A routine postprocedural chest radiograph had been a safe, checklist-based final step of the procedure, since the start of central venous catheter insertion for hemodialysis to check the position of the catheter tip and to rule out complications. However, the chest radiograph is a suboptimal method to rule out complications like pneumothorax and is not a reliable test to confirm its position. Although it is relatively inexpensive, it is labor-intensive and exposes patient to unnecessary radiation exposure, cost, and often results in delayed use of the catheter. Various studies question the value of a routine chest radiograph as a screening test to rule out the mechanical complications of catheter insertion. We, in this brief viewpoint, present evidence to support the futility of a routine postprocedural chest radiograph in majority of asymptomatic patients and support Choosing Wisely Initiative to avoid low-value studies. However, it should be considered under specific indications, as discussed.
McGeeDCGouldMK.Preventing complications of central venous catheterization. N Engl J Med2003; 348(12): 1123–1133.
2.
ChuiJSaeedRJakobowskiL, et al. Is routine chest X-ray after ultrasound-guided central venous catheter insertion choosing wisely? a population-based retrospective study of 6,875 patients. Chest; 154(1): 148–156.
3.
KDOQI. Clinical practice guidelines for vascular access. Am J Kidney Dis2006; 48(Suppl. 1): S248–S273.
4.
VeselyTM.Central venous catheter tip position: a continuing controversy. J Vasc Interv Radiol2003; 14(5): 527–534.
5.
DariushniaSRWallaceMJSiddiqiNH, et al. Quality improvement guidelines for central venous access. J Vasc Interv Radiol; 21(7): 976–981.
6.
SilberzweigJESacksDKhorsandiAS, et al. Reporting standards for central venous access. J Vasc Interv Radiol2003; 14(9Pt 2): S443–S452.
7.
AshSR.Advances in tunneled central venous catheters for dialysis: design and performance. Semin Dial2008; 21(6): 504–515.
8.
ScottWL.Central venous catheters. An overview of Food and Drug Administration activities. Surg Oncol Clin N Am1995; 4(3): 377–393.
9.
AslamyZDewaldCLHeffnerJE.MRI of central venous anatomy: implications for central venous catheter insertion. Chest1998; 114(3): 820–826.
10.
KowalskiCMKaufmanJARivitzSM, et al. Migration of central venous catheters: implications for initial catheter tip positioning. J Vasc Interv Radiol1997; 8(3): 443–447.
11.
KimMCKimKSChoiYK, et al. An estimation of right- and left-sided central venous catheter insertion depth using measurement of surface landmarks along the course of central veins. Anesth Analg2011; 112(6): 1371–1374.
VinayMTejeshCA.Depth of insertion of right internal jugular central venous catheter: comparison of topographic and formula methods. Saudi J Anaesth2016; 10(3): 255–258.
14.
LeeJHBahkJHRyuHG, et al. Comparison of the bedside central venous catheter placement techniques: landmark vs electrocardiogram guidance. Br J Anaesth2009; 102(5): 662–666.
15.
SalimiFHekmatniaAShahabiJ, et al. Evaluation of routine postoperative chest roentgenogram for determination of the correct position of permanent central venous catheters tip. J Res Med Sci2015; 20(1): 89–92.
16.
EsmailianMAzizkhaniRNajafiN. Saline Flush versus chest X-ray in confirmation of central venous catheter placement; a diagnostic accuracy study. Emerg (Tehran); 5(1): e75.
17.
PikwerABaathLDavidsonB, et al. The incidence and risk of central venous catheter malpositioning: a prospective cohort study in 1619 patients. Anaesth Intensive Care2008; 36(1): 30–37.
18.
FarrellJWalsheJGellensM, et al. Complications associated with insertion of jugular venous catheters for hemodialysis: the value of postprocedural radiograph. Am J Kidney Dis1997; 30(5): 690–692.
19.
BaileySHShapiroSBMoneMC, et al. Is immediate chest radiograph necessary after central venous catheter placement in a surgical intensive care unit. Am J Surg2000; 180(6): 517–521; discussion 521–522.
20.
CoteraABenaventeDLagunaJ, et al. Usefulness of thoracic radiography after insertion of transitory catheters for hemodialysis. Nefrologia2003; 23(1): 47–52.
21.
PikwerABaathLPerstoftI, et al. Routine chest X-ray is not required after a low-risk central venous cannulation. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand2009; 53(9): 1145–1152.
22.
HourmozdiJJMarkinAJohnsonB, et al. Routine chest radiography is not necessary after ultrasound-guided right internal jugular vein catheterization. Crit Care Med2016; 44(9): e804–e808.
23.
AblordeppeyEADrewryAMBeyerAB, et al. Diagnostic accuracy of central venous catheter confirmation by bedside ultrasound versus chest radiography in critically ill patients: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Crit Care Med2017; 45(4): 715–724.
24.
DaltonBGGonzalezKWKeirsyMC, et al. Chest radiograph after fluoroscopic guided line placement: no longer necessary. J Pediatr Surg2016; 51(9): 1490–1491.
25.
JanikJECothrenCCJanikJS, et al. Is a routine chest x-ray necessary for children after fluoroscopically assisted central venous access. J Pediatr Surg2003; 38(8): 1199–1202.
26.
BjorkanderMBentzerPSchottU, et al. Mechanical complications of central venous catheter insertions: a retrospective multicenter study of incidence and risks. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand2018; 63(1): 61–68.
27.
RabindranathKSKumarEShailR, et al. Use of real-time ultrasound guidance for the placement of hemodialysis catheters: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Am J Kidney Dis; 58(6): 964–970.
28.
VatsHS.Complications of catheters: tunneled and nontunneled. Adv Chronic Kidney Dis2012; 19(3): 188–194.
29.
AlrajabSYoussefAMAkkusNI, et al. Pleural ultrasonography versus chest radiography for the diagnosis of pneumothorax: review of the literature and meta-analysis. Crit Care; 17(5): R208.
30.
VezzaniABrusascoCPalermoS, et al. Ultrasound localization of central vein catheter and detection of postprocedural pneumothorax: an alternative to chest radiography. Crit Care Med2009; 38(2): 533–538.
31.
LanzaCRussoMFabrizziG.Central venous cannulation: are routine chest radiographs necessary after B-mode and colour Doppler sonography check. Pediatr Radiol2006; 36(12): 1252–1256.
32.
KuchleCSuttmannYWenM.Placement of central venous dialysis catheters without X-ray: safety and feasibility. J Nephrol Ren Dis2017; 1(1): 1–3.
33.
FraserJReedM.Appropriateness of imaging in Canada. Can Assoc Radiol J2013; 64(2): 82–84.
34.
MolgaardONielsenMSHandbergBB, et al. Routine X-ray control of upper central venous lines: is it necessary. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand2004; 48(6): 685–689.
35.
ZadehMKShirvaniA.The role of routine chest radiography for detecting complications after central venous catheter insertion. Saudi J Kidney Dis Transpl2014; 25(5): 1011–1016.
36.
JordaensLRobbensEVan WassenhoveE, et al. Incidence of arrhythmias after atrial or dual-chamber pacemaker implantation. Eur Heart J1989; 10(2): 102–107.
