Long-Term Outcome of Anatomical Reconstruction Versus Tenodesis for the Treatment of Chronic Anterolateral Instability of the Ankle Joint: A Multicenter Study

Abstract

The long-term clinical outcome after anatomical reconstruction and tenodesis in the treatment of chronic anterolateral ankle instability was assessed in a retrospective multicentre study.

The first group (AR) consisted of 25 patients (mean age at operation 22 yrs ± 5.7) who underwent anatomical reconstruction and the second group (TE) of 29 patients (mean age 23 yrs ± 6.6) who underwent tenodesis. For both groups, the mean follow-up period was 12.3 yrs (AR ± 2.5 yrs, TE ± 2.7 yrs). At physical examination, there were significantly more patients in the TE group (n = 18) with a positive anterior drawer sign as compared with the AR group (n = 7) (p = 0.02). Medially located degenerative changes in the ankle joint as seen on standard radiographs were seen more often in the TE group (n = 7) than in the AR group (n = 1) (p = 0.03). The mean talar tilt, 4.7° in the AR group vs 6.9° in the TE group, (p = 0.02) and anterior talar translation, 2.9 mm in the AR group vs 4.3 mm in the TE group, (p = 0.04) were significantly higher in the TE group at radiographic stress examination. According to the rating system developed by Good et al. (1975), significantly fewer patients in the TE group (n = 8) had an excellent result as compared with the AR group (n = 15) (p = 0.03) and more patients in the TE group (n = 9) had a fair or poor result (p = 0.04) as compared with the AR group (n = 2).

We conclude that a tenodesis procedure does not restore the normal anatomy of the lateral ankle ligaments. When compared with anatomical reconstruction, a tenodesis leads to inferior results in terms of functional and mechanical stability, as well as overall satisfaction at long-term follow-up.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Broström

Sprained ankles IV. Surgical treatment of ‘chronic’ ligament ruptures. Acta Chir Scand 132: 551–65, 1966.

2. Castaing

Le Chevallier

P.L.

Meunier

Entorse à répétition ou subluxation récidivante de la tibio-tarsienne. Une technique simple de ligamentoplastie externe. Rev Chir Orthop 47: 598–608, 1961.

3. Chrisman

O.D.

Snook

G.A.

Reconstruction of lateral ligament tears of the ankle: an experimental study and clinical evaluation of seven patients treated by a new modification of the Elmslie procedure. J Bone Joint Surg (Am) 51: 904–12, 1969.

4. Colville

M.R.

Grondel

R.J.

Anatomic reconstruction of the lateral ankle ligaments using a split peroneus brevis tendon graft. Am J Sports Med 23: 210–3, 1995.

5. Elmslie

R.C.

Recurrent subluxation of the ankle joint. Ann Surg 19: 1392–5, 1934.

6. Evans

D.L.

Recurrent dislocation of the ankle. A method of surgical treatment. Proc Roy Soc Med 46: 343–4, 1953.

7. Gillespie

H.S.

Boucher

Watson-Jones repair of lateral instability of the ankle. J Bone Joint Surg (Am) 53: 920–4, 1971.

8. Good

C.J.

Jones

M.A.

Livingstone

B.N.

Reconstructions of the lateral ligament of the ankle. Injury 7: 63–5, 1975.

9. Gould

Seligson

Gassman

Early and late repair of lateral ligaments of the ankle. Foot Ankle 1: 84–9, 1980.

10.

10. Harrington

K.D.

Degenerative arthritis of the ankle secondary to long-standing lateral ligament instability. J Bone Joint Surg 61: 354–61, 1979.

11.

11. Hedeboe

Johannsen

Recurrent instability of the ankle joint: Surgical repair by the Watson-Jones method. Acta Orthop Scand 50: 337–40, 1979.

12.

12. Hennrikus

W.L.

Mapes

Rc.

Lyons

P.M.

Lapoint

J.M.

Outcomes of the Chrisman-Snook and modified Broström procedures for chronic lateral ankle instability. A prospective, randomized comparison. Am J Sports Med 24: 400–4, 1996.

13.

13. Karlsson

Bergsten

Lansinger

Peterson

Lateral instability of the ankle treated by the Evans procedure, a long-term clinical and radiological follow-up. J Bone Joint Surg (Br) 70: 476–80, 1988.

14.

14. Karlsson

Bergsten

Lansinger

Peterson

Surgical treatment of chronic lateral instability of the ankle joint. A new procedure. Am J Sports Med 17: 273–86, 1989.

15.

15. Karlsson

Bergsten

Peterson

Zachrisson

B.E.

Radiographic evaluation of ankle joint instability. Clin J Sports Med 1: 166–75, 1991.

16.

16. Karlsson

Lansinger

Lateral instability of the ankle joint. Clin Orthop & Rel Res 276: 253–61, 1992.

17.

17. Lanzetta

Meani

Inverate instability of the ankle as an outcome of capsulo-ligamentous lesions. It J Sports Traumatology 6: 311–3, 1984.

18.

18. Lee

H.G.

Surgical repair in recurrent dislocation of the ankle joint. J Bone Joint Surg (Am) 39: 828–34, 1957.

19.

19. Lindstrand

Mortensson

Anterior instability in the ankle joint following acute lateral sprain. Acta Radiol 18: 529–39, 1977.

20.

20. Liu

S.H.

Baker

C.L.

Comparison of lateral ankle ligamentous reconstruction procedures. Am J Sports Med 22: 313–7, 1994.

21.

21. Mabit

Chaudruc

J.M.

Fiorenza

Huc

Pecout

Lateral ligament reconstruction of the ankle: comparative study of peroneus brevis tenodesis versus periosteal ligamentoplasty. Foot and Ankle Surgery 4: 71–6, 1998.

22.

22. Nilsonne

Making a new ligament in ankle sprain. J Bone Joint Surg 14: 380–1, 1932.

23.

23. Reichelt

Weyrauch

H.J.

Beitrag zur operativen Behandlung von Bandverletzungen des oberen Sprunggelenkes. Unfallheilkunde 85: 427–30, 1982.

24.

24. Rosenbaum

Becker

Sterk

Gerngross

Claes

L.E.

. Long-term results of the modified Evans repair for chronic ankle instability. Orthopaedics 19: 451–5, 1996.

25.

25. Rosenbaum

Becker

Wilke

H.J.

Claes

L.E.

Tenodeses destroy the kinematic coupling of the ankle joint complex. A three dimensional in vitro analysis of joint movement. J Bone Joint Surg 80: 162–8, 1998.

26.

26. Stören

A new method for operative treatment of insufficiency of the lateral ligaments of the ankle joint. Acta Chir Scand 117: 501–9, 1959.

27.

27. Sugimoto

Takakura

Akiyama

Kamei

Kitada

Kumai

Long-term results of Watson-Jones tenodesis of the ankle. Clinical and radiographic findings after ten to eighteen years of follow-up. J Bone Joint Surg (Am) 80: 1587–96, 1998.

28.

28. Tegner

Lysholm

Rating systems in the evaluation of knee ligament injuries. Clin Orthop 198: 43–9, 1985.

29.

29. Van der Rijt

A.J.

Evans

G.A.

The long-term results of Watson-Jones tenodesis. J Bone Joint Surg (Br) 66: 371–5, 1984.

30.

30. Van Dijk

C.N.

Bossuyt

P.M.

Marti

R.K.

Medial ankle pain after lateral ligament rupture. J Bone Joint Surg (Br) 78: 562–567, 1996.

31.

31. Van Dijk

C.N.

Tol

J.L.

Verheyen

C.C.

A prospective study of prognostic factors concerning the outcome of arthroscopic surgery of anterior ankle impingement. Am J Sports Med 25(6): 737–45, 1997.

32.

32. Viernstein

Rosemeyer

Artmann

Eine Operationsmethode zur Behandlung der chronischen fibularen Bandinsuffizienz. Arch Orthop Unfallchir 78: 157–60, 1974.

33.

33. Wallenböck

Ledinski

Hofler

Spätergebnisse nach operativer Behandlung einer chronisch antero-lateralen Instabilität des oberen Sprunggelenks. Langenbecks Archiv für Chirurgie 378: 139–44, 1993.

34.

34. Watson Jones

Fractures and joint injuries. Vol 2, 4th Ed., E. and Livingstone Ltd. Edinburgh. 1960, pp. 821–3.

35.

35. Windfeld

Treatment of undue mobility of the ankle joint following severe sprain of ankle with avulsion of anterior and middle band of external ligament. J Bone Joint Surg (Am) 105: 299–344, 1953.

36.

36. Zenni

E.J.

Jr Grefer

Krieg

J.K.

Lambert

M.B.

Florez

Lateral ligamentous instability of the ankle: a method of surgical reconstruction by a modified Watson-Jones technique. Am J Sports Med 5: 78–83, 1977.