Comprehensive Environmental Assessment for Cooling Towers with Various Controls

Abstract

Cooling towers are generally used in water-cooled chiller systems, which provide cooling energy for commercial buildings. This article assesses how the various control systems of cooling towers influence plume emissions and the electricity and water consumption of a chilled water system. Integrated with real control of cooling tower fans, chiller and cooling tower models were developed to analyze how the energy performance of a chiller and the water loss rate varied under different operating conditions. The status of air flows through the cooling tower was investigated to judge plume formation under various cooling tower controls. A simulation analysis on a chilled water system serving an office building showed that optimizing the fan speed control of cooling towers enables the annual electricity and water consumption costs to save 4.6% while also reducing the plume generation. The optimum control means adjusting the temperature of cooling water leaving the cooling tower in response to the chiller load and wet bulb outdoor temperature. The results of this article provide important insights into how to enhance the environmental performance of cooling towers for use in water-cooled chiller systems.

Keywords

coefficient of performance plume formation water consumption water-cooled chiller

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Electrical and Mechanical Services Department (EMSD) : Pilot Scheme for Wider Use of Fresh Water in Evaporative Cooling Towers for Energy-efficient Air Conditioning Systems, Hong Kong, Author Press, 2000.

Braun JE , Klein SA , Mitchell JW , Beckman WA : Applications of optimal control to chilled water systems without storage : ASHRAE Trans 1989;95(1):663-675.

Braun JE , Diderrich GT : Near-optimal control of cooling towers for chilled water systems: ASHRAE Trans 1990, SL-90-13-3.

Shelton SV , Weber ED : Modelling and optimization of commercial building chiller/ cooling tower systems : ASHRAE Trans 1991;97(2):1209-1216.

Austin SB : Optimum chiller loading: ASHRAE J 1991;33(7):40-43.

Kaya A. : Improving efficiency in existing chillers with optimization technology : ASHRAE J 1991;33(10):30-38.

Beyene A. : Performance evaluation of conventional chiller systems: ASHRAE J 1995;37(6):36-44.

Roper MA : Energy efficient chiller control (Technical Note TN 16/2000). Bracknell: Building Services Research and Information Association, 2000.

Ahn BC , Mitchell JW : Optimal control development for chilled water plants using a quadratic representation : Energy Buildings 2001;33:371-378.

10.

Avery G. : Improving the efficiency of chilled water plants: ASHRAE J 2001;43(5):14-18.

11.

Hartman T. : All-variable speed centrifugal chiller plants: ASHRAE J 2001;43(9):43-53.

12.

Briley GC : Increasing operating efficiency: ASHRAE Journal 2003;45(5):73.

13.

Crowther H. , Furlong J. : Optimizing chillers and towers ASHRAE J 2004 ;46(7):34-40.

14.

Chan CWH : Optimizing chiller plant control logic: ASHRAE J 2006;48(7):38-42.

15.

Kairouani L. , Hassairi M. , Tarek Z. : Performance of cooling tower in south of Tunis ia: Building Environ 2004;39:351-355.

16.

Qureshi B. , Zubair S. : Prediction of evaporation losses in wet cooling towers: Heat Transfer Engineer 2006;27(9):86-92.

17.

Wang SW , Tyagi SK , Sharma A. , Kaushik SC : Application of solar collectors to control the visible plume from wet cooling towers of a commercial building in Hong Kong: A case study: Appl Thermal Engineer 2007;27:1394- 1404.

18.

Winter RJ : Control of visible plumes from cooling towers; in Proc Institution Mech Engineer 1997;211(A):67-72.

19.

Fisher BEA : Predicting cooling tower plume dispersion ; in Proc Institution Mech Engineer 1997;211(A):291-297.

20.

Browne MW , Bansal PK : Challenges in modeling vapour-compression liquid chillers: ASHRAE Trans 1998;104(1):474-486.

21.

Bourdouxhe JP , Grodent M. , Lebrun JJ : Reference guide for dynamic models of HVAC equipment, Atlanta, Georgia: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers, Inc, 1998.

22.

Yu FW , Chan KT : Life cycle analysis of enhanced condenser features for air-cooled chillers serving air-conditioned buildings: Building Environ 2006;41:981-991.

23.

Solar Energy Laboratory : TRNSYS 15: A Transient System Simulation Program (Reference Manual), Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin-Madison Press , 2000.

24.

Yu FW , Chan KT : Optimization of water-cooled chiller system with load-based speed control : Appl Energy 2008;85:931-950.

25.

Braun JE : Methodologies for the Design and Control of Chilled Water Systems . PhD thesis. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin / Madison, 1988.

26.

Air-conditioning & Refrigeration Institute (ARI) : Standard 550/590: Performance Rating of Water Chilling Packages using the Vapor Compression Cycle, Arlington, Virginia: 2003.

27.

Manske KA , Reindl DT , Klein SA : Evaporative condenser control in industrial refrigeration systems : Intl J Refrig 2001;24:676-691.

28.

Love RJ , Cleland, DJ , Merts, I. , Eaton B. : What is the optimum compressor discharge pressure set point for condensers? : EcoLibrium August 2005;24-29.

29.

Wen D. : Cooling tower plume abatement. WM Group Engineers, P.C. , 2003. Available at: www.wmgroupeng.com/Papers/030214-CTPlumeAbate.pdf