In this article the authors assess the impact of the European Commission's state aid policy on the public service remit of public broadcasting organizations in the digital age. The article consists of two parts. In the first part the authors give an overview of the policy and legal context in which state aid control of public service broadcasting evolves. Second, recent state aid cases that touch upon the issue of digitization and public service broadcasting are analysed. Whereas Member States fear too much Commission intervention, the European Commission, on the contrary, fears that Member States abuse the margins of the European Treaty in order to expand the digital public service remit in unauthorized ways, such as financing commercial digital activities. Whether the Commission is right to fear a `mission creep' on behalf of the public service broadcasters due to vague and overambitious digitilization plans, remains to be seen however.
Antoniadis, A. (2006) `The Financing of Public Service Broadcasting' , in M.S. Rydelski (ed.) The EC SA Regime: Distortive Effects of SA on Competition and Trade, pp. 591-630. London: Cameron May.
2.
Appelman, M., Van Dijk, M., Nahuis, R., Vollaard, B. and Waagmeester, D. (2005) `Een economisch vooronderzoek ten behoeve van het rapport van de WRR over de media' (An economic explorative analysis contributing to the WRR Report on the media), in W.B.H.J. Van de Donk, D.W.J. Broeders and F.J.P.M. Hoefnagel (eds) Trends in het medialandschap. Vier verkenningen (Trends in the media landscape: Four explorations), pp. 11-65. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
3.
Armstrong, M. (2005) `Public Service Broadcasting', Fiscal Studies26(3): 281-99.
4.
Armstrong, M. and Weeds, E. (2005) `Public Service Broadcasting in the Digital World' , URL (consulted March 2007): http://12932941/eps/io/papers/0507/050710.pdf
5.
Bavasso, A. (2006) `Broadcasting', in L. Hancher, T. Ottervanger and P.J. Slot (eds) EC SAs, pp. 420-38. London : Thomson Sweet and Maxwell.
6.
Buendia Sierra, J.L. (2006) `An Analysis of Article 86(2) EC', in M.S. Rydelski (ed.) The EC SA Regime: Distortive Effects of SA on Competition and Trade, pp. 541-74. London: Cameron May.
7.
Burgelman, J.C. (1990) Omroep en politiek in België. Het Belgisch audiovisuele bestel als resultante van de naoorlogse partijpolitieke machtsstrategieën (1940-1960) (Broadcasting and politics in Belgium. The Belgian audiovisual landscape as a result of post war party political power strategies (1940-1960)) . Brussels: BRT.
8.
Cini, M. and McGowan, L. (1998) Competition Policy in the European Union. London: Macmillan.
9.
Collins, R., Finn, A., McFadyen, S. and Hoskins, C. (2001) `Public Service Broadcasting Beyond 2000: Is There a Future for Public Service Broadcasting?' Canadian Journal of Communication26(1): 3-15.
10.
Coppens, T. and Saeys, F. (2006) `Enforcing Performance: New Approaches to Govern Public Service Broadcasting', Media, Culture & Society28(2): 261-84.
11.
Coppieters, S. (2003) `The Financing of Public Service Broadcasting' , in A. Biondi, P. Eeckhout and J. Flynn (eds) The Law of SA in the European Union, pp. 265-79. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
12.
Craufurd-Smith, R. (2004) `The Development of Cultural Policy by the European Community', in R. Craufurd-Smith (ed.) Culture and European Union Law, pp. 19-80. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
13.
Davies, G. (2005) `The BBC and Public Value', in D. Helm, D. Green , M. Oliver, S. Terrington, A. Graham, B. Robinson, G. Davies, J. Mayhew and L. Bradley-Jones (eds) Can the Market Deliver? Funding Public Service Television in the Digital Age, pp. 129-50. Eastleigh: John Libbey.
14.
Davies, G., Black, H., Budd, A., Evans, R., Gordon, J., Lipsey, D., Neuberger, J. and Newton, T. (1999) The Future Funding of the BBC: Report of the Independent Review Panel. London: Department of Culture, Media and Sport.
15.
Depypere, S. and Tigchelaar, N. (2004) `The Commission's SA Policy on Activities of Public Service Broadcasters in Neighbouring Markets', Competition Policy Newsletter2: 19-22.
16.
Dinan, D. (1999) Ever Closer Union. An Introduction to European Integration. London: Macmillan.
17.
Duff, A. (1997) The Treaty of Amsterdam. London : The Federal Trust.
18.
European Commission (1999) - 14 December 1999 - Decision SA: Financing of a 24-Hour Advertising-Free News Channel out of the Licence Fee by the BBC (SG(99) D/10201).
19.
European Commission (2001) - 15 November 2001 - Communication on the Application of SA Rules to Public Service Broadcasting (PB C 320).
20.
European Commission (2002) - 22 May 2002 - Decision SA: BBC Licence Fee (C(2002)1886).
21.
European Commission (2003) - 1 November 2003 - Decision SA: BBC Digital Curriculum (C(2003)3371).
22.
European Commission (2004a) - 3 February 2004 - Preliminary Investigation: ad-hoc Measures to Dutch Public Broadcasters and NOB (2004/C 61/05).
23.
European Commission (2004b) - 19 May 2004 - Decision SA: Measures Implemented by Denmark for TV2/Danmark (C(2004)1814).
24.
European Commission (2006) - 22 June 2006 - Decision SA: ad hoc Financing of Dutch Public Service Broadcasters (C 2/2004).
25.
European Commission (2007) - 24 April 2007 - Decision SA: Financing of Public Service Broadcasters in Germany (C(2007)1761)
26.
European Communities (1997) Protocol on the System of Public Service Broadcasting in the Member States (Part of the Amsterdam Treaty).
27.
Garnham, N. (1990) Capitalism and Communication: Global Culture and the Economics of Information. London: SAGE.
28.
Goodwin, I. and Spittle, S. (2002) `The European Union and the Information Society: Discourse, Power and Policy', New Media and Society4(2): 225-50.
29.
Harpcourt, A. (2004) `Institution-Driven Competition: The Regulation of Cross-Border Broadcasting in the EU' (European Forum Series Working Paper), Florence, European University Institute. Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies.
30.
Hargreaves Heap, S.P. (2005) `Public Service Broadcasting: Television in a Digital Age: What Role for Public Service Broadcasting?'Economic Policy20(41): 112-57.
31.
Harrison, J. and Woods, L.M. (2001) `Defining European Public Service Broadcasting' , European Journal of Communication16(4): 477-504.
32.
Hencsey, M., Reymond, O., Riedl, A., Santamato, S. and Westerhof, J.G. (2005) `SA Rules and Public Funding of Broadband', Competition Policy Newsletter1: 8-15.
33.
Héritier, A. (2001) `Market Integration and Social Cohesion: The Politics of Public Services in European Regulation', Journal of European Public Policy8(5): 825-52.
34.
Hitchens, L. (2006) Broadcasting Pluralism and Diversity. A Comparative Study of Policy and Regulation. Oxford: Hart Publishing.
35.
Hobbelen, H., Harris, V. and Dominguez, I. (2007) `The Increasing Importance of EC SA Rules in the Communications and Media Sectors', European Competition Law Review2: 101-15.
36.
Hoskins, C., McFadyen, S. and Finn, A. (2004) Media Economics. Applying Economics to New and Traditional Media. London: SAGE .
37.
Knox, F. (2005) `The Doctrine of Consumers' Sovereignty', Review of Social Economy63(3): 383-94.
38.
Kroes, N. (2006) `Strengthening the European Creative Industries in the Light of the i2010 Strategy', opening address at the Austrian Presidency Expert Seminar, Content For Competitiveness, 2 March. Vienna.
39.
Martin, W.J. (1995) The Global Information Society. Aldershot: Aslib Gower.
40.
Nihoul, P. (1998) `Les services d'intérêt général dans le Traité d'Amsterdam' (Services of general economic interest in the Amsterdam Treaty) , in Y. Lejeune (ed.) Le Traité d'Amsterdam: espoirs et déceptions (The Amsterdam Treaty: Hope and disapointment), pp. 341-55. Brussels: Bruylant .
41.
Nitsche, I. (2001) Broadcasting in the European Union: The Role of Public Interest in Competition Analysis. The Hague: TMC Asser Press.
42.
NN (2006) `Action Brought on 4 September 2006: Nederlandse Omroep Stichting vs. Commission of the European Communities (T237/06)', Official Journal of the European Union49.
43.
Papadias, L., Riedl, A. and Westerhof, J.G. (2006) `Public Funding for Broadband Networks - Recent Developments', Competition Policy Newsletter3: 13-8.
44.
Pauwels, C. and Burgelman, J.-C. (2003) `Policy Challenges Resulting from the Creation of a European Information Society: A Critical Analysis' , in J. Servaes (ed.) The European Information Society: A Reality Check, pp. 59-86. Bristol and Portland: Intellect.
45.
Peacock, A. (2000) `Editorial - Market Failure and Government Failure in Broadcasting', Economic Affairs20(4): 2-6.
46.
Petrella, R. (1997) Het algemeen belang. Lof van de solidariteit (The public interest: Praising solidarity). Brussels: VUBPress.
47.
Reding, V. (2006) `Foreword', in E. Richards, R. Foster and T. Kiedrowski (eds) Communications - The Next Decade: A Collection of Essays Prepared for the UK Office of Communications , pp. 59-86. London: Ofcom.
48.
Rizza, C. (2003) `The Financial Assistance Granted by Member States to Undertakings Entrusted with the Operation of a Service of General Economic Interest', in A. Biondi, P. Eeckhout and J. Flynn (eds) The Law of SA in the European Union, pp. 67-84. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
49.
Robinson, B., Raven, J. and Low, L.P. (2005) `Paying for Public Services Television in the Digital Age', in D. Helm, D. Green, M. Oliver, S. Terrington, A. Graham , B. Robinson, G. Davies, J. Mayhew and L. Bradley-Jones (eds) Can the Market Deliver? Funding Public Service Television in the Digital Age. Eastleigh: John Libbey.
50.
Sawers, D. (2000) `The Future of Broadcasting - Public Service Broadcasting: A Paradox of our Time', Economic Affairs20(4): 33-5.
51.
Schoser, C. and Santamato, S. (2006) `The Commission's SA Policy on the Digital Switchover' , Competition Policy Newsletter1: 23-7.
52.
Syvertsen, T. (2003) `Challenges to Public Television in the Era of Convergence and Commercialisation', Television and New Media4(2): 155-76.
53.
Szyszczak, E. (2004) `Public Services in the New Economy', in C. Graham and F. Smith (eds) Competition, Regulation and the New Economy, pp. 185-206. Portland: Hart Publishing.
54.
Tracey, M. (1998) The Decline and Fall of Public Service Broadcasting . Oxford: Oxford University Press .
55.
Van Dijk, M., Nahuis, R. and Waagmeester, D. (2006) `Does Public Service Broadcasting Serve the Public? The Future of Television in the Changing Media Landscape', The Economist154(2): 251-76.
56.
Wiedemann, V. (2004) `Public Service Broadcasting, SA, and the Internet: Emerging EU Law' (online EBU publication), URL (consulted August 2007): http://www.ebu.ch/en/union/diffusion_on_line/pub_broadcasting/
