School effectiveness and the ‘other outcomes’ of secondary schooling: a reassessment of three decades of British research

Abstract

It has long been assumed that schools which were ‘effective’ with respect to one set of outcomes (usually academic performance) were generally more ‘effective’ in relation to others. This article reviews the last three decades of British evidence across a range of affective, social and other non-cognitive outcomes including: pupils’ attitudes to school; their levels of involvement; truancy and attendance; citizenship issues; use of alcohol and drugs. The review draws two main conclusions. First, that schools’ effects on these forms of outcomes do not seem as significant as those relating to academic ones. Second, that the evidence for a single underlying dimension of school effectiveness is limited. The factors which explain differences between schools in terms of academic progress appear to have limited explanatory power in relation to these ‘other’ outcomes. The implications of this reassessment for the analysis of schools’ functioning and the development of accountability systems are subsequently considered.

Keywords

affective and social outcomes of schooling relationships between school outcomes school organization and functioning student social outcomes theories of school effectiveness

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ainley, J. , Batten, M. , Collins, C. & Withers, G. (1998) Schools and the Social Development of Young Australians. Camberwell: the Australian Council for Educational Research .

Daly, P. & Hefty, N. (2001) Investigating variation across high schools in students’ attitudes to school, in their attitudes to science and in their attainment in science . Paper presented to the Annual Conference of the American Educational Research Association, Seattle, April.

Gray, J. , McPherson, A. & Raffe, D. (1983) Reconstructions of Secondary Education: Theory, Myth and Practice Since the War. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul .

Hargreaves, D. H. (2001) A capital theory of school effectiveness and improvement . British Educational Research Journal, 27(4), 487-503 .

Jencks, C. , Smith, M. , Acland, H. , Bane, M. , Cohen, D. , Gintis, H. , Heyns, B. & Michelson, S. (1972) Inequality: A Reassessment of the Effects of Family and Schooling in America. London: Penguin .

Keys, W. & Fernandes, C. (1993) What Do Students Think About School? Research into the factors associated with positive and negative attitudes towards school and education.A Report to the National Commission on Education. Slough: NFER .

Knuver, J. & Brandsma, H. (1993) Cognitive and affective outcomes in school effectiveness research . School Effectiveness and School Improvement, 4(3), 189-204 .

Lauder, H. , Jamieson, I. & Wikeley, F. (1998) Models of effective schools: limits and capabilities. In R. Slee , G. Weiner & S. Tomlinson (eds) School Effectiveness for Whom? Challenges to the School Effectiveness and School Improvement Movements, pp. 51-69. London: Falmer Press .

Lee, V. , Bryk, A. & Smith, J. (1993) The organisation of effective high schools . Review of Educational Research, 19, 171-267 .

10.

Mortimore, P. , Sammons, P. , Stoll, L. , Lewis, D. & Ecob, R. (1988) School Matters: The Junior Years. Wells: Open Books .

11.

Murphy, J. (1992) School effectiveness and school restructuring: contributions to educational improvement . School Effectiveness and School Improvement, 3(2), 90-109 .

12.

Reynolds, D. (1976) The delinquent school. In M. Hammersley & P. Woods (eds) The Process of Schooling, pp. 217-229. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul .

13.

Rutter, M. , Maughan, B. , Mortimore, P. & Ouston, J. with Smith, A. (1979) Fifteen Thousand Hours: Secondary Schools and their Effects on Children. London: Open Books .

14.

Sammons, P. (1999) School Effectiveness: Coming of Age in the Twenty-First Century. Lisse: Swets and Zeitlinger .

15.

Sammons, P. , Thomas, S. & Mortimore, P. (1997) Forging Links: Effective Schools and Effective Departments. London: Paul Chapman .

16.

Schagen, I. (2002) Attitudes to citizenship in England: Multilevel statistical analysis of the IEA civics data . Research Papers in Education, 17(3), 229-259 .

17.

Smith, D. J. & Tomlinson, S. (1989) The School Effect: A Study of Multi-Racial Comprehensives. London: Policy Studies Institute .

18.

Teddlie, C. , Reynolds, D. & Sammons, S. (2000) The methodology and scientific properties of school effectiveness research. In C. Teddlie & D. Reynolds (eds) International Handbook of School Effectiveness Research, pp. 55-133. London: Falmer Press .

19.

Thomas, S. , Smees, R. , MacBeath, J. , Robertson, P. & Boyd, B. (2000) Valuing pupils’ views in Scottish schools . Educational Research and Evaluation, 6(4), 281-316 .

20.

Tymms, P. (2001) A test of the big fish in a little pond hypothesis: An investigation into the feelings of seven year old pupils in school . School Effectiveness and School Improvement, 12(2), 161-181 .

21.

Weick, K. (1976) Educational organisations as loosely coupled systems . Administrative Science Quarterly, 21, 1-19 .

22.

West, P. , Sweeting, H. & Leyland, A. (in press) School effects on pupils’ health behaviours: evidence in support of the health promoting school. Research Papers in Education.

23.

Wrigley, T. (2003) Schools of Hope: A New Agenda for School Improvement. Stoke-on-Trent: Trentham Books .