Evaluating The Credibility Of Current State Policy In Governing The Management Of Stormwater Pond Sediment

Abstract

Florida state policy—not promulgated regulation—governs stormwater pond sediment disposal, considers sediment a solid waste, and restricts disposal to specific facility types. The policy’s restrictions and lack of regulatory criteria provide no disposal management options for local government. The unnecessarily restrictive state policy prompted the city of Tallahassee to conduct a stormwater pond sediment study to determine whether existing sediment is contaminated, if land use can provide guidance in evaluating disposal options, and whether acceptable disposal alternatives exist. Study findings reveal that considerable variation of contaminant concentrations exists, that land-use features influence contaminant concentration, and that all ponds do not contain or are not likely to contain sediment contaminated to a level requiring restrictive disposal. Findings compared with regulatory criteria reveal public health and the environment can be protected without the current state policy provided local government examines sediment and considers restrictions.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Society for Testing and Materials . (1986). Soil, rock, and building stones. In Annual book of ASTM standards, 4.08 (Section 4, pp. 499-500). West Conshohocken, PA: Author.

Cox, J.H. , Allick, S. , & Be, E. (1998). Characterization of stormwater contaminated sediment and debris for determining proper disposal methods (Final report). Tallahassee: Florida Department of Environmental Protection.

Dewberry and Davis . (1990). Investigation of potential sediment toxicity from BMP ponds (Prepared for Northern Virginia Planning District Commission and Occoquan Policy Board and Virginia State Water Control Board). Fairfax, VA: Author.

Ecology and Environment Inc . (1998). Comprehensive quality assurance plan (No. 860165). Tallahassee, FL: Author.

Fernandez, M., Jr. , & Hutchinson, C.B. (1993). Hydrogeology and chemical quality of water and bottom sediment at three stormwater detention ponds, Pinellas County, Florida (Water Resources Investigations Report No. 92-4139). Tallahassee, FL: United States Geological Survey.

Florida Department of Environmental Protection . (1992). Guidelines for sampling, analyzing, and disposing of stormwater sediments. Tallahassee, FL: Author.

Grizzard, T.J. , Randall, C.W. , Weand, B.L. , & Ellis, K.L. (1986). Effectiveness of extended detention ponds. In Urban Runoff Quality, Impact and Quality Enhancement Technology (pp. 323-337). New York: American Society of Civil Engineers.

Guo, Q. (1997). Sediment and heavy metal accumulation in dry storm water detention basins. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 123(5), 295-301.

Jones, J., Anderson, S., Fognani, J., & McGregor, F.R. (1995, May). BMPs and hazardous sediment. Public Works, 51-54.

10.

Lee, F.L., & Jones-Lee, A. (1995, May). Issues in managing urban storm water runoff quality. Water Engineering and Management, 51-53.

11.

Marsalek, J. , Watt, W.E. , Anderson, B.C. , & Jaskot, C. (1997). Physical and chemical characteristics of sediment from a stormwater management pond. Water Quality Research Journal of Canada, 42, 89-100.

12.

Martin, E.H. , & Smoot, J.L. (1986). Constituent-load changes in urban stormwater runoff routed through a detention pond-wetlands system in central Florida (Water Resources Investigation Report No. 85-4310). Tallahassee, FL: United States Geological Survey.

13.

McGuire, C. (1999). Legal authority to regulate street sweepings (Interdepartmental memorandum to Mary Jean Yon). Tallahassee, FL: Florida Department of Environmental Protection.

14.

Schiffer, D.M. (1989). Effects of three highway-runoff detention methods on water quality of the surficial aquifer system in central Florida. Water Resources Investigation Report 88-4170. Tallahassee, FL: United States Geological Survey.

15.

Statsoft . (1994). Statistica (Version 5.1). Tulsa, OK: Author.

16.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency . (1997). Test methods for evaluating solid waste (SW-846, 3rd ed., Update 3). Washington, DC: Office of Emergency and Remedial Response.

17.

Wanielista, M.P. , & Yousef, Y.A. (1993). Stormwater management. New York: John Wiley.

18.

Whipple, W. (1979). Dual-purpose detention basins. Journal of Water Resource Planning and Management, 105, 403-412.

19.

Yousef, Y.A. , Hvived-Jacobsen, T. , Sloat, J. , & Lindeman, W. (1994). Sediment accumulation in detention or retention ponds. Science of the Total Environment, 146/147, 451-456.

20.

Yousef, Y.A. , Lin, L. , Sloat, J.V. , & Kaye, K.Y. (1991). Maintenance guidelines for accumulated sediments in ponds receiving highway runoff (Final Report No. FL-ER-47-91 prepared for the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Tallahassee). Orlando: University of Central Florida, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering.

21.

Yousef, Y.A. , Wanielista, M.P. , Harper, H.H. , & Jacobsen, T.H. (1986). Effectiveness of retention detention ponds for control of contaminants in highway runoff (Final Report No. FL-ER-34-86 prepared for the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Tallahassee). Orlando: University of Central Florida, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering.