This study examined whether the ideology of machismo is essentially a class-based structural phenomenon found primarily among poor and uneducated, working-class immigrant Latino men or an endemic cultural trait and value. We compared the responses on the Mirandé Sex Role Inventory (MSRI), a measure of traditional gender roles, of a sample of Day Laborer (DLG), immigrant men (N = 37) who work in the secondary labor market in menial, low-wage jobs with those of more educated, largely nonimmigrant, men (N = 105)1 who are part of the primary labor market group (PLG) and have higher-wage stable jobs. DLG consistently scored higher on the Traditionalism items on the MSRI than the PLG sample and endorsed traditional beliefs that restrict women’s behavior and/or activities and reinforce the double sexual standard but results of separate factor analyses conducted with two or three components revealed considerable overlap and consistency in the two samples on the various components of the MSRI, particularly the Traditionalism Factor. The diversity of responses between the two samples suggests that there is not one but a wide range and variety of Latino masculinities.
Almaguer, Tomás.1991. Chicano men: A cartography of homosexual identity and behavior. Differences3:75-100.
2.
Baca-Zinn, Maxine.1979. Chicano family research: Conceptual distortions and alternative directions. Journal of Ethnic Studies7:59-71.
3.
Baca-Zinn, Maxine.1982. Chicano men and masculinity. Journal of Ethnic Studies10:29-44.
4.
Beattie, Peter M.2002. Beyond machismos: Recent examinations of masculinities in Latin America. Men and Masculinities4:303-8.
5.
Bem, Sandra L.1974. The measurement of psychological androgyny. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology42:155-62.
6.
Cantú, Lionel.2001. A place called home: A queer political economy of Mexican immigrant men’s family experiences. In Queer families, queer politics: Challenging culture and state, ed. Mary Berstein and Renate Reimann, 112-36. New York: Columbia University Press.
7.
Coltrane, Scott, and Elsa Valdez.1993. Reluctant compliance: Work-family role allocation in dual-earner families. In Men, Work and Family ed. Jane C. Hood, 151-75. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE.
8.
Coltrane, Scott, Ross D. Parke, and Michele Adams.2004. Complexity of father involvement in low-income Mexican American families. Family Relations53:179-89.
9.
Connell, Robert W.1995. Masculinities. Berkeley: University of California Press.
10.
Connell, Robert W.2000. The men and the boys. Berkeley : University of California Press.
11.
De La Cancela, Victor.1981. Towards a critical psychological analysis of machismo: Puerto Ricans and mental health. PhD Diss., City University of New York. Dissertation Abstracts International, 42:368B.
12.
De La Cancela, Victor.1986. A critical analysis of Puerto Rican machismo: Implications for clinical practice. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training23:291-6.
13.
De La Cancela, Victor.1991. Working affirmatively with Puerto Rican men: Professional and personal reflections. In Feminist approaches for men in family therapy, ed. Michele Bograd, 195-211. Binghamton, NY: Harrington Park Press.
14.
Diaz-Guerro, Rogelio.1967. Psychology of the Mexican: Culture and personality . Austin: University of Texas Press.
15.
Gámez, Grace.2008. Negotiating intimate partner violence, ethnicity, and traditional sex roles in interpersonal relationships: An exploratory study of Latino and Non-Latino college students’ health beliefs (Powerpoint Presentation. Academy on Violence and Abuse).
16.
Gilmore, David.1990. Manhood in the making: Cultural concepts of masculinity . New Haven: Yale University Press .
17.
Gutmann, Mathew.1996. Meanings of macho: Being a man in Mexico city. Berkeley: University of California Press .
18.
Gutmann, Mathew.2003. Changing men and masculinities in Latin America . Durham: Duke University Press .
19.
Hawkes, Glenn R., and Minna Taylor.1975. Power structure in Mexican and Mexican-American farm labor families. Journal of Marriage and the Family37:807-11.
20.
Hondagneu-Sotelo, Pierrette.1994. Gendered transitions: Mexican experiences of immigration . Berkeley: University of California Press.
21.
Ingoldsby, Bron B.1985. A theory for the development of Machismo. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the National Council on Family Relations, Dallas, Texas, November 4-8. Eric (Document Reproduction Service No. ED268399).
22.
Kerr, Daniel, and Christopher Dole .2001. Challenging exploitation and abuse: A study of the Day Labor industry in Cleveland ( Cleveland City Council. Rep., Cleveland, Ohio, Cleveland Oral History Project, Case Western Reserve).
23.
Leonardo, J., and J. O’Shea .1997. A quantitative analysis of ‘‘Shape-ups’’ on long island (Rep. Workplace Project, Hempstead, New York).
24.
Madsen, William.1973. The Mexican Americans of South Texas. New York: Holt.
25.
Mayo, Y.1994. The utilization of mental health aervices, acculturation, and machismo among Puerto Rican men. PhD Diss., Adelphi University.
26.
Alfredo, Mirandé1979. A reinterpretation of male dominance in the Chicano family . The Family Coordinator28:473-9.
27.
Alfredo, Mirandé1988. Que Gacho es ser Macho: It’s a drag to be a macho man. Aztlán17:63-9.
28.
Alfredo, Mirandé1997. Hombres y machos: Masculinity and Latino culture . Boulder: West-view Press.
29.
Mirandé, Alfredo1977. The Chicano family: A reanalysis of conflicting views . Journal of Marriage and the Family39:747-56.
30.
Montiel, Miguel.1970. The social sciences myth of the Mexican American family . El Grito: A Journal of Contemporary Mexican American Though3:56-63.
31.
Neff, James Alan.2001. A confirmatory factor analysis of a measure of ‘machismo’ among Anglo, African American, and Mexican American male drinkers. Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences23:171-88.
32.
Ojeda, Lizette, Rocío Rosales, and Glenn E. Good.2008. Socioeconomic status and cultural predictors of male role attitudes among Mexican American men: ‘‘Son Mas Machos?’’Psychology of Men and Masculinity9:133-8.
33.
Paredes, Américo.1966. The Anglo-American in Mexican folklore. In New voices in American studies, ed. Ray B. Brown, Donald M. Winkelman, and Allen Hayman, 113-28. Lafayette: Purdue University Press.
34.
Paz, Octavio.1961. The labyrinth of solitude. Trans. Lysander Kemp. New York: Grove.
35.
Peña, Manuel.1991. Class, gender and machismo: The treacherous-woman folklore of Mexican male workers. Gender and Society5:30-46.
36.
Peñalosa, Fernando.1968. Mexican family roles. Journal of Marriage and the Family30:680-9.
37.
Ramos, Samuel.1962. Profile of man and culture in Mexico. Trans. Peter G. Earle. Austin: University of Texas Press .
38.
Rudoff, Alvin.1971. The incarcerated Mexican-American delinquent. Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science62:224-38.
39.
Smith, Robert C.2006. Mexico en Nueva York. México D.F.: Porrua.
40.
Staton, Ross D.1972. A comparison of Mexican and Mexican-American families . The Family Coordinator21:325-30.
41.
Stevens, Evelyn P.1965. Mexican machismo: Politics and value orientations . The Western Political Quarterly18:848-57.
42.
Stevens, Evelyn P.1973. Machismo and marianismo. Society10:57-63.
43.
Theodore, Nikolas.2000. A fair day’s pay? Homlesss day laborers in Chicano (Center for Urban Economic Development. University of Illinois at Chicago).
44.
Torres, José B.1998. Masculinity and gender roles among Puerto Rican men: A dilemma for Puerto Rican men’s personal identity. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry68:16-26.
45.
Torres, José B., V. ScottH. Solberg, and Aaron H. Carlstrom.2002. The myth of sameness among Latino men and their machismo. American Journal of Othropsychiatry72: 163-81.
46.
Valenzuela, Abel, Jr.1999. Day laborers in Southern California: Preliminary findings from the day labor survey (Working paper, Cent. Study Urban Poverty, Inst. Soc. Sci. Res., University of California , Los Angeles).
47.
Valenzuela, Jr. Abel.2002. Working on the Margins in Metropolitan Los Angeles: Immigrants in Day Labor Work. Migraciones Internacionales . 1(2):5-28.
48.
Valenzuela, Abel.2003. Day labor work. Annual Review of Sociology29:307-33.
49.
Valenzuela, Abel, and Edwin Meléndez , 2002. Working on the margins in metropolitan Los Angeles: Immigrants in day labor work. Migraciones Internacionales1:5-28.
50.
Valenzuela, Abel, Edwin Meléndez, and Nik Theodore .2003. Day labor in New York: Findings from the NYDL Survey. Working paper. Center for the Study of Urban Poverty, University of California, Los Angeles & Community Development Research Center, New School University.
51.
Vega, Willima A., T. Patterson, J. Sallis, P. Nader, C. Atkins, and I. Abramson.1986. Cohesion and adaptability in Mexican-American and Anglo Families. Journal of Marriage and the Family48:857-67.
