The legal framework for organ donation in Denmark is informed consent. But due to the unsatisfactory number of organ donors, Denmark is considering changing legislation to presumed consent. This article discusses the public debate on organ donation and presumed consent in Denmark, and asks whether the right issues are being addressed in the quest towards more available organs and better donor rates? Basing our considerations on the various arguments in the debate and on scientific findings, we question the potential benefits of presumed consent and challenge some of the assumptions and rationalizations that characterize the discussions in Denmark regarding public support, public trust and the role of the family in donation decisions.
SheldonT.Dutch to start presumed consent for organ donation in 2020. BMJ2018; 360: k768.
5.
BoseleyS.Jeremy Hunt launches opt-out organ donation plans in England. The Guardian, 12December2017, p. 5.
6.
SymvoulakisEKMarkakiAGalanakisC, et al. Shifting towards an Opt-Out System in Greece: A General practice-based pilot study. Int J Med Sci2013; 10: 1547–1551.
7.
Dansk Center for Organdonation. DCD Donation efter Cirkulatorisk Død: Vurdering af Grundlaget i Danmark. Report from the Working Group for DCD in Denmark, July2018.
8.
Riis-JørgensenK.Det handler om livet. Dagbladet Køge/Ringsted/Roskilde, 28April2008, p. 4.
9.
JohansenS.Ny forening vil gøre alle til organdonorer fra fødslen, Kristeligt Dagblad, 6June2014, p. 11.
Guldborg HansenP. Tænk over dette, før du støtter, at alle over 18 år automatisk registreres som organdonorer. Videnskab.dk, 20August2018.
18.
AlbertsenA.Derfor er automatisk organdonation en god idé. Videnskab.dk, 23August2018.
19.
Ritzau. Folketingsflertal vil lade 15-årige tage stilling til organdonation. Berlingske, 24November2018, p. 6.
20.
HoeyerKOlofssonBOMjörndalT, et al. The ethics of research using biobanks: Reason to question the importance attributed to informed consent. Arch Inter Med2005; 165: 97–100.
Sundhedsstyrelsen. Organdonation 1995–2015: Danskernes viden, holdning og adfærd. Report for the Danish Health Agency, Denmark, 5October2016.
23.
NordfalkFOlejazMJensenAMB, et al. From motivation to acceptability: A survey of public attitudes towards organ donation in Denmark. Transplant Res2016: 5: 1–8.
24.
Andreassen RixB. Brain death, ethics and politics in Denmark. In: SchapiroRArnoldRMYoungerSJ (eds) The Definition of Death: Contemporary controversies, Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1999, pp 227–238.
25.
EllerE.Professor advarer mod forslag om at gøre flere til donorer. Randers Amtsavis, 8October2016, p. 41.
26.
TerkelsenLH.Myter skaber modstand. Kristeligt Dagblad, 6March2009, p. 4.
Editorial. Organdonor: nej ikke mig. Ekstra Bladet, 11October2012, p. 2.
29.
ShepherdLOʼCarrollREFergusonR.An international comparison of deceased and living organ donation/transplant rates in opt-in and opt-out systems: a panel studyBMC Medicine2014; 12: 131.
GfK UK Ltd. Evaluation of the Human Transplantation (Wales) Act: Impact Evaluation Report. Report for the Welsh Government. Report no. 71, 30November2017.
32.
ParsonsJA.Welsh 2013 deemed consent legislation falls short of expectations, Health Policy2018; 122: 941–944.
33.
AlbertsenA.Deemed consent: Assessing the new opt-out approach to organ procurement in Wales. J Med Ethics2018; 44: 314–318.
34.
Editorial. Increasing organ donation rates: Is legislation enough?Lancet Gastroenterol Hepatol2017; 2: 235.
35.
RithaliaAMcDaidCSuekarranS, et al. Impact of presumed consent for organ donation on donation rates: a systematic review. BMJ2009; 338: a3162.
36.
DomínguezJRojasJL.Presumed consent legislation failed to improve organ donation in Chile. Transplant Proc2013; 45:1316–1317.
37.
BeaS.No heroics, please: Mapping deceased donation practices in a Catalan hospital. PhD Thesis, University of Edinburgh, UK, 2017.
38.
FunchM.Forening vil sætte fart på organdonor-proces, Kristeligt Dagblad, 22June2017, p. 3.
39.
PetersenTSRosdalV.Pårørende bør ikke kunne omgøre organdonors ønske. Dagens Medicin, 27September2007, p 21.
40.
AlnæsAH.Minding matter: Organ donation and medical modernity’s difficult decisions. PhD Thesis. University of Oslo, Norway, 2001.
41.
JensenAMB. ‘Make sure somebody will survive from this’: Transformative practices of hope among Danish organ donor families. Med Anthropol Q2016; 30: 378–394.
42.
BerntzenHBjørkIT.Experiences of donor families after consenting to organ donation: A qualitative study. Intensive Crit Care Nurs2014; 30: 266–274.
43.
ForsbergAFlodénALennerlingA, et al. The core of after death care in relation to organ donation: A grounded theory study. Intensive Crit Care Nurs2014; 30: 275–282.
