Legal procedures have long been implemented to protect the rights of persons with mental illness, to mandate treatment for those unable to care for themselves, and to protect society from dangerous behavior. Although legal, mandated treatment poses ethical concerns. This article analyzes ethical issues emerging from a case study. Ethical principles, considered within a common morality framework, are applied to consider dilemmas inherent in the case study. A care-ethics lens is then introduced to enrich the ethical perspective and offer additional options for individualized and respectful resolutions. Considerations for nursing practice and research are offered.J Am Psychiatr Nurses Assoc, 2007; 13(2), 101-108.
American Psychiatric Association. (2000). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed., text rev.). Washington, DC: Author .
2.
Beauchamp, T.L. , & Childress, J.F. (2001). Principles of biomedical ethics (5th ed.). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press .
3.
Beck, P.R. (2000). Law and ethics in psychiatry . Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 45(10), 890-891 .
4.
Bowden, P. (2000). An “ethic of care” in clinical settings: Encompassing “feminine” and “feminist” perspectives . Nursing Philosophy, 1, 36-49 .
5.
California Healthcare Association (CHA). ( 2004). Mental health law: A handbook on laws governing mental health treatment (2nd ed.). Sacramento, CA: Author .
6.
Drake, R.E. , Green, A.I. , Mueser, K.T. , & Goldman, H.H. (2003). The history of community mental health treatment and rehabilitation for persons with severe mental illness . Community Mental Health Journal, 39(5), 427-440 .
7.
Gadow, S. (1999). Relational narrative: The postmodern turn in nursing ethics. Scholarly Inquiry for Nursing Practice: AnInternational Journal, 13(1), 57-70 .
8.
Gilligan, C. (1982). In a different voice: Psychological theory and women's development. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
9.
Hamann, J. , Cohen, R. , Leucht, S. , Busch, R. , & Kissling, W. (2005). Do patients with schizophrenia wish to be involved in decisions about their medical treatment?The American Journal of Psychiatry,162, 2382-2384 .
10.
Hatfield, B. , Bindman, J. , & Pinfold, V. (2004). Evaluating the use of supervised discharge and guardianship in cases of severe mental illness: A follow-up study . Journal of Mental Health, 13(2), 197-209 .
11.
Heffern, W.A. , & Austin, W. (1999). Compulsory community treatment: Ethical considerations . Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 6, 37-42 .
Johansson, I.M. , & Lundman, B. (2002). Patients' experience of involuntary psychiatric care: Good opportunities and great losses . Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 9, 639-647 .
14.
Lind, M. , Kaltiala-Heino, R. , Suominen, T. , Leino-Kilpi, H. , & Valimaki, M. (2004). Nurses' ethical perceptions about coercion . Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 11, 379-385 .
15.
Lowry, D.A. (1998). Issues of non-compliance in mental health . Journal of Advanced Nursing, 28(2), 280-287 .
16.
Matthews, E. (2000). Autonomy and the psychiatric patient . Journal of Applied Philosophy, 17(1), 59-70 .
17.
Mclachlan, A.J. , & Mulder, R.T. (1999). Criteria for involuntary hospitalization . Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 33, 729-733 .
18.
Meyers, C. (2004). Cruel choices: Autonomy and critical care decision-making . Bioethics, 18(2), 104-119 .
19.
Milton, C.L. (2003). Structuring meaning through new language: Going beyond the ethics of caring. NursingScience Quarterly, 16(1), 21-24 .
20.
Mohr, W. (2006). Psychiatric-mental health nursing (6th ed.). Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins .
21.
National Institute of Mental Health. (2001 ). The impact of mental illness on society. Retrieved April 11, 2006, from http://www.nimh.nih.gov/publicat/burden.cfm
22.
O'Brien, A.J. , & Golding, C.G. (2003). Coercion in mental healthcare: The principle of least coercive care . Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 10, 167-173 .
23.
Olofsson, B. , Gilje, F. , Jacobsson, L. , & Norberg, A. (1998). Nurses' narratives about using coercion in psychiatric care . Journal of Advanced Nursing, 28(1), 45-53 .
24.
Olofsson, B. , & Jacobsson, L. (2001). A plea for respect: Involuntarily hospitalized psychiatric patient's narratives about being subjected to coercion . Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 8, 357-366 .
25.
Olsen, D.P. (2003). Influence and coercion: Relational and rights-based ethical approaches to forced psychiatric treatment . Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 10, 705-712 .
26.
Pinfold, V. , Rowe, A. , Hatfield, B. , Bindman, J. , Huxley, P. , Thornicroft, G. , et al. (2002). Lines of resistance: Exploring professionals' views of compulsory community supervision . Journal of Mental Health, 11(2), 177-190 .
27.
Poulsen, H.D. , & Engberg, M. (2001). Validation of psychiatric patients' statements on coercive measures . Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 103, 60-65 .
28.
President's New Freedom Commission on Mental Health. (2002). Achieving the promise: Transforming mental health care in America, executive summary. Retrieved June 9, 2005, from http://www.mentalhealthcommission.gov/reports/FinalReport/FullReport.htm
29.
Reynolds, S.L. , & Wilbur, K.H. (1997). Protecting persons with severe cognitive and mental disorders: An analysis of public conservatorship in Los Angeles County, California. Aging andMental Health, 1(1), 87-97 .
30.
Richardson, G. (2002). Autonomy, guardianship and mental disorder: One problem, two solutions . The Modern Law Review Limited, 65(5), 702-723 .
31.
Roberts, M. (2004). Psychiatric ethics: A critical introduction for mental health nurses . Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 11, 583-588 .
32.
Stebnicki, M.A. (1994). Ethical dilemmas in adult guardianship and substitute decision-making: Consideration for rehabilitation professionals . Journal of Rehabilitation, April/May/June, 23-27.
33.
Szasz, T. (2005). Idiots, infants, and the insane: Mental illness and legal incompetence. Journal of MedicalEthics, 31, 78-81 .
34.
Valimaki, M. , & Leino-Kilpi, H. (1998). Preconditions for and consequences of self-determination: The psychiatric patient's point of view . Journal of Advanced Nursing, 27, 204-212 .
35.
Verkerk, M. (1999). A care perspective on coercion and autonomy . Bioethics, 13(3/4), 358-368 .
36.
Wilber, K. , Reiser, T. , & Harter, K. (2001). New perspectives on conservatorship: The views of older adult conservatees and their conservators. Aging Neuropsychology andCognition, 8(3), 225-240 .
37.
Woodward, V.M. (1998). Caring, patient autonomy and the stigma of paternalism . Journal of Advanced Nursing, 28(5), 1046-1052 .
