Cross-national comparisons of non-harmonized indicators may lead to more confusion than clarification

Abstract

Aims: A newly published study showed that the life expectancy for Danes was below the European Union (EU) average. Furthermore, the study showed that healthy life years (HLYs) at 50 years of age were much higher in Denmark than in the other EU countries in 2005. However, the results of this study should be interpreted with caution. Methods: The analyses regarding HLYs were based on the global long-term activity limitation index as a measure of disability and were included in the EU Survey on Income and Living Condition (EU-SILC). In Denmark two response categories were used to asses long-term activity limitation (yes; no) compared to three levels in all other countries (severely limited; limited but not severely; none). In addition, the wording of the question in Denmark makes cross-national comparisons even more inadequate. The questions and the response categories were revised in the Danish SILC-2008. Results: A comparison of the previous and the revised indicator shows that the estimated number of HLYs at 50 years of age is approximately three years lower for both men and women in 2008 than in 2005. Furthermore, in Denmark data was collected via telephone interviews or postal questionnaires. However, in almost all other countries data was collected via face-to-face interviews. It is well known that the mode of data collection may affect response distributions. Conclusions: Results based on non-harmonized indicators should always be interpreted cautiously to avoid policy-makers and others reaching erroneous conclusions.

Keywords

Health expectancy life expectancy self-reported health

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Jagger C. , Gillies C. , Moscone F. , Cambois E. , Van Oyen H. , Nusselder W. , Robine JM EHLEIS team. Inequalities in healthy life years in the 25 countries of the European Union in 2005: a cross-national meta-regression analysis. Lancet 2008; 372:2124-31.

Sullivan DF A single index of mortality and morbidity . Health Serv Ment Health Rep 1971;86:347-54.

Verma V. Issues in data quality and comparability in EU-SILC. In: Comparative EU statistics on income and living conditions: issues and challenges . Proceedings of the EU-SILC Conference; Nov 6-8 2006. Helsinki, Finland. Luxembourg : Office for Official Publications of the European Communities; 2007. pp. 287-309.

Bowling A. Mode of questionnaire administration can have serious effects on data quality . J Public Health 2005; 27:281-91.

Feveile H. , Olsen O. , Hogh A. A randomised trial of mailed questionnaires versus telephone interviews: response patterns in a survey. BMC Med Res Methodol 2007;7:27.

Picavet HSJ. National health surveys by mail or home interview: effects on response. J Epidemiol Community Health 2001;55: 408-13.

Ekholm O. , Kjøller M. , Davidsen M. , Hesse U. , Eriksen L. , Christensen AI , Grønbæk M. The Danish Health Interview Survey & trends since 1987. Copenhagen, Denmark: National Institute of Public Health ; 2006.