Working together — primary care doctors’ and nurses’ attitudes to collaboration

Abstract

Background: Multidisciplinary teamwork is recommended for various disorders and it has been suggested that it is a way to meet the new challenges and demands facing general practitioners (GPs) in modern society. Attempts to introduce the method in primary care have failed partly due to GPs’ unwillingness to participate. The aim of this study was to measure attitudes towards collaboration among GPs and district nurses (DN) and to investigate whether there is a correlation between a positive attitude toward collaboration and high self-esteem in the professional role. Methods: The Jefferson Scale of Attitudes toward Physician Nurse Collaboration and the Professional Self-Description Form (PSDF) was used to study a cohort of 600 GPs and DNs in Västra Götaland region. The purpose was to map differences and correlations of attitude between DNs and GPs, between male and female GPs, and between older and younger DNs and GPs. Results: Four hundred and one answers were received. DNs (mean 51.7) were significantly more positive about collaboration than GPs (mean 49.4). There was no difference between younger and older, male and female GPs. DNs scored higher on the PSDF-scale than GPs. Conclusions: DNs were slightly more positive about collaboration than GPs. A positive attitude towards collaboration did not seem to be a part of the GPs’ professional role to the same extent as it is for DNs. Professional norms seem to have more influence on attitudes than do gender roles. DNs seem more confident in their profession than GPs.

Keywords

Cooperative behaviour district nurse general practitioner professional role science teamwork

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Grumbach K. , Bodenheimer T.

Can health care teams improve primary care practice?

JAMA 2004;291:1246-51.

Ridd M. , Shaw A. , Salisbury C. Two sides of the coin - the value of personal continuity to GPs: a qualitative interview study. Fam Pract 2006 ;23:461-8.

Cook TH

The effectiveness of inpatient case management: fact or fiction?

J Nursing Admin 1998;31:36-46.

van Weel C. Teamwork. Lancet 1994;344:1276-9.

The National Board of Health and Welfare. Treatment of chronic pain. SoS-rapport 1994;4 [In Swedish].

SBU - The Swedish Council on Technology Assessment in Health Care. Back and neck pain. Report number: 145. Stockholm; 2000 [Full text in Swedish].

Cook R. Paths to effective teamwork in primary care settings. Nursing Times 1996;14:44-5.

Bailey P. , Jones L. , Way D. Family physician/nurse practitioner: stories of collaboration. J Adv Nursing 2006; 53:381-91.

Wilson K. , Coulon L. , Hillege S. , Swann W. Nurse practitioners’ experiences of working collaboratively with general practitioners and allied health professionals in New South Wales, Australia . Aus J Adv Nursing 2005 Dec- 2006 Feb;23:22-7.

10.

Hultberg E-L. , Lönnroth K. , Allebeck P. Co-financing as a means to improve collaboration between primary health care, social insurance and service in Sweden - a qualitative study of collaboration experiences among rehabilitation partners. Health Policy 2003 ;64:143-52.

11.

Hansson A. , Friberg F. , Segesten K. , Gedda B. , Mattsson B. Two sides of the coin - general practitioners experience of working in multidisciplinary teams. J Interprof Care 2008;22:5-16.

12.

Sweet SJ , Norman I. The nurse-doctor relationship: a selective literature review. J Adv Nursing 1995;22:165-70.

13.

Hojat M. , Fields SK , Rattner SL , Griffiths M. , Gohen MJ , Plumb JD Attitudes toward physicians-nurse alliance: comparisons of medical and nursing students. Acad Med 1997;72:S1-3.

14.

Hojat M. , Fields SK , Veloski JJ , Griffiths M. , Gohen MJM , Plumb JD Psychometric properties of an attitude scale measuring physician-nurse collaboration . Eval Health Prof 1999;22:169-83.

15.

Hojat M. , Gonella JS , Nasca TJ , Fields SK , Cicchetti A. , Lo Scalzo A. , et al. Comparison of American, Israeli, Italian and Mexican physicians and nurses on the total factor scores of the Jefferson scale of attitudes toward physician-nurse collaborative relationships. Int J Nurs Studies 2003; 40:427-35.

16.

Yildirim A. , Ates M. , Akinci F. Physician-nurse attitudes toward collaboration in Istanbul’s public hospitals. Int J Nurs Studies 2005;42:429-37.

17.

Dagenais F. , Meleis AI Professionalism, work ethic, and empathy in nursing. The nurse self-description form. West J Nurs Res 1982;4:407-22.

18.

Olsson HM , Gullberg MT The use of nurse self-description forms in Sweden. Scand J Caring Sci 1988;1: 69-75.

19.

Gullberg M. Health care professionals’ self-description, Department of Caring Sciences , Linköping: Faculty of Health Sciences, Linköping University; 1996.

20.

Jonsson A. , Segesten K. Daily stress and concept of self in Swedish ambulance personnel. Prehosp Disaster Med 2003;19:226-34.

21.

Degeling P. , Maxwell S. , Kennedy J. , Coyle B.

Medicine, management, and modernisation: a ‘‘danse macabre’’?

BMJ 2003;326:649-52.

22.

Baggs JG , Schmitt MH , Mushlin AI , Eldredge DH , Oakes D. , Hutson AD Nurse-physician collaboration and satisfaction with the decision-making process in three critical care units. Am J Crit Care 1997;6:393-9.

23.

Davies C. Getting health professionals to work together. There’s more to collaboration than simply working side by side. BMJ 2007;320:1021-2.

24.

Farrell MP , Schmitt MH , Heinemann GD Informal roles and the stages of interdisciplinary team development. J Interprof Care 2001;15:281-95.

25.

Salvage J. , Smith R. Doctors and nurses: doing it differently . BMJ 2000;320:1019-20.

26.

Gjerberg E. , Kjølsrød L.

The doctor-nurse relationship: how easy is it to be a female doctor co-operating with a female nurse?

Soc Sci Med 2001;52:189-202.

27.

Edwards N. , Kornacki M. , Silversin J.

Unhappy doctors: what are the causes and what can be done?

BMJ 2002 ; 324:835-8.

28.

Dougherty MB , Larson E. A review of instruments measuring nurse-physician collaboration. J Nursing Admin 2005; 35:244-53.