When Lagrange wrote his masterpiece Mécanique Analytique, the foundations of analysis were not completely understood: to erect the great building of Analytical Mechanics upon solid foundations, the Piedmontese mathematician tried to lay the foundations of differential calculus in a purely algebraic way, using power series instead of functions, regardless about convergence and uniqueness issues. While this foundation was unsatisfactory as shown by Cauchy some decades later, it can shed light on how Lagrange considered the analytical objects (curves, energies, etc.) he dealt with in Mechanics. In this paper, we review these Lagrangian foundations of analysis, and we try to adopt its obvious modern counterpart, i.e., formal power series, to express some results in Analytical Mechanics related to Helmholtz conditions and Rayleigh description of dissipation. By means of purely algebraic manipulations, we will easily recover results otherwise proved by means of modern analysis.
BersaniAMCaressaP.Lagrangian descriptions of dissipative systems: a review. Math Mech Solids2020; 26: 785–803.
2.
AbrahamRMarsdenJERatiuT, et al. Foundations of mechanics. 2nd ed.Madison, WI: AMS Chelsea Publishing, 2008.
3.
DemidovSS. Leonhard Euler, treatise on the differential calculus, (1755). In: Grattan-GuinnessI (ed.) Landmark writings in Western mathematics 1640–1940. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2005, pp. 191–198.
4.
ReichK. Leonhard Euler, introduction to analysis, (1748). In: Grattan-GuinnessI (ed.) Landmark writings in Western mathematics 1640–1940. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2005, pp. 181–190.
5.
BottazziniU.Il calcolo sublime: storia dell’analisi matematica da Euler a Weierstrass. Lezioni e seminari. Turin: Boringhieri, 1981.
6.
FraserC.Joseph Louis Lagrange’s algebraic vision of the calculus. Hist Math1987; 14: 38–53.
GrabinerJV.The origins of Cauchy’s rigorous calculus (Dover books on mathematics). Mineola, NY: Dover Publications, 2005.
9.
GrabinerJV.Historian looks back the calculus as algebra and selected writings: spectrum. Washington, DC: Mathematical Association of America, 2014.
10.
PepeL.Il giovane Lagrange e i fondamenti dell’analisi. In: Sfogliando la Méchanique analytique: Giornata di studio su Louis Lagrange. Milano, 19 Ottobre 2006, pp. 37–49, Milano: Istituto Lombardo. Accademia Di Scienze E Lettere.
11.
RayleighJWS.The theory of sound, 2 Vols in one. Mineola, NY: Dover, 1945.
12.
Dell’IsolaFAndreausUCazzaniA, et al. On a debated principle of Lagrange analytical mechanics and on its multiple applications. In: The complete works of Gabrio Piola: volume I, volume 38 of advanced structured materials. Berlin: Springer, 2014, https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00991089
CapecchiD.History of virtual work laws: a history of mechanics prospective—science networks: historical studies no.42. Cham: Springer, 2012.
15.
YourgrauWMandelstamS.Variational principles in dynamics and quantum theory. 3rd ed.London: Pitman, 1968.
16.
CaressaP.Piccola storia della matematica, vol. 2. Milan: Alphatest, 2010.
17.
FraserC.Lagrange’s analytical mathematics, its cartesian origins and reception in Comte’s positive philosophy. Stud Hist Philos Sci1990; 21: 243–256.
18.
LagrangeJL.Théorie des fonctions analytiques. 2nd ed.Morton, IL: Courcier, 1813.
19.
LagrangeJL.Leçons sur le calcul des fonctions. 2nd ed.Morton, IL: Courcier, 1806.
20.
ChurchA.The calculi of lambda-conversion: annals of mathematical studies. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1941.
21.
CauchyAL.Résumé des leçons données à l’École royale polytechnique sur le calcul infinitésimal, vol. I. Paris: Debure, 1823.
22.
WalkerRJ.Algebraic curves. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1950.
23.
GoldstineHH.A history of the calculus of variations from the 17th through the 19th century (Studies in the history of mathematics and physical sciences no.5). Cham: Springer, 1980.
24.
LagrangeJL.Oeuvres de Lagrange, publiées par les soins de M. J.-A Serret et de Gaston Darboux, vol. 14. Paris: Gauthier-Villars et Fils, 1892.
25.
TodhunterI.A history of the progress of the calculus of variations during the nineteenth century. New York: Macmillan, 1861.
26.
FraserC.JL Lagrange’s changing approach to the foundations of the calculus of variations. Arch Hist Exact Sci1985; 32: 151–191.
27.
Gel’fandIMDikiiLA.Asymptotic behaviour of the resolvent of Sturm–Liouville equations and the algebra of the Korteweg–de Vries equations. Russian Math Surv1975; 30: 77–113.
28.
Gel’fandIMDorfmanIY.Hamiltonian operators and algebraic structures related to them. Funct Anal Appl1980; 13: 248–262.
29.
VinogradovAMKrasil’shchikIS.What is the Hamiltonian formalism?Russian Math Surv1975; 30: 177–202.
30.
CaressaP.Examples of Poisson modules, I. Rend Circ Mate Paler2003; 52: 419–452.
31.
CaressaP.Examples of Poisson modules, II. Rend Circ Mate Paler2004; 53: 23–60.
32.
BourbakiN.Algèbre (chapitres 4 à 7), volume II. Cham: Springer, 2007.
33.
AndronovAAVittAAKhaikinSE.Theory of oscillators, volume 4 of international series of monograph in physics. Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1966.
34.
DelbourgoRSalamAStrathdeeJ.Infinities of nonlinear and Lagrangian theories. Phys Rev1969; 187: 1999–2007.
35.
MathewsPMLakshmananM.On a unique nonlinear oscillator. Quart Appl Math1974; 32: 7.
