Mentoring and Organisational Constraints as Predictors of Attitudes to Work in the Nigerian Public Health Sector

Abstract

The present study examines work attitudes in the public health sector using the relative impact of mentoring and organisational constraints on job satisfaction and organisational commitment. Data was collected from 161 employees in a large government-owned hospital in south western Nigeria. Results of the hierarchical regression analysis (which controlled for the effects of relevant covariates) showed that when informal mentoring and perceived organisational constraints were entered in the second step, R² for organisational commitment and job satisfaction increased from .17 to .45 (p = < .001), and from .15 to .49 (p = < .001), respectively. These findings suggest that work attitudes in the public health sector can be improved by facilitating mentoring relationships and removing organisational obstacles. The implications of these findings for policy formulation and effective health care delivery are explained.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aniftos

M. G.

, 2002. Problematic futures? Challenging negative self-fulfilling prophesies through mentoring. Paper presented at the 2002 National Conference of Australia Association for Research in Education.

Appelbaum

S. H.

, Ritchie

, and Shapiro

B. T.

. 1994. Mentoring revisited: an organisational behaviour construct? International Journal of Career Management, 6 (3): 3–10.

Baker

L. C.

, and Cantor

J. C.

. 1993. Physician satisfaction under managed care. Health Aff. (Millwood) 12: 258–270.

Baldwin

, 1992. Effects of alternative modelling strategies on outcomes of interpersonal-skills training. Journal of Applied Psychology, 77(2): 147–154.

Bauer

T. N.

, 1999. Perceived mentoring fairness: relationships with gender, mentoring type, mentoring experience and mentoring needs. Sex Roles, 40(3/4): 211–225.

Blau

G. J.

, 1986. Job involvement and organisational commitment as interactive predictors of tardiness and absenteeism. Journal of Management, 1: 577–584.

Blau

, 1999. Testing the longitudinal impact of work variables and performance appraisal satisfaction on subsequent overall job satisfaction. Human Relations 52: 1099–1113.

Blau

, and Boal

. 1989. Using job involvement and organisational commitment interactively to predict turnover. Journal of Management, 15: 115–127.

Bordens

K. S.

, and Abbott

B. B.

. 1988. Research design and methods: a process approach. Mayfield Publishing Company. Mountain View, California.

10.

Brooke

P. P.

, Russell

D. W.

, and Price

J. L.

. 1988. Discriminant validation of measures of job satisfaction, job involvement, and organisational commitment. Journal of Applied Psychology, 73: 139–145.

11.

Brown

, and Mitchell

. 1993. Organizational obstacles: Links with financial performance, customer satisfaction, and job satisfaction in a service environment. Human Relations, 46: 725–757.

12.

Burke

R. J.

, Mckeen

C. A.

, and McKenna

. 1994. Benefits of mentoring in organizations: The mentor's perspective. Journal of Managerial Psychology. 9(3): 23–32.

13.

Chankova

, Nguyen

, Chipanta

, Kombe

, Onaja

and Ogungbemi

. 2006. A Situation Assessment of Human Resources in the Public Health Sector in Nigeria. Retrieved on 07/02/08 at http://www.hrhresourcecenter.org/node/1007.

14.

Chao

G. T.

, Walz

P. M.

, and Gardner

P. D.

. 1992. Formal and informal mentorships: A comparison on mentoring functions and contrast with nonmentored counterparts. Personnel Psychology 45: 619–636.

15.

Dancer

J. A.

, 2003. Mentoring in healthcare: theory in search of practice? Clinician in Management 12: 21–31.

16.

Deming

, 1986. Out of the crisis. Cambridge: MIT Center for Advanced Engineering Study, Cambridge.

17.

DeVaney

S. A.

, and Chen

. 2003. Job satisfaction of recent graduates in financial services. Retrieved on 12/12/2006 at http://www.bls.gov/opub/cwc/cm20030522ar01p1.htm.

18.

Dreher

G. F.

, and Cox

T. H.

. 1996. Race, gender, and opportunity: A study of compensation attainment and the establishment of mentoring relationships. Journal of Applied Psychology, 81 (3): 297–308.

19.

Ellickson

M. C.

, 2002. ‘Determinants of job satisfaction of municipal government employees’. Public Personnel Management. Fall. Retrieved on 04/11/2006 at http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3779/is_200210/ai_n9085349.

20.

Engel

J. F.

, Blackwell

R. D.

, and Miniard

P. W.

. 1995. Consumer behaviour (8th ed.). The Dryden Press, Orlando.

21.

Eulberg

, O'Connor

, Peters

, and Watson

. 1984. Performance constraints: A selective review of relevant literature. Psychological Documents.

22.

Fagan

, and Walter

. 1982. Mentoring among teachers. Journal of Educational Research, 76(2): 113–117.

23.

George

J. M.

, and Jones

G. R.

. 1996. The experience of work and turnover intentions: interactive effects of value attainment, job satisfaction and positive mood. Journal of Applied Psychology, 81(3): 318–326.

24.

George

and Peace

S. D.

. 1997. Mentoring new faculty. Education Week, 17(13): 36–38.

25.

Gilley

J. W.

, and Boughton

N. W.

. 1996. Stop managing, start coaching!: how performance coaching can enhance commitment and improve productivity. Irwin Professional Publishing, Chicago.

26.

Hackman

, and Oldman

. 1976. Motivation through the design of work: test of theory. Organisational Behaviour and Human Performance, 16: 250–279.

27.

Hawkins

D. I.

, Best

R. J.

, and Coney

K. A.

. 1989. Consomer behaviour: implications for marketing strategy. Richard D. Irwin, Inc., Homewood, Illinois.

28.

Hill

S. K.

, and Bahnink

M. H.

. 2000. Mentoring: from the editors. Review of Business, 21(1): 32.

29.

Hunt

D. M.

, and Michael

. 1983. Mentorship: A career training and development tool. Academy of Management Review, 8: 475–485.

30.

Jans

N. A.

, 1989. Organisational commitment, career factors and career/life stage, Journal of Organisational Behaviour, 10(3): 247–266.

31.

Johnson

S. K.

, Geroy

G. D.

, and Griego

O. V.

. 1999. The mentoring model theory: dimensions in mentoring protocols. Career Development International, 4(7): 384–391.

32.

Judge

T. A.

, Boudreau

J. W.

, and Bretz

R. D.

. 1994. Job and life attitudes of executives. Journal of Applied Psychology, 79(5): 767–782.

33.

Judge

T. A.

, Thoresen

C. J.

, Bono

J. E.

, and Patton

G. K.

. 2001. The job satisfaction, job performance relationship: a qualitative and quantitative review. Psychological Bulletin, 127: 376–407.

34.

Kalbfleisch

P. J.

, and Davies

A. B.

. 1993. An interpersonal model for participation in mentoring relationships. Western Journal of Speech Communication, 57: 399–415.

35.

Kram

K.E.

, 1983. Phases of mentor relationship. Academy of Management Journal, 26(4): 608–625.

36.

Kram

K. E.

, 1985. Mentoring at Work: Developmental Relationships in Organizational Life. Scott, Foresman & Co, Glenview, III.

37.

Linn

L. S.

, Brook

R. H.

, Clark

V. A.

, , 1985. Physician and patient satisfaction as factors related to the organisation of internal medicine group practices. Medicine Care, 23(10): 1171–1178.

38.

Marks

S. R.

, 1994. Intimacy in the public realm: the case of co-workers. Social Forces. March: 843–858.

39.

Mathieu

J. E.

, and Farr

J. L.

. 1991. Further evidence for the discriminant validity of measures of organisational commitment, job involvement, and job satisfaction. Journal of Applied Psychology, 76: 127–133.

40.

Mathieu

, and Zajac

. 1990. A review and meta-analysis of the antecedents, correlates and consequences of organisational commitment. Journal of Applied Psychology, 108: 171–194.

41.

Melville

, 1980. Job satisfaction in general practice: implications for prescribing. Social Sciences Medicine, 14: 495–499.

42.

Meyer

J. P.

, Paunonen

S. V.

, Gellatly

I. R.

, Goffin

R. D.

, and Jackson

D. N.

. 1989. Organisational commitment and job performance: it's the nature of the commitment that counts. Journal of Applied Psychology, 74: 152–156.

43.

Miller

, 1980. Individual and occupational determinants of job satisfaction. Work and Occupations. August: 337–366.

44.

Mobley

G. M.

, Jaret

, Marsh

, and Lim

Y. Y.

. 1994. Mentoring, job satisfaction, gender and the legal profession. Sex Roles 31: 79–97.

45.

Murray

, 1995. Mentoring the new masters. IMA Newsletter. Spring Issue.

46.

Okurame

D. E.

, 2002. Influence of Psychosocial Factors and the Mediatory Role of Informal Mentoring on Career Outcomes of First-line Bank Managers in Nigeria, Unpublished Doctoral Thesis, Department of Psychology, University of Ibadan, Nigeria.

47.

Okurame

D. E.

, 2006. Organisational Behaviour, in Balogun

S. K.

., Ehigie

B. O.

and Sunmola

A. N.

(ed.) Managerial Psychology: An Overview. Ibadan: Department of Psychology, University of Ibadan.

48.

Okurame

D. E.

, 2007. ‘Perceived mentoring functions: Does mentor's gender matter?’, Women in Management Review, 22(5): 418–427.

49.

Okurame

D. E.

, 2008a. Mentoring and preferences: a diagnostic survey for equal mentoring opportunity. Equal Opportunities International, Vol. 27(6): 519–536.

50.

Okurame

D. E.

, 2008b. ‘Impact of mentoring on perceived adequacy of extrinsic organizational rewards’, Ife Psychologia: An Intrenational Journal, 16 (1): 212–223.

51.

Payne

, 2006. Mentoring a smart business decision, research shows. Retrieved 12/12/2006 at http://communications.tamu.edu/newsarchives/05/020705-10.html.

52.

Peters

, and O'Connor

. 1988. Measuring work obstacles: Procedures, issues, and implications. In Facilitating work effectiveness, ed. Schoorman

E. D.

and Schneider

, pp. 105–124. MA: Lexington Books, Lexington.

53.

Peters

, O'Connor

, and Eulberg

. 1985. Situational constraints: Sources, consequences, and future considerations. In Research in personnel and human resources management, ed. Rowland

K.M.

and Ferris

G. R.

, pp. 79–113. CT: JAI Press, Greenwich.

54.

Phillips-Jones

, 1983. Establishing a formalised mentoring program. Training and Development Journal 2: 38–42.

55.

Pool

, 1997. The relationship of job satisfaction with substitutes of leadership, leadership behavior, and work motivation. The Journal of Psychology 131: 271–283.

56.

Porter

L. W.

, and Smith

F. J.

. 1970. The etiology of organisational commitment, Unpublished Paper, Graduate School of Administration, University of California, Irvine.

57.

Ragins

B. R.

, Cotton

J. L.

, and Miller

J. S.

. 2000. Marginal mentoring: the effects of type of mentor, quality of relationship, and program design on work and career attitudes. Academy of Management Journal, 43(6): 1177–1194.

58.

Randall

D. M.

, 1990. The consequences of organisational commitment: methodological investigation, Journal of Organisational Behaviour, 11(5): 361–378.

59.

Reilly

, Chatman

, and Caldwell

D. E.

. 1991. People and organizational culture: A profile comparison approach to assessing person-organizational fit. Academy of Management Journal 34: 487–516.

60.

Sarason

I. G.

, Sarason

B. R.

, Piece

G. R.

, Shearin

E. N.

, and Sayers

M. H.

. 1991. A social learning approach to increasing blood donations. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 21: 896–918.

61.

Scandura

T. A.

, 1998. Dysfunctional mentoring relationships and outcomes. Journal of Management, 24: 449–467.

62.

Shore

L. M.

, Barksdale

, and Shore

T. H.

. 1995. Managerial perception of employee commitment to the organisation. Academy of management Journal, 38: 1593–1615.

63.

Sousa-poza

, and Sousa-poza

A. A.

. 2000. Well-being at work: A cross-national analysis of the levels and determinants of job satisfaction. The Journal of Socio-economics, 517–538.

64.

Spector

P. E.

, 1985. Measurement of human service staff satisfaction: Development of the Job Satisfaction Survey. American Journal of Community Psychology 13: 693–713.

65.

Spector

P. E.

, and Jex

S. M.

. 1998. Development of Four Self-Report Measures of Job Stressors and Strain: Interpersonal Conflict at Work Scale, Organizational Constraints Scale, Quantitative Workload Inventory, and Physical Symptoms Inventory. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 3: 356–367.

66.

Steijn

, 2004. Human resource management and job satisfaction in the Dutch public sector. Vol. 24(4): 291–303.

67.

Stephen

, 1996. Essential mentoring skills. Stanley Thornes, Cheltenham.

68.

Stueart

R. D.

, and Barbara

B. M.

. 1993. Library and information center management. Colorado: Libraries Unlimited, Englewood.

69.

Ting

, 1997. Determinants of job satisfaction of federal government employees. Public Personnel Management. Fall. Retrieved 27/10/2006 at http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3779/is_199710/ai_n8770471.

70.

Vasu

, Stewart

, and Garson

. 1998. Organizational behavior and public management. Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York.

71.

Walton

, 1986. The Deming management method. Perigee, New York.

72.

Wanous

J. P.

, Poland

T. D.

, Premark

S. L.

, and Davis

K. S.

. 1992. The effects of unmet expectations on newcomer attitude and behaviour: A review and meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology 77: 288–297.

73.

Wharton

A. S.

, and Baron

J. N.

. 1991. Satisfaction? The psychological impact of sex segregation on women at work. The Sociological Quarterly, 365–388.

74.

Wright

B. E.

, 2004. Participation's influence on job satisfaction. Review of Public Personnel Administration 24(1): 18–40.