Quantifying fandom: Identity,romance,and platform preferences on archive of our own

Abstract

Fan scholars typically study single fandoms and gain rich insight into their identities and practices, but without systematic study, it has proven difficult to draw broader conclusions about patterns across fandoms. In this study, we attempt to provide a broad systemic analysis of fandom, using a survey of 4874 fans who use the fan fiction posting site, Archive of Our Own. Through our analysis, we examine the interplay of fan identity with their practices: what type of romantic content fans prefer and which platforms fans prefer to use. We find that both romantic content and platform preference are shaped by fans’ identities, which provides important insights into broad patterns of how identity impacts behavior among fan fiction writers and readers across fandoms.

Keywords

Age fan fiction platforms quantitative methods race

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allington

(2007) “How come most people don’t see it?”: slashing The Lord of the Rings. Social Semiotics 17(1): 43–62.

AO3_Policy_and_Abuse (2024) AO3 terms of service: 2024 update guide: appendix A. Available at: https://archiveofourown.org/works/58283857/chapters/150137587#workskin (accessed 7 November 2024).

Åström

(2010) ‘Let’s get those Winchesters pregnant’: male pregnancy in “Supernatural” fan fiction. Transformative Works and Cultures 4.

Bacon-Smith

(1991) Enterprising Women: Television Fandom and the Creation of Popular Myth. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.

Benjamin

(2019) Race after Technology: Abolitionist Tools for the New Jim Code. 1st ed. Medford, MA: Polity.

Binnie

(2024) Using the Murdoch Mysteries fandom to examine the types of content fans share online. Transformative Works and Cultures 42.

Black

(2006) Language, culture, and identity in online fanfiction. e-Learning and Digital Media 3(2): 170–184.

Brock

Jr (2020) Distributed Blackness: African American Cybercultures. New York: NYU Press.

Busse

(2017) Framing Fan Fiction: Literary and Social Practices in Fan Fiction Communities. Iowa City, IA: University of Iowa Press.

10.

Busse

Lothian

(2008) Bending gender: feminist and (trans) gender discourses in the changing bodies of slash fan fiction. In: Hotz-Davies

Kirchhofer

Leppänen

(eds) Internet Fictions. Cambridge: Cambridge Scholars Publishing, pp. 105–126.

11.

Callis

(2016) Homophobia, heteronormativity, and slash fan fiction. Transformative Works and Cultures 22.

12.

Census.gov (n.d.) Race. Available at: https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/note/US/RHI625222 (accessed 15 May 2024).

13.

Coccia

(2022) Femslash fandom and the cultivation of white queer genealogies: longing for histories, reading for futures. Transformative Works and Cultures 37.

14.

Coker

Viars

(2017) Welcoming the Dark Side? Exploring Whitelash and Actual Space Nazis in TFA Fanfiction. NANO: New American Notes Online 12.

15.

Coppa

(2006) A brief history of media fandom. In: Hellekson

Busse

(eds) Fan Fiction and Fan Communities in the Age of the Internet: New Essays. Jefferson, NC: McFarland, pp. 41–59.

16.

Coppa

(2013) Pop culture, fans, and social media. In: Hunsinger

Senft

(eds) The Social Media Handbook. London: Routledge, pp. 76–92.

17.

Daniels

(2013) Race and racism in internet studies: a review and critique. New Media & Society 15(5): 695–719.

18.

Daniels

(2018) The algorithmic rise of the “alt-right.” Contexts 17(1): 60–65.

19.

Das

Farber

(2020) User-generated online queer media and the politics of queer visibility. Sociology Compass 14(9): e12824.

20.

De Kosnik

(2015) Fifty shades and the archive of women’s culture. Cinema Journal 54(3): 116–125.

21.

De Kosnik

(2016) Rogue Archives: Digital Cultural Memory and Media Fandom. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.

22.

Donlan

(2017) From <mrsniall-horan-until-the-end> to <keepingupwith1d>: online usernames and identity in the One Direction fandom. The Journal of Fandom Studies 5(3): 285–300.

23.

Duggan

(2020) Who writes Harry Potter fan fiction? Passionate detachment, “zooming out,” and fan fiction paratexts on AO3. Transformative Works and Cultures 34.

24.

Dym

Fiesler

(2020) Ethical and privacy considerations for research using online fandom data. Transformative Works and Cultures 33.

25.

Dym

Brubaker

Fiesler

(2018) “Theyre all trans sharon”: authoring gender in video game fan fiction. Game Studies 18(3).

26.

Ehrenreich

Hess

Jacobs

(1992) Beatlemania: girls just want to have fun. In: Lewis

(ed.) The Adoring Audience: Fan Culture and Popular Media. London: Routledge, pp. 84–106.

27.

end-otw-racism (2023) End OTW racism: a call to action. Tumblr. Available at: https://end-otw-racism.tumblr.com/post/716978822501875712/fandom-against-racism-a-manifesto (accessed 19 August 2023).

28.

Fathallah

(2020) Digital fanfic in negotiation: LiveJournal, Archive of Our Own, and the affordances of read–write platforms. Convergence 26(4): 857–873.

29.

Fiesler

Dym

(2020) Moving across lands: online platform migration in fandom communities. Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction, 42, 1–25.

30.

Fiesler

Morrison

Bruckman

(2016) An archive of their own: a case study of feminist HCI and values in design. In: Proceedings of the 2016 CHI conference on human factors in computing systems, San Jose, CA, 7–12 May, pp. 2574–2585. New York: ACM.

31.

Flegel

Roth

(2010) Annihilating love and heterosexuality without women: romance, generic difference, and queer politics in Supernatural fan fiction. Transformative Works and Cultures 4.

32.

Floegel

(2020) “Write the story you want to read”: world-queering through slash fanfiction creation. Journal of Documentation 76(4): 785–805.

33.

Gilliland

(2016) Racebending fandoms and digital futurism. Transformative Works and Cultures 22.

34.

Gonzalez

(2016) Swan Queen, shipping, and boundary regulation in fandom. Transformative Works and Cultures 22.

35.

Green

Jenkins

(1998) Normal female interest in men bonking: selections from the Terra Nostra Underground and Strange Bedfellows. In: Harris

Alexander

(eds) Theorizing Fandom: Fans, Subculture and Identity. Creskill, NJ: Hampton Press, pp. 9–38.

36.

Ben Hagai

Meza

Pinchbeck

, et al. (2024) In: Ryan-Flood

Murphy

(eds) Queering Desire: Lesbians, Gender and Subjectivity. London: Routledge, pp. 155–170.

37.

Hampton

(2015) Bound princes and monogamy warnings: Harry Potter, slash, and queer performance in LiveJournal communities. Transformative Works and Cultures 18.

38.

Harrington

Bielby

(2010) A life course perspective on fandom. International Journal of Cultural Studies 13(5): 429–450.

39.

Highfield

Harrington

Bruns

(2013) Twitter as a Technology for Audiencing and Fandom. Information, Communication & Society 16(3): 315–339.

40.

Howell

(2018) Fandom as Classroom Practice: A Teaching Guide. Iowa City, IA: University of Iowa Press.

41.

James

(2012) Fifty Shades of Grey. New York: Vintage Books.

42.

Jenkins

(1992) Textual Poachers: Television Fans & Participatory Culture. New York: Routledge.

43.

Johnson

(2015) Misogynoir and antiblack racism: what The Walking Dead teaches us about the limits of Speculative Fiction fandom. Journal of Fandom Studies 3(3): 259–275.

44.

Johnson

(2019) Transformative racism: the black body in fan works. Transformative Works and Cultures 29.

45.

Johnson

(2014) Fan fiction metadata creation and utilization within fan fiction archives: three primary models. Transformative Works and Cultures 17.

46.

Jones

(2018) The kids are queer: the rise of post-millennial American queer identification. In: Stewart

(ed.) Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender Americans at Risk: Problems and Solutions, 3 vols. London: Bloomsbury Publishing USA, pp. 205–226.

47.

Kelly

(2019) Fan fiction as feminist citation: lesbian (para)textuality in chainofclovers’s “Done with the Compass, Done with the Chart” (2017). Transformative Works and Cultures 30.

48.

Kennedy

(2024) ‘It’s not your tumblr’: commentary-style tagging practices in fandom communities. Transformative Works and Cultures 42.

49.

Kies

(2011) One true threesome: reconciling canon and fan desire in “Star Trek: Voyager.” Transformative Works and Cultures 8.

50.

Kies

Connor

(eds) (2022) Fandom, the Next Generation. Iowa City, IA: University Of Iowa Press.

51.

Lackner

Lucas

Reid

(2006) Cunning linguists: the bisexual erotics of Words/Silence/Flesh. In: Hellekson

Busse

(eds) Fan Fiction and Fan Communities in the Age of the Internet: New Essays. Jefferson, NC: McFarland, pp. 189–206.

52.

Lammers

Palumbo

(2017) Barriers to fanfiction access: results from a usability inspection of fanfiction.net. Journal of Media Literacy Education 9(2): 76–90.

53.

Largent

Popova

Vist

(2020) Toward some fanons of fan studies. Transformative Works and Cultures 33.

54.

Lopez

(2012) Fan activists and the politics of race in The Last Airbender. International Journal of Cultural Studies 15(5): 431–445.

55.

Lothian

Stanfill

(2021) An archive of whose own? White feminism and racial justice in fan fiction’s digital infrastructure. Transformative Works and Cultures 36.

56.

Lothian

Busse

Reid

(2007) “Yearning void and infinite potential”: online slash fandom as queer female space. English Language Notes 45(2): 103–111.

57.

Lowe

JSA

(2019) Approaching whiteness in slash via Marvel Cinematic Universe’s Sam Wilson. Transformative Works and Cultures 29.

58.

Lowe

JSA

(2020) Kitten think of nothing but murder all day: tumblr text post memes as fandom détournement. In: McCracken

Cho

Stein

, et al. (eds) A Tumblr Book: Platform and Cultures. University of Michigan Press, pp. 181–193. Available at: https://www.fulcrum.org/concern/monographs/x346d608w (accessed 3 October 2022).

59.

McCracken

Cho

Stein

, et al. (eds) (2020) A roundtable discussion about the cultures of fandom on culture with Flourish Klink, Rukmini Pande, Zina Hutton, and Lori Morimoto. In: A Tumblr Book: Platform and Cultures. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, pp. 167–180. Available at: https://www.fulcrum.org/concern/monographs/x346d608w (accessed 3 October 2022).

60.

Marks

(2023) Fan perspectives of queer representation in DC’s Legends of Tomorrow on Tumblr and AO3. Transformative Works and Cultures 40.

61.

Martin

Jr (2025) Fandom for Us, by Us: The Pleasures and Practices of Black Audiences. New York: NYU Press.

62.

Massanari

(2017) #Gamergate and The Fappening: how Reddit’s algorithm, governance, and culture support toxic technocultures. New Media & Society 19(3): 329–346.

63.

Matamoros-Fernández

(2018) Inciting anger through Facebook reactions in Belgium: the use of emoji and related vernacular expressions in racist discourse. First Monday, 1 September. DOI: 10.5210/fm.v23i9.9405.

64.

Navar-Gill

Stanfill

(2018) “We shouldn’t have to trend to make you listen”: queer fan hashtag campaigns as production interventions. Journal of Film and Video 70(3–4): 85–100.

65.

Ocone

(2024) Fandom and the ethics of world-making: building spaces for belonging on BobaBoard. Transformative Works and Cultures 42.

66.

Pande

(2018) Squee from the Margins: Fandom and Race. 1st ed. Iowa City, IA: University Of Iowa Press.

67.

Pande

Moitra

(2017) ‘Yes, the Evil Queen is Latina!’: racial dynamics of online femslash fandoms. Transformative Works and Cultures 24.

68.

Penley

(1997) NASA/Trek: Popular Science and Sex in America. New York: Verso.

69.

Petersen-Reed

(2019) Fanfiction as performative criticism: Harry Potter racebending. Journal of Creative Writing Studies 4(1).

70.

Raw

(2019) Normalizing disability: Tagging and disability identity construction through Marvel cinematic universe fanfiction. Canadian Journal of Disability Studies 8(2): 185–200.

71.

Reiner

(dir.) (1990) Misery. Castle Rock Entertainment.

72.

Rouse

(2021) Fan fiction comments and their relationship to classroom learning. Transformative Works and Cultures 35.

73.

Rouse

Stanfill

(2023) Fan Demographics on Archive of Our Own. Flow: A Critical Forum on Media and Culture. Over*Flow. https://www.flowjournal.org/2023/02/fan-demographics-on-ao3/

74.

Rouse

Condis

Stanfill

(2024) Making fandom great again: silencing discussions of racism in reactionary and transformative fandoms. Popular Communication 22(2): 67–79.

75.

Russ

(1985) Pornography by women, for women, with love. In: Magic Mommas, Trembling Sisters, Puritans & Perverts. Trumansburg, NY: The Crossing Press, pp. 79–100.

76.

Russo

(2017) The queer politics of femslash. In: Click

Scott

(eds) The Routledge Companion to Media Fandom. New York: Routledge, pp. 164–155.

77.

Stanfill

(2020a) Introduction: the reactionary in the fan and the fan in the reactionary. Television & New Media 21(2): 123–134.

78.

Stanfill

(2020b) Straight (White) Women Writing about Men Bonking? Complicating our Understanding of Gender and Sexuality in Fandom. In: Goins MN, McAlister JF, and Alexander BK (eds) The Routledge Handbook of Gender and Communication. London New York: Routledge, pp. 446–458.

79.

Stanfill

(2024) The platformization of fandom and its discontents: understanding platform harms through the archive of our own. International Journal of Communication 18: 4209–4226.

80.

Taylor

(2015) Investigating fans of fictional texts: fan identity salience, empathy, and transportation. Psychology of Popular Media Culture 4(2): 172–187.

81.

Thomas

(2006) Fan fiction online: engagement, critical response and affective play through writing. The Australian Journal of Language and Literacy 29(3): 226–239.

82.

Thomas

(2019) The Dark Fantastic: Race and the Imagination from Harry Potter to the Hunger Games. New York: New York University Press. Available at: https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.18574/nyu/9781479864195.001.0001/html (accessed 30 October 2024).

83.

toastystats (destinationtoast) (2019) [Fandom stats] Shipping on Wattpad vs. AO3 and FFN. Available at: https://archiveofourown.org/works/18721183 (accessed 13 May 2024).

84.

Tosenberger

(2008a) Homosexuality at the online Hogwarts: Harry Potter slash fanfiction. Children’s Literature 36: 185–207.

85.

Tosenberger

(2008b) ‘The epic love story of Sam and Dean’: “Supernatural,” queer readings, and the romance of incestuous fan fiction. Transformative Works and Cultures 1.

86.

Waggoner

(2018) Bury your gays and social media fan response: television, LGBTQ representation, and communitarian ethics. Journal of Homosexuality 65(13): 1877–1891.

87.

Walls-Thumma

(2024) The fading of the elves: techno-volunteerism and the disappearance of Tolkien fan fiction archives. Transformative Works and Cultures 42.

88.

Warner

(2017) (Black Female) fans strike back: the emergence of the Iris West Defense Squad. In: Click

Scott

(eds) The Routledge Companion to Media Fandom. London: Routledge, pp. 253–261.

89.

Wei

(2014) Iron Man in Chinese boys’ love fandom: a story untold. Transformative Works and Cultures 17.

90.

Wood

Baughman

(2012) Glee fandom and Twitter: something new, or more of the same old thing? communication Studies 63(3): 328–344.