Culture and Empirically Supported Treatments: On the Road to a Collision?

Abstract

The dual influence of culturally sensitive therapies (CSTs) and empirically supported treatments (ESTs) on clinical practitioners has grown quickly in the United States. While CST advocates have been driven by the need to provide culturally diverse populations with services that are consistent with their cultural characteristics, practitioners of ESTs have striven to empirically demonstrate the benefits of psychotherapy. However, as EST's influence grows, it may increasingly threaten CST's advances. Some assumptions underlying the development of ESTs are not culturally sensitive and can be detrimental to the well-being of culturally diverse patients. This article highlights these assumptions in four interrelated areas and provides suggestions to overcome these shortcomings. Cultural assumptions and methodological implications of ESTs are presented, as well as some suggestions on how to broaden their cultural understandings. To conclude, some general recommendations on how to start bridging the gap between ESTs and CSTs are proposed.

Keywords

culture diversity empirically supported treatments ethnic minorities psychotherapy research methods

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abreu, J.M. , & Gabarain, G. (2000). Social desirability and Mexican American counselor preferences: Statistical control for a potential confound . Journal of Counseling Psychology, 47, 165-176.

Alvidrez, J. , Azocar, F. , & Miranda, J. (1996). Demystifying the concept of ethnicity for psychotherapy research . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 64, 903-908.

American Psychiatric Association. (1994). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed.). Washington, DC: Author .

American Psychological Association. (2002a). Criteria for evaluating treatment guidelines . American Psychologist , 57, 1052-1059.

American Psychological Association. (2002b). Ethical principles of psychologists and code of conduct . American Psychologist, 57, 1060-1073.

American Psychological Association. (2003). Guidelines on multicultural education, training, research, practice, and organizational change for psychologists . American Psychologist, 58, 377-402.

American Psychological Association. (2006). Evidence-based practice in psychology: APA Presidential Task Force on Evidence-Based Practice . American Psychologist, 61, 271-285.

Atkinson, D.R. , Bui, U. , & Mori, S. (2001). Multiculturally sensitive empirically supported treatments-An oxymoron? In J.G. Ponterotto , J.M. Casas , L.A. Suzuki , & C.M. Alexander (Eds.), Handbook of multicultural counseling (2nd ed., pp. 542-574). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Barlow, D.H. (2004). Psychological treatments . American Psychologist, 59, 869-879.

10.

Barlow, D.H. , Gorman, J.M. , Shear, M.K. , & Woods, S.W. (2000). Cognitive-behavioral therapy, imipramine, or their combination for panic disorder: A randomized controlled trial . Journal of the American Medical Association, 283, 2529-2536.

11.

Bernal, G. (2006). Intervention development and cultural adaptation research with diverse families . Family Process, 45, 143-151.

12.

Bernal, G. , & Saéz-Santiago, E. (2005). Toward culturally centered and evidenced based treatments for depressed adolescents. In W.M. Pinsof & J. Lebow (Eds.), Family psychology: The art of the science (pp. 471-489). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

13.

Bernal, G. , & Scharrón-del-Río, M.R. (2001). Are empirically-supported treatments valid for ethnic minorities? Toward an alternative approach for treatment research . Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology, 7, 328-342.

14.

Berry, J.W. , & Kim, U. (1988). Acculturation and mental health. In P.R. Dansen , J.W. Berry , & N. Sartorius (Eds.), Health and cross-cultural psychology (pp. 207-236). Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

15.

Betancourt, H. , & Lopez, S. (1993). The study of culture, ethnicity and race in American psychology. American Psychologist, 48, 629-637.

16.

Bonham, V.L. , Warshauer-Baker, E. , & Collins, F.S. (2005). Race and ethnicity in the genome era: The complexity of the constructs . American Psychologist, 60, 9-15.

17.

Borkovec, T.D. , Echemendia, R.J. , Ragusea, S.A. , and Ruiz, M. (2001). The Pennsylvania Practice Research Network and possibilities for clinically meaningful and scientifically rigorous psychotherapy effectiveness research . Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice , 8, 155-167.

18.

Borkovec, T.D. , Mathews, A.M. , Chambers, A. , Ebrahimi, S. , Lytle, R. , & Nelson, R. (1987). The effects of relaxation training with cognitive or nondirective therapy and the role of relaxation-induced anxiety in the treatment of generalized anxiety . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 55, 883-888.

19.

Brown, C. , Schulberg, H.C. , Sacco, D. , Perel, J.M. , & Houck, P.R. (1999). Effectiveness of treatments for major depression in primary medical care practice: A post hoc analysis of outcomes for African American and white patients . Journal of Affective Disorders , 53, 185-192.

20.

Bruner, J. (1990). Acts of meaning. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

21.

Butler, G. , Fennell, M. , Robson, P. , & Gelder, M. (1991). Comparison of behavior therapy and cognitive behavior therapy in the treatment of generalized anxiety disorder . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 59, 167-175.

22.

Byrne, B.M. , & Campbell, T.L. (1999). Cross-cultural comparisons and the presumption of equivalent measurement and theoretical structure: A look beneath the surface . Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology , 30, 555-574.

23.

Carpinello, S.E. , Rosenberg, L. , Stone, J. , Schwager, M. , & Felton, C.J. (2002). New York State's campaign to implement evidence-based practice practices for people with serious mental disorders . Psychiatric Services, 53, 153-155.

24.

Carter, R.T. , & Qureshi, A. (1995). A typology of philosophical assumptions in multicultural counseling and training. In J.G. Ponterotto , J.M. Casas , L.A. Suzuki , & C.M. Alexander (Eds.), Handbook of multicultural counselling (pp. 239-262). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

25.

Chambless, D.L. , Baker, M.J. , Baucom, D.H. , Beutler, L.E. , Calhoun, K.S. , Crits-Christoph, P. , et al. (1998). An update on empirically validated therapies II . The Clinical Psychologist, 51, 3-16.

26.

Chambless, D.L. , Sanderson, W.C. , Shoham, V. , Bennet, B.E. , Johnson, S. , Pope, K.S. , et al. (1996). An update on empirically validated therapies . The Clinical Psychologist, 49, 5-18.

27.

Clark, R. , Anderson, N.B. , Clark, V.R. , & Williams, D.R. (2000). Racism as a stressor for African Americans: A biopsychosocial model . American Psychologist , 54, 805-816.

28.

Clay, D. , Mordhorst, M. , & Lehn, L. (2002). Empirically supported treatment in pediatric psychology: Where is the diversity ? Journal of Pediatric Psychology, 27, 325-337.

29.

Constantino, M.J. , Castonguay, L.G. , & Schut, A.J. (2002). The working alliance: A flagship for the `scientist-practitioner' model in psychotherapy. In G. Tyron (Ed.), Counseling based on process research (pp. 81-131). New York: Allyn & Bacon.

30.

Costantino, G. , Malgady, R. , & Rogler, L. (1986). Cuento therapy: A culturally sensitive modality for Puerto Rican children . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 54, 639-645.

31.

Crits-Christoph, P. (1998). Training in empirically validated treatments In K.S. Dobson & K.D. Craig (Eds.), Empirically supported treatments: Best practices in professional psychology (pp. 3-25). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

32.

Cushman, P. (1995). Constructing the self, constructing America: Studies in the cultural history of psychotherapy. New York: Addison-Wesley.

33.

D'Andrade, R. (1990). Some propositions about the relationship between culture and human cognition. In J. Stigler , R. Shweder , & G. Herdt (Eds.), Cultural psychology: Essays on comparative human development (pp. 88-120). New York: Cambridge University Press.

34.

DeLeon, P. , & VandenBos, G. (1995). Psychotherapy in managed care mental health care: Integrating federal policy with clinical practice. In C. Austad & W. Berman (Eds.), Psychotherapy in managed health care: The optimal use of time and resources (pp. 251-263). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association .

35.

Doyle, A.B. (1998). Are empirically validated treatments valid for culturally diverse populations? In K.S. Dobson & D.D. Craig (Eds.), Empirically supported therapies: Best practices in professional psychology (pp. 93-103). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

36.

Flaskerud, J.H. (1986). The effects of culture-compatible intervention on the utilization of mental health services by minority clients . Community Mental Health Journal, 22, 127-141.

37.

Gamst, G. , Dana, R.H. , Der-Karaberian, A. , & Kramer, T. (2000). Ethnic match and patient ethnicity effects on global assessment and visitation . Journal of Community Psychology , 28, 547-564.

38.

Geertz, C. (1973). Interpretation of cultures. New York: Basic Books.

39.

Greenberg, L.S. , & Newman, F.L. (1996). An approach to psychotherapy change process research: Introduction to the special section . Journal of Consulting and Community Psychology, 64, 435-438.

40.

Griner, D. , & Smith, T.B. (2006). Culturally adapted mental health intervention: A meta-analytic review . Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training, 43, 531-548.

41.

Hall, C.C.I. (1997). Cultural malpractice: The growing obsolescence of psychology with the changing U.S . population. American Psychologist, 52, 642-651.

42.

Hall, G.C.N. (2001). Psychotherapy research with ethnic minorities: Empirical, ethical, and conceptual issues . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 69, 502-510.

43.

Helms, J.E. , Jernigan, M. , & Macher, J. (2005). The meaning of race in psychology and how to change it: A methodological perspective . American Psychologist, 60, 27-36.

44.

Huppert, J.L. , Bufka, L.F. , Barlow, D.H. , Gorman, J.M. , Shear, M.K. , & Woods, S.W. (2001). Therapists, therapist variables, and cognitive-behavioral therapy outcome in a multicenter trial for panic disorder . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 69, 747-755.

45.

Jacobson, N.S. , Dobson, K.S. , Truax, P.A. , Addis, M.E. , Koerner, K. , Gollan, J.K. , Gortner, E. , & Prince, S.E. (1996). A component analysis of cognitive-behavioral treatment for depression . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology , 64, 295-304.

46.

Jahoda, G. (1992) Crossroads between culture and mind: Continuities and change in theories of human nature. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

47.

Johnson, T. , Kulesa, P. , Cho, Y.I. , & Shavitt, S. (2005). The relation between culture and response styles . Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 36, 264-277.

48.

Kazdin, A.E. (1999). Overview of research design issues in clinical psychology. In P.C. Kendall , J.N. Butcher , & G.N. Holmbeck (Eds.), Handbook of research methods in clinical psychology (pp. 3-30). New York: Wiley .

49.

Kim, U. (2000). Indigenous, cultural, and cross-cultural psychology: A theoretical, conceptual, and epistemological analysis . Asian Journal of Social Psychology, 3, 265-287.

50.

Kim, U. , & Berry, J.W. (1993) Indigenous psychologies: Experience and research in cultural context. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

51.

Kim, U. , Park, Y.S. , &, Park, D.H. (2000). The challenge of cross-cultural psychology: The role of indigenous psychologies . Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 31, 63-75.

52.

Kleinman, A. (1988). Rethinking psychiatry: From cultural category to personal experience. New York: Free Press.

53.

Kopta, S.M. , Lueger, R.J. , Saunders, S.M. , & Howard, K.I. (1999). Individual psychotherapy outcome and process research: Challenges leading to greater turmoil or a positive transition ? Annual Review of Psychology, 50, 441-469.

54.

Lambert, M.J. , & Ogles, B.M. , (2003). The effectiveness of psychotherapy. In M.J. Lambert (Ed.), Bergin and Garfield's handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change (5th ed., pp. 139-193). New York: Wiley .

55.

Landrine, H. , & Klonoff, E.A. (1996). African American acculturation. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage

56.

La Roche, M. (2005). The cultural context and the psychotherapeutic process: Toward a culturally sensitive psychotherapy . Journal of Psychotherapy and Integration, 15, 153-180.

57.

La Roche, M. , D'Angelo, E. , Gualdron, L. , & Leavell, J. (2006). Culturally sensitive guided imagery for allocentric Latinos: A pilot study . Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training, 43, 555-560.

58.

La Roche, M. , Koinis-Mitchell, D. , & Gualdron, L. (2006). A culturally competent asthma management intervention: A randomized controlled pilot study . Annals of Asthma and Immunology, 96, 85-91.

59.

La Roche, M. , & Maxie, A. (2003). Ten considerations in addressing cultural differences in psychotherapy . Professional Psychology: Research and Practice , 34, 180-186.

60.

La Roche, M. , & Turner, C. (2002). At the crossroads: Managed mental health care, the ethics code and ethnic minorities . Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology, 8, 187-198.

61.

Linehan, M. (1993). Cognitive-behavioral treatment of borderline personality disorder. New York: Guilford.

62.

Little, T.D. (1997). Mean and covariance structures (MACS) analysis of cross-cultural data: Practical and theoretical issues . Multivariate Behavioral Research, 32, 53-76.

63.

Little, T.D. , Card, N.A. , Slegers, D.W. , & Ledford, E.C. (2007). Representing contextual effects in multiple group MACS models. In T.D. Little , J.A. Bovaird , & N.A. Card (Eds.), Modeling contextual effects in longitudinal studies (pp. 121-148). New York: Routledge .

64.

Lopez, S.R. , & Guarnaccia, P. (2000). Cultural psychopathology: Uncovering the social world of mental illness . Annual Review of Psychology, 51, 571-598.

65.

Markowitz, J.C. , Spielman, L.A. , Sullivan, M. , & Fishman, B. (2000). An exploratory study of ethnicity and psychotherapy outcome among HIV-positive patients with depressive symptoms . Journal of Psychotherapy Practice & Research, 9, 226-231.

66.

Marsella, A.J. (1998). Toward a `global-community psychology': Meeting the needs of a changing world . American Psychologist, 53, 1282-1291.

67.

Miranda, J. , Bernal, G. , Lau, A. , Kohn, L. , Hwang, W.-C. , & LaFromboise, T. (2005). State of the science on psychosocial interventions for ethnic minorities . Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, 1, 113-142.

68.

Miranda, J. , Nakamura, R. , & Bernal, G. (2003). Including ethnic minorities in mental health intervention research: A practical approach to a longstanding problem . Culture, Medicine, & Psychiatry, 27, 467-486.

69.

Muñoz, R.F. , & Mendelson, T. (2005). Toward evidence-based interventions for diverse populations: The San Francisco General Hospital prevention and treatment manuals . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 73, 790-799.

70.

Norasakkunkit, V. , & Kalick, S.M. (2002). Culture, ethnicity, and emotional distress measures: The role of self-construals and self-enhancement . Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 33, 56-70.

71.

Norcross, J.C. (Ed.). (2002). Psychotherapy relationships that work: Therapist contributions and responsiveness to patient needs. New York: Oxford University Press.

72.

Oyserman, D. , Coon, H. , & Kemmelmeier, M. (2002). Rethinking individualism and collectivism: Evaluation of theoretical assumptions and meta-analyses . Psychological Bulletin, 128, 3-72.

73.

Phinney, J.S. (1996). When we talk about American ethnic groups, what do we mean? American Psychologist, 51, 918-927.

74.

Rhode, P. , Sealey, J.R. , Kaufman, N.K. , Clark, G.N. , & Stice, E. (2006). Predicting time to recovery among depressed adolescents treated in two psychosocial group interventions . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 74, 80-88.

75.

Rowe, D.C. (2002). IQ, birth weight, and number of sexual partners in White, African American, and mixed race adolescents . Populations , 23, 513-524.

76.

Rupert, P. , & Baird, R. (2004). Managed care and the independent practice of psychology . Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 35, 185-193.

77.

Samuda, R.J. , Feuerstein, R. , Kaufman, A.S. , Lewis, J.E. , Sternberg, R.J. , et al. (1998) Advances in cross-cultural assessment. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

78.

Shweder, R. (1995). Cultural psychology: What is it? In N. Rule-Goldberger & J. Bennet-Veroff (Eds.), The culture and psychology reader (pp. 41-86). New York: New York University Press.

79.

Shweder R. , & Bourne E. (1982). Does the concept of person vary cross-culturally? In R. Shweder & R. Levine (Eds.), Culture theory: Essay on mind, self and emotion (pp. 97-111). New York: Cambridge University Press.

80.

Singelis, T. , Triandis, H. , & Bhawuk, D.M. (1996). Horizontal and vertical dimensions of individualism and collectivism: A theoretical and measurement refinement . Cross-Cultural Research, 29, 240-276.

81.

Smith, M.L. , & Glass, G.V. (1977). Meta-analysis of psychotherapy outcome studies . American Psychologist, 32, 752-760.

82.

Smith, M.L. , Glass, G.V. , & Miller, T.L. (1980). Benefits of psychotherapy. Baltimore , MD: Johns Hopkins University Press .

83.

Snowden, L.R. (2003). Bias in mental health assessment and intervention: Theory and evidence . American Journal of Public Health, 93, 239-243.

84.

Snowden, L.R. , Martinez, M. , & Morris, A. (2000). Community psychology and ethnic minority populations . In J. Rappaport & E. Seidman (Eds.), Handbook of community psychology (pp. 833-856). New York: Plenum.

85.

Sternberg, R.J. (2006). Evidence-based practice: Gold standard, gold plated, or fool's gold? In C.D. Goodheart , A.E. Kazdin , & R.J. Sternberg (Eds.), Evidence-based psychotherapy: Where practice and research meet. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

86.

Stuart, G.L. , Treat, T.A. , & Wade, W.A. (2000). Effectiveness of an empirically based treatment for panic disorder delivered in a service clinic setting: 1-year follow-up . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 68, 506-512.

87.

Sue, D.W. , Ivey, A.E. , & Pedersen, P.B. , (1996). A theory of multicultural therapy and therapy. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole .

88.

Sue, S. (1999). Science, ethnicity and bias: Where have we gone wrong ? American Psychologist, 54, 1070-1077.

89.

Sue, S. , Fujino, D.C. , Hu, L. , Takeuchi, D.T. , & Zane, N. (1991). Community mental health services for ethnic minority groups: A test of the cultural responsiveness hypothesis . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 59, 533-540.

90.

Sue, S. , Kuraski, K. , & Srinivasan, S. (1999). In P.C. Kendall , J.N. Butcher , & G.N. Holmbeck (Eds.), Handbook of research methods in clinical psychology (pp. 330-349). New York: Wiley.

91.

Sue, S. , Zane, N. , Levant, R.F. , Silverstein, L.B. , Brown, L.S. , Olkin, R. , et al. (2006). How well do both evidence-based practices and treatment as usual satisfactorily address the various dimensions of diversity? In J.C. Norcross , L.E. Beutler , & R.F. Levant (Eds.), Evidence-based practices in mental health: Debate and dialogue on the fundamental questions (pp. 329-337). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

92.

Takaki, R. (1993). A different mirror: A history of multicultural America. Boston, MA: Little Brown .

93.

Takeuchi, D.T. , & Uehara, E.S. (1996). Ethnic minority mental health services: Current research and future conceptual directions, In B.L. Levin & J. Petrilla (Eds.), Mental health services: A public health perspective (pp. 63-80). New York: Oxford University Press.

94.

Task Force on the Promotion and Dissemination of Psychological Procedures. (1995). Training in dissemination of empirically-validated psychological treatments The Clinical Psychologist, 48, 3-23.

95.

Triandis, H.C. (1995). Individualism and collectivism. Boulder, CO: Westview.

96.

Triandis, H.C. (2000). Dialectics between cultural and cross-cultural psychology . Asian Journal of Social Psychology, 3, 185-195.

97.

US Census Bureau. (2001). Profile of general demographic characteristics: 2000 Census of Population and Housing, United States. Retrieved November 20, 2007 from http://www.census.gov/population/www./socdemo/race.html.

98.

US Department of Health and Human Services. ( 2001). Mental health: Culture, race and ethnicity-A supplement to Mental health: A report of the Surgeon General. Rockville, MD: US Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Services, Offices of the Surgeon General.

99.

Wampold, B.E. (2001). The great psychotherapy debate: Models, methods and findings. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum .

100.

Wampold, B.E. , & Brown, G. (2005). Estimating therapist variability in outcomes attributable to therapists: A naturalistic study of outcomes in managed care . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 73, 914-923.

101.

Wang, P.S. , Berglund, P. , & Kessler, R.C. (2000). Recent care of common mental disorders in the United States . Journal of General Internal Medicine, 15, 284-292.

102.

Weissman, M. , Markowitz, J. , & Klerman, G. (2000). Comprehensive guide to interpersonal psychotherapy . New York: Basic Books.

103.

Westen, D. , Novotny, C.M. , & Thompson-Brenner, H. (2004). The empirical status of empirically supported psychotherapies: Assumptions, findings and reporting in controlled clinical trials . Psychological Bulletin, 130, 631-663.

104.

Westen, D. , Novotny, C.M. , & Thompson-Brenner, H. (2005). EBP is not equal to EST: Reply to Crits-Christoph et al. (2005) and Weisz et al. (2005) . Psychological Bulletin, 131, 427-433.