Physician dissatisfaction often drives public policy, and is associated with lower quality of care and disruption of treatment relationships. Physicians expressed strong dissatisfaction with managed care, leading to enactment of patient protection laws. By 2001, almost all states enacted laws to curb alleged abuses of managed care organizations. To date, no studies have examined whether such laws improved physician satisfaction. This article examines whether enactment of these laws improved physician satisfaction, using responses to the Physician Survey component of the Community Tracking Study (CTS), supplemented with data on state statutes/regulations. Career satisfaction increased for both primary care physicians (PCPs) and specialists following enactment of such laws; improvements were limited to early-adopting states. Enactment was associated with improvements in early-adopting states for specialists but not for PCPs on: ability to provide high quality care, clinical freedom, and ability to make clinical decisions in patients' interests without sacrificing physician income.
Baker, L.C., and J.C. Cantor.1993. Physician satisfaction under managed care. Health Affairs (Millwood)12 (Suppl.): 258—270.
2.
Borowsky, S.J., M.K. Davis, C.D.C. Goertz, and N. Lurie.1997. Are all health plans created equal? The physician view. Journal of theAmerican Medical Association278(100): 917—921.
3.
Chebab, E.L., N. Panicker, P.R. Alper, L.C. Baker, S.R. Wilson, and T.A. Raffin.2001. The impact of practice setting on physician perceptions of the quality of practice and patient care in the managed care era. Archives ofInternal Medicine161: 202—211.
4.
Cykert, S., C. Hansen, R. Layson, and J. Joines.1997. Primary care physicians and capitated reimbursement. experience, attitudes, and predictors. Journal of General Internal Medicine12(3): 192—194.
5.
Donelan, K., R.J. Blendon, G.D. Lundberg et al. 1997. The new medical marketplace: Physicians' views. Health Affairs (Millwood)16(5): 139—48.
6.
Feldman, D.S., D.H. Novack, and E. Gracely.1998. Effects of managed care on physician-patient relationships, quality of care, and the ethical practice of medicine: A physician survey. Archives ofInternal Medicine158(15): 1626—1632.
7.
Fenn, P., A. Gray, and N. Rickman.In press. Liability insurance and medical practice. Journal of Health Ecnomics.
8.
Firshein, J.1996. U.S. doctors fight gag clauses in contracts. Lancet 347 (8994): 113.
9.
Gabel, J.R., P.B. Ginsburg, H.H. Whitmore, and J.D. Pickreign.2000. Withering on the vine: The decline of indemnity health insurance. Health Affairs (Millwood)19(5): 152—157.
10.
Grembowski, D., C.M. Ulrich, D. Paschane, P. Dieher, W. Katon, D. Martin, D.L. Patrick, and C. Velicer.2003. Managed care and primary physician satisfaction . Journal of American Board of Family Practice16: 383—393.
11.
Grembowski, D., D. Paschane, P. Diehr et al. 2005. Managed care, physician job satisfaction, and the quality of primary care. Journal of General Internal Medicine20: 271—277.
12.
Grumbach, K., D. Osmond, K. Vranizan, D. Jaffe, and A.B. Bindman.1998. Primary care physicians' experiences of financial incentives in managed-care systems. New England Journal of Medicine339: 1516—1521.
13.
Haas, J.S., E.F. Cook, R.L. Puopolo, H.R. Burtin, P.D. Cleary, and T.A. Brennan.2000. Is the professional satisfaction of general internists associated with patient satisfaction?Journal of General Internal Medicine15(2): 122—128.
14.
Hadley, J., and J.M. Mitchell.2002. The growth of managed care and change in physicians' incomes, autonomy, and satisfaction, 1991—1997. International Journal of Health Care Finance & Economics2(1): 37—50.
15.
Hadley, J., J.C. Cantor, T.R. Konrad, R.J. Willkie, J. Feder, and A.B. Cohen.1992. Young physicians most and least likely to have second thoughts about a career in medicine. Academic Medicine67(3):180—190.
16.
Hall, M.A.2004. Managed care patient protection or provider protection? A qualitative assessment. American Journal of Medicine117(12):32—37.
17.
Hall, M.A.2005. The “death” of managed care: A regulatory autopsy. Journal of Health Politics, Policy & Law30:427—452.
18.
Hueston, W.J.1998. Family physicians' satisfaction with practice. Archives of Family Medicine7(3):242—247.
19.
Jensen, G.A., M.A. Morrisey, S. Gaffney, and D.K. Liston.1997. The new dominance of managed care insurance trends in the 1990s. Health Affairs16(1):125—136.
20.
Kemper, P., D. Blumenthal, J.M. Corrigan, P.J. Cunningham, S.M. Felt, J.M. Grossman, L.T. Kohn, C.E. Metcalf, R. F. St. Peter, R.C. Strouse, and P.B. Ginsburg.1996. The design of the Community Tracking Study: A longitudinal study of health system change and its effects on people . Inquiry33(2):195—206.
21.
Kerr, E.A., R.D. Hays, B.S. Millman, A.L. Siu, B. Leake, and R.H. Brook.1997. Primary care physicians' satisfaction with quality of care in California capitated medical groups. Journal of theAmerican Medical Association278(4):308—312.
22.
Landon, B.E., J. Reschovsky, and D. Blumenthal.2003. Changes in career satisfaction among primary care and specialist physicians, 1997—2001. Journal of the American Medical Association289:442—449.
23.
Landon, B.E., J.D. Reschovsky, H.H. Pham, and D. Blumenthal.2006. Leaving medicine: The consequences of physician dissatisfaction. Medical Care44(3):234—242.
24.
Leigh, J.P., R.L. Kravitz, M. Schembri, S.J. Samuels, and S. Mobley.2002. Physician career satisfaction across specialities. Archives ofInternal Medicine162:1577—1584.
25.
Linzer, M., T.R. Konrad, J. Douglas et al. 2000. Managed care, time pressure, and physicians job satisfaction: Results from the Physician Worklife Study. Journal of General Internal Medicine15(7):441—450.
26.
Mello, M.M., D.M. Studdert, and T.A. Brennan.2003. The new medical malpractice crisis. New England Journal of Medicine348(23):2281—2284.
27.
Mello, M.M., D.M. Studdert, C.M. DesRoches, J. Peugh, K. Zapert, T.A. Brennan, and W.M. Sage.2004. Caring for patients in a malpractice crisis: Physician satisfaction and quality of care. Health Affairs23:42—53.
28.
Metcalf, C.E., P. Kemper, L.T. Kohn, and J.D. Pickreign.1996. Site definition and sample design for the Community Tracking Study. Technical Publication no. 1. Washington, DC: Center for Studying Health System Change.
29.
National Center for Education Statistics.1997. Job satisfaction among America's teachers: Effects of workplace conditions, background characteristics, and teacher compensation . Statistical Analysis Report.http://nces.ed.Gov/pubs97/97471.pdf (accessed August 21, 2006 ).
30.
Pathman, D.E., T.R. Konrad, E.S. Williams, W.E. Scheckler, M. Linzer, and L. Douglas.2002. Physician job satisfaction, dissatisfaction, and turnover. Journal of Family Practice51(7):593.
31.
Schiltz, P.1999. On being a happy, healthy and ethical member of an unhappy, unhealthy and unethical profession. VanderbiltLaw Review52:871—951.
32.
Sloan, F.A., and M.A. Hall.2002. Market failures and the evolution of state regulation of managed care. Law & Contemporary Problems64(4):169—206.
33.
Sloan, F.A., J.R. Rattliff, and M.A. Hall.2005. Impacts of managed care patient protection on health services utilization and patient satisfaction with care. Health Services Research40(3):647—667.
34.
Steinbrook, R.2002. Nursing in the crossfire. New England Journal of Medicine 346(22): 1757 —1766.
35.
Sturm, R.2002. Effect of managed care and financing on practice constraints and career satisfaction in primary care. Journal of the American Board of Family Practice15(5):367—377.
36.
Warren, M.G., R. Weitz, and S. Kulis.1999. The impact of managed care on physicians . Health Care Management Review24(2):44—56.
37.
Williams, E.S., and A.C. Skinner.2003. Outcomes of physician job satisfaction: A narrative review, implications, and directions for future research. Health Care Management Review28:119—140.
38.
Zuger, A.2004. Dissatisfaction with medical practice. New England Journal of Medicine350(1):69—75.
