Research on race-specific homicide rates has paid insufficient attention to the issue of data quality. This article compares the two main sources of race-specific homicide rates: the FBI Age, Sex, and Race Record Cards (ASR) and the FBI Uniform Crime Report Supplementary Homicide Reports (SHR), focusing primarily on Black homicide rates. Probably the most important finding of this research is that ASR and SHR race-specific homicide rates cannot both be valid indicators of Black homicide rates in cities. Further analysis suggests that SHR data probably more often provide a valid indicator of overall or race-specific offender homicide rates than do ASR data. Analysis indicates SHR data must be properly examined and screened if they are to provide a valid indicator of race-specific homicide data. This research addresses problems with SHR race-specific homicide data, including outright errors, cases where the race of the offender is unknown, and multiple offender and victim cases.
Black, D., & Reiss, A. (1970). Police control of juveniles. American Sociological Review, 35, 63-77.
2.
Block, C. (1998). An evaluation of the completeness and accuracy of SHR data: Chicago, 1993 and 1994. Chicago: Illinois Criminal Justice Information Authority.
3.
Braga, A., Piehl, A., & Kennedy, D. (1999). Youth homicide in Boston: An assessment of Supplementary Homicide Report data. Homicide Studies, 3, 277-299.
4.
Brownstein, H. (1996). The rise and fall of a violent crime wave. Guilderland, NY: Harrow and Heston.
5.
Federal Bureau of Investigation. (2004). Uniform Crime Reports. Retrieved March 2004 from http://www.fbi.gov/ucr/ucr.htm
6.
Fox, J.A. (2001). Uniform Crime Reports: Supplementary Homicide Reports, 1976-1999. [Computer file and codebook]. ICPSR version. Northeastern University College of Criminal Justice [Producer]. Ann Arbor, MI: Interuniversity Consortium for Political and Social Research.
7.
Gottfredson, M., & Gottfredson, D. (1980). Decision making in criminal justice. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.
8.
Gove, W., Hughes, M., & Geerken, M. (1985). Are uniform crime reports a valid indicator of the index crimes? An affirmative answer with minor qualifications. Criminology, 23, 451-491.
9.
Hindelang, M. (1978). Race and involvement in common law personal crimes. American Sociological Review, 43, 93-109.
10.
Krivo, L., & Peterson, R. (2000). The structural context of homicide: Accounting for racial differences in process. American Sociological Review, 65, 547-560.
11.
LaFree, G., Drass, K., & O’Day, P. (1992). Race and crime in post-war America: Determinants of African American and White rates, 1957-1988. Criminology, 30, 157-185.
12.
Langford, L., Isaac, N., & Kabat, S. (1998). Homicides related to intimate partner violence in Massachusetts: Examining case ascertainment and validity of the SHR. Homicide Studies, 2, 353-377.
13.
Lee, M. (2000). Concentrated poverty, race and homicide. Sociological Quarterly, 41, 189.
14.
Maguire, K., Pastore, A., & Flanagan, T. (1992-1993). Sourcebook of criminal justice statistics. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office. Available at http://www.albany.edu/sourcebook
15.
Maltz, M. (1999). Bridging gaps in police crime data NCJ 176365. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.
16.
Maxfield, M. (1989). Circumstances in Supplementary Homicide Reports: Variety and validity. Criminology, 27, 671-695.
17.
Messner, S., & Golden, R. (1992). Racial inequality and racially disaggregated homicide rates: An assessment of alternative theoretical explanations. Criminology, 30, 421-447.
18.
Messner, S., Raffalovich, L., & McMillan, R. (2001). Economic deprivation and changes in homicide arrest rates for White and Black youths, 1967-1998: A national time-series analysis. Criminology, 39, 591-614.
19.
Messner, S., & South, S. (1986). Economic deprivation, opportunity structure, and robbery victimization: Intra- and interracial patterns. Social Forces, 64, 975-991.
20.
Messner, S. & South, S. (1988). Estimating race-specific offending rates: An inter-city comparison of arrest data and victim reports. Journal of Crime and Justice, 11, 25-45.
21.
National Center for Health Statistics. (1994). Vital statistics of the United States, 1990. Washington, DC: Public Health Service. Retrieved March 2004 from http://www.cdc.gov/nchs
22.
National Center for Health Statistics. (1996). Vital statistics of the United States, 1991. Washington, DC: Public Health Service. Retrieved March 2004 from http://www.cdc.gov/nchs
23.
Ousey, G. (1999). Homicide, structural factors and the racial invariance assumption. Criminology, 37, 405-426.
24.
Parker, K., & McCall, P. (1997). Adding another piece to the inequality-homicide puzzle: The impact of structural inequality on racially disaggregated homicide rates. Homicide Studies, 1, 35-60.
25.
Parker, K., & McCall, P. (1999). Structural conditions and racial homicide patterns: A look at multiple disadvantages in urban areas. Criminology, 37, 447-477.
26.
Parker, K., & Pruitt, M. (2000a). How the West was one: Explaining the similarities in race-specific homicide rates in the West and South. Social Forces, 78, 1483-1508.
27.
Parker, K., & Pruitt, M. (2000b). Poverty, poverty concentration and homicide. Social Science Quarterly, 81, 555-570.
28.
Peterson, R., & Krivo, L. (1993). Racial segregation and Black urban homicide. Social Forces, 71, 1001-1026.
29.
Peterson, R., & Krivo, L. (1999). Racial segregation, the concentration of disadvantage, and Black and White homicide victimization. Sociological Forum, 14, 465-493.
30.
Rantala, R. (2000). Effects of NIBRS on crime statistics. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.
31.
Riedel, M. (1990). Nationwide homicide data sets: An evaluation of the Uniform Crime Reports and the National Center for Health Statistics data. In D. L. MacKenzie, P. J. Baunach, & R. R. Roberg (Eds.), Measuring crime: Large-scale, long-range effects (pp. 175-205). Albany, NY: SUNY Press.
32.
Riedel, M. (1999). Sources of homicide data. In M. Smith & M. Zahn (Eds.), Studying and preventing homicide: Issues and challenges (pp. 31-52). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
33.
Shihadeh, E., & Flynn, N. (1996). Segregation and crime: The effect of Black social isolation on the rates of Black urban violence. Social Forces, 74, 1325-1352.
34.
Shihadeh, E., & Maume, M. (1997). Segregation and crime: The relationship between Black centralization and urban Black homicide. Homicide Studies, 1, 254-280.
35.
Shihadeh, E., & Ousey, G. (1996). Metropolitan expansion and Black social dislocation: The link between suburbanization and center-city crime. Social Forces, 75, 649-666.
36.
Shihadeh, E., & Ousey, G. (1998). Industrial restructuring and violence: The link between entry-level jobs, economic deprivation and Black and White homicide. Social Forces, 77, 185-206.
37.
Shihadeh, E., & Steffensmeier, D. (1994). Economic inequality, family disruption and urban Black violence: Cities as units of stratification and social control. Social Forces, 73, 729-751.
38.
Stamp, J. (1929). Some economic factors in modern life. London: P. S. King and Son.
39.
U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation. (2002). The National Archive of Criminal Justice Data. Ann Arbor, MI: Interuniversity Consortium for Political and Social Research. Retrieved March 2004 from http://www.icpsr.umich.edu/NACJD/
40.
Williams, K., & Flewelling, R. (1987). Family, acquaintance and stranger homicide: Alternative procedures for rate calculations. Criminology, 25, 543-560.
41.
Williams, K., & Flewelling, R. (1988). The social production of criminal homicide: A comparative study of disaggregated rates in American cities. American Sociological Review, 53, 421-431.
