Abstract
This article proposes a novel white-light interference (WLI) force-monitoring ring for bridge cable force monitoring and temperature compensation. The WLI force-monitoring ring employs a sensing optical fiber wrapped around the outer surface of an elastomer to measure the expansion caused by applied load and temperature. By installing WLI force-monitoring ring between the anchor plate and the spherical plate of the cable, cable force can be captured by the sensing optical fiber and thus measured after temperature compensation. Based on white-light interferometry, two force-monitoring rings with resolution of 0.25 µ are designed. To find a route to temperature compensation, laboratory experiments are carried to study the effects of temperature on WLI force-monitoring ring both in free and forced states. Theoretical analysis and calibration experiments are implemented to verify the effectiveness of the proposed WLI force-testing ring, and the experiment results expose that the temperature-induced strain can be compensated using a WLI force-monitoring ring in free state. As a comparison, similar work is made for four fiber Bragg grating sensors attached to the elastomer evenly near the sensing optical fiber. The comparison results verify that the WLI method achieves better linear relation and repeatability than fiber Bragg grating. The WLI force-monitoring ring provides a high-precision and low-cost method for bridge cable force monitoring.
Introduction
The cables are most important components of bridges such as cable-stayed bridges, suspension bridges, and arch bridges. However, during the construction and operation conditions of the cable-stayed bridge, the cable forces are frequently affected by deck vehicles, wind load, cable corrosion, and so on. Considering the fact that bridge is a statically indeterminate structure, once the cable force deviates from the designed value, the bridge internal force distribution will be changed, and a deterioration in safety may be resulted as a consequence (Sakamoto and Kobori, 1995). Therefore, it is of great benefit to monitor the cable force for the purpose of online evaluation of the structural safety condition.
Long-term monitoring of cable force has been deeply studied. Magneto-elastic method measures the cable force through the calibrated relationship between the permeability and the load after compensating the temperature effect (Wang et al., 2001). Although the cable is magnetized, the advantages of magneto-elastic method are that the physical and mechanical properties of the cable are not affected (Wang et al., 1999), and it is not necessary to install the sensor during the construction period (Sumitro et al., 2002). However, it is difficult to accurately calibrate the relationship between the permeability and the load. The frequency method identifies the natural frequencies from the recorded cable responses by installing the accelerometer on the cable (Hearn and Testa, 1991; Hsieh et al., 2006). Utilizing the relation between natural frequencies and the cable force, the force can be extracted thereafter once the density and length of the cable are known (Cunha et al., 2001). Besides, the development of wireless sensor networks makes frequency method more convenient to monitor the cable force (Cho et al., 2008). The smartphones are also applied in the cable force monitoring (Zhao et al., 2015, 2016). Surely, it will not be a perfect method, because that in addition to the cable force, the natural frequency of bridge cable is also affected by flexural rigidity, boundary conditions, sag, and so on (Li et al., 2011).
Optical sensing technique is relatively practical for long-term monitoring. Existing measurement systems are mainly based on the fiber Bragg grating (FBG). One of them measures the cable force by the intelligent fiber cable, which monitors the internal force of cable wires through the FBG inside the bridge cable (He et al., 2013; Ni et al., 2002). However, the FBG sensors inside the bridge cable are vulnerable, and thus restrict the applicability of fiber cable. The FBG force-testing ring is also introduced for cable force measurement (Li et al., 2015; Nan et al., 2006). The drawback of this system is that every FBG sensor can only monitor the strain of its attached location. The measurement results of all FBG will show a wide variation since the strain on the surface of the force-monitoring ring is not uniform in practice. Generally, if the force-monitoring ring is loaded along the axis with different rotation angle, a large deviation may exist in the determination of the loading forces.
The first optical fiber displacement sensing system based on white-light interferometry was reported in 1984 (Bosselmann and Ulrich, 1984). After that, the WLI sensing technique has been widely applied to monitor displacement (Brundavanam et al., 2008), temperature (Chen and Taylor, 2002), and strain (Yuan and Ansari, 1997). Here, authors proposed a WLI force-monitoring ring to reduce the cable force measurement errors in the scenario of the uneven force distribution on the surface of the force-monitoring ring. This research’s content is described as follows. Section “Principle of white-light interferometry” presents the principle of the WLI. Section “Design of WLI force-monitoring ring” demonstrates the design of WLI force-monitoring ring. In section “Temperature compensation of WLI force-monitoring ring,” the experiments to explore the route for temperature compensation are carried out, and its results show that the temperature effect can be effectively compensated using a WLI force-monitoring ring in a free state. Theoretical analysis and comparative calibration experiments on WLI force-monitoring ring are implemented in section “Comparison of calibration experiments on WLI and FBG.” Section “Conclusion” concludes this article.
Principle of white-light interferometry
The configuration of optical fiber white-light interferometer based on Michelson interferometer is shown in Figure 1 (Zhao and Ansari, 2001). A beam of light emitted from the superluminescent light-emitting diode (SLED) passes through the circulator, along

Configuration of white-light interferometer.
In the optical circuit of the white-light interferometer, the location of WLI fringe records the location of moving mirror, and the location of the moving mirror corresponds to the length of the sensing optical fiber. Consequently, the length of the sensing optical fiber can be measured by recording the location of WLI fringe. Before and after the change in length of the sensing optical fiber, two WLI fringes are obtained, and the change in length of the sensing optical fiber can be calculated according to the spacing between the two WLI fringes. Therefore, the following equations can be established
where
As can be seen from the above equations, when measuring the strain of the sensing optical fiber, the resolution of the white-light interferometer depends on the
Design of WLI force-monitoring ring
The WLI force-testing ring is composed of the elastomer and a WLI sensing optical fiber wrapped around the elastomer. The elastomer is the main component of the WLI force-monitoring ring, which is a hollow cylinder with flanges on upper and lower edges made by the 45# steel, as shown in Figure 2. Note that the flanges on the upper and lower edges are designed to be convex to avoid stress concentration. The outer and inner diameters of the elastomer are 174 and 145 mm, respectively. In real application, the WLI force-testing ring is installed between the anchor plate and the spherical plate as shown in Figure 3. Figure 4 shows the basic calculation model of WLI force-testing ring in a forced state. As the cable anchorage goes through the internal hole of the WLI force-testing ring, the internal WLI sensing optical fiber will sense the compression when the cable force puts the pressure on the elastomer through the anchor. In such a way, the cable force can be finally determined through monitoring the transferred deformation (ΔS) from the cable to the elastomer. Under the action of vertical load, the expansion of the elastomer occurs at the outer surface. By the wrapped sensing optical fiber around the outer surface to measure the expansion, the cable force can be obtained as a result.

WLI force-monitoring ring: (a) real product and (b) sketch.

Model of bridge cable.

Basic calculation model of WLI force-testing ring in a forced state.
The length of the sensing optical fiber wrapped around the outer surface of the elastomer is 20 m, so the resolution of the designed WLI force-monitoring ring can reach to
Temperature compensation of WLI force-monitoring ring
The sensing element of WLI force-monitoring ring is the optical fiber, which is sensitive to both the strain and the temperature. In bridge cable force monitoring, there is generally a large variation of temperature. For the purpose of accurately measuring the cable force, it is indispensable to compensate the effect of temperature.
The current design of WLI force-monitoring ring includes the elastomer and the sensing optical fiber which is wrapped around the elastomer. Consequently, the effect of temperature on the WLI force-monitoring ring can be categorized into two parts. One part comes from the expansion and shrinkage of the elastomer produced by the variation of experimental temperature, and another part comes from the deformation of the sensing optical fiber caused by the change of temperature. Surely, the effect of temperature on both of the elastomer and the sensing optical fiber should be removed.
In this article, a WLI force-monitoring ring in a free state is employed to compensate the temperature effect of the one in a forced state. The temperature compensation is used to compensate the temperature effects both on the elastomer and on the mechanical effects on the reading of the sensing optical fiber. The premise of such strategy is that the effect of temperature is the same on WLI force-monitoring ring either in a free and forced state. To verify the premise, this section demonstrates the effect of temperature on WLI force-monitoring ring in free and forced states through theoretical and experimental investigations.
Effect of temperature on WLI force-monitoring ring in free state
The sensing optical fiber of WLI force-monitoring ring is affected by both the axial force generated by the expansion of the elastomer and the change of temperature. Because both the sensing optical fiber and the elastomer operate within the extent of elasticity, the strain of the sensing optical fiber is linearly proportional to the axial force of the sensing optical fiber and the temperature difference as well. It can be expressed as follows
where
In free state, the axial force f generated by the expansion of the elastomer caused by the change of temperature can be expressed by
where
Combining equations (3) and (4), the strain
The own strain
According to equations (5) and (6), the total strain
If the temperature coefficient
Equation (7) can be written as
It can be found that, in a free state of WLI force-monitoring ring, the strain of the sensing optical fiber is proportional to the change of temperature. To verify equation (9), a static temperature experiment on the WLI force-monitoring ring in a free state is carried out in the laboratory. The designed WLI force-monitoring ring is put into a water tank to be heated in water bath as shown in Figure 5(a) with the

Temperature tests on WLI force-monitoring ring in a free state: (a) temperature test setup, (b) first cycle, (c) second cycle, (d) third cycle, and (e) repeatability.
Effect of temperature on WLI force-monitoring ring in forced state
The last experiment shows the effect of temperature on WLI force-monitoring ring in a free state. To illustrate that the effect of temperature on WLI force-monitoring ring does not depend on the force state, an experiment is carried out in the laboratory as shown in Figure 6(a).

Temperature compensation of WLI force-monitoring ring: (a) temperature test setup and (b) experimental result.
During the experiment, a WLI force-monitoring ring is placed on a press machine and subjected to a continuous loading up to 400 kN. At the same time, another WLI force-monitoring ring in a free state is placed on the side to monitor the change of temperature. The initial locations of WLI fringe
Comparison of calibration experiments on WLI and FBG
The strain of the sensing optical fiber in the WLI force-monitoring ring includes the effects from the load and the change of temperature. Section “Temperature compensation of WLI force-monitoring ring” has verified that there is no coupling of the load and the temperature. Therefore, if the effect of the temperature is removed, the axial force of the sensing optical fiber becomes linearly related to the load on the WLI force-monitoring ring, which can be described as
where F is the load on WLI force-monitoring ring in kN and
If the load coefficient
The strain
According to equations (9) and (12), the total strain
Equation (13) shows that the strain of the sensing optical fiber is proportional to the cable force after removing the temperature effect using a WLI force-monitoring ring in free state. To verify equation (13), a calibration experiment of the WLI force-monitoring ring is carried out using the same arrangement as Figure 6(a) with the load F varying from 100 to 600 kN. The initial locations of WLI fringe
The strains of the four FBGs after temperature compensation are shown in Figure 7, where the FBG1, FBG2, FBG3, and FBG4 are the FBG sensors attached to the elastomer of the WLI force-monitoring ring, and the strain used to compensate temperature is the average of four FBG sensors in the WLI force-monitoring ring in free state. It is shown that the strain of every FBG sensor is approximately linear to the load on force monitoring, and the results of the three cycles are nearly close. However, the strains of the four FBG sensors are different at the same load level and the linear relationship between the load and the strain is poor especially when the load is less than 300 kN, where the slopes of FBG1 and FBG4 increase, but the corresponding slopes of FBG2 and FBG3 decrease compared to those with greater loads. Through the above analysis, one possible reason why the precision of FBG sensors is worse is that the pressed WLI sensor suffers slight eccentricity press when the load is less than 300 kN because of the machining error of the elastomer or uneven surface of the press machine. Another possible reason is that the less precision of the FBG is due to the use of the glue. When the sensor is pressed on press machine, the FBGs were stretched, but the elongation of the FBGs was restricted by the glue.

Strain of FBG1 to FBG4 after temperature compensation under loading and unloading: (a) first cycle, (b) second cycle, and (c) third cycle.
The comparison of calibration results between WLI and FBG are shown in Figure 8 where

Comparison of calibration results between WLI and FBG under loading and unloading: (a) first cycle, (b) second cycle, (c) third cycle, and (d) repeatability.
From the comparison between the WLI and FBG, it can be concluded that the WLI has better performance to monitor the applied load than FBG. Besides, the fabrication process of the WLI sensor is easier because only the two ends of the sensing optical fiber need to be fixed. In addition, the WLI monitoring of the average strain of the sensing optical fiber is a significant advantage to monitor the strain distributed in large area.
Conclusion
For the purpose of accurately measuring the cable force, a novel type of WLI force-monitoring ring is proposed in this article. Based on the principle of white-light interferometry, the WLI force-monitoring ring is designed, in which a bending optical fiber with known length is wrapped around the outer surface of elastomer to measure the load of force-monitoring ring. Since the strain of the sensing optical fiber depends on the applied load and environmental temperature, their effects are theoretically and experimentally studied. It shows that the strain of the sensing optical fiber is linearly related to the load and the temperature, and the temperature effect can be compensated by measuring another WLI force-monitoring ring in a free state. By comparing its performance with the FBG-based method, the high accuracy of the proposed WLI sensor, even in the condition of uneven strain, is demonstrated. The WLI force-monitoring ring has numerous advantages such as high measuring accuracy and, especially, lower cost, allowing effective cable force monitoring of bridges.
The proposed WLI force-monitoring ring presents excellent performance to monitor the applied load under laboratory conditions. However, the ends of the WLI sensing optical fiber are fixed on the elastomer using glue, which will be a threat to the durability of the sensor used in real cable force monitoring. In future studies, a metal clamp will be presented to replace the glue and increase the durability of the WLI force-monitoring ring.
Footnotes
Declaration of Conflicting Interests
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Funding
The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation (Grant No. 51278085) and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities of China (Grant No. DUT16ZD219).
