Does Depression Screening Have an Effect on the Diagnosis and Treatment of Mood Disorders in General Medical Settings? An Instrumental Variable Analysis of the National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online August, 2011
Does Depression Screening Have an Effect on the Diagnosis and Treatment of Mood Disorders in General Medical Settings? An Instrumental Variable Analysis of the National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey
This study examined the association of depression screening with the diagnoses of mood disorders and prescription of antidepressants in 73,712 visits to nonpsychiatrist physician offices drawn from the 2005-2007 U.S. National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey. Physicians used depression screening selectively for patients whom they perceived as more likely to have a mood disorder. In bivariate probit analyses with instrumental variables, depression screening did not increase the prevalence of either mood disorder diagnoses or prescription of antidepressants. However, screening was associated with lower rates of antidepressants prescription without a diagnosis of a mood disorder. In visits in which antidepressants were prescribed, 47.4% of the screened visits compared with 16.3% of nonscreened visits had a mood disorder diagnosis. As currently practiced in medical settings, depression screening may help improve targeting and appropriate use of antidepressant medications. Wider use of depression screening may help curb the growing trend of off-label antidepressant prescriptions.
Andersen, R.M. ( 1995). Revisiting the behavioral model and access to medical care: Does it matter? Journal of Health and Social Behavior , 36, 1-10.
2.
Bao, Y., Duan, N., & Fox, S.A. ( 2006). Is some provider advice on smoking cessation better than no advice? An instrumental variable analysis of the 2001 National Health Interview Survey. Health Services Research, 41, 2114-2135.
3.
Barbui, C., Tognoni, G., & Garattini, S. ( 2002). Clinical databases of patients receiving antidepressants. The missing link between research and practice? Journal of Affective Disorders, 70, 191-196.
4.
Bethell, C., Klein, J., & Peck, C. ( 2001). Assessing health system provision of adolescent preventive services: The Young Adult Health Care Survey. Medical Care , 39, 478-490.
5.
Bhattacharya, J., Goldman, D., & McCaffrey, D. ( 2006). Estimating probit models with self-selected treatments . Statistics in Medicine, 25, 389-413.
6.
Blanco, C., Olfson, M., Goodwin, R.D., Ogburn, E., Liebowitz, M.R., Nunes, E.V., & Hasin, D.S. ( 2008). Generalizability of clinical trial results for major depression to community samples: Results from the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol and Related Conditions. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry , 69, 1276-1280.
7.
Brookhart, M.A., Wang, P.S., Solomon, D.H., & Schneeweiss, S. (2006). Instrumental variable analysis of secondary pharmacoepidemiologic data. Epidemiology, 17, 373-374.
8.
Callahan, E.J., Bertakis, K.D., Azari, R., Helms, L.J., Robbins, J., & Miller, J. ( 1997). Depression in primary care: Patient factors that influence recognition. Annals of Family Medicine, 29, 172-176.
9.
Calnan, M., & Williams, S. ( 1993). Coronary heart disease prevention: The role of the general practitioner. Family Practice, 10, 137-151.
10.
Charles, J., Britt, H., & Valenti, L. ( 2006). The independent effect of age of general practitioner on clinical practice. Medical Journal of Australia, 185, 105-109.
11.
Cherry, D.K., Hing, E., Woodwell, D.A., & Rechtsteiner, E.A. (2008). National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2006 summary. National Health Statistics Report, 3, 1-39.
12.
Cherry, D.K., Woodwell, D.A., & Rechtsteiner, E.A. (2007). National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2005 summary. Advance Data, 387, 1-39.
13.
Cooper, C., Bebbington, P., McManus, S., Meltzer, H., Stewart, R., Farrell, M., . . . Levingstone, G. (in press). The treatment of common mental disorders across age groups: Results from the 2007 adult psychiatric morbidity survey . Journal of Affective Disorders.
14.
Croghan, T.W. ( 2001). The controversy of increased spending for antidepressants . Health Affairs (Millwood), 20, 129-135.
15.
de Jong, J.D., Groenewegen, P.P., & Westert, G.P. ( 2003). Mutual influences of general practitioners in partnerships . Social Science & Medicine, 57, 1515-1524.
16.
Dowrick, C., Leydon, G.M., McBride, A., Howe, A., Burgess, H., Clarke, P., . . . Kendrick, T. ( 2009). Patients’ and doctors’ views on depression severity questionnaires incentivised in UK quality and outcomes framework: Qualitative study. British Medical Journal, 338, b663. doi:10.1136/bmj.b663
17.
Druss, B.G. ( 2006). Rising mental health costs: What are we getting for our money?Health Affairs (Millwood), 25, 614-622.
18.
Edlund, M.J., Unutzer, J., & Wells, K.B. ( 2004). Clinician screening and treatment of alcohol, drug, and mental problems in primary care: Results from healthcare for communities. Medical Care, 42, 1158-1166.
19.
Epstein, S.A., Hooper, L.M., Weinfurt, K.P., DePuy, V., Cooper, L.A., Harless, W.G., . . . Cynthia, M.T. ( 2008). Primary care physicians’ evaluation and treatment of depression: Results of an experimental study using video vignettes. Medical Care Research and Review, 65, 674-695.
20.
French, M.T., & Popovici, I. ( 2009). That instrument is lousy! In search of agreement when using instrumental variables estimation in substance use research . Health Economy. doi:10.1002/hec.1572
21.
Gallo, J.J., Meredith, L.S., Gonzales, J., Cooper, L.A., Nutting, P., Ford, D.E., . . . Quality Improvement for Depression Consortium. (2002). Do family physicians and internists differ in knowledge, attitudes, and self-reported approaches for depression?International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine, 32, 1-20.
22.
Gilbody, S., House, A.O., & Sheldon, T.A. ( 2001). Routinely administered questionnaires for depression and anxiety: Systematic review. British Medical Journal, 322, 406-409.
23.
Gilbody, S., Sheldon, T., & House, A. ( 2008). Screening and case-finding instruments for depression: A meta-analysis. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 178, 997-1003.
24.
Gilbody, S., Sheldon, T., & Wessely, S. ( 2006). Should we screen for depression? British Medical Journal, 332, 1027-1030.
25.
Gilchrist, V.J., Stange, K.C., Flocke, S.A., McCord, G., & Bourguet, C.C. (2004). A comparison of the National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (NAMCS) measurement approach with direct observation of outpatient visits. Medical Care, 42, 276-280.
26.
Goldman, L.S., Nielsen, N.H., & Champion, H.C. (1999). Awareness, diagnosis, and treatment of depression. Journal of General Internal Medicine , 14, 569-580.
27.
Goldston, K., & Baillie, A.J. ( 2008). Depression and coronary heart disease: A review of the epidemiological evidence, explanatory mechanisms and management approaches . Clinical Psychology Review, 28, 288-306.
28.
Grant, A.M., Niyonsenga, T., Dion, I., Delisle, E., Xhignesse, M., & Bernier, R. ( 1998). Cardiovascular disease. Physician attitudes toward prevention and treatment. Canadian Family Physician, 44, 780-787.
29.
Gump, B.B. ( 2008). More severe symptoms of depression increase coronary heart disease mortality. Evidence Based Mental Health, 11, 56.
30.
Halpern-Felsher, B.L., Ozer, E.M., Millstein, S.G., Wibbelsman, C.J., Fuster, C.D., Elster, A.B., & Irwin, C.E., Jr. (2000). Preventive services in a health maintenance organization: How well do pediatricians screen and educate adolescent patients? Archives of Pediatric & Adolescent Medicine , 154, 173-179.
31.
Jureidini, J., & Tonkin, A. ( 2006). Overuse of antidepressant drugs for the treatment of depression. CNS Drugs, 20, 623-632.
32.
Kendrick, T., Dowrick, C., McBride, A., Howe, A., Clarke, P., Maisey, S., . . . Smith, P.W. ( 2009). Management of depression in UK general practice in relation to scores on depression severity questionnaires: Analysis of medical record data. British Medical Journal, 338, b750.
33.
Kessler, R.C., Berglund, P., Demler, O., Jin, R., Koretz, D., Merikangas, K.R., . . . Wang, M.D. ( 2003). The epidemiology of major depressive disorder: Results from the National Comorbidity Survey Replication (NCS-R). Journal of the American Medical Association, 289, 3095-3105.
34.
Kirsch, I., Deacon, B.J., Huedo-Medina, T.B., Scoboria, A., Moore, T.J., & Johnson, B.T. ( 2008). Initial severity and antidepressant benefits: A meta-analysis of data submitted to the Food and Drug Administration. PLoS Medicine, 5, e45.
35.
LaRocco-Cockburn, A., Melville, J., Bell, M., & Katon, W. ( 2003). Depression screening attitudes and practices among obstetrician-gynecologists . Obstetrics and Gynecology, 101, 892-898.
36.
Larson, M.J., Miller, K., & Fleming, K.J. ( 2007). Treatment with antidepressant medications in private health plans. Administration & Policy in Mental Health , 34, 116-126.
37.
Laws, R.A., Jayasinghe, U.W., Harris, M.F., Williams, A.M., Powell Davies, G., & Kemp, L.A. ( 2009). Explaining the variation in the management of lifestyle risk factors in primary health care: A multilevel cross sectional study. BMC Public Health, 9, 165.
May, H.T., Horne, B.D., Carlquist, J.F., Sheng, X., Joy, E., & Catinella, A.P. (2009). Depression after coronary artery disease is associated with heart failure. Journal of the American College of Cardiology, 53, 1440-1447.
40.
McAlpine, D.D., & Wilson, A.R. ( 2004). Screening for depression in primary care: What do we still need to know? Depression & Anxiety, 19, 137-145.
41.
Menchetti, M., Belvederi Murri, M., Bertakis, K., Bortolotti, B., & Berardi, D. ( 2009). Recognition and treatment of depression in primary care: Effect of patients’ presentation and frequency of consultation. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 66, 335-341.
42.
Milea, D., Verpillat, P., Guelfucci, F., Toumi, M., & Lamure, M. ( 2010). Prescription patterns of antidepressants: Findings from a US claims database. Current Medical Research & Opinion , 26, 1343-1353.
43.
Mitchell, A. J., & Coyne, J. C. (Eds.). (2010). Screening for depression in clinical practice: An evidence-based guide. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
44.
Mitchell, A.J., Kaar, S., Coggan, C., & Herdman, J. ( 2008). Acceptability of common screening methods used to detect distress and related mood disorders-preferences of cancer specialists and non-specialists. Psychooncology, 17, 226-236.
45.
Mitchell, A.J., Vaze, A., & Rao, S. ( 2009). Clinical diagnosis of depression in primary care: A meta-analysis . Lancet, 374, 609-619.
46.
Mojtabai, R. ( 1999). Datapoints: Prescription patterns for mood and anxiety disorders in a community sample. Psychiatric Services, 50, 1557.
47.
Mojtabai, R. ( 2002). Diagnosing depression and prescribing antidepressants by primary care physicians: The impact of practice style variations. Mental Health Services Research, 4, 109-118.
48.
Mojtabai, R. ( 2008). Increase in antidepressant medication in the US adult population between 1990 and 2003. Psychotherapy & Psychosomatics , 77, 83-92.
49.
National Center for Health Statistics. (n.d.-a). 2005NAMCS micro-data file documentation. Retrieved from ftp://ftp.cdc.gov/pub/Health_Statistics/NCHS/Dataset_Documentation/NAMCS/doc05.pdf
50.
National Center for Health Statistics. (n.d.-b). 2006NAMCS micro-data file documentation. Retrieved from ftp://ftp.cdc.gov/pub/Health_Statistics/NCHS/Dataset_Documentation/NAMCS/doc06.pdf
51.
National Center for Health Statistics. (n.d.-c). 2007NAMCS micro-data file documentation. Retrieved from ftp://ftp.cdc.gov/pub/Health_Statistics/NCHS/Dataset_Documentation/NAMCS/doc07.pdf
52.
Nimalasuriya, K., Compton, M.T., & Guillory, V.J. (2009). Screening adults for depression in primary care: A position statement of the American College of Preventive Medicine. Journal of Family Practice, 58, 535-538.
53.
O’Connor, E.A., Whitlock, E.P., Beil, T.L., & Gaynes, B.N. ( 2009). Screening for depression in adult patients in primary care settings: A systematic evidence review. Annals of Internal Medicine, 151, 793-803.
54.
Olfson, M., Cherry, D.K., & Lewis-Fernandez, R. (2009). Racial differences in visit duration of outpatient psychiatric visits. Archives of General Psychiatry, 66, 214-221.
55.
Olfson, M., & Marcus, S.C. ( 2009). National patterns in antidepressant medication treatment . Archives of General Psychiatry, 66, 848-856.
56.
Olfson, M., Marcus, S.C., Druss, B., Elinson, L., Tanielian, T., & Pincus, H.A. ( 2002). National trends in the outpatient treatment of depression . Journal of the American Medical Association, 287, 203-209.
57.
Olfson, M., Marcus, S.C., & Pincus, H.A. ( 1999). Trends in office-based psychiatric practice. American Journal of Psychiatry, 156, 451-457.
58.
Palmer, S.C., & Coyne, J.C. ( 2003). Screening for depression in medical care: Pitfalls, alternatives, and revised priorities. Journal of Psychosomatic Research , 54, 279-287.
59.
Paulden, M., Palmer, S., Hewitt, C., & Gilbody, S. ( 2009). Screening for postnatal depression in primary care: Cost effectiveness analysis. British Medical Journal, 339, b5203.
60.
Paulose-Ram, R., Safran, M.A., Jonas, B.S., Gu, Q., & Orwig, D. ( 2007). Trends in psychotropic medication use among U.S. adults . Pharmacoepidemiology & Drug Safety, 16, 560-570.
61.
Pignone, M.P., Gaynes, B.N., Rushton, J.L., Burchell, C.M., Orleans, C.T., Mulrow, C.D., . . . Lohr, K.N. ( 2002). Screening for depression in adults: A summary of the evidence for the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. Annals of Internal Medicine, 136, 765-776.
62.
Rassen, J.A., Brookhart, M.A., Glynn, R.J., Mittleman, M.A., & Schneeweiss, S. (2009). Instrumental variables I: Instrumental variables exploit natural variation in nonexperimental data to estimate causal relationships. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology , 62, 1226-1232.
63.
Schneider, D., Appleton, L., & McLemore, T. ( 1979). A reason for visit classification for ambulatory care . Vital Health Statistics, 78, 1-63.
64.
Simon, G.E., Fleck, M., Lucas, R., & Bushnell, D.M. (2004). Prevalence and predictors of depression treatment in an international primary care study. American Journal of Psychiatry, 161, 1626-1634.
65.
Sleath, B., & Shih, Y.C. ( 2003). Sociological influences on antidepressant prescribing . Social Science & Medicine, 56, 1335-1344.
66.
Staiger, D., & Stock, J.H. ( 1997). Instrumental variables regression with weak instruments . Econometrica, 65, 557-586.
67.
StataCorp. (2010). Stata Statistical Software (Release 11) [Computer software]. College Station, TX: Stata Corporation.
68.
Stockdale, S.E., Lagomasino, I.T., Siddique, J., McGuire, T., & Miranda, J. ( 2008). Racial and ethnic disparities in detection and treatment of depression and anxiety among psychiatric and primary health care visits, 1995-2005. Medical Care, 46, 668-677.
69.
Thombs, B.D., de Jonge, P., Coyne, J.C., Whooley, M.A., Frasure-Smith, N., Mitchell, A.J., . . . Ziegelstein, R.C. (2008). Depression screening and patient outcomes in cardiovascular care: A systematic review. Journal of the American Medical Association, 300, 2161-2171.
70.
U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. (2009 ). Screening for depression in adults: U.S. preventive services task force recommendation statement. Annals of Internal Medicine , 151, 784-792.
71.
Van Voorhees, B.W., Fogel, J., Houston, T.K., Cooper, L.A., Wang, N.Y., & Ford, D.E. ( 2006). Attitudes and illness factors associated with low perceived need for depression treatment among young adults. Social Psychiatry & Psychiatric Epidemiology, 41, 746-754.
72.
Walton, S.M., Schumock, G.T., Lee, K.V., Alexander, G.C., Meltzer, D., & Stafford, R.S. (2008). Prioritizing future research on off-label prescribing: Results of a quantitative evaluation. Pharmacotherapy, 28, 1443-1452.
73.
Williams, S.B., O’Connor, E.A., Eder, M., & Whitlock, E.P. (2009). Screening for child and adolescent depression in primary care settings: A systematic evidence review for the US Preventive Services Task Force. Pediatrics, 123, e716-e735.
74.
Wooldridge, J.M. ( 2003). Introductory econometrics: A modern approach (2nd ed.). Cincinnati, OH: South-Western College Publishing.
75.
Young, A.S., Klap, R., Sherbourne, C.D., & Wells, K.B. ( 2001). The quality of care for depressive and anxiety disorders in the United States. Archives of General Psychiatry, 58, 55-61.
76.
Ziegelstein, R.C., Thombs, B.D., Coyne, J.C., & de Jonge, P. ( 2009). Routine screening for depression in patients with coronary heart disease never mind. Journal of the American College of Cardiology, 54, 886-890.
