Despite the large potential role that community nurses have in providing individualized health promotion to older people, there is a lack of consensus in the literature regarding this role's effectiveness and efficiency. This article presents a literature review and synthesis of 12 randomized controlled trials selected from 344 published studies on preventive home visitation programs for older people. The findings suggest that a diversity of home visiting interventions carried out by nurses can favorably affect health and functional status, mortality rates, use of hospitalization and nursing homes, and costs. Further research is needed that focuses on the outcomes of quality of life, mental health, social support, caregiver burden, the acceptability of intervention, and specific subgroups of clients who benefit most. Findings also indicate the need for a theoretical foundation, increased emphasis on health-promotion strategies, and more research using a more complete economic evaluation to establish efficiency.
Alessi, C. A., H. U. Aronow, J. C. Beck, C. J. Bula, R. Fanello, M. Gold, R. Madison, L. Z. Rubenstein, F. Segal-Gidan, A. E. Stuck, and K. E. Yuhas. 1997. The process of care in preventive in-home comprehensive geriatric assessment. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society45:1044–1050.
2.
Anderson, G. F., and P. S. Hussey. 2000. Population aging: A comparison among industrialized countries. Health Affairs19:191–203.
3.
Bergman, H., F. Beland, P. Lebel, A. Contandriopoulos, P. Tousignant, Y. Brunelle, T. Kaufman, E. Leibovich, P. Rodriguez, and M. Clarfield. 1997. Caring for Canada's frail elderly population: Fragmentation or integration?Canadian Medical Association Journal157 (8): 1116–1120.
4.
Bernabei, R., F. Landi, G. Gambassi, A. Sgadari, G. Zuccala, V. Mor, D. Rubin, and P. Carbonin. 1998. Randomized trial of impact of model of integrated care and case management for older people living in the community. British Medical Journal316:1348–1351.
5.
Birch, A., and A. Gafni. 2003. Economics and the evaluation of health care programmes: Generalizability of methods and implications for generalizability of results. Health Policy64:207–219.
6.
Bowsher, J., M. Bramlett, I. M. Burnside, and S. H. Gueldner. 1993.Methodological considerations in the study of frail elderly people. Journal of Advanced Nursing18 (6): 873–879.
7.
Briggs, A. H.2001. Handling uncertainty in economic evaluation and presenting the results. In Economic evaluation in health care, edited by M. Drummond and A. McGuire, 173–214. London, UK: Office of Health Economics.
8.
Briggs, A. H., B. J. O'Brien, and G. Blackhouse. 2002. Thinking outside the box: Recent advances in the analysis and presentation of uncertainty in cost-effectiveness studies. Annual Review of Public Health23:377–401.
9.
Browne, G., J. Roberts, C. Byrne, A. Gafni, R. Weir, and B. Majumdar. 2001. The costs and effects of addressing the needs of vulnerable populations: Results of 10 years of research. Canadian Journal of Nursing Research33 (1): 65–76.
10.
Browne, G., J. Roberts, A. Gafni, C. Byrne, R. Weir, B. Majumdar, and S. Watt. 1999. Economic evaluations of community-based care: Lessons from twelve studies in Ontario. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice5 (3): 1–19.
11.
Browne, G., J. Roberts, R. Weir, A. Gafni, S. Watt, and C. Byrne. 1993. The cost of poor adjustment to chronic illness: Lessons from 3 studies. Health and Social Care2:85–93.
12.
Bula, C. J., A. C. Berod, A. E. Stuck, C. A. Alessi, H. U. Aronow, B. Santos-Eggimann, L. Z. Rubenstein, and J. C. Beck. 1999. Effectiveness of preventive in-home geri atric assessment in well functioning, community-dwelling older people: Secondary analysis of a randomized trial. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society47 (4): 389–395.
13.
Byles, J. E.2000. A thorough going over: Evidence for health assessments for older persons. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health24 (2): 117–123.
14.
Clark, R.1996. Home and community-based care: The U.S. example. Canadian Journal on Aging15 (1): 91–102.
15.
Cook, D. J., D. L. Sackett, and W. O. Spitzer. 1995. Methodological guidelines for systematic reviews of randomized control trials in health care from the Potsdam consultation on meta-analysis. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology48 (1): 167–171.
16.
Cox, C.1993. The frail elderly: Problems, needs and community responses. Westport, CT: Auburn House.
17.
Dalby, D. M., J. W. Sellors, F. D. Fraser, C. Fraser, C. van Ineveld, and M. Howard. 2000. Effect of preventive home visits by a nurse on the outcomes of frail elderly people in the community: A randomized controlled trial. Canadian Medical Association Journal162 (4): 497–500.
18.
DiCenso, A., G. Guyatt, and D. Ciliska. 2005. Evidence-based nursing: A guide to clinical practice. St. Louis, MO: Mosby.
19.
Drummond, M. F., B. O'Brien, G. L. Stoddart, and G. W. Torrance. 1997. Methods for the economic evaluation of health care programmes. 2d ed.Toronto, Canada: Oxford University Press.
20.
Elkan, R., and D. Kendrick. 2004. What is the effectiveness of home visiting or home-based support for older people?World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe. Retrieved June 2003 from the http://www.euro.who.int/HEN/Syntheses/homesupport/20040614_4.
21.
Elkan, R., D. Kendrick, M. Dewey, M. Hewitt, J. Robinson, M. Blair, D. Williams, and K. Brummell. 2001. Effectiveness of home-based support for older people: Systematic review and meta-analysis. British Medical Journal323:1–8.
22.
Elkan, R., D. Kendrick, M. Hewitt, J. J. A. Robinson, K. Tolley, M. Blair, M. Dewey, D. Williams, and K. Brummell. 2000. The effectiveness of domiciliary health visiting: A systematic review of international studies and selective review of the British literature. Health Technology Assessment4 (13): 1–339.
23.
Epp, J.1986. Achieving health for all: A framework for health promotion. Ottawa, Ontario: Health and Welfare Canada.
24.
Gill, D., and M. Sharpe. 1999. Frequent consulters in general practice: A systematic review of studies of prevalence, associations, and outcome. Journal of Psychosomatic Research47:115–130.
25.
Gold, M. R., J. E. Siegel, L. B. Russell, and M. C. Weinstein. 1996. Cost-effectiveness in health and medicine. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
26.
Green, J.2000. The role of theory in evidence-based health promotion practice. Health Education Research15 (2): 125–129.
27.
Green, J., and K. Tones. 1999. Towards a secure evidence base for health promotion. Journal of Public Health Medicine21 (2): 133–139.
28.
Gunner-Svensson, F., J. Ipsen, J. Olsen, and B. Waldstrom. 1984. Prevention of relocation of the aged in nursing homes. Scandinavian Journal Primary Health Care2:49–56.
29.
Hall, N., P. De Beck, D. Johnson, K. Mackinnon, G. Gutman, and N. Glick. 1992. Randomized trial of a health promotion program for frail elders. Canadian Journal on Aging11 (1): 72–91.
30.
Hebert, R.1997. Functional decline in old age. Canadian Medical Association Journal157 (8): 1037–1045.
31.
Hebert, R., G. Bravo, N. Korner-Bitensky, and L. Voyer. 1996. Predictive validity of a postal questionnaire for screening community dwelling elderly individuals at risk of functional decline. Age and Ageing25:159–167.
32.
Hebert, R., L. Robichaud, P. M. Roy, G. Bravo, and L. Voyer. 2001. Efficacy of a nurseled multidimensional preventive programme for older people at risk of functional decline: A randomized controlled trial. Age and Ageing30:147–153.
33.
Hendriksen, C., E. Lund, and E. Stromgard. 1984. Consequences of assessment and intervention among elderly people: A three year randomised controlled trial. British Medical Journal289:1522–1524.
34.
Hendriksen, C., E. Lund, and E. Stromgard. 1989. Hospitalization of elderly people: A 3-year controlled trial. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society37 (2): 117–122.
35.
Hirdes, J. P., P. J. Naus, and J. E. Young. 1994. The use of preventive home visits among frail elderly persons: Evidence from three European countries. Canadian Journal on Aging13 (4): 499–509.
36.
Hodgson, R., T. Abbasi, and J. Clarkson. 1996. Effective mental health promotion: A literature review. Health Education Journal55:55–74.
37.
Holder, H. D., A. J. Treno, R. F. Saltz, and J. W. Grube. 1997. Summing up: Recommendations and experiences for evaluation of community-level prevention programs. Evaluation Review21 (2): 268–277.
38.
Jadad, A. R., R. A. Moore, D. Carroll, C. Jenkinson, D. J. Reynolds, D. J. Gavaghan, and H. J. McQuay. 1996. Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: Is blinding necessary?Controlled Clinical Trials17 (1): 1–12.
39.
Johri, M., F. Beland, and H. Bergman. 2003. International experiments in integrated care for the elderly: A synthesis of the evidence. International Journal of Geriatric Psychology18:222–235.
40.
Khan, K. S., G. ter Riet, J. Popay, J. Nixon, and J. Kleijnen. 2001. Undertaking systematic reviews of research on effectiveness. 2d ed. University of York, NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination. Retrieved September 2004 from http://www.york.ac.uk/inst/crd/report4.htm
41.
Koelen, M. A., L. Vaandrager, and C. Colomer. 2001. Health promotion research: Dilemmas and challenges. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health55:257–262.
42.
Martin, S., A. E. Stuck, C. E. Minder, and J. C. Beck. 2000. Health service utilization of elderly Swiss: Evidence from panel data. Health Economics9:533–545.
43.
McInnes, E., and L. Askie. 2004. Evidence review on older people's views and experiences of falls prevention strategies. Worldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing1 (1): 20–37.
44.
McNaughton, D. B.2000. A synthesis of qualitative home visiting research. Public Health Nursing17 (6): 405–414.
45.
McWilliam, C. L., W. L. Diehl-Jones, J. Jutai, and S. Tadrissi. 2000. Care delivery approaches and seniors' independence. Canadian Journal on Aging19 (supp. 1): 101–124.
46.
McWilliam, C. L., M. Stewart, J. B. Brown, K. Desai, and P. Coderre. 1996. Creating health with chronic illness. Advances in Nursing Science18 (3): 1–15.
47.
McWilliam, C. L., M. Stewart, J. B. Brown, S. McNair, K. Desai, M. L. Patterson, N. Del Maestro, and B. J. Pittman. 1997. Creating empowering meaning: An interactive process of promoting health with chronically ill older Canadians. Health Promotion International12 (2): 111–123.
48.
Miller, C.1995. Nursing care of older adults: Theory and practice. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott.
49.
Moher, D., and I. Olkin. 1995. Meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials: A concern for standards. Journal of the American Medical Association274 (24): 1962–1964.
50.
National Advisory Council on Aging. 1999. Positions, recommendations and policy statements on caregiving. Retrieved March 20, 2000, from http://www.naca.ca/position/21_recommendations/21_recomm_index_e.htm.
51.
National Institute of Mental Health. 2003. Older adults: Depression and suicide facts. Retrieved April 2003 from http://www.nimh.nih.gov/publicat/elderlydepsuicide.cfm.
52.
Pathy, M. S. J., A. Bayer, K. Harding, and A. Dibble. 1992. Randomized trial of case finding and surveillance of elderly people at home. The Lancet340 (8824): 890–893.
53.
Pender, N., C. L. Murdaugh, and M. Parsons. 2002. Health promotion in nursing practice. 4th ed.Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education.
54.
Registered Nurses Association of Ontario. 1999. Reclaiming a vision: Making longterm care community services work. 1–22 .Retrieved February 2002 from http://www2.rnao.org/policy/Reclaiming_a_vision_report.asp.
55.
Roberts, J., G. Browne, C. Milne, L. Spooner, A. Gafni, M. Drummond-Young, J. LeGris, S. Watt, K. LeClair, and L. Beaumont. 1999. Problem solving counselling for caregivers of the cognitively impaired: Effective for whom?Nursing Research48 (3): 162–172.
56.
Rogers, A. C.1997. Vulnerability, health and health care. Journal of Advanced Nursing26: 65–72.
57.
Rubenstein, L. Z., H. U. Aronow, M. Schloe, A. Steiner, C. A. Alessi, K. E. Yuhas, M. Gold, M. Kemp, K. Raube, R. Nisenbaum, A. Stuck, and J. C. Beck. 1994. A homebased geriatric assessment, follow-up and health promotion program: Design, methods, and baseline findings from a 3-year randomized controlled trial. Aging Clinical Experimental Research6:105–120.
58.
Rubenstein, L. Z., A. L. Siu, and D. Wieland. 1989. Comprehensive geriatric assessment: Toward understanding its efficacy. Aging1 (2): 87–98.
59.
Rubenstein, L. Z., and A. E. Stuck. 2001. Preventive home visits for older people: Defining criteria for success. Age and Ageing30:107–109.
60.
Rubenstein, L. Z., A. E. Stuck, A. L. Siu, and D. Wieland. 1991. Impacts of geriatric evaluation and management programs on defined outcomes: Overview of the evidence. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society39:8S–16S.
61.
Rychetnik, L., and M. Wise. 2004. Advocating evidence-based health promotion: Reflections and a way forward. Health Promotion International19 (2): 247–257.
62.
Sidani, S., and L. Sechrest. 1999. Putting program theory into operation. American Journal of Evaluation20 (2): 227–238.
63.
Stachtchenko, S., and M. Jenicek. 1990. Conceptual differences between prevention and health promotion: Research implications for community health programs. Canadian Journal of Public Health81 (1): 53–59.
64.
Steffens, D., J. Hays, L. K. George, K. R. R. Krishnan, and D. G. Blazer. 1996. Sociodemographic and clinical correlates of number of previous depressive episodes in the depressed elderly. Journal of Affective Disorders39 (2): 99–106.
65.
Stuck, A. E., H. U. Aronow, A. Steiner, C. A. Alessi, C. J. Bula, M. N. Gold, K. E. Yuhas, R. Nisenbaum, L. Z. Rubenstein, and J. C. Beck. 1995. A trial of annual in-home comprehensive geriatric assessments for elderly people living in the community. The New England Journal of Medicine333 (18): 1184–1189.
66.
Stuck, A. E., M. Egger, A. Hammer, C. E. Minder, and J. C. Beck. 2002. Home visits to prevent nursing home admission and functional decline in elderly people: Systematic review and meta-regression analysis. Journal of the American Medical Association287 (8): 1022–1028.
67.
Stuck, A. E., A. Mayer-Oakes, and L. Z. Rubenstein. 1993. Geriatric in-home preventive programs: Facts and challenges. Facts and Research in Gerontology7:357–365.
68.
Stuck, A. E., C. E. Minder, I. Peter-Wuest, G. Gillman, C. Egli, A. Kesselring, R. E. Leu, and J. C. Beck. 2000. A randomized trial of in-home visits for disability prevention of community-dwelling older people at low and high risk for nursing home admission. Archives of Internal Medicine160 (7): 977–986.
69.
Stuck, A. E., A. L. Siu, D. Wieland, and L. Z. Rubenstein. 1993. Comprehensive geriatric assessment: A meta-analysis of controlled trials. The Lancet342 (8878): 1032–1036.
70.
Stuck, A. E., J. M. Walthert, T. Nikolaus, C. J. Bula, C. Hohman, and J. C. Beck. 1999. Risk factors for functional status decline in community-living elderly people: A systematic literature review. Social Science and Medicine48:445–469.
71.
Trojan, L., and O. Yonge. 1993. Developing trusting, caring relationships: Home care nurses and elderly clients. Journal of Advanced Nursing18:1903–1910.
72.
Tugwell, P., K. J. Bennett, D. L. Sackett, and R. B. Haynes. 1985. The measurement iterative loop: A framework for the critical appraisal of need, benefits and costs of health interventions. Journal of Chronic Disease38 (4): 339–351.
73.
United Nations. 2002. World Population Ageing: 1950–2050. Population Division, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, United Nations. Retrieved June 1, 2001, from http://www.un.org/esa/population/publications/worldageing19502050/.
74.
van Haastregt, J. C. M., M. Diederiks, E. van Rossum, L. P. de Witte, P. M. Voorhoeve, and F. J. M. Crebolder. 2000. Effects of a programme of multifactorial home visits on falls and mobility impairments in elderly people at risk: A randomized controlled trial. British Medical Journal321 (7267): 994–998.
75.
van Rossum, E., C. M. A. Frederiks, H. Philipsen, K. Portengen, J. Wiskerke, and P. Knipschild. 1993. Effects of preventive home visits to elderly people. British Medical Journal307:27–32.
76.
Vetter, N. J., D. A. Jones, and C. R. Victor. 1984. Effect of health visitors working with elderly patients in general practice: A randomized controlled trial. British Medical Journal288:369–372.
77.
World Health Organization. 2003. Health promotion evaluation: Recommendations to policy-makers. World Health Organization, Regional Office for Europe. Retrieved June 2004 from http://www.who.dk/document/e60706.pdf.
78.
Zimmer, J. G., A. Groth-Juncker, and J. McCusker. 1985. A randomized controlled study of a home health care team. American Journal of Public Health75 (2): 134–141.
