Much of what is known concerning human brain injury thresholds is based upon impacts to cadavers and animal models that were used to generate the Wayne State Concussion Tolerance Curve (WSTC) and similar curves. These curves are the foundation for predictive metrics used in standard development as well as helmet design. These curves were based upon a very narrow range of impacts; impacts whose characteristics differ greatly from how the head is impacted in sport. This research examines the uses of time-based curves like the WSTC in the context of understanding mechanisms of brain injury and head protection. Published linear/rotational acceleration magnitude/duration data from Hybrid III laboratory reconstructions of brain injury events were plotted. This research further develops the understanding of injury thresholds in comparison to threshold curves such as the WSTC and Brain Injury Curve Leuven. The data demonstrate the relationships between magnitude and duration of dynamic response on minor traumatic brain injury (mTBI) in sport.
O’Donoghue D. Biomechanics of frontal and occipital head impact injuries: A plane strain simulation of coup and contrecoup contusion. Master’s thesis, University College Dublin, Ireland, 1999.
2.
GurdjianESLissnerHRLatimerFR. Quantitative determination of acceleration and intracranial pressure in experimental head injury: Preliminary report. Neurology1953; 3: 417–423.
3.
GennarelliTAThibaultLE. Biomechanics of acute subdural hematoma. J Trauma1982; 22: 680–686.
4.
Gennareli TA. Head injury in man and experimental animals: Clinical aspects. Acta Neurochir 1983; Suppl. 32: 1–13.
5.
WillingerRRyanGAMcLeanAJ. Mechanisms of brain injury related to mathematical modelling and epidemiological data. Acc Anal Prev1994; 26: 767–779.
6.
GilchristM. Modelling and accident reconstruction of head impact injuries. Key Eng Mat2003; 245–246: 417–429.
7.
SanoKNakamuraNHirakawaK. Correlative studies of dynamics and pathology in whip-lash and head injuries. Scand J Rehab Med1972; 4: 47–54.
8.
Van Lierde C. Biomechanics of head injury – damage criteria for skull and brain lesions. PhD dissertation, K.U. Leuven, Belgium, 2005.
9.
Ono KK, Nakamura M, Kobayashi H, et al. Human head tolerance to sagittal impact reliable estimation deduced from experimental head injury using subhuman primates and human cadaver skulls. SAE paper #801303, 1980.
10.
Versaci J. A review of the severity index. In: Proc. 15th Stapp car crash conference, 1971, SAE paper no. 710881, pp.771–796. Warrendale PA, USA: SAE international.
11.
HardyWNKhalilTBKingAI. Literature review of head injury biomechanics. Int J Impact Eng1994; 15: 561–586.
12.
MeaneyDFSmithDH. Biomechanics of concussion. Clin Sports Med2011; 30: 19–31.
13.
PostAHoshizakiTB. Mechanisms of brain impact injuries and their prediction: a review. Trauma2012; 14: 327–349.
14.
FernandesFAOde SousaRJA. Head injury predictors in sports trauma – a state-of-the-art review. J Eng Med2015; 229: 592–608.
15.
GurdjianESWebsterJELissnerHR. Observations on the mechanism of brain concussion, contusion, and laceration. Surg Gyn Obst1955; 101: 680–690.
16.
GurdjianESHodgsonVRHardyWG. Evaluation of the protective characteristics of helmets in sports. J Trauma1964; 4: 309–324.
17.
GurdjianESRobertsVLThomasLM. Threshold curves of acceleration and intracranial pressure and protective index in experimental head injury. J Trauma1966; 6: 600–604.
18.
Hodgson VR, Thomas LM and Prasad P. Testing the validity and limitations of the severity index. In: Fourteenth Stapp car crash conference, Ann Arbor, MI, 1970, SAE Paper No. 700901. Warrendale PA, USA: SAE international.
19.
StappJPVoluntary human threshold levels. In: GurdjianESLangeWPatrickLM (eds). Impact injury and crash protection, Springfield: Charles C Thomas, 1970, pp. 308–349.
20.
Gadd CW. Use of a weighted impulse criterion for estimating injury hazard. In: Tenth Stapp car crash conference, Holloman Air Force Base, NM, 1966, pp.164–174.
21.
NewmanJAKinematics of head injury. In: YoganandanNPintarFALarsonSJ (eds). Frontiers in head and neck trauma: clinical and biomechanical, Amsterdam, the Netherlands: IOS Press, 1998, pp. 200–214.
22.
Hoshizaki TB, Post A, Kendall M, et al. The relationship between head impact and brain trauma. J Neurol Neurophysiol 2013; 5: 1–8.
23.
WennbergRATatorCH. National Hockey league reported concussions, 1986–87 to 2001–02. Can J Neurol Sci2003; 30: 206–209.
24.
CassonIRVianoDCPowellJW. Twelve years of National Football League concussion data. Sports Health2010; 2: 471–483.
25.
YoganandanNLiJZhangJ. Influence of angular acceleration-deceleration pulse shapes on regional brain strains. J Biomech2008; 41: 2253–2262.
26.
PostAHoshizakiTBGilchristMD. Finite element analysis of the effect of loading curve shape on brain injury predictors. J Biomech2012; 45: 679–683.
27.
Kendall M, Post A, Rousseau P, et al. A comparison of dynamic impact response and brain deformation metrics of head impact reconstructions for three mechanisms of head injury in ice hockey. In: IRCOBI, Dublin, Ireland, 2013, 10–14 September, pp. 430–440. Zurich, Switzerland: International Research Council on the Biomechanics of Injury.
28.
Gennarelli TA, Thibault LE and Ommaya A. Pathophysiological responses to rotational and translational accelerations of the head. SAE paper No 720970, 1972.
29.
HolbournAHS. Mechanics of head injuries. Lancet1943; 242: 438–441.
30.
King AI, Yang KH, Zhang L, et al. Is head injury caused by linear or rotational acceleration. In: IRCOBI conference, Lisbon, Portugal, 2003, pp. 1–12. Zurich, Switzerland: International Research Council on the Biomechanics of Injury.
31.
Forero RuedaMACuiLGilchristMD. Finite element modelling of equestrian helmet impacts exposes the need to address rotational kinematics in future helmet designs. Comput Meth Biomech Biomed Eng2013; 14: 1021–1031.
32.
PostAHoshizakiTB. Rotational acceleration, brain tissue strain, and the relationship to concussion. J Biomech Eng2015; 137. doi: 10.1115/1.4028983.
33.
PellmanEJVianoDCTuckerAM. Concussion in professional football: reconstruction of game impacts and injuries. Neurosurgery2003; 53: 799–814.
34.
Rousseau P. An analysis of dynamic concussion metrics associated with elite ice hockey elbow-to-head and shoulder-to-head collisions. PhD Thesis, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, 2014.
35.
MartlandHS. Punch drunk. JAMA1928; 91: 1103–1107.
36.
GuskiewiczKMMarshallSWBailesJ. Association between recurrent concussion and late-life cognitive impairment in retired professional football players. Neurosurgery2005; 57: 719–726.
37.
OmaluBIDeKoskySTMinisterRL. Chronic traumatic encephalopathy in a National Football League player. Neurosurgery2005; 57: 128–134.
38.
McKeeACSternRANowinskiCJ. The spectrum of disease in chronic traumatic encephalopathy. Brain2013; 136: 43–64.
39.
RowsonSDumaSM. Brain injury prediction: assessing the combined probability of concussion using linear and rotational head acceleration. Ann Biomed Eng2013; 41: 873–882.
40.
SeigmundGPGuskiewiczKMMarshallSW. Laboratory validation of two wearable sensor systems for measuring head impact severity in football players. Ann Biomed Eng2016; 44: 1257–1274.
41.
Auer C, Schonpflug M, Beier G, et al. An analysis of brain injuries in real work pedestrian traffic accidents by computer simulation reconstruction. In: International Society of Biomechanics XVIIIth Congress, Zurich, Switzerland, 8–13 July 2001, pp. 1–3.
42.
O’RiordainKThomasPMPhillipsJP. Reconstruction of real world head injury accidents resulting from falls using multibody dynamics. Clin Biomech2003; 18: 590–600.
43.
DoorlyMCGilchristMD. The use of accident reconstruction for the analysis of traumatic brain injury due to head impacts arising from falls. Comput Meth Biomech Biomed Eng2006; 9: 371–377.
44.
Doorly MC. Investigations into head injury criteria using numerical reconstruction of real life accident cases. PhD thesis, University College Dublin, Ireland, 2007.
45.
YoganandanNPintarFA. Biomechanics of temporo-parietal skull fracture. Clin Biomech2004; 19: 225–239.
46.
Fahlstedt M, Baeck K, Halldin P, et al. Influence of impact velocity and angle in a detailed reconstruction of a bicycle accident. In: IRCOBI, Dublin, Ireland, 12–14 September 2012, pp. 800–812. Zurich, Switzerland: International Research Council on the Biomechanics of Injury.
47.
FréchèdeBMcIntoshAS. Numerical reconstructions of real-life concussive football impacts. Med Sci Sports Exer2009; 41: 390–398.
48.
CriscoJJWilcoxBJBeckwithJG. Head impact exposure in collegiate football players. J Biomech2011; 44: 2673–2678.
49.
RowsonSDumaSMGreenwaldRM. Can helmet design reduce the risk of concussion in football?J Neurosurg2014; 120: 919–922.
50.
ZhangLYangKHKingAI. A proposed injury threshold for mild traumatic brain injury. J Biomech Eng2004; 126: 226–236.
51.
HitosugiMMurayamaHMotozawaY. Biomechanical analysis of acute subdural hematoma resulting from judo. Biomed Res2014; 35: 339–344.
52.
DeckCWillingerR. Improved head injury criteria based on head FE model. Int J Crash2008; 13: 667–679.
53.
Cournoyer J, Post A, Rousseau P, et al. A comparison of brain deformation for head impact resulting in persistent post-concussive syndrome and concussion for elite hockey players. In: The sport concussion conference, Chicago, IL, 11–13 July, 2014.
54.
PostAHoshizakiTBGilchristMD. Traumatic brain injuries: the influence of the direction of impact. Neurosurgery2015; 76: 81–91.
55.
PostAKendallMKoncanD. Characterization of persistent concussive syndrome through injury reconstruction and finite element modelling. J Mech Behav Biomed Mat2015; 41: 325–335.
56.
Kendall M. Characterization of concussive brain injury mechanisms. PhD Thesis, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Canada, 2016.
57.
RousseauPHoshizakiTB. Defining the effective impact mass of elbow and shoulder strikes in ice hockey. Sport Biomech2015; 14: 57–67.
58.
Morrison B III, Cater HL, Wang CCB, et al. A tissue level threshold criterion for living brain developed in an In Vitro model of traumatic mechanical loading. SAE Paper No. 2003-22-00066, 2003.
59.
PostAOeurRAHoshizakiTB. Examination of the relationship of peak linear and angular acceleration to brain deformation metrics in hockey helmet impacts. Comput Meth Biomech Biomed Eng2013; 16: 511–519.
