Varying the cause of a challenge to exercise identity behaviour: Reactions of individuals of differing identity strength

Abstract

Research shows that people with stronger exercise identity (EXID) exhibit greater negative affect and self-regulatory efficacy (SRE) when behaviour is inconsistent with identity. However, related attributions have not been examined. Using social cognitive and identity theories, we examined causes of failing to exercise. In a two (EXID: stronger, weaker) by two (Cause: personally-controllable, situational) design, participants (N = 224) were randomized to Cause and read a condition-relevant no-exercise vignette. MANOVA revealed main effects for Cause and EXID, p’s < .001. Participants explaining their Cause differed on attributional dimensions, and stronger EXID participants reported greater negative affect and higher SRE, p’s < .001.

Keywords

affect attributions exercise identity identity theory self-efficacy

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson DF and Cychosz CM ( 1994) Development of an exercise identity scale. Perceptual and Motor Skills 78: 747-751.

Anderson DF and Cychosz CM ( 1995) Exploration of the relationship between exercise behavior and exercise identity. Journal of Sport Behaviour 18: 159-166.

Anderson DF , Cychosz CM and Franke WD ( 1998) Association of exercise identity with measures of exercise commitment and physiological indicators of fitness in a law enforcement cohort . Journal of Sport Behaviour 21: 233-241.

Bandura A. (1997) Self-Efficacy: The Exercise of Control. New York, NY: Freeman Press.

Bandura A. ( 2004) Health promotion by social cognitive means. Health Education & Behavior 31: 143-164.

Burke PJ ( 1980) The self: Measurement from an interactionist perspective . Journal of Social Psychology Quarterly 43: 18-29.

Burke PJ ( 2006) Identity change. Social Psychology Quarterly 69: 81-96.

Burke PJ and Harrod MM ( 2005) Too much of a good thing? Social Psychology Quarterly 68: 359-374.

Cardinal BJ and Cardinal MK ( 1997) Changes in exercise behaviour and exercise identity associated with a 14-week aerobic exercise class. Journal of Sport Behaviour 20: 377-386.

10.

Cast AD and Burke PJ ( 2002) A theory of self-esteem, Social Forces 80: 1041-1068.

11.

Courneya KS and McAuley E. ( 1993) Efficacy, attributional, and affective responses of adults following an acute bout of exercise. Journal of Social Behavior and Personality 8: 729-742.

12.

Courneya KS and McAuley E. ( 1996) Understanding intentions to exercise following a structured exercise program: An attributional perspective. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 26: 670-685.

13.

Fekadu Z. and Kraft P. ( 2001) Self-identity in planned behaviour perspective. Past behaviour and its moderating effects on identity-intention relations. Social Behaviour and Personality 29: 671-686.

14.

Gecas V. and Burke PJ ( 1995) Self and identity. In: Cook K , Fine GA and House JS (eds) Sociological Perspective on Social Psychology. Boston: Allyn & Bacon, 41-67.

15.

Ingledew DK , Hardy L. and Cooper CL ( 1996) An attributional model applied to health behaviour change . European Journal of Personality 10: 111-132.

16.

Maddux JE and Gosselin JT ( 2003) Self-efficacy. In: Leary RM and Tangney JP (eds) Handbook of Self and Identity. New York, NY: Guilford Press, 218-238.

17.

Mancuso CA , Sayles W. , Robbins L and Allegrante JP (2010) Novel use of patient-derived vignettes to foster self-efficacy in an asthma self-management workbook. Health Promotion Practice 11: 44-53.

18.

McAuley E. ( 1991) Efficacy, attributional, and affective responses to exercise participation. Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology 13: 382-393.

19.

McAuley E. and Mihalko SL ( 1998) Measuring exercise-related self-efficacy. In: Duda JL (ed.) Advances in Sport and Exercise Psychology Measurement. Morgantown, W. Va. Fitness Information Technology, 371-390.

20.

McAuley E. , Duncan TE and Russell D. ( 1992) Measuring causal attributions: The Revised Causal Dimension Scale (CDSII). Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 18: 566-573.

21.

McAuley E. , Poag K. , Gleason A. and Wraith S. ( 1990) Attrition from exercise programs: Attributional and affective perspectives. Journal of Social Behaviour and Personality 5: 591-602.

22.

Miller KH , Ogletree RJ and Welshimer K. ( 2002) Impact of activity behaviours on physical activity identity and self-efficacy. American Journal of Health Behaviour 26: 323-330.

23.

Nickel D. and Spink KS (in press) Attributions for health-related physical activity. Journal of Applied Social Psychology.

24.

Petosa RL , Suminski R. and Hortz B. ( 2003) Predicting vigorous physical activity using social cognitive theory. American Journal of Health Behaviour 27: 301.

25.

Ryan RM and Deci EL ( 2003) On assimilating identities to the self: A self-determination theory perspective on internalization and integrity within cultures. In: Leary MR and Tangney JP (eds) Handbook of Self and Identity. New York: Guilford Press. 253-272.

26.

Shields CA , Brawley LR and Lindover TI ( 2006) Self-Efficacy as a mediator of the relationship between causal attributions and exercise behaviour. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 36: 2785-2802.

27.

Stets JE and Burke PJ ( 2003) A sociological approach to self and identity. In: Leary MR and Tangney JP (eds) Handbook of Self and Identity. New York: Guilford Press, 128-152.

28.

Storer JH , Cychosz CM and Anderson DF ( 1997) Wellness behaviours, social identities and health promotion . American Journal of Health Behaviour 21: 260-268.

29.

Strachan SM and Brawley LR ( 2008) Reactions to a challenge to identity: A focus on exercise and healthy eating. The Journal of Health Psychology 13: 575-588.

30.

Strachan SM , Brawley LR , Spink KS and Glazebrook K. (2010) Older adults’ physically-active identity: Relationships between social-cognitions, physical activity and satisfaction with life. Psychology of Sport and Exercise 11: 114-121.

31.

Strachan SM , Brawley LR , Spink KS and Jung ME (2009) Strength of exercise identity and identity-exercise consistency: Affective and social cognitive relationships. Journal of Health Psychology, 14: 1196-1206.

32.

Strachan SM , Woodgate J. , Brawley LR and Tse A. ( 2005) The relationship of self-efficacy and self-identity to long-term maintenance of vigorous physical activity. Journal of Applied Biobehavioural Research 10: 98-112.

33.

Stryker S. ( 1980) Symbolic Interactionism: A Social Structural Version. Memlo Park, CA: Benjamin/Cummings.

34.

Stryker S. and Burke PJ ( 2000) The past, present and future of identity theory. Social Psychology Quarterly 63: 284-297.

35.

Tabachnick BG and Fidell LS ( 2001) Using Multivariate Statistics, Fourth Edition. Needham Heights, MA: Allyn & Bacon.

36.

Weiner B. ( 1985) An attributional theory of achievement motivation and emotion. Psychological Review 92(4): 548-573.

37.

Weiner B. ( 1986) An Attributional Theory of Motivation and Emotion. New York: Springer-Verlag.

38.

Woodgate J. and Brawley LR ( 2008) Use of an efficacy-enhancing message to influence the self-regulatory efficacy of cardiac rehabilitation participants: A field experiment . Rehabilitation Psychology 53: 153-161.