Music Teachers' Role in Preparing Students for Live Symphonic Experiences

Abstract

This study investigated the effect of varying the extent of music teacher involvement and training with concert-related instructional materials on student achievement and interest in music following live symphonic experiences. Three hundred and ninety-two middle school students were randomly assigned to one of six music teachers for the purposes of receiving pre-concert instruction. These six music teachers were randomly assigned to one of three different levels of involvement and training relative to the development and use of pre-concert instructional materials. Steps were taken to minimize teacher differences confounding with teacher involvement and training.

There were no significant differences in music achievement or interest scores among middle school subjects based on the extent of their music teacher's involvement and training with pre-concert instructional materials. Based on this study, there are no benefits, specifically in terms of student achievement or interest, in music teachers having a high degree of involvement or training with concert-related instructional materials. Future researchers may wish to examine possible affective benefits when music teachers are involved in the design of and training with concert-related instructional materials.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Colwell, R. (1968). Music achievement tests.. Chicago: Follett Educational Corporation.

Dorman, P.E. (1980). Facilitating integration of the youth concert program with the total school music program. Paper presented at the Music Educators National Conference, Miami.

Froseth, J.O. (1973). How I feel about music. Chicago : GIA Publications.

Froseth, J.O. (1974). The NABIM recruiting manual. Chicago: GIA Publications.

George, W.E. (1980). Measurement and evaluation of musical behaviors . In D.A. Hodges (Ed.), Handbook of music psychology. Lawrence, KS: National Association of Music Therapy.

Hart, P. (1973). The educational role of the symphony orchestra . Music Educators Journal, 60, 26-29 and 79-81.

Higa, H. (1985). The Honolulu Symphony in-school ensembles. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED294 775).

Hill, T.H. , & Thompson, H.M. (1968). The organization and presentation of symphony orchestra youth concert activities for music educational purposes in selected cities. (Office of Education, Bureau of Research, No. BR-6-1548) , Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.

Hintch, E. (1996). Bringing young audiences to classical concerts . Clavier, 35, 10-13.

10.

Jacob, E. (1996). Educating audiences for music: training performers to teach. Arts Education Policy Review, 97, 15-21.

11.

Kaplan, M. (1966). Foundations and frontiers of music education. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston .

12.

Kiser, J. (1997). Reaching out to audiences. Clavier , 36, 13-18.

13.

Kyme, G. (1971). The appropriateness of Young Audience music programs for primary grade children. Journal of Research in Music Education , 19, 366-372.

14.

Lockhart, K. (1997). Reaching audiences. Music Educators Journal, 84, 38-40.

15.

Morgan, H.N. (1947). Concerts for children and young people as a part of music education. In H.N. Morgan (eds.), Music education source book. Chicago: Music Educators 0National Conference.

16.

Mueller, K.H. (1956). Studies in music appreciation. Journal of Research in Music Education, 4, 3-25.

17.

Pucciani, L. (1983). Maximizing mini performances. Music Educators Journal, 69, 54 & 71.

18.

Shehan, P.K. (1986). Music instruction for the live performance. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 88, 51-57.

19.

Sigurdson, G.A. (1971). The effect of a live symphonic concert experience on listening skills and interest in music. Unpublished doctoral dissertation , Michigan State University.

20.

Suthers, L. (1993). Introducing young children to live orchestral performance. Early Childhood Development and Care, 90, 55-64.