In the past, results have shown the influence of oil-additive systems in the life of rolling bearings, also hypotheses have been formulated on the influence of lubricant formulation on the development of early bearing damage associated with white etching cracks. In some earlier work of the authors with different operating conditions, early damage, and white etching cracks had been generated by mechanical stresses. In this study, tests with custom-made lubricants have been performed on thrust as well as radial bearings to clarify some assumptions. The tested oils differ only by the presence of three additives, but only one oil has led systematically to white etching cracks despite the fact that both oils lead to similar mechanical stresses. The results confirm that under mixed lubrication conditions with certain lubricant formulations, early damage, in particular white etching cracks, can be influenced by the oil-additive system likely affecting the bearing steel. Hypotheses are formulated and the influence of different parameters is discussed. This paper, combined with earlier work of the authors, confirms that the understanding and solution to an early bearing damage associated with white etching cracks can only be validated using the appropriate test method.
StadlerKVegterRHVaesD. White etching cracks – a consequence, not a root cause of bearing failure. SKF Evol2018; 1: 21–29.
2.
EvansM-H. An updated review: white etching cracks (WECs) and axial cracks in wind turbine gearbox bearings. Mater Sci Technol2016; 0836: 160226082749003–160226082749003.
3.
ManieriFStadlerKMorales-EspejelG, et al.The origins of white etching cracks and their significance to rolling bearing failures. Int J Fatigue Submitted, 2018.
4.
RuellanACavoretJVilleF, et al.Understanding white etching cracks in rolling element bearings: state of art and multiple driver transposition on a twin-disc machine. Proc IMechE, Part J: J Engineering Tribology2017, pp. 231–231.
5.
ErrichelloRBudnyREckertR. Investigations of bearing failures associated with white etching areas (WEAs) in wind turbine gearboxes. Tribol Trans2013; 56: 1069–1076.
6.
GrecoAShengSKellerJ, et al.Material wear and fatigue in wind turbine systems. Wear2013; 302: 1583–1591.
7.
Stadler K, Vegter E, Ersson M, et al. Causes for premature bearing failures and the role of white etching cracks. In: Proceedings of the “Tribologie-Fachtagung 2016”, Gesellschaft für Tribologie (GfT), Göttingen, 2016.
8.
LaiJStadlerK. Investigation on the mechanisms of white etching crack (WEC) formation in rolling contact fatigue and identification of a root cause for bearing premature failure. Wear2016; 364–365: 244–256.
9.
Stadler K, Andreen M and Ersson M. Short term heavy loads – one cause for premature bearing failures and white etching cracks. In: Proceeding paper 58. Tribologie Fachtagung – Gesellschaft für Tribologie, 2017.
10.
GouldBGrecoAStadlerK, et al.Using advanced tomography techniques to investigate the development of White Etching Cracks in a prematurely failed field bearing. Tribol Int2017, pp. 116–116.
11.
GouldBDemasNGGrecoAC. The influence of steel microstructure and inclusion characteristics on the formation of premature bearing failures with microstructural alterations. Mater Sci Eng A2019; 751: 237–245.
12.
Al-TameemiHLongHDwyer-JoyceR. Damage characterisation of white etching cracks in a black oxide coated wind turbine gearbox bearing. Wear2019; 432–433: 102923–102923.
13.
WanGTYLankampHde VriesA, et al.The effect of extreme pressure (EP) lubricants on the life of rolling element bearings. Proc IMechE, Part J: J Engineering Tribology1994; 208: 247–252.
14.
PasaribuHRLugtPM. The composition of reaction layers on rolling bearings lubricated with gear oils and its correlation with rolling bearing performance. Tribol Trans2012; 55: 351–356.
15.
DanielsenHGutiérrez GuzmánFMuskulusM, et al.FE8 type laboratory testing of white etching crack (WEC) bearing failure mode in 100Cr6. Wear2019; 7: 202962–202962.
16.
Franke J, Holweger W, Surborg H, et al. Influence of tribolayer on rolling bearing fatigue performed on a FE8 test rig. In: Proceedings of the TAE 19th International Colloquium Tribology, Ostfildern, Esslingen, Germany, 21–23 January 2014.
17.
Gutiérrez GuzmánFOezelMJacobsG, et al.Reproduction of white etching cracks under rolling contact loading on thrust bearing and two-disc test rigs. Wear2017; 390–391: 23–32.
18.
HolwegerWWolfMMerkD, et al.White etching crack root cause investigations. Tribol Trans2015; 58: 59–69.
19.
RichardsonADEvansM-HWangL, et al.The evolution of white etching cracks (WECs) in rolling contact fatigue-tested 100Cr6 steel. Tribol Lett2018; 66: 6–6.
20.
FrankeJCareyJTKorresS, et al.White etching cracking—simulation in bearing rig and bench tests. Tribol Trans2017; 0: 1–11.
21.
KruhöfferWLoosJ. WEC formation in rolling bearings under mixed friction: influences and “friction energy accumulation” as indicator. Tribol Trans2017; 60: 516–529.
22.
GouldBDemasNGPollardG, et al.The effect of lubricant composition on white etching crack failures. Tribol Lett2019; 67: 7–7.
23.
HaqueTKorresSCareyJT, et al.Lubricant effects on white etching cracking failures in thrust bearing rig tests. Tribol Trans2018; 0: 1–33.
24.
PaladuguMLucasDRScott HydeR. Effect of lubricants on bearing damage in rolling-sliding conditions: evolution of white etching cracks. Wear2018; 398–399: 165–177.
25.
PapeFTerweyJTWieskerS, et al.Tribological research on the development of White Etching Cracks (WECs). Forschung im Ingenieurwesen2018; 82: 341–352.
26.
RichardsonAEvansM-HWangL, et al.The effect of over-based calcium sulfonate detergent additives on white etching crack (WEC) formation in rolling contact fatigue tested 100Cr6 steel. Tribol Int2019; 133: 246–262.
27.
KinoN. The influence of hydrogen on rolling contact fatigue life and its improvement. JSAE Rev2003; 24: 289–294.
28.
KoharaMKawamuraTEgamiM. Study on mechanism of hydrogen generation from lubricants. Tribol Trans2006; 49: 53–60.
29.
KürtenDKhaderIRagaR, et al.Hydrogen assisted rolling contact fatigue due to lubricant degradation and formation of white etching areas. Eng Fail Anal2019; 99: 330–342.
30.
Gegner J. Tribological aspects of rolling bearing failures. In: Kuo C (ed) Tribology – Lubricants and Lubrication. Rijeka, Croatia: InTech, 2011, pp.34–94.
31.
CantleyRE. Predicting the effects of lubricant chemistry on bearing fatigue life. A S L E Trans1983; 26: 80–86.
32.
MeheuxMMinfrayCVilleF, et al.Effect of lubricant additives in rolling contact fatigue. Proc IMechE, Part J: J Engineering Tribology2010; 224: 947–955.
33.
Surborg H. Einfluss von Grundölen und Additiven auf die Bildung von WEC in Wälzlagern. Dissertation, University of Magdeburg, Germany, 2014.
34.
Nixon HP and Zantopulos H. Observations of the impact of lubricant additives on the fatigue life performance of tapered roller bearings. SAE Technical Paper 952124, Society of Automotive Engineers, Warrendale, PA, 1995.
35.
HarrisTKotzalasMN. Advanced concepts of bearing technology: rolling bearing analysis, 5th ed. Boca Raton: CRC Press, 2006, pp. 368–368.
36.
Topolovec-MiklozicKForbusTRSpikesHA. Film thickness and roughness of ZDDP antiwear films. Tribol Lett2007; 26: 161–171.
37.
BrizmerVPasaribuHRMorales-EspejelGE. Micropitting performance of oil additives in lubricated rolling contacts. Tribol Trans2013; 56: 739–748.
38.
PaladuguMLucasDRScott HydeR. Influence of raceway surface finish on white etching crack generation in WEC critical oil under rolling-sliding conditions. Wear2019; 422–423: 81–93.
39.
HolwegerW. Progresses in solving White etching crack phenoma, Golden, Colorado: NREL – Gearbox Reliability Collaborative, 2014.
40.
Fujita S, Mitamura N and Murakami Y. Research of new factors affecting rolling contact fatigue life. In: Proceedings of WTC2005, World Tribology Congress III, Volume 2, 12–16 September 2005, Washington, D.C., USA.
41.
GouldBGrecoA. The influence of sliding and contact severity on the generation of white etching cracks. Tribol Lett2015; 60: 29–29.
42.
GuzmánFGOezelMOJacobsG, et al.Influence of slip on the formation of White Etching Cracks on a two-disc test rig. Lubricants2017; 6: 17–20.
43.
StadlerKHanBBrizmerV, et al.Benefits of using black oxidized bearings in wind applications. SKF Evol2015, pp. 1–6.
44.
OoiSWYanPVegterRH. Black oxide coating and its effectiveness on prevention of hydrogen uptake. Mater Sci Technol2019; 35: 12–25.
45.
BlassTTrohjahnWMerkD. Influence of material and heat treatment on the formation of WECs on test rig FE8. Bear Steel Technol2017; 11: 129–150.
