Health tests and health consultations reduced cardiovascular risk without psychological strain,increased healthcare utilization or increased costs

Abstract

Background: Few randomized controlled trials (RCT) have evaluated health tests and health consultations in primary care with a long follow-up period. The Ebeltoft Health Promotion Project (EHPP) evaluated health tests and health consultations over a period of 5 years in the frame of a health technology assessment. Objective: To review the results of EHPP. Design: RCT with a control group answering questionnaires and two intervention groups having questionnaires, a comprehensive health test with written advice followed by either a normal consultation on demand or a planned 45 minutes patient-centred consultation. Setting: Primary care. Participants: The target population was all 30—49 year old persons in the municipality of Ebeltoft, Denmark. Invitations were received by 2000 randomly selected persons. Intervention: A comprehensive biomedical health test including a cardiovascular risk score (CVRS) followed by written advice and health consultations. Main outcome measures: Biomedical measures, psychological measures, healthcare contacts, life years gained, direct and total health costs. Results: At baseline 75% participated. During the 5 years 85% participated at least once. Elevated CVRS was found in 19% in the control group compared to 10% in the intervention groups (p<0.01) after 5 years. There were no measurable long term psychological reactions. Numbers of contacts to the healthcare system were not increased. Significantly better life expectancy was found without extra direct and total costs. Conclusions: An offer of health tests and patient-centred health consultations to the middle-aged population can be cost-effective and may be considered in the fight against the increasing burden of lifestyle diseases.

Keywords

Cardiovascular risk general practice health care costs health care utilisation health consultation health test middle-aged multiphasic screening prevention psychological strain randomized controlled trial

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

The World Health Report. Making a difference. 2006. Geneva: WHO; 1999.

World Health Organization. Diet, nutrition, and the prevention of chronic disease . Geneva: WHO. WHO Technical Report Series 916; 2002 .

World Cancer Research Fund and American Institute for Cancer Research , 1997. Food, nutrition and prevention of cancer: a global perspective . Nutrition 1999;15:523-5.

US Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF). Guide to clinical preventive services. Agency for Health Care Research and Quality; 2006. Available at: http://www.ahrq.gov/clinic/pocketgd.pdf (accessed 13 May 2008).

The Canadian Task Force on Periodic Health Examination. Guide to clinical preventive services, 2nd ed, 1996. National Library of Medicine, Health Services Technology Assesment Text ; 1996. Available at: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/bv.fcgi?rid=hstat3.chapter.10062 (accessed 13 May 2008).

Ebrahim S. , Smith GD Systematic review of randomised controlled trials of multiple risk factor interventions for preventing coronary heart disease . BMJ 1997;314: 1666-74.

Wood DA , Kinmonth AL , Davies GA , Yarwood J. , Thompson SG , Pyke SDM , et al. Randomised controlled trial evaluating cardiovascular screening and intervention in general practice: principal results of British family heart study. Family Heart Study Group . BMJ 1994;308:313-20.

Imperial Cancer Research Fund OXCHECK Study Group. Effectiveness of health checks conducted by nurses in primary care: final results of the OXCHECK study . BMJ 1995;310:1099-04.

Engberg M. , Christensen B. , Karlsmose B. , Lous J. , Lauritzen T. General health screenings to improve cardiovascular risk profiles: a randomized controlled trial in general practice with 5-year follow-up . J Fam Pract 2002;51: 546-52.

10.

Wonderling D. , Langham S. , Buxton M. , Normand C. , McDermott C. What can be concluded from the Oxcheck and British family heart studies: commentary on cost effectiveness analyses . BMJ 1996;312:1274-8.

11.

Wonderling D. , McDermott C. , Buxton M. , Kinmonth AL , Pyke S. , Thompson S. , et al. Costs and cost effectiveness of cardiovascular screening and intervention: the British family heart study . BMJ 1996;312:1269-73.

12.

Lauritzen T. , Leboeuf -Y de C , Lunde IM , Nielsen KD Ebeltoft project: baseline data from a five-year randomized, controlled, prospective health promotion study in a Danish population . Br J Gen Pract 1995;45:542-7.

13.

Anggard EE , Land JM , Lenihan CJ , Packard CJ , Percy MJ , Ritchie LD , et al. Prevention of cardiovascular disease in general practice: a proposed model . Br Med J Clin Res 1986;293:177-80.

14.

Kanstrup H. , Refsgaard J. , Engberg M. , Lassen JF , Larsen ML , Lauritzen T. Cholesterol reduction following health screening in general practice . Scand J Prim Health Care 2002;20:219-23.

15.

Jensen MS , Thomsen JL , Jensen SE , Lauritzen T. , Engberg M. Electrocardiogram interpretation in general practice . Fam Pract 2005;22:109-13.

16.

Jensen MS , Thomsen JL , Jensen SE , Lauritzen T. , Engberg M. Low prevalence of ischemic electrocardiographic findings in a Danish population . Scand Cardiovasc J 2003;37:49-57.

17.

Christensen B. , Engberg M. , Lauritzen T. No long-term psychological reaction to information about increased risk of coronary heart disease in general practice . Eur J Cardiovasc Prev Rehabil 2004;11:239-43.

18.

Larsen EL , Thomsen JL , Lauritzen T. , Engberg M. Forebyggende helbredsundersøgelser og helbredssamtaler i almen praksis. En analyse af patientperspektivet [Preventive health checks/screenings and health discussions/conversations in general practice. An analysis of the patient perspective]. An analysis with specific focus on the Danish Health Project Ebeltoft and other randomised studies. Health technology assessment. Copenhagen: The Danish National Board of Health, Danish Centre for Evaluation and Technology Assessment; 2006. Available at: http://www.sst.dk/publ/Publ2006/CEMTV/Ebeltoft/ebeltoft_ptpersp.pdf (accessed 13 May 2008).

19.

Bach Nielsen KD , Dyhr L. , Lauritzen T. , Malterud K. Long-term impact of elevated cardiovascular risk detected by screening. A qualitative interview study . Scand J Prim Health Care 2005;23:233-8.

20.

Nielsen KD , Dyhr L. , Lauritzen T. , Malterud K. You can't prevent everything anyway: a qualitative study of beliefs and attitudes about refusing health screening in general practice . Fam Pract 2004 ;21:28-32.

21.

Jacobsen ET , Rasmussen SR , Christensen M. , Engberg M. , Lauritzen T. Perspectives on lifestyle intervention: the views of general practitioners who have taken part in a health promotion study . Scand J Public Health 2005;33:4-10.

22.

Geest TA , Engberg M. , Lauritzen T. Discordance between self-evaluated health and doctor-evaluated health in relation to general health promotion . Scand J Prim Health Care 2004;22:146-51.

23.

Thomsen JL , Parner ET , Karlsmose B. , Thulstrup AM , Lauritzen T. , Engberg M. Effect of preventive health screening on long-term primary health care utilization. A randomized controlled trial . Fam Pract 2005;22:242-8.

24.

Thomsen JL , Karlsmose B. , Parner ET , Thulstrup AM , Lauritzen T. , Engberg M. Secondary healthcare contacts after multiphasic preventive health screening: a randomized trial . Scand J Public Health 2006;34:254-61.

25.

Rasmussen SR , Thomsen JL , Kilsmark J. , Hvenegaard A. , Engberg M. , Lauritzen T. , et al. Preventive health screenings and health consultations in primary care increase life expectancy without increasing costs . Scand J Public Health 2007;35:365-72.

26.

Steffensen FH , Lauritzen T. , Sorensen HT Validity of self-reported smoking habits . Scand J Prim Health Care 1995;13:236-7.

27.

Steffensen FH , Sorensen HT , Brock A. , Vilstrup H. , Lauritzen T. Alcohol consumption and serum liver-derived enzymes in a Danish population aged 30-50 years . Int J Epidemiol 1997;26:92-9.

28.

Thulstrup AM , Sorensen HT , Steffensen FH , Vilstrup H. , Lauritzen T. Changes in liver-derived enzymes and self-reported alcohol consumption. A 1-year follow-up study in Denmark . Scand J Gastroenterol 1999 ;34:189-93.

29.

Thulstrup AM , Norgard B. , Steffensen FH , Vilstrup H. , Sorensen HT , Lauritzen T. Waist circumference and body mass index as predictors of elevated alanine transaminase in Danes aged 30 to 50 years . Dan Med Bull 1999;46: 429-31.

30.

Karlsmose B. , Pedersen HB , Lauritzen T. , Parving A. Audiometry in general practice: validation of a pragmatic pure-tone audiometry method . Scand Audiol 1998;27:137-42.

31.

Karlsmose B. , Lauritzen T. , Parving A. Prevalence of hearing impairment and subjective hearing problems in a rural Danish population aged 31-50 years . Br J Audiol 1999;33:395-402.

32.

Karlsmose B. , Lauritzen T. , Engberg M. , Parving A. A five-year longitudinal study of hearing in a Danish rural population aged 31-50 years . Br J Audiol 2000;34:47-55.

33.

Karlsmose B. , Lauritzen T. , Engberg M. , Parving A. A randomised controlled trial of screening for adult hearing loss during preventive health checks . Br J Gen Pract 2001;51:351-5.

34.

Leboeuf-Yde C. , Klougart N. , Lauritzen T. How common is low back pain in the Nordic population? Data from a recent study on a middle-aged general Danish population and four surveys previously conducted in the Nordic countries . Spine 1996;21:1518-25.

35.

Leboeuf -Y de C , Yashin A. , Lauritzen T. Does smoking cause low back pain? Results from a population-based study . J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1996;19:99-108.

36.

Hartvigsen J. , Bakketeig LS , Leboeuf -Y de C , Engberg M. , Lauritzen T. The association between physical workload and low back pain clouded by the ``healthy worker'' effect: population-based cross-sectional and 5-year prospective questionnaire study . Spine 2001;26:1788-92.

37.

Lauritzen T. , Christiansen JS , Brock A. , Mogensen CE Repeated screening for albumin-creatinine ratio in an unselected population. The Ebeltoft Health Promotion Study, a randomized, population-based intervention trial on health test and health conversations with general practitioners . J Diabetes Complications 1994;8:146-9.

38.

Sorensen HT , Thulstrup AM , Norgdard B. , Engberg M. , Madsen KM , Johnsen SP , et al. Fetal growth and blood pressure in a Danish population aged 31-51 years . Scand Cardiovasc J 2000;34:390-5.

39.

Ziegler B. , Johnsen SP , Thulstrup AM , Engberg M. , Lauritzen T. , Sorensen HT Inverse association between birth weight, birth length and serum total cholesterol in adulthood . Scand Cardiovasc J 2000;34:584-8.

40.

Johnsen SP , Sorensen HT , Thulstrup AM , Norgard B. , Engberg M. , Lauritzen T. Fetal growth and urinary albumin excretion among middle-aged Danes . Scand J Urol Nephrol 2001;35:314-18.

41.

Johnsen SP , Sorensen HT , Thomsen JL , Gronbaek H. , Flyvbjerg A. , Engberg M. , et al. Markers of fetal growth and serum levels of insulin-like growth factor (IGF) I, -II and IGF binding protein 3 in adults . Eur J Epidemiol 2004;19:41-7.

42.

Rubak S. , Sandbaek A. , Lauritzen T. , Christensen B. Motivational interviewing: a systematic review and meta-analysis . Br J Gen Pract 2005;55:305-12.

43.

Hestbaek L. , Leboeuf -Y de C , Engberg M. , Lauritzen T. , Bruun NH , Manniche C. The course of low back pain in a general population. Results from a 5-year prospective study . J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2003;26:213-19.

44.

Leboeuf -Y de C , Lauritsen JM , Lauritzen T. Why has the search for causes of low back pain largely been nonconclusive . Spine 1997 ;22:877-81.

45.

Hjermann I. , Byre KV , Holme I. , Leren P. Effect of diet and smoking intervention on the incidence of coronary heart disease . Lancet 1981;2:1303-10.

46.

Puska P. , Tuomilehto J. , Nissinen A. , Salonen JT , Vartiainen E. , Pietinen P. , et al. The North Karelia project: 15 years of community-based prevention of coronary heart disease . Ann Med 1989;21:169-73.

47.

Fortmann SP , Flora JA , Winkleby MA , Schooler C. , Taylor CB , Farquhar JW Community intervention trials: reflections on the Stanford Five-City Project Experience . Am J Epidemiol 1995;142:576-86.

48.

Wilhelmsen L. , Berglund G. , Elmfeldt D. , Tibblin G. , Wedel H. , Pennert K. , et al. The multifactor primary prevention trial in Göteborg, Sweden . Eur Heart J 1986 ;7: 279-88.

49.

Effectiveness of health checks conducted by nurses in primary care: results of the OXCHECK study after one year. Imperial Cancer Research Fund OXCHECK Study Group . BMJ 1994;308:308-12.

50.

Wood DA , Kinmonth AL , Davies G. , Yarwood J. , Thompson SG , Pyke SDM , et al. British family heart study: its design and method, and prevalence of cardiovascular risk factors. Family heart study group . Br J Gen Pract 1994;44: 62-7.

51.

Knutsen SF , Knutsen R. The Tromso Survey: the Family Intervention study-the effect of intervention on some coronary risk factors and dietary habits, a 6-year follow-up . Prev Med 1991;20:197-212.

52.

Cupples ME , McKnight A. Randomised controlled trial of health promotion in general practice for patients at high cardiovascular risk [see comments] . BMJ 1994;309:993-6.

53.

Ramcharan S. , Cutler JL , Feldman R. , Siegelaub AB , Campbell B. , Friedman GD , et al. Multiphasic checkup evaluation study. 2. Disabilty and chronic disease after seven years of multiphasic health checkups . Prev Med 1973;2:207-20.

54.

Dales LG , Friedman GD , Collen MF Evaluating periodic multiphasic health checkups: A controlled trial . J Chronic Dis 1979;32:385-404.

55.

Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial Research Group. Multiple risk factor intervention trial. Risk factor changes and mortality results . JAMA 1982;248:1465-77.

56.

Stott NC , Kinnersley P. , Rollnick S. The limits to health promotion [editorial; comment] . BMJ 1994;309:971-2.

57.

Stott N. Screening for cardiovascular risk in general practice. Blanket health promotion is wast of resources . BMJ 1994;308:285-6.

58.

McCormick J. , Skrabanek P. Coronary heart disease is not preventable by population interventions . Lancet 1988;2: 839-41.

59.

Waller D. , Agass M. , Mant D. , Coulter A. , Fuller A. , Jones L. Health checks in general practice: another example of inverse care? [see comments] . BMJ 1990;300:1115-18.

60.

Stewart BS , Farmer A. Screening could seriously damage your health [editorial] [see comments] . BMJ 1997;314: 533-4.

61.

Holland WW , Creese AL , DeSouza MF , Partridge JRJ , Shannon D. , Stone DH , et al. A controlled trial of multiphasic screening in middle-age: Results of the South-East London screening study . Int J Epidemiol 1977;6:357-63.

62.

Dales LG , Friedman GD , Ramcharan S. , Siegelaub AB , Campbell BA , Feldman R. , et al. Multiphasic checkup evaluation study. 3. Outpatient clinic utilization, hospitalization, and mortality experience after seven years . Prev Med 1973;2:221-35.

63.

Andersen TF , Madsen M. , Jorgensen J. , Mellemkjoer L. , Olsen JH The Danish National Hospital Register. A valuable source of data for modern health sciences . Dan Med Bull 1999;46:263-8.

64.

Olivarius NF , Hollnagel H. , Krasnik A. , Pedersen PA , Thorsen H. The Danish National Health Service Register. A tool for primary health care research . Dan Med Bull 1997;44:449-53.

65.

Langham S. , Thorogood M. , Normand C. , Muir J. , Jones L. , Fowler G. Costs and cost effectiveness of health checks conducted by nurses in primary care: the Oxcheck study . BMJ 1996 ;312:1265-8.

66.

Dansk Lungemedicinsk Selskab , Pedersen JT , Dirksen A. , Groth S. , Kjaerulff J. , Madsen F. , et al. Spirometri . En recommendation Vanløse: Nationalforeningen ; 1986.

67.

Åstrand PO Experimental studies of physical working capacity in relation to sex and age . København: Ejnar Munksgaard ; 1952.