Feeling Unwanted: Understanding Digital Place-Making and Uncertainty in EU Settlement Scheme Digital Communities

Abstract

The EU Settlement Scheme has sought to provide a legal framework for the residence of European Union citizens in post-Brexit Britain. In the meantime, digital communities have emerged, seeking to mitigate the errors, delays, and communication gaps that have plagued the scheme since its inception. Engaging with scholarship on digital place-making, this paper discusses a yearlong digital ethnography conducted in four Facebook communities and a visual analysis of the content shared by applicants. We deployed a mixed-method strategy to map group membership while analysing the language of uncertainty in posts. Results indicate a complex space of advice-seeking, reproducing much of the scheme’s bureaucratic nature and weakening these spaces’ potential for demonstrating alternative forms of solidarity.

Keywords

Brexit diaspora EU Settlement Scheme immigration social media United Kingdom

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abranches

Theuerkauf

(2021) Visual and oral narratives of place and belonging during Brexit. Visual Anthropology 34(5): 423–453.

Acerbi

(2022) From storytelling to Facebook: Content biases when retelling or sharing a story. Human Nature 33(2): 132–144.

Ahmed

(2004) The Cultural Politics of Emotion. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

Alacovska

(2018) Hope labour revisited: Post-socialist creative workers and their methods of hope. In: Taylor

Luckman

(eds) The new Normal of Working Lives: Critical Studies in Contemporary Work and Employment. Cham: Springer, pp. 41–63.

Bakharia

Corrin

(2019) Using recent advances in contextual word embeddings to improve the quantitative ethnography workflow. In: Advances in Quantitative Ethnography: First International Conference, ICQE 2019, Madison, WI, 20–22 October, pp. 299–306. Cham: Springer.

Barnard

Fraser Butlin

Costello

(2022) The changing status of European Union nationals in the United Kingdom following Brexit: The lived experience of the European Union Settlement Scheme. Social & Legal Studies 31(3): 365–388.

Basaraba

(2023) The emergence of creative and digital place-making: A scoping review across disciplines. New Media & Society 25(6): 1470–1497.

Benson

Sigona

(2024) Reimagining, repositioning, rebordering: Intersections of the biopolitical and geopolitical in the UK’s Post-Brexit migration regime (and why it matters for migration research). International Migration Review 58(4): 2040–2065.

Bericat

(2016) The sociology of emotions: Four decades of progress. Current Sociology 64(3): 491–513.

10.

Bhandari

Bimo

(2022) Why’s everyone on TikTok now? The algorithmized self and the future of self-making on social media. Social Media+ Society 8(1): 20563051221086241.

11.

Boguraev

(1997) Salience-based content characterisafion of text documents. In: Intelligent Scalable Text Summarization. Available at: https://aclanthology.org/W97-0702.pdf (accessed 05 January 2026).

12.

Botterill

Bogacki

Burrell

, et al. (2020) Applying for settled status: Ambivalent and reluctant compliance of EU citizens in post-Brexit Scotland. Scottish Affairs 29(3): 370–385.

13.

Brändle

(2020) Reality bites: EU mobiles’ experiences of citizenship on the local level. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 46(13): 2800–2817.

14.

Brown

(2015) Theorising uncertainty and risk across different modernities: Considering insights from ‘non-North-Western’. Studies’, Health, Risk & Society 17(3–4): 185–195.

15.

Brown

(2016) From rationalities to lifeworlds: Analysing the everyday handling of uncertainty and risk in terms of culture, society and identity. Health, Risk & Society 18(7-8): 335–347.

16.

Bruzelius

Reinprecht

Seeleib-Kaiser

(2017) Stratified social rights limiting EU citizenship. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies 55(6): 1239–1253.

17.

Cook

Cuervo

(2019) Agency, futurity and representation: Conceptualising hope in recent sociological work. The Sociological Review 67(5): 1102–1117.

18.

Eisenlauer

(2014) Facebook: A multimodal discourse analysis of (semi-) automated communicative modes. Interactions, Images and Texts: A Reader in Multimodality 11: 313.

19.

Etias.com (2024) UK Tightens Border Controls for EU Citizens with Pre-Settled Status. Etias.com. Available at: https://etias.com/articles/uk-tightens-border-controls-for-eu-citizens-with-pre-settled-status (accessed 17 November 2024).

20.

Furseth

(2023) Forced to become British: How Brexit created a new European diaspora. Al Jazeera, 9 December. Available at: https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2023/12/9/how-brexit-created-a-new-european-diaspora-in-britain

21.

Gallardo

(2023) NHS’ may have wrongly charged’ EU nationals, watchdog says. Politico, 10 May.

22.

García-Esparza

Nikšič

(2024) Revealing the community’s interpretation of place: Integrated digital support to embed photovoice into placemaking processes. Urban Planning 9.

23.

Goffman

([1959] 2002) The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. New York: Knopf Doubleday.

24.

Google (2024) Vision AI: Extract insights from images, documents, and videos. Available at: https://cloud.google.com/vision (accessed 1 December 2024).

25.

Griffith

Yeo

(2021) The UK’s hostile environment: Deputising immigration control. 2021. Critical Social Policy 41(4): 521–544.

26.

Grzymala-Kazlowska

Ryan

(2022) Bringing anchoring and embedding together: Theorising migrants’ lives over-time. Comparative Migration Studies 10(1): 46.

27.

Han

Lee

, et al. (2017) Reciprocal nature of social capital in Facebook: An analysis of tagging activity. Online Information Review 41(6): 826–839.

28.

Harbin

O’Callaghan

(2016) Text and the sensorium: The augmented palimpsest as an augmented reality text. In: Travis

von Lünen

(eds) The Digital Arts and Humanities: Neogeography, Social Media and Big Data Integrations and Applications. Cham: Springer, pp. 169–186.

29.

Harding

Pribram

(2002) The power of feeling. Locating Emotions in Culture’. European Journal of Cultural Studies 5(4): 407–426.

30.

Harding

Pribram

(2009) Emotions: A Cultural Studies Reader. London and New York: Routledge.

31.

Hill

(2017) ‘Hostile environment’: The hardline Home Office policy tearing families apart. The Guardian, 28 November. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/nov/28/hostile-environment-the-hardline-home-office-policy-tearing-families-apart (accessed 1 December 2024).

32.

Hine

(2020) Ethnography for the Internet: Embedded, Embodied and Everyday. London: Taylor & Francis.

33.

Hockaday

(2024) What is settled status? Home Office U-turn after French grandmother who has lived in the UK for 42 years faced deportation. Yahoo! News, 10 December. Available at: https://consent.yahoo.com/v2/collectConsent?sessionId=4_cc-session_1768c577-bb9e-4bcf-8fd4-5adbb0e36070

34.

Home Office (2019) Home Office launches nationwide campaign for EU Settlement Scheme. Home Office News Story. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/home-office-launches-nationwide-campaign-for-eu-settlement-scheme (accessed 27 April 2024).

35.

Home Office (2023a) EU Settlement Scheme quarterly statistics, September 2023. Home Office. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/eu-settlement-scheme-quarterly-statistics-september-2023/eu-settlement-scheme-quarterly-statistics-september-2023 (accessed 5 March 2024).

36.

Home Office (2023b) £2.5 million funding boost to support vulnerable EUSS applicants. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/25-million-funding-boost-to-support-vulnerable-euss-applicants (accessed 9 March 2024).

37.

Hurley

(2023) #Dubailiving and digital placemaking on TikTok: Migrant, domestic, and service workers’ affective social mediascapes. Social Media+ Society 9(3).

38.

Inwood

Zappavigna

(2024) The legitimation of screenshots as visual evidence in social media: YouTube videos spreading misinformation and disinformation. Visual Communication. Epub ahead of print 6 October. DOI: 10.1177/14703572241255664.

39.

Jorgensen

(2024) Family fortunes: The UK’s new income requirement for partner visas. Oxford Migration Observatory. Available at: https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/commentaries/family-fortunes-the-uks-new-income-requirement-for-partner-visas/

40.

Kazmierska

(2006) Migration experiences and changes of identity. The analysis of a narrative. Historical Social Research/Historische Sozialforschung 31: 72–89.

41.

Kirkup

Winnett

(2012) Theresa May interview: ‘We’re going to give illegal migrants a really hostile reception’. The Telegraph, 25 May. Available at: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/0/theresa-may-interview-going-give-illegal-migrants-really-hostile/ (accessed 18 March 2022).

42.

Kress

Van Leeuwen

(2001) Multimodal discourse : The modes and media of contemporary communication. London: Arnold.

43.

Kuehn

Corrigan

(2013) Hope labor: The role of employment prospects in online social production. The Political Economy of Communication 1(1): 9–25.

44.

Labayen

Gutierrez

(2021) Digital placemaking as survival tactics: Sub-Saharan migrants’ videos at the Moroccan–Spanish border. Convergence 27(3): 664–678.

45.

Leurs

Witteborn

(2021) Digital migration studies. In: McAuliffe

(ed.) Research Handbook on International Migration and Digital Technology. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 15–28.

46.

Levy

(2023). Young Venezuelans’ experiences of migration on YouTube: Self-mediatization, consumerism and digital settlements. Journal of Global Diaspora & Media 4(1): 7–23.

47.

Lintelo

Hernandez

Lakshman

(2024) Migrant digital placemaking for wellbeing: A netnography of Facebook groups. Wellbeing, Space and Society 6: 100196.

48.

Lupton

(2013) Risk and emotion: Towards an alternative theoretical perspective. Health, Risk & Society 15(8): 634–647.

49.

Mallinder

(2024) UK passes bill to deport asylum seekers to Rwanda: What’s next? Al Jazeera, 23 April. Available at: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/4/23/uk-passes-rwanda-migrant-bill-whats-next (accessed 27 April 2024).

50.

Marino

(2015) Making space, making place: Digital togetherness and the redefinition of migrant identities online. Social Media+ Society 1(2): 2056305115622479.

51.

Masullo

Coppola

(2023) Potential and limitations of digital ethnographic research: A case study on a web community. Frontiers in Sociology 7: 1092181.

52.

Morris

Qureshi

(2021) The EU settlement scheme and the hostile environment. IPPR Report. Available at: https://www.ippr.org/articles/eu-settlement-scheme-hostile-environment

53.

Mpofu

Asak

Salawu

(2022) Facebook groups as transnational counter public sphere for diasporic communities. Cogent Arts & Humanities 9(1): 2027598.

54.

Nedelcu

(2012) Migrants’ new transnational habitus: Rethinking migration through a cosmopolitan lens in the digital age. Journal of ethnic and migration studies, 38(9), 1339–1356.

55.

O’Carroll

(2023) Italian citizen’s bank accounts frozen owing to ‘shameful’ post-Brexit rules. The Guardian, 22 December 2023. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/dec/22/italian-citizen-bank-accounts-frozen-post-brexit-rules

56.

O’Carroll

(2024) ‘Given my life back’: Home Office restores rights to French woman after Brexit mix-up. The Guardian, 16 January. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/jan/16/home-office-restores-rights-to-french-woman

57.

Palmberger

(2022) Refugees enacting (digital) citizenship through placemaking and care practices near and far. Citizenship Studies 26(6): 781–798.

58.

Parker

(2024) Roma EU citizens’ struggles with the EU Settlement Scheme: Lessons for the new government? The UK in a Changing Europe. Available at: https://ukandeu.ac.uk/roma-eu-citizens-struggles-with-the-eu-settlement-scheme-lessons-for-the-new-government/ (accessed 10 July 2024).

59.

Paulus

Warren

Lester

(2016) Applying conversation analysis methods to online talk: A literature review. Discourse, Context & Media 12: 1–10.

60.

Pavlovskaya

(2016) Digital place-making: Insights from critical cartography and GIS. In: Travis

von Lünen

(eds) The Digital Arts and Humanities: Neogeography, Social Media and Big Data Integrations and Applications. Cham: Springer, pp. 153–167.

61.

Ponzanesi

(2020) Digital diasporas: Postcoloniality, media and affect. Interventions 22(8): 977–993.

62.

Postill

(2017) Remote ethnography: Studying culture from afar. In: Hjorth

Horst

Galloway

, et al (eds) The Routledge Companion to Digital Ethnography. London: Routledge, pp. 87–95.

63.

Quille

(2018) The Windrush generation in Britain’s ‘hostile environment’: racializing the crimmigration narrative. Criminal Justice, Borders and Citizenship Research Paper, (3274533).

64.

Radziwinowiczówna

Galasińska

(2021) ‘The Vile Eastern European’: Ideology of deportability in the Brexit media discourse. Central and Eastern European Migration Review 10(1).

65.

Restelica

(2024) UK’s border force officers can now cancel pre-settled status of EU citizens who do not meet the rules. Schengen News, 12 August. Available at: https://schengen.news/uks-border-force-officers-can-now-cancel-pre-settled-status-of-eu-citizens-who-do-not-meet-the-rules/ (accessed 12 August 2024).

66.

Ribeiro

Benevenuto

Zagheni

(2020) How biased is the population of Facebook users? Comparing the demographics of Facebook users with census data to generate correction factors. In: Proceedings of the 12th ACM Conference on Web Science, Southampton, 6–10 July, pp. 325–334. New York: ACM.

67.

Ruas

PHB

Machado

Silva

, et al. (2019) Identification and characterisation of Facebook user profiles considering interaction aspects. Behaviour & Information Technology 38(8): 858–872.

68.

Shabani

(2023) UK: Applications for the EU Settlement Scheme dropped 37% in 2023. Visa Guide News, 13 December. Available at: https://visaguide.world/news/uk-applications-for-eu-settlement-scheme-dropped-by-37-in-2023/ (accessed 9 March 2024).

69.

Shin

Gutierrez

(2024) Migrant placemaking as a response to governing through mobility-making: An ethnic enclave and a digital community in South Korea. Asia Pacific Viewpoint 65(3): 430–447.

70.

Smellie

(2023) Migration narratives in media and social media. The Case of the United Kingdom. Zenodo. Available at: https://zenodo.org/records/7937160

71.

Sturge

Wilkins

(2019) The eu settlement scheme: A summary. Uk parliament: house of commons library. Available at https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/the-eu-settlement-scheme-asummary/ (accessed 5 January 2026).

72.

Sumption

(2020) Not settled yet? Understanding the EU settlement scheme using the available data. The Migration Observatory. Available at: https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/reports/not-settled-yet-understanding-the-eu-settlement-scheme-using-the-available-data/

73.

Sumption

Fernández-Reino

(2020) Unsettled status – 2020: Which EU citizens are at risk of failing to secure their rights after Brexit. The Migration Observatory. Available at: https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/reports/unsettled-status-2020/

74.

Tagarelli

Interdonato

(2014) Lurking in social networks: topology-based analysis and ranking methods. Social Network Analysis and Mining 4: 1–27.

75.

Taylor

(2020) Representing the Windrush generation: metaphor in discourses then and now. Critical Discourse Studies 17(1): 1–21.

76.

Taylor

(2024) Portuguese man who has lived legally in the UK since 2001 faces deportation. The Guardian, 4 February. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2024/feb/04/portuguese-man-who-has-lived-legally-in-uk-since-2001-facing-deportation

77.

Thomas

(2021) The EU Settlement Scheme: The greatest story never told? Social Market Foundation. Available at: https://www.smf.co.uk/publications/euss/

78.

Tomlinson

(2019) Quick and uneasy justice: An administrative justice analysis of the EU Settlement Scheme. Available at: https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/id/eprint/150715/1/Joe_Tomlinson_Quick_and_Uneasy_Justice.pdf

79.

Trendall

(2024) Not fit for purpose and seriously compromised’ – urgent calls for new government to rethink digital immigration plans. Public Technology.net. Available at: https://www.publictechnology.net/2024/07/16/society-and-welfare/not-fit-for-purpose-and-seriously-compromised-urgent-calls-for-new-government-to-rethink-digital-immigration-plans/ (accessed 17 November 2024).

80.

Turcatti

Vargas-Silva

(2022) ‘I returned to being an immigrant’: Onward Latin American migrants and Brexit. Ethnic and Racial Studies 45(16): 287–307.

81.

Wagner

Singer

Karimi

, et al. (2017) Sampling from social networks with attributes. In: Proceedings of the 26th international conference on world wide web, 3–7 April, Perth, WA, Australia, pp. 1181–1190. New York: ACM.

82.

Webber

(2019) On the creation of the UK’s ‘hostile environment’. Race & Class 60(4): 76–87.

83.

Williams

Baláž

(2012) Migration, risk, and uncertainty: Theoretical perspectives. Population, Space and Place 18(2): 167–180.

84.

Witteborn

(2021) Digital placemaking and the datafication of forced migrants. Convergence 27(3): 637–648.

85.

Yong

(2023) A gendered EU Settlement Scheme: Intersectional oppression of immigrant women in a post-Brexit Britain. Social & Legal Studies 32(5): 756–775.

86.

Zhang

Chib

(2024) Elusive embeddedness of immigrant entrepreneurs: Tensions between digital place-making and physical spaces. In: ICA 2024 annual conference: Communication and global human rights. Brisbane, QLD, Australia: International Communication Association.

87.

Zinn

(2008) Heading into the unknown: Everyday strategies for managing risk and uncertainty. Health, Risk & Society 10(5): 439–450.

88.

Zinn

(2016) ‘In-between’ and other reasonable ways to deal with risk and uncertainty: A review article. Health, Risk & Society 18(7–8): 348–366.