Ethical concerns about animal-based tourism are raising ongoing attention from the international community, and investigation of tourists’ ethically responsible behaviors in animal eco-tourism is limited. This study investigated the formation of ethically responsible behaviors by integrating constituents from the value-belief-norm (VBN) theory, the norm-activation model (NAM), and the theory of planned behavior (TPB), including biospheric value, altruistic value, ethical beliefs, awareness of ethical issues, ascribed responsibility, personal norm, attitude, social norm, and behavioral intentions with regard to animal-based tourism. The cultural involvement of Confucian harmony and media coverage were found to positively influence awareness of ethical issues. The proposed research framework was further optimized by identifying a moderator, described as perceptions of animal protection. Methodologically, along with structural equation modeling (SEM) analysis, this study also used fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) to evaluate asymmetric configurations (causal recipes) and necessary conditions for predicting different levels of behavioral intentions in animal-based tourism.
ÄijäläM (2021) Mobile video ethnography for evoking animals in tourism. Annals of Tourism Research89: 103203.
2.
AlonsoMEGonzález-MontañaJRLomillosJM (2020) Consumers’ concerns and perceptions of farm animal welfare. Animals10(3): 385.
3.
BagozziRPYiY (1988) On the evaluation of structural equation models. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science16: 74–94.
4.
BersaglioBMarguliesJ (2022) Extinctionscapes: spatializing the commodification of animal lives and afterlives in conservation landscapes. Social & Cultural Geography23(1): 10–28.
5.
BertellaG (2013) Ethical content of pictures of animals in tourism promotion. Tourism Recreation Research38(3): 281–294.
6.
BertellaG (2021) Animal-based experiences and animal experiences: farm animals’ perspective on human leisure in rural settings. Annals of Leisure Research24(5): 631–645.
7.
BroadGM (2018) Effective animal advocacy: effective altruism, the social economy, and the animal protection movement. Agriculture and Human Values35(4): 777–789.
8.
BroadGM (2020) Using focus groups to explore public perceptions of legal rights for animals. Anthrozoös33(5): 613–627.
9.
CaplowS (2021) Using value-belief-norm theory to explore visitor responses to education programs at animal-themed facilities. The Journal of Environmental Education52(3): 190–204.
10.
ChemliSToanoglouMValeriM (2022) The impact of COVID-19 media coverage on tourist's awareness for future travelling. Current Issues in Tourism25(2): 179–186.
11.
ChiXChengXZhouH, et al. (2024) Investigation on driving mechanism of heritage tourism consumption: a multi-method analytical approach. Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing41(8): 1141–1160.
12.
ChiXHanHKimS (2022) Protecting yourself and others: festival tourists’ pro-social intentions for wearing a mask, maintaining social distancing, and practicing sanitary/hygiene actions. Journal of Sustainable Tourism30(8): 1915–1936.
13.
ChiXMengBLeeH, et al. (2023) Pro-environmental employees and sustainable hospitality and tourism businesses: Exploring strategic reasons and global motives for green behaviors. Business Strategy and the Environment32(7): 4167–4182.
14.
ChiXZhouHCaiG, et al. (2024) Investigation into the festival brand co-creation mechanism: extended application of the customer-based brand equity model. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing41(3): 377–395.
15.
DengCDPengKLShenJH (2023) Back to a post-pandemic city: the impact of media coverage on revisit intention of Macau. Journal of Quality Assurance in Hospitality & Tourism24(1): 1–23.
16.
DenleyTJWoosnamKMRibeiroMA, et al. (2020) Individuals’ intentions to engage in last chance tourism: applying the value-belief-norm model. Journal of Sustainable Tourism28(11): 1860–1881.
17.
DuffyRMooreL (2011) Global regulations and local practices: the politics and governance of animal welfare in elephant tourism. Journal of Sustainable Tourism19(4–5): 589–604.
18.
FakfarePLeeJSKimJJ, et al. (2023) Animal ethics and tourism: deepening a Stimulus–Organism–Response (SOR) framework. Journal of Travel Research63(4): 940–958.
19.
FakfarePManosuthiNLeeJS, et al. (2024) Investigating the formation of ethical animal-related tourism behaviors: a self-interest and pro-social theoretic approach. Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research: 1–19.
20.
FennellDA (2012) Tourism, animals and utilitarianism. Tourism Recreation Research37(3): 239–249.
21.
FennellDA (2013) Tourism and animal welfare. Tourism Recreation Research38(3): 325–340.
22.
FennellDA (2014) Exploring the boundaries of a new moral order for tourism's global code of ethics: an opinion piece on the position of animals in the tourism industry. Journal of Sustainable Tourism22(7): 983–996.
23.
FennellDA (2020) Tourism and wildlife photography codes of ethics: developing a clearer picture. Annals of Tourism Research85: 103023.
24.
FennellDA (2022a) An animal welfare literacy framework for tourism. Annals of Tourism Research96: 103461.
25.
FennellDA (2022b) Bridging the global-local animal-based tourism divide. Annals of Tourism Research96: 103459.
26.
FennellDA (2023) Empathy in animal-based tourism contrasting constructed care and care ethics at a captive wildlife venue. Tourism Recreation Research: 1–16.
27.
FennellDAKlineCMkonoM, et al. (2024) Tourism, animals & the vacant niche: a scoping review and pedagogical agenda. Current Issues in Tourism: 1–29.
28.
FennellDASheppardV (2021) Tourism, animals and the scales of justice. Journal of Sustainable Tourism29(2–3): 314–335.
29.
FennellDAThomsenB (2021) Tourism & animal suffering: mapping the future. Annals of Tourism Research91: 103317.
30.
FlowerEKBurnsGLJonesDN (2021) How tourist preference and satisfaction can contribute to improved welfare standards at elephant tourism venues in Thailand. Animals11(4): 1094.
31.
FontXBonilla-PriegoMJKantenbacherJ (2019) Trade associations as corporate social responsibility actors: an institutional theory analysis of animal welfare in tourism. Journal of Sustainable Tourism27(1): 118–138.
32.
FritzellJHvindenBKauttoM, et al. (2005) Nordic Welfare States in the European Context. London: Routledge.
33.
Graf-VlachyLOliverAGBanfieldR, et al. (2020) Media coverage of firms: background, integration, and directions for future research. Journal of Management46(1): 36–69.
34.
HanH (2015) Travelers’ pro-environmental behavior in a green lodging context: converging value-belief-norm theory and the theory of planned behavior. Tourism Management47: 164–177.
35.
HanH (2020) Theory of green purchase behavior (TGPB): a new theory for green hotel and green restaurant products. Business Strategy and the Environment29(6): 2815–2828.
36.
HanHChiXKimCS, et al. (2020) Activators of airline customers’ sense of moral obligation to engage in pro-social behaviors: impact of CSR in the Korean marketplace. Sustainability12(10): 4334.
37.
HanHHwangJLeeMJ (2017) The value-belief-emotion-norm model: investigating customers’ eco-friendly behavior. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing34(5): 590–607.
38.
HanWWangYScottM (2021) Social media activation of pro-environmental personal norms: an exploration of informational, normative and emotional linkages to personal norm activation. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing38(6): 568–581.
39.
HeYXuFWangL, et al. (2023) Modeling tourists’ pro-environmental behavior: a combination of the value-belief-norm theory and environmental identity theory. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management: 1–24.
40.
HerdoizaNWorrellEvan den, et al. (2024) Including animal welfare targets in the SDGs: the case of animal farming. Agriculture and Human Values41(2): 815–830.
41.
HooperJ (2023) Thinking with civets: the role of zoos in the decolonisation of animal tourism. Animals13(11): 1739.
42.
HoyLSStanglBMorganN (2023) The social behavior of traveling with dogs: drivers, behavioral tendencies, and experiences. Journal of Vacation Marketing: 1–20.
43.
KiatkawsinKSutherlandILeeSK (2020) Determinants of smart tourist environmentally responsible behavior using an extended norm-activation model. Sustainability12(12): 4934.
44.
KimJJFakfarePLeeJ, et al. (2023) Determinants of travelers’ image and desire toward animal tourism. Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research28(10): 1088–1105.
45.
KimJJHwangJ (2020) Merging the norm activation model and the theory of planned behavior in the context of drone food delivery services: does the level of product knowledge really matter?Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management42: 1–11.
46.
KlineCFischerB (2023) Morality on holiday: inspiring ethical behaviour in animal-based tourism through non-moral values. Tourism Recreation Research48(2): 147–158.
47.
KoehnD (2022) Applying Aristotelian and Confucian virtue ethics to humane work in the business context. Humanistic Management Journal7(2): 189–209.
48.
KöllenTSchneebergerD (2023) Avoiding unnecessary suffering: towards a moral minimum standard for humans’ responsibility for animal welfare. Business Ethics, the Environment & Responsibility32(4): 1139–1149.
49.
LeTHWuHCHuangWS, et al. (2021) Determinants of tourists’ intentions to agrotourism in Vietnam from perspectives of value–belief–norm theory. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing38(9): 881–899.
50.
LeeK (2011) The role of media exposure, social exposure and biospheric value orientation in the environmental attitude-intention-behavior model in adolescents. Journal Of Environmental Psychology31(4): 301–308.
51.
LiCDüringD (2022) Harmony as a virtue in confucianism. In LiCDüringD (eds) The Virtue of Harmony (21–C1.P56). New York: Oxford University Press.
52.
LiXWeiF (2023) What Confucian eco-ethics can teach us about solving the dilemma of interpreting the concept of sustainability. Religions14(9): 1216.
53.
LiaoSSLinCYXieXZ (2023) Effects of short-form video application users’ guanxi on intention to visit rural tourism destinations: The moderating role of tourism fatigue. Journal of Vacation Marketing13567667231171457: 1–23.
54.
LiuYLiX (2021) Pro-environmental behavior predicted by media exposure, SNS involvement, and cognitive and normative factors. Environmental Communication15(7): 954–968.
55.
MengBChiXKimJJ, et al. (2024) Norm activation and self-interested process in ethical behaviours for animal tourism: exploring the function of animal co-creation and Asian cultural values. Current Issues in Tourism27(13): 2066–2082.
56.
MkonoMHolderA (2019) The future of animals in tourism recreation: social media as spaces of collective moral reflexivity. Tourism Management Perspectives29: 1–8.
57.
MoorhouseTD'CruzeNCMacdonaldDW (2017) Unethical use of wildlife in tourism: what's the problem, who is responsible, and what can be done?Journal of Sustainable Tourism25(4): 505–516.
58.
OnwezenMCAntonidesGBartelsJ (2013) The Norm Activation Model: an exploration of the functions of anticipated pride and guilt in pro-environmental behaviour. Journal of Economic Psychology39: 141–153.
59.
OramsMB (2002) Feeding wildlife as a tourism attraction: a review of issues and impacts. Tourism Management23(3): 281–293.
60.
PackerJBallantyneRHughesK (2014) Chinese And Australian tourists’ attitudes to nature, animals and environmental issues: implications for the design of nature-based tourism experiences. Tourism Management44: 101–107.
61.
PeléMGeorgesJYMatsuzawaT, et al. (2021) Perceptions of human-animal relationships and their impacts on animal ethics, law and research. Frontiers in Psychology11: 631238.
62.
PetettaFCiccocioppoR (2021) Public perception of laboratory animal testing: historical, philosophical, and ethical view. Addiction Biology26(6): e12991.
63.
RaginCC (2008) Measurement versus calibration: A set-theoretic approach.
64.
RistSDahdouh-GuebasF (2006) Ethnosciences––A step towards the integration of scientific and indigenous forms of knowledge in the management of natural resources for the future. Environment, Development and Sustainability8: 467–493.
65.
RizzoloJB (2023) Wildlife tourism and consumption. Journal of Sustainable Tourism31(5): 1181–1194.
66.
RyanC (1998) Saltwater crocodiles as tourist attractions. Journal of Sustainable Tourism6(4): 314–327.
67.
SinclairMLeeNYHötzelMJ, et al. (2022) International perceptions of animals and the importance of their welfare. Frontiers in Animal Science3: 1–23.
68.
SingerP (2013). Equality for animals? In Ethics, Humans and Other Animals. London: Routledge, pp. 169–177.
69.
SisonAJGFerreroIRedínDM (2020) Some virtue ethics implications from Aristotelian and Confucian perspectives on family and business. Journal of Business Ethics165: 241–254.
70.
SniehottaFFPresseauJAraújo-SoaresV (2014) Time to retire the theory of planned behaviour. Health Psychology Review8(1): 1–7.
71.
StrenPC (2000) Toward a coherent theory of environmentally significant behaviour. Journal of Social Issues56(3): 407–424.
72.
Suárez-RojasCGonzález HernándezMMLeónCJ (2022) Do tourists value responsible sustainability in whale-watching tourism? Exploring sustainability and consumption preferences. Journal of Sustainable Tourism30(8): 2053–2072.
73.
ThomsenBThomsenJCopelandK, et al. (2023) Multispecies livelihoods: a posthumanist approach to wildlife ecotourism that promotes animal ethics. Journal of Sustainable Tourism31(5): 1195–1213.
74.
TkaczynskiAXieJRundle-ThieleSR (2023) The role of environmental knowledge and interest on perceived value and satisfaction. Journal of Vacation Marketing29(3): 428–444.
75.
TollsCCarrN (2021) The role of nature on horse trail rides: tourist experience expectations. Current Issues in Tourism24(9): 1257–1269.
76.
TrangHLeeJHanH (2019) How do green attributes elicit guest pro-environmental behaviors? The case of green hotels in Vietnam. Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing36(1): 14–28.
77.
VermaVKChandraBKumarS (2019) Values and ascribed responsibility to predict consumers’ attitude and concern towards green hotel visit intention. Journal of Business Research96: 206–216.
Von EssenEAllenM (2021) Killing with kindness: when hunters want to let you know they care. Human Dimensions of Wildlife26(2): 179–195.
80.
Von EssenELindsjöJBergC (2020) Instagranimal: animal welfare and animal ethics challenges of animal-based tourism. Animals10(10): 1830.
81.
WanZHWanSLZhanY (2022) For harmony and democracy: secondary students’ views on the value of developing critical thinking in a Confucian heritage context. Thinking Skills and Creativity44: 101031.
82.
WangSWangJWanL, et al. (2023) Social norms and tourists’ pro-environmental behaviors: do ethical evaluation and Chinese cultural values matter?Journal of Sustainable Tourism31(6): 1413–1429.
83.
WattanacharoensilWFakfarePManosuthiN, et al. (2024) Determinants of traveler intention toward animal ethics in tourism: developing a causal recipe combining cognition, affect, and norm factors. Tourism Management100: 104823.
84.
WenJHuangSSYingT (2019) Relationships between Chinese cultural values and tourist motivations: a study of Chinese tourists visiting Israel. Journal of Destination Marketing & Management14: 100367.
85.
WhangHYongSKoE (2016) Pop culture, destination images, and visit intentions: theory and research on travel motivations of Chinese and Russian tourists. Journal of Business Research69(2): 631–641.
86.
WinterC (2020) A review of research into animal ethics in tourism: launching the annals of tourism research curated collection on animal ethics in tourism. Annals of Tourism Research84: 102989.
87.
WongIALinZZhangX (2023) A techno-exchange engagement model of social media engagement: a social exchange and engagement theoretical synthesis. Journal of Vacation Marketing29(3): 461–475.
88.
YingTWangKYeS, et al. (2022) Examining tourists’ ethical perceptions of game eating. Tourism Management91: 104498.
89.
ZhaoBRawwasMYZengC (2020) How does past behaviour stimulate consumers’ intentions to repeat unethical behaviour? The roles of perceived risk and ethical beliefs. Business Ethics: A European Review29(3): 602–616.
90.
ZhuP.ChiX.RyuH. B., et al. (2022). Traveler pro-social behaviors at heritage tourism sites. Frontiers in Psychology, 13, 901530.
