A theory of criminal punishment that introduces the organization of knowledge production and of political and legal decision-making as central concepts (Savelsberg, 1994a) is further developed. This article first explicates the general theoretical model. Second, the comparative perspective is enhanced as a previous comparison between the Federal Republic of Germany (FRG) and the United States (US) is extended to include the experience of state socialist systems. Three distinct empirical patterns of punishment dynamics are identified. Each of them is associated with a distinct type of social organization: decentralized domination - personalistic; decentralized domination - bureaucratic; and monopolized domination - bureaucratic. An analysis of the cases of Poland, building on earlier work by Greenberg (1980), and the German Democratic Republic reveals that the organization of domination and knowledge production are crucial to the understanding of criminal punishment under conditions of totalitarianism as well. Yet, bureaucratization does not necessarily lead to stability in punishment trends as the US-West German comparison had suggested. Bureaucratization in combination with monopolization of decision-making power is likely to result in rather dynamic trends. Further, punishment under conditions of totalitarianism appears to follow immediate and strategic political rationales. Politics of punishment in such contexts also do not face the translation problems that haunt the application of political motives to control practices in systems with decentralized power structures.
Beckett, Katherine
(1997) Making crime pay: law and order in contemporary American politics. New York: Oxford University Press.
2.
Beirne, Piers
and Hunt, Alan (1988) `Law and the constitution of Soviet society: the case of Comrade Lenin', Law and Society Review22: 575-614.
3.
Bentham, Jeremy
(1780/1948) An introduction to the principles of morals and legislation. New York: Hafner.
4.
Black, Donald
(1976) The behavior of law. Orlando: Academic Press.
5.
Black, Donald
(1989) Sociological justice. New York: Oxford University Press.
6.
Box, Steven
and Hale, Chris (1982) `Economic crisis and the rising prisoner population in England and Wales', Crime and Social Justice17: 20-35.
7.
Boyle, Elizabeth Heger
(1998) `Political frames and legal activity: the case of nuclear power in four countries', Law and Society Review32: 141-174.
8.
Brustein, William
(1996) The logic of evil: the social origins of the Nazi Party, 1925-1933. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
9.
Calahan, Margaret Werner
(1986) Historical correction statistics in the United States, 1850-1984. Washington, DC: US Department of Justice.
10.
Cartwright, B.C.
and Schwartz, R.D. (1973) `The invocation of legal norms: an empirical investigation of Durkheim and Weber', American Sociological Review38: 340-354.
11.
Chiricos, Theodore G.
and DeLone, Miriam A. (1992) `Labor surplus and punishment: a review and assessment of theory and evidence', Social Problems39: 421-446.
12.
Coser, Lewis A.
(1968) `Sociology of knowledge', in David L. Sills (ed.) International encyclopedia of the social sciences, pp. 428-435. New York: Macmillan and the Free Press.
13.
Croan, Melvin
(1992) `Germany and Eastern Europe', in Joseph Held (ed.) The Columbia history of Eastern Europe in the twentieth century, pp. 345-393. New York: Columbia University Press.
14.
Doyle, Daniel P.
and Luckenbill, David F. (1991) `Mobilizing law in response to collective problems: a test of Black's theory of law', Law and Society Review25: 103-116.
15.
Durkheim, Emile
(1893) De la division du travail social. Paris: Alcan.
Fishbein, M.
and Ajzen, I. (1975) Belief, attitude, intention and behavior: an introduction to theory and research. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
18.
Foucault, Michel
(1979) Discipline and punish: the birth of the prison. New York: Randon House.
19.
Garland, David
(1985a) `The criminal and his sentence: a critical account of the formation of criminology at the end of the nineteenth century', British Journal of Criminology25: 109-137.
20.
Garland, David
(1985b) Punishment and welfare: a history of penal strategies. Aldershot: Gower.
21.
Garland, David
(1990) Punishment and modern society: a study in social theory. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
22.
Gibson, J.L.
(1978) `Judges' role orientations, attitudes, and decisions: an interactive model', The American Political Science Review72: 911-924.
23.
Giddens, Anthony
(1976) New rules of sociological method: a positive critique of interpretive sociologies. London: Hutchinson.
24.
Goldhagen, Daniel
(1996) Hitler's willing executioners: ordinary Germans and the Holocaust. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
25.
Gottfredson, Michael R.
and Hindelang, Michael J. (1979) `A study of “The behavior of law” ', American Sociological Review44: 3-18.
26.
Greenberg, David F.
(1977) `The dynamics of oscillatory punishment processes', The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology68: 643-651.
27.
Greenberg, David F.
(1980) `Penal sanctions in Poland: a test of alternative models', Social Problems28: 194-204.
28.
Greenberg, David F.
(forthcoming) `Punishment, division of labor, and social solidarity', in Advances in Criminological Theory.
29.
Greenberg, David F.
and Humphries, Drew (1980) `The cooptation of fixed sentencing reform', Crime and Delinquency26: 206-225.
30.
Greenberg, M.S.
and Ruback, R.B. (1982) Social psychology of the criminal justice system. Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole.
31.
Heimer, Karen
(1997) `Socioeconomic status, subcultural definitions, and violent delinquency', Social Forces74: 799-833.
32.
Hembroff, Larry A.
(1987) `The seriousness of acts and social context: a test of Black's theory of the behavior of law', American Journal of Sociology93: 322-347.
33.
Huntington, S.P.
(1991) The Third Wave: democratization in the late twentieth century. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.
34.
Inverarity, James
and McCarthy, Daniel (1988) `Punishment and social structure revisited: unemployment and imprisonment in the United States, 1948-1984', The Sociological Quarterly29: 263-279.
35.
Jacobs, David
and Helms, Ronald E. (1996) `Toward a political model of incarceration: a Time-Series examination of multiple explanations for prison admission rates', American Journal of Sociology102: 323-357.
36.
Jankovic, Ivan
(1977) `Labor markets and imprisonment', Crime and Social Justice8: 17-31.
37.
Knoke, David
and Pappi, Franz Urban (1991) `Organizational action sets in the US and German labor policy domains', American Sociological Review56: 506-523.
38.
Kruttschnitt, Candace
(1980-1) `Social status and sentences of female offenders', Law and Society Review15: 247-265.
39.
Los, Maria
(1988) Communist ideology, law, and crime. New York: St Martin's Press.
40.
Luhmann, Niklas
(1977) `Arbeitsteilung und Moral: Durkheims Theorie', in E. Durkheim Über die Teilung der sozialen Arbeit, pp. 17-35. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.
41.
Mannheim, Karl
(1984) Konservatismus: Ein Beitrag zur Soziologie des Wissens. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.
42.
Markovits, Inga
(1989) `Law and Glasnost: some thoughts about the future of judicial review under socialism', Law and Society Review23: 399-448.
43.
Markovits, Inga
(1993) Die Abwicklung: Ein Tagebuch zum Ende der DDR-Justiz. München: C.H. Beck.
44.
Marx, Karl
(1871/1969) `The Civil War in France', in Karl Marx and Frederick Engels: selected works, Vol. 2. Moscow: Progress.
45.
Melossi, Dario
(1985) `Punishment and social action: changing vocabularies of punitive motive within a political business cycle', Current Perspectives in Social Theory6: 169-197.
46.
Melossi, Dario
(1993) `Gazette of morality and social whip: punishment, hegemony and the case of the USA, 1970-92', Social and Legal Studies2: 259-279.
47.
Myers, Martha A.
(1980) `Predicting the behavior of law: a test of two models', Law and Society Review14: 835-857.
48.
Oswald, Margit
(1994) Psychologie des richterlichen Strafens. Stuttgart: Enke.
49.
Pampel, Fred C.
, Williamson, John B. and Stryker, Robin (1990) `Class context and pension response to demographic structure in advanced industrial democracies', Social Problems37: 535-550.
Roth, Gunther
(1987) Politische Herrschaft und persönliche Freiheit: Heidelberger Max-Weber-Vorlesungen 1983. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.
52.
Rusche, Georg
and Kirchheimer, Otto (1939) Punishment and social structure. New York: Columbia University Press.
53.
Savelsberg, Joachim
(1994a) `Knowledge, domination, and criminal punishment', American Journal of Sociology99: 911-943.
54.
Savelsberg, Joachim
(with contributions by Peter Brühl) (1994b) Constructing white-collar crime: rationalities, communication, power. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
55.
Savelsberg, Joachim
(1995) `Crime, inequality, and justice in Eastern Europe: anomie, domination, and revolutionary change', in John Hagan and Ruth D. Peterson (eds) Crime and inequality, pp. 206-224. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
56.
Scheingold, Stuart
(1997) `Criminology and the politicization of crime and punishment', in Stuart Scheingold (ed.) Politics, crime control, and culture. Brookfield, VT: Ashgate: The International Library of Criminology, Criminal Justice, and Penology.
57.
Scheppele, Kim Lane
(1996) `The history of normalcy: rethinking legal autonomy and the relative dependence of law at the end of the Soviet Empire', Law and Society Review30: 627-650.
58.
Schwartz, Richard D.
and Miller, James C. (1965) `Legal evolution and societal complexity', American Journal of Sociology70: 159-169.
59.
Seron, Carroll
and Munger, Frank (1996) `Law and inequality: race, gender... and, of course, class', Annual Review of Sociology22: 187-212.
60.
Sewell, William H.
(1992) `A theory of structure: duality, agency, and transformation', American Journal of Sociology98: 1-29.
61.
Simon, Jonathan
(1997) `Governing through crime', paper presented at the Annual Meetings of the American Sociological Association, Toronto.
62.
Smelser, Neil
(1998) `Presidential address to the American Sociological Association', American Sociological Review63/1: 1-16.
63.
Solomon, Peter H.
(1985) `Local political power and Soviet criminal justice, 1922-41', Soviet Studies37: 305-329.
64.
Spitzer, Steven
(1974-5) `Punishment and social organization: a study of Durkheim's theory of penal evolution', Law and Society Review9: 613-637.
Stryker, Robin
(1994) `Rules, resources, and legitimacy processes: some implications for social conflict, order, and change', American Journal of Sociology99: 847-910.
69.
Sutton, John
(1996) `Change, welfare politics, and imprisonment: evidence from five common-law countries, 1955-1985', revised paper originally presented at the 1994 Meetings of the International Sociological Association, Bielefeld, FRG.
70.
Tyler, Tom R.
and Boeckmann, Robert (1997) `Three strikes and you are out, but why?: the psychology of public support for punishing rule breakers', Law and Society Review31: 237-265.
71.
US Department of Justice
(1990) Sourcebook of criminal justice statistics. Washington, DC: Department of Justice.
72.
US Department of Justice
(1992) `Prisoners in 1991', Bureau of Justice Statistics Bulletin. Washington: Department of Justice.
73.
Walmsley, Roy
(1996) Prison systems in Central and Eastern Europe: progress, problems, and the international standards. Helsinki: European Institute for Crime Prevention and Control.
74.
Weber, Max
(1978) Economy and society. Berkeley: University of California Press.
75.
Werkentin, F.
(1995) Politische Strafjustiz in der Ära Ulbricht. Berlin: Links Verlag.
76.
Zimring, Franklin E.
and Hawkins, Gordon (1991) The scale of imprisonment. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
