Coaching has enjoyed substantial commercial growth, but empirical support for its effectiveness is limited. Nowhere is this more so than in the matching process between coach and coachee. This study describes the results from a coaching programme in which coachees were asked to reflect on and justify their choice of coach. Initial, qualitative results suggested that female coachees favoured the choice of female coaches, partly as a role model of business success. Male coachees tended to justify the selection of a female coach as more approachable for the discussion of sensitive, personal issues. A minority of male respondents also displayed sexist attitudes in their comments on the selection process. Subsequent quantitative analysis of the data, however, revealed no bias towards the choice of either female or male coaches. While the results show no statistical significance in gender choices, for a minority of coachees, gender is a rather surprising factor in the selection process.
Alleman, E. and Newman, I. ( 1984) ‘Interpersonal Perceptions in Mentoring Relationships’ , paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans , Louisiana, 23-7 April.
2.
Allen, T.D. and Eby, L.T. ( 2004) ‘Factors Related to Mentor Reports of Mentoring Functions Provided: Gender and Relational Characteristics’, Sex Roles50(1/2): 129-36.
3.
Allen, T.D., Poteet, M.L. and Russell, J.E. ( 2000) ‘Protégé Selection by Mentors: What Makes the Difference?’ Journal of Organizational Behaviour21(3): 271-82.
4.
Allinson, C.W., Armstrong, S.J. and Hayes, J. ( 2001) ‘The Effects of Cognitive Style on Leader-Member Exchange: A Study of Manager-Subordinate Dyads’, Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology74(2): 201-20.
5.
Archer, D., Iritani, B., Kimes, D.D. and Barrios, M. ( 1983) ‘Face-ism: Five Studies of Sex Differences in Facial Prominence’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology45(4): 725-35.
6.
Armstrong, S.J., Allinson, C.W. and Hayes, J. ( 2004) ‘The Effects of Cognitive Style on Research Supervision: A Study of Student-Supervisor Dyads in Management Education’, Academy of Management Learning and Education3(1): 41-63.
7.
Armstrong, S.J., Allinson, C.W. and Hayes, J. ( 2002) ‘Formal Mentoring Systems: An Examination of the Effects of Mentor/Protégé Cognitive Styles on the Mentoring Process’, Journal of Management Studies39(8): 1111-37.
8.
Bachkirova, T. and Cox, E. ( 2004) ‘A Bridge over Troubled Water: Bringing together Coaching and Counselling’, International Journal of Mentoring and Coaching2(1): 1-10.
9.
Baumgarder, T.L., Lord, R.G. and Maher, K.J. ( 1991) ‘Perceptions of Women in Management’, in R. G.Lord and K. J. Maher (eds) Leadership and Information Processing, pp. 95-113. Boston, MA: Unwin Hyman.
10.
Bennetts, C. ( 1995) ‘Interpersonal Aspects of Informal Mentor/Learner Relationships: A Research Perspective’, in Proceedings of the Third European Mentoring Conference, Sheffield Business School. London: European Mentoring Centre.
11.
Berglass, S. ( 2002) ‘The Very Real Dangers of Executive Coaching’ , Harvard Business Review80(6): 86-93.
Brefach, D.A. ( 1986) ‘The mentor experience: The Influences of Female/Male Mentors on the Personal and Professional Growth of Female Psychologists’, PhD dissertation, Boston University, Boston, MA.
14.
Britton, K. ( 2008) ‘Increasing Job Satisfaction: Coaching with Evidence-based Interventions’, Coaching: An International Journal of Theory, Research and Practice1(2): 176-85.
15.
Bryman, A. and Burgess, R.G. (eds) (1994) Analyzing Qualitative Data. London: Routledge.
16.
Burke, R.J. ( 1984) ‘Mentors in Organizations’, Group and Organization Studies9(3): 253-72.
17.
Burke, R.J., McKeen, C.A. and McKenna, C.S. ( 1990) ‘Sex Differences and Cross-sex Effects on Mentoring: Some Preliminary Data’, Psychological Reports67(3): 1011-23.
18.
Bushardt, S.C., Fretwell, C. and Holdnak, B.J. ( 1991) ‘The Mentor/Protégé Relationship: A Biological Perspective’, Human Relations44(6): 619-39.
19.
Catalyst (2003) ‘Women in US Corporate Leadership: 2003’, URL (consulted 6 February 2009): http://www.catalyst.org
20.
Clawson, J.G. and Kram, K.E. ( 1984) ‘Managing Cross-Gender Mentoring’, Business Horizons27(3): 22-32.
21.
Clutterbuck, D. ( 2008) ‘What’s Happening in Coaching and Mentoring? And What Is the Difference between Them?’, Development and Learning in Organizations22(4): 8-10.
22.
Creswell, J.W., Plano Clark, V., Gutmann, M. and Hanson, W. ( 2003) ‘Advances in Mixed Methods Design’, in A. Tashakkori and C. Teddlie (eds) Handbook of Mixed Methods in the Social and Behavioural Sciences. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
23.
Denzin, N.K. ( 1978) The Research Act: A Theoretical Introduction to Sociological Methods (2nd edn). New York: McGraw-Hill.
24.
Dingman, M.E. ( 2006) ‘Executive Coaching: What’s the Big Deal?’ , International Journal of Leadership Studies1(2): 2-5.
25.
Ellinger, A.D. and Bostrom, R.P. ( 1999) ‘Managerial Coaching Behaviours in Learning Organizations’ , Journal of Management Development18(9): 752-71.
26.
Feldman, D.C. ( 2001) ‘Career Coaching: What HR Professionals and Managers Need to Know’, Human Resource Planning24(2): 26-35.
27.
Feldman, D.C. and Lankau, M.J. ( 2005) ‘Executive Coaching: A Review and Future Research Agenda’, Journal of Management31(6): 829-48.
28.
Flick, H. ( 2006) An Introduction to Qualitative Research (3rd edn). London: Sage .
29.
Frisch, M.H. ( 2001) ‘The Emerging Role of the Internal Coach’ , Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research53(4): 240-50.
30.
Garvey, B. ( 1994) ‘A Dose of Mentoring’, Education + Training36(4): 18-26.
31.
Garvey, B. ( 2004) ‘When Mentoring Goes Wrong’, in D. Clutterbuck and G. Lane (eds) The Situational Mentor, pp 160-77. Aldershot : Gower.
32.
Garvey, B., Stokes, P. and Megginson, D. ( 2009) Coaching and Mentoring: Theory and Practice. London: Sage.
33.
Gorby, C.B. ( 1937) ‘Everyone Gets a Share of the Profits’, Factory Management and Maintenance95(1): 82-3.
34.
Graham, S., Wedman, J.F. and Garvin-Kester, B. ( 1993) ‘Manager Coaching Skills: Development and Application’ , Performance Improvement Quarterly6(1): 2-13.
35.
Graham, S., Wedman, J.F. and Garvin-Kester, B. ( 1994) ‘Manager Coaching Skills: What Makes a Good Coach ?’ Performance Improvement Quarterly7(2):81-94.
36.
Grant, A. ( 2003) ‘The Impact of Life Coaching on Goal Attainment, Metacognition and Mental Health’, Behavior and Personality31(3): 253-64.
37.
Grant, A. ( 2005) ‘What is Evidence-Based Executive, Workplace and Life Coaching?’, in M. Cavanagh, A. M. Grant and T. Kemp (eds) Evidence-based Coaching Vol. 1: Theory, Research and Practice from the Behavioural Sciences, pp. 1-12. Bowen Hills, Qld: Australian Academic Press.
38.
Gray, D.E. ( 2006) ‘Executive Coaching-towards a Dynamic Alliance of Psychotherapy and Transformative Learning Processes’, Management Learning37(4): 475-97.
39.
Gray, D.E. ( 2007) ‘Towards a Systemic Model of Coaching Supervision- some Lessons from Psychotherapeutic and Counselling Models’, Australian Psychologist42(4): 300-9.
40.
Gray, D.E. ( 2009) Doing Research in the Real World (2nd edn). London: Sage.
41.
Gray, D.E., Ekinci, Y. and Goregaokar, H. (In press) ‘Coaching SME Managers: Business Development or Personal Therapy?: A Mixed Methods Study’, International Journal of Human Resource Management. (Accepted for publication 15 July 2009).
42.
Green, S., Oades, L.G. and Grant, A.M. ( 2005) ‘An Evaluation of a Life-Coaching Group Program: Initial Findings from a Waitlist Control Study’, in M. Cavanagh, A. M. Grant and T. Kemp (eds) Evidence-based Coaching Vol 1: Theory, Research and Practice from the Behavioural Sciences, pp. 127-41. Bowen Hills, Qld: Australian Academic Press.
43.
Greene, J.C., Caracelli, J. and Graham, W.F. ( 1989) ‘Toward a Conceptual Framework for Mixed-Method Evaluation Designs’, Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis11(3): 255-74.
44.
Griffiths, K. and Campbell, M.A. ( 2008) ‘Semantics or Substance? Preliminary Evidence in the Debate between Life Coaching and Counselling’, Coaching: An International Journal of Theory, Research and Practice1(2): 164-75.
45.
Hall, D.T., Otazo, K.L. and Hollenback, G.P. ( 1999) ‘Behind Closed Doors: What really Happens in Executive Coaching’, Organizational Dynamics27(3): 39-53.
46.
Hamlin, R., Ellinger, A. and Beattie, R. ( 2006) ‘Coaching at the Heart of Managerial Effectiveness: A Cross- cultural Study of Managerial Behaviours’, Human Resource Development International9(3): 305-51.
47.
Hamlin, R., Ellinger, A. and Beattie, R. ( 2008) ‘The Emerging Coaching Industry: A Wake-up Call for HRD Professionals’, Human Resource Development International6(1): 2-13.
48.
Hart, V., Blattner, J. and Leipsic, S. ( 2001) ‘Coaching Versus Therapy: A Perspective’, Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research53(4): 229-37.
49.
Hu, C., Thomas, K.M. and Lance, C.E. ( 2008) ‘Intentions to Initiate Mentoring Relationships: Understanding the Impact of Race, Proactivity, Feelings of Deprivation, and Relationship Roles’, Journal of Social Psychology148(6): 727-44.
50.
Hurley, A.E. and Fagenson-Eland, E.A. ( 1996) ‘Challenges in Cross-gender Mentoring Relationships: Psychological Intimacy, Myths, Rumours, Innuendoes and Sexual Harassment’, Leadership & Organization Development Journal17(3): 42-9.
51.
International Coach Federation (ICF) (2009 ) Personal communication with Research and Education committee , 18 February.
52.
Jabri, M. and Pounder, J. ( 2001) ‘The Management of Change: A Narrative Perspective on Management Development’, Journal of Management Development20(8): 682-90.
53.
Jarvis, L. ( 2008) Coaching and Buying Coaching Services: A Guide. London: CIPD.
54.
Jones, R.K. ( 2000) ‘The Unsolicited Diary as a Qualitative Research Tool for Advanced Research Capacity in the Field of Health and Illness’ , Qualitative Research10(4): 555-67.
55.
Kemp, T. ( 2005) ‘Psychology’s Unique Contribution to Solution-faced Coaching: Exploring Clients’ Past to Inform their Present and Design their Future’, in M. Cavanagh, A. M. Grant and T. Kemp (eds) Evidence-based Coaching Vol 1: Theory, Research and Practice from the Behavioural Sciences, pp. 37-47. Bowen Hills, Qld: Australian Academic Press.
56.
Kilburg, R.R. ( 1996) ‘Toward a Conceptual Understanding and Definition of Executive Coaching’, Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research11(6): 134-44.
57.
Koberg, C.S., Boss, R.W. and Goodman, E. ( 1998) ‘Factors and Outcomes Associated with Mentoring among Health-care Professionals’, Journal of Vocational Behavior53(1): 161-84.
58.
Kram, K.E. ( 1985) Mentoring at Work: Developmental Relationships in Organizational Life. Glenview, IL: Scott, Foresman .
59.
Kram, K.E., and Hall, D.T. ( 1996) ‘Mentoring in a Context of Diversity and Turbulence’ , in E. E. Kossek and S. Lobel (eds) Managing Diversity: Human Resource Strategies for Transforming the Workplace, pp. 108-36. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell Business.
60.
Lillis, A. ( 1999) ‘A Framework for the Analysis of Interview Data from Multiple Field Research Sites’, Accounting and Finance39(1): 79-105.
61.
Llewellyn, C.D., McGurk, M. and Weinman, J. ( 2005) ‘Striking the Right Balance: A Qualitative Pilot Study Examining the Role of Information on the Development of Expectations in Patients Treated for Head and Neck Cancer’, Psychology, Health and Medicine10(2): 180-93.
62.
Lobel, S.A., Quinn, R.E., St. Clair, L. and Warfield, A. (1994) ‘Love without Sex: The Impact of Psychological Intimacy between Men and Women at Work’, Organizational Dynamics 23(1): 4-16.
63.
McLean, G., Yang, B., Kuo, M.-H.C., Tolbert, A.S. and Larkin, C. ( 2005) ‘Development and Initial Validation of an Instrument Measuring Managerial Coaching Skill’, Human Resource Development Quarterly16(2): 157-78.
64.
Mead, G., Campbell, J. and Milan, M. ( 1999) ‘Mentor and Athene: Supervising Professional Coaches and Mentors’, Career Development International4(5): 283-90.
65.
Megginson, D. and Clutterbuck, D. ( 1995) Mentoring in Action: A Practical Guide for Managers. London: Kogan Page.
66.
Morgan, D.L. ( 1997) Focus Groups as Qualitative Research (2nd edn). London: Sage.
67.
Morgan, L.M. and Davidson, M.J. ( 2008) ‘Sexual Dynamics in Mentoring Relationships: A Critical Review’, British Journal of Management19: S120-S129.
68.
Morrison, A., White, R. and Van Velsor, E. ( 1987) Breaking the Glass Ceiling. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
69.
Noe, R.A. ( 1988) ‘An Investigation of the Determinants of Successful Assigned Mentoring Relationships’, Personnel Psychology41(3): 457-79.
70.
O’Brien K.E., Biga A., Kessler S. R. and Allen T. D. ( 2010) ‘A Meta-analytic Investigation of Gender Differences in Mentoring’, Journal of Management36(2): 537-54.
71.
Olian, J.D., Carroll, S.J. and Giannantonio, C.M. ( 1993) ‘Mentor Reactions to Proteges: An Experiment with Managers’, Journal of Vocational Behavior43(3): 266-78.
72.
O’Neil, R.M., Horton, S. and Crosby, F.J. ( 1999) ‘Gender Issues in Developmental Relationships’ , in A. J. Murrell, F. J. Crosby and R. J. Ely (eds) Mentoring Dilemmas: Developmental Relationships Within Multicultural Organizations . Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates .
73.
Onwuegbuzie, A.J. and Leech, N.L. ( 2005) ‘On Becoming a Pragmatic Researcher: The Importance of Combining Quantitative and Qualitative Research Methodologies’, International Journal of Social Research Methodology8(5): 375-87.
Peel, D. ( 2008) ‘What Factors Affect Coaching and Mentoring in Small and Medium Sized Enterprises’, International Journal of Evidence-Based Coaching and Mentoring6(2): 1-18.
76.
Peterson, D.B. ( 1996) ‘Executive Coaching at Work: The Art of One-to-One Change’, Consulting Psychology Journal48(2): 78-86.
77.
Polkinghorne, D.E. ( 2005) ‘Language and Meaning: Data Collection in Qualitative Research’, Journal of Counseling Psychology52(2): 137-45.
78.
PricewaterhouseCoopers (2007) International Coach Federation Global Coaching Study. Lexington, KY: International Coach Federation.
79.
Quinn, R.E. and Lees, P.L. ( 1984) ‘Attraction and Harassment: Dynamics of Sexual Politics in the Workplace’, Organizational Dynamics13(2) 35-46.
80.
Ragins, B.R. ( 1989) ‘Barriers to Mentoring’, Human Relations42(1): 1-22.
81.
Ragins, B.R. ( 1997) ‘Diversified Mentoring Relationships in Organizations: A Power Perspective’, Academy of Management Review22: 482-521.
82.
Ragins, B.R. and Cotton, J.L. ( 1989) ‘Perceived Barriers to Mentors among Male and Female Proteges’, Academy of Management Proceedings: 360-4.
83.
Ragins, B.R. and Cotton, J.L. ( 1991) ‘Easier Said than Done: Gender Differences in Perceived Barriers to Gaining a Mentor’, Academy of Management Journal34(4): 939-51.
84.
Ragins, B.R. and Cotton, J.L. ( 1999) ‘Mentor Functions and Outcomes: A Comparison of Men and Women in Formal and Informal Mentoring Relationships’, Journal of Applied Psychology84(4): 529-50.
85.
Ragins, B.R. and McFarlin, D.B. ( 1990) ‘Perceptions of Mentor Roles in Cross-gender Mentoring Relationships’, Journal of Vocational Behavior37(3): 321-39.
86.
Richie, J. and Spencer, L. ( 1994) ‘Quantitative Data Analysis for Applied Policy Research’ , in A. Bryman and R. Burgess (eds) Analysing Qualitative Research, pp. 173-94. London: Routledge.
87.
Rock, D. and Donde, R. ( 2008) ‘Driving Organizational Change with Internal Coaching Programs: Part One’, Industrial and Commercial Training40(1): 10-18.
88.
Russell, J.E.A. ( 2006) ‘Career Counseling for Women in Management’ , in W. B. Walsh and M. J. Heppner (eds) Handbook of Career Counseling for Women (2nd edn). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
89.
Saunders, M., Lewis, P. and Thornhill, A. ( 2009) Research Methods for Business Students (5th edn). Harlow: Pearson Education.
90.
Seligman, M.E.P. ( 2007) ‘Coaching and Positive Psychology’, Australian Psychologist42(4): 266-7.
91.
Shapiro, E.C., Haseltine, F.P., and Rowe, M.P. ( 1978) ‘Moving up: Role Models, Mentors and the "Patron System"’, Sloan Management Review19(3): 51-8.
92.
Shaw, P. and Linnecar, R. ( 2007) Business Coaching: Achieving Practical Results through Effective Engagement. Chichester: Capstone.
93.
Siegel, P., Smith, J.W. and Mosca, J.B. ( 2001) ‘Mentoring Relationships and Interpersonal Orientation’ , Leadership & Organization Development Journal22(3): 114-25.
94.
Singh, V., Vinnicombe, S. and James, K. ( 2006) ‘Constructing a Professional Identity: How Young Female Managers Use Role Models’, Women in Management Review21(1): 67-81.
95.
Sosik, J.J., and Godshalk, V.M. ( 2000) ‘The Role of Gender in Mentoring: Implications for Diversified and Homogenous Mentoring Relationships’, Journal of Vocational Behavior57(1): 102-22.
96.
Spence, G.B. and Grant, A. ( 2004) ‘Individual and Group Life Coaching: Findings from a Randomised, Controlled Trial’, in M. Cavanagh, A. M. Grant and T. Kemp (eds) Evidence-based Coaching Vol 1: Theory, Research and Practice from the Behavioural Sciences, pp. 143-58. Bowen Hills, Qld: Australian Academic Press.
97.
Standing Committee on Post-graduate Medical and Dental Education (SCOPME) (1998) Supporting Doctors and Dentists at Work: An Enquiry into Mentoring. London: SCOPME.
98.
Stern, L. ( 2004) ‘Executive Coaching: A Working Definition’ , Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research56(3): 154-62.
99.
Stober, D.R. and Parry, C. ( 2005) ‘Current Challenges and Future Directions in Coaching Research’, in M. Cavanagh, A. M. Grant and T. Kemp (eds) Evidence-based Coaching Vol 1: Theory, Research and Practice from the Behavioural Sciences, pp. 13-19. Bowen Hills, Qld: Australian Academic Press.
100.
Tashakkori, A. and Teddlie, C. (eds) (2003) Handbook of Mixed Methods in the Social and Behavioural Sciences. Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage.
101.
Task Force on Barriers to Women in the Public Service ( 1990) Beneath the Veneer: The Report of the Task Force, Vols 1-4. Ottawa: Ministry of Supply and Services Canada.
102.
Tharenou, P. ( 2005) ‘Does Mentor Support Increase Women’s Career Advancement More than Men’s? The Differential Effects of Career and Psychosocial Support’, Australian Journal of Management , 30(1) 77-109.
103.
Thomas, D. ( 1990) ‘The Impact of Race on Managers’ Experiences of Developmental Relationships (Mentoring and Sponsorship): An Intra-organizational Study’, Journal of Organizational Behavior11(6): 479-92.
104.
Wanberg, C.R., Kammeyer-Mueller, J. and Marchese, M. ( 2006) ‘Mentor and Protégé Predictors and Outcomes of Mentoring in a Formal Mentoring Program’, Journal of Vocational Behavior69(3): 410-23.
105.
Wanberg, C.R., Welsh, E.T.Hezlett, S.A. ( 2003) ‘Mentoring Research: A Review and Dynamic Process Model’, in J. J. Martocchio and G. R. Ferris (eds) Research in Personnel and Human Resources Management, Vol. 22, pp. 39-124. Oxford: JAI Press/Elsevier Science.
106.
Wasylyshyn, K.M., Gronsky, B. and Haas, J.W. ( 2006) ‘Tigers, Stripes, and Behavior Change: Survey Results of a Commissioned Coaching Program’, Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research58(2): 65- 81.
107.
Zeus, P. and Skiffington, S. ( 2002) The Coaching at Work Toolkit. New York : McGraw-Hill.
