Mortality among Bricklayers and Carpenters/cabinet makers

Abstract

Mortality among members of two medium-sized trade unions, the union of carpenters/cabinet makers and the union of bricklayers, has been studied during the period 1.1.71–31.12.75, primarily to investigate if the greater exposure to dust and organic solvents of the carpenters/ cabinet makers caused any increase in the mortaility from lung diseases. The study did not reveal any significant differences in mortality regarding any category of diagnoses except suicide, when the analysis was based on the main diagnosis recorded on the death certificate. However, when including underlying causes of death too, statistically significant increased death rates from larynx cancer, asthma, bronchitis and emphysema were found among the bricklayers, as compared with the carpenters/ cabinet makers. No explanation can be given for these observations. They may be a result of an unequal distribution of confounding variables in the two groups, or they may reflect various grades and forms of “Healthy Worker” selection. This study is a cross-section study and such studies and longitudinal studies over a period of a few years of occupational mortality are very sensitive to the selection of the occupational groupings. The analysis is based on deaths among life-insured members under the age of 67 years, in the two trade unions. Copies of the death certificates were obtained from the National Health Service and then coded by us along the lines indicated by the NHS.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Adelstein, A. M. : Occupational mortality: cancer. An Occup Hyg 15: 53, 1972.

2. Bahn, A. K. : Hodgkin's disease in schoolteachers (cont.). N Engl J Med 207, 1974.

3. Baxter, P. J. & Fow, A. J. : Angiosarcoma of the liver as the certified cause of death 1963-73. Lancet i: 27, 1975.

4. Bolander, S.-M. : Linkage of Census and Death Records to Obtain Mortality Registers for Epidemiological Studies in Sweden. National Central Bureau of Statistics, Sweden.

5. Bruce, D. L. , Eide, K. A. , Linde, H. W. & Eckenhoff, J. E. : Causes of death among anesthesiologists: A 20-year survey. Anesthesiology 29: 565, 1968.

6. Cochrane, A. L. : An epidemiologist's view of the relationship between simple pneumoconiosis and morbidity and mortality. Proc R Soc Med 69: 4, 1976.

7. Cooper, W. C. & Gaffey, W. R. : Mortality of lead workers. J Occup Med 17: 100, 1975.

8. Doll, R. , Morgan, L. G. & Speizer, F. E. : Cancers of the lung and nasal sinuses in nickel workers. Br J Cancer 24: 623, 1970.

9. Duck, B. W. , Carter, J. T. & Coombes, E. J. : Mortality study of workers in a polyvinyl-chloride production plant. Lancet ii: 1197, 1975.

10.

10. Dunn, J. E. & Meir, J. M. : A prospective study of mortality of several occupational groups. Arch Environ Health 17: 71, 1968.

11.

11. Fox, A. J. & Collier, P. F. : A survey of occupational cancer in the rubber and cablemaking industries: Analysis of deaths occurring in 1972-74. Br J Ind Med 33: 249, 1976.

12.

12. Hart, J. T. : Data on occupational mortality, 1959-63. Lancet i: 192, 1972.

13.

13. Holmes, R. : Occupational mortality and coronary disease. Proc R Soc Med 67: 673, 1974.

14.

14. Horwitz, O. & Knudsen, J. : A follow-up study of tuberculosis incidence and general mortality in various occupational-social groups of the Danish population. Bull Org Mond Santé 24: 793, 1961.

15.

15. Jeune, B. : Mortality of male members of the Danish semiskilled and unskilled workers union in 1973. Int J Epid, 6: 247, 1977.

16.

16. King, H. & Bailar, J. C. : Mortality among Lutheran clergymen. Milbank Mem Fund Quart 46: 527, 1968.

17.

17. Knox, E. G. : Computer simulation of industrial hazards. Br J Ind Med 30: 54, 1973.

18.

18. Koskela, R. S. , Hemberg, S. , Kärävä, R. , Järvinen, E. & Nurminen, M. : A mortality study of foundry workers. Scand J Work Environ Health, 2: Suppl. 1: 73, 1976.

19.

19. Lee, W. R. : Statistics of occupational mortality and morbidity. Trans Soc Occup Med 21: 47, 1971.

20.

20. Lynge, E. : Dødelighed i Danmark 1951-1971. Magisterkonferens i sociologi. Stencil, København, 1974.

21.

21. Lynge, E. : To artikler om erhverv og dødelighed. Socialmedicinsk Institut, Aarhus Universitet, udgivelse nr. 15, Aarhus, 1977.

22.

22. McMichael, A. J. , Spirtas, R. , Kupper, L. L. & Gamble, J. F. : Solvent exposure and leukemia among rubber workers: An epidemiologic study. J Occup Med 17: 234, 1975.

23.

23. Menck, H. R. & Henderson, B. E. : Occupational differences in rates of lung cancer. J Occup Med 18: 797, 1976.

24.

24. Prutting, J. : The autopsy. JAMA 222: 556, 1976.

25.

25. Public Health Service Publications No. 1103, Smoking and Health, Washington, 1964, pp. 117-120.

26.

26. Redmond, C. K. , Ciocco, A. , Lloyd, J. W. & Rush, H. W. : Long-term mortality study of steelworkers. J Occup Med 14: 621, 1972.

27.

27. Redmond, C. K. & Breslind, P. P. : Comparison of methods for assessing occupational hazards. J Occup Med 17: 313, 1975.

28.

28. Registrar-General, Decennial Supplement , Occupational Mortality Tables, 1961. HMSO, London, 1971.

29.

29. Spiers, P. S. : Hodgkin's disease in workers in the wood industry. Publ Health Rep 84: 385, 1969.

30.

30. Hazardous occupations . Stat Bull 50: 3, 1969.

31.

31. Longevity of prominent men . Stat Bull 50: 3, 1969.

32.

32. Occupational mortality 1970-73 . Statistiske Analyser No. 21, Central Bureau of Statistics, Oslo, 1976.

33.

33. Sørensen, T. : Den professionelle dødelighed. Hospitalstidende 4: 447, 1886.

34.

34. Sørensen, T. : De økonomiske forhold og beskéftigelsens indflydelse på dodeligheden. I-II. Reitzels forlag, København, 1884.