraw-Hill: 236-77.
45.
1969 "Deterrence in history," in Theory and Research on the Causes of War, Dean G. Pruitt and Richard C. Snyder, eds., Englewood Cliffs, N.J., Prentice-Hall: 150-64.
46.
1970a "What have we learned from cross-cultural surveys?" American Anthropologist72: 1227-88.
47.
1970 b "Galton's problem, in A Handbook of Method in Cultural Anthropology , Raoul Naroll and Ronald Cohen, eds., Garden City, Natural History Press: 974-89.
48.
Naroll, Raoul, and Ronald Cohen, eds. 1970A handbook of method in cultural anthropology, Garden City, Natural History Press.
49.
Nunnally, Jum C.1967Psychometric theory, New York, McGraw-Hill.
50.
O'Leary, Timothy J.1969 "A preliminary bibliography of cross-cultural studies," Behavior Science Notes4: 95-115.
51.
Otterbein, Keith F.1968a "Cross-cultural studies of armed combat," BuffaloStudies4: 89-109.
52.
1968b "Internal war, a cross-cultural study," American Anthropologist70: 277-89.
53.
1968c "Military sophistication and territorial expansion; a cross-cultural study," American Anthropological Association, Bulletin1, no. 3: 105.
54.
1970The evolution of war; a cross-cultural study, New Haven, HRAF Press.
55.
Otterbein, Keith F., and Charlotte S. Otterbein1965 "An eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth; a cross-cultural study," American Anthropologist67: 1470-82.
56.
Roberts, John M., Malcolm J. Arth, and Robert R. Bush1959 "Games in culture," American Anthropologist61: 597-605.
57.
Rummel, Rudolf J.1970Applied factor analysis, Evanston, Northwestern University Press.
58.
Russell, Bertrand1929Marriage and morals, London, Horace Liveright.
59.
Sawyer, Jack, and Robert A. LeVine
60.
1966 "Cultural dimensions: a factor analysis of the World Ethnographic Sample," American Anthropologist68: 708-31.
61.
Schuessler, Karl F., and Harold E. Driver1956 "A factor analysis of sixteen primitive societies," American Sociological Review21: 493-99.
62.
Simmons, Leo W.1937 "Statistical correlations in the science of society," in Studies in the Science of Society, George Peter Murdock, ed., New Haven, Yale University Press: 495-517.
63.
1945The role of the aged in primitive society, New Haven, Yale University Press.
64.
Slater, Philip E.1965Culture, sexuality, and narcissism: a cross-cultural study, unpublished manuscript, Waltham, Brandeis University.
65.
1970The pursuit of loneliness; American culture at the breaking point, Boston, Beacon Press.
66.
Slater, Philip E., and Dori A. Slater1965 "Maternal ambivalence and narcissism: a cross-cultural study," Merrill-Palmer Quarterly of Behavior and Development11: 241-59.
67.
Spiro, Melford E.1965 "A typology of social structure and patterning of social institutions: a cross-cultural study," American Anthropologist67: 1097-1119.
68.
Stephens, William N.1962The Oedipus complex: cross-cultural evidence, New York, Free Press of Glencoe.
69.
Sumner, William Graham, AlbertGalloway Keller, and Maurice ReaDavie1927 The science of society, 4 vols., New Haven , Yale University Press.
70.
Swanson, Guy E.1960The birth of the gods: the origin of primitive beliefs , Ann Arbor, University of Michigan Press.
71.
Textor, Robert B.1967A cross-cultural summary, New Haven , HRAF Press.
72.
Tinbergen, Niko1968 "On war and peace in animals and man," Science160: 1411-18.
73.
Vayda, Andrew Peter1968 "Hypotheses about functions of war," in War—The Anthropology of Armed Conflict and Aggression, Morton Fried, Marvin Harris , and Robert Murphy, eds., Garden City, Natural History Press: 85-91.
74.
Veblen, Thorstein1919The nature of peace, New York, B. W. Huebsch.
75.
Whiting, John W. M.1968 "Methods and problems in cross-cultural research," in The Handbook of Social Psychology (2d ed.), Gardner Lindzey, and Elliott Aronson, eds., Reading, Mass. , Addison-Wesley: 2, 693-728.
76.
Whiting, John W. M., and Irvin L. Child1953Child training and personality: a cross-cultural study , New Haven, Yale University Press .
77.
Whiting, John W. M., Richard Kluckhohn, and Albert S. Anthony1958 "The function of male initiation ceremonies at puberty," in Readings in Social Psychology, 3d ed., Eleanor E. Maccoby, Theodore M. Newcomb, and Eugene L. Hartley, eds., New York, Holt, Rinehart & Winston: 359-70.
78.
Wright, Quincy1942A study of war, 2 vols., Chicago , University of Chicago Press (2d rev. ed., 1965).
