To offer mythic appeal or ritual value, news must be framed not only to make certain
facts and interpretations salient but also to resonate with what writers and readers
take to be real and important matters of life. Paralleling salience as an
effect of selectivity in fact-gathering and emphasis in news-writing, this study
argues that resonance is an effect of those same practices when
accomplished with eloquence. Continuing coverage of a particular news event provides
the opportunity to study the recurring narrative structures and rhetorical
strategies that just seemed to work in telling the story. That story, a
poignant death and its aftermath, illustrates three resources for crafting resonance
- all of which point to an ultimate source of resonance in the complexities of human desire.
Bhabha, Homi K.
(1983)
‘The Other Question - Homi K. Bhabha Reconsiders the Stereotype
and Colonial Discourse’
, Screen24(6):
18-36
.
2.
Binder, Amy
(1993)
‘Constructing Racial Rhetoric: Media Depictions of Harm in Heavy
Metal and Rap Music’
, American Sociological Review58(Dec.):
753-767
.
3.
Bird, S. Elizabeth
(2003) The Audience in Everyday Life.
New York: Routledge
.
4.
Bird, S. Elizabeth
and
Robert W. Dardenne
(1988) ‘Myth, Chronicle and Story: Exploring the
Narrative Qualities of News’, in
James W. Carey
(ed.) Media, Myths, and Narratives: Television and the Press.
Newbury Park, CA: Sage
.
5.
Boston Globe (1992)
‘Japanese Mourners Call for US Gun Ban’
(27 Oct.):
1
.
6.
Cheakalos, Christina
(1993)
‘Culture Clash Plays Out in Louisiana’
, Atlanta Constitution (7 Jan.):
A3
.
7.
Chicago Tribune (1993)
‘Just a Normal Baton Rouge Killing’
(25 May):
A18
.
8.
Entman, Robert M.
(1993)
‘Framing: Toward Clarification of a Fractured Paradigm’
, Journal of Communication43(4):
51-68
.
9.
Frederick, Howard M.
(1993) Global Communication & International
Relations.
Belmont, CA: Wadsworth
.
10.
Haymaker, Holley G.
and
Richard Haymaker
(1992)
‘Another Magnum, Another Victim’
, The New York Times (31 Oct.):
A21
.
11.
Lule, Jack
(2001) Daily News, Eternal Stories: The Mythological Role of
Journalism.
New York: The Guilford Press
.
12.
Mann, Thomas
(1960) ‘The Art of the
Novel’, in
Haskell M. Block
and
Herman Salinger
(eds) The Creative Vision: Modern European Writers on Their Art.
Grove Press: New York
.
13.
Margolick, David
(1994)
‘Lamenting Lost Lives, Lost Dreams’The New York Times (29 Mar.):
B7
.
14.
Moffat, Susan
and
Jesus Sanchez
(1994)
‘U.S. Rushes to Reassure Japan after Carjacking’
, Los Angeles Times (29 Mar.):
A1
.
15.
Muecke, D. C.
(1969) The Compass of Irony.
London: Methuen
.
16.
Nicholas, Peter
(1992)
‘Killing Hurts Nation’s Image’
, New Orleans Times Picayune (21 Oct.):
B1, B2
.
17.
Nickerson, Colin
(1993)
‘Japanese Saddened, Not Shocked at US Verdict’
, Boston Globe (25 May):
1, 13
.
18.
Nossiter, Adam
(1992)
‘Student’s Trust in People Proved Fatal’
, The New York Times (23 Oct.):
A12
.
19.
Prestowitz, Clyde
(1988) Trading Places: How We Allowed Japan to Take the
Lead.
New York: Basic Books
.
20.
Price, Richard
and
Jonathan T. Lovitt
(1994)
‘Murder of Two Students Stuns Japan’
, USA Today (29 Mar.):
1A
.
21.
Putnam, Hilary
(1981) Reason, Truth and History.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
22.
Reese, Stephen D.
,
Oscar H. Gandy Jr
and
August E. Grant
(2001) Framing Public Life: Perspectives on Media and Our
Understanding of the Social World.
Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
.
23.
Reid, T. R.
(1992)
‘Japanese Image of U.S. Affirmed in Student’s Death’
, The Washington Post (20 Oct.):
A1, A32
.
24.
Reid, T. R.
(1993a)
‘Japanese Media Disparage Acquittal in “Freeze
Case” ’
, The Washington Post (25 May):
A14
.
25.
Reid, T. R.
(1993b)
‘Parents of Slain Japanese Student Mulling Civil Suit’
, The Washington Post (26 May):
A22
.
26.
Rofe, John
(1994)
‘Japanese Decry Tragedy in L.A.’
, San Diego Union-Tribune (29 Mar.):
A3
.
27.
Rose, Christopher
(1992)
‘One Cloudy Night on a Quiet Street’
, New Orleans Times Picayune (20 Oct.):
E1, E10
28.
Ryan, Charlotte
,
Kevin M. Carragee
and
William Meinhofer
(2001)
‘Theory into Practice: Framing, the News Media, and Collective Action’
, Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media45:
175-182
.
29.
Sanchez, Sandra
(1994)
‘Violence in USA Again Stuns Japan’
, USA Today (28 Mar.):
6A
.
30.
San Francisco Chronicle (1993)
‘The Heavy Cost of Guns at Home’
(25 May):
A18
.
31.
Schudson, Michael
(1989)
‘How Culture Works: Perspectives from Media Studies on the
Efficacy of Symbols’
, Theory and Society18:
153-180
.
32.
Schwartz, Tony
(1973) The Responsive Chord.
Garden City: Anchor Press/Doubleday
.
33.
Siegle, Robert
(1986) The Politics of Reflexivity: Narrative and the
Constitutive Poetics of Culture.
Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press
.
34.
Snow, David A.
and
Robert D. Benford
(1988)
‘Ideology, Frame Resonance, and Participant Mobilization’
, International Social Movement Research1:
197-217
.
35.
Snow, David A.
and
Robert D. Benford
(1992) ‘Master Frames and Cycles of
Protest’, in
Aldon D. Morris
and
Carol McClurg Mueller
(eds) Frontiers in Social Movement Theory, pp.
133-155.
New Haven, CT: Yale University Press
.
36.
Snow, David A.
,
E. Burke Rochford Jr
,
Steven K. Worden
and
Robert D. Benford
(1986)
‘Frame Alignment Processes, Micromobilization, Movement and Participation’
, American Sociological Review51:
464-481
.
37.
The New York Times (1992)
‘Grief Spans Sea as Gun Ends a Life Mistakenly’
(21 Oct.):
A1
.
38.
The New York Times (1993a)
‘Japan Watches Intently as Slaying Trial Begins’
(19 May):
A12
.
39.
The New York Times (1993b)
‘Acquittal in Doorstep Killing of Japanese Student’
(24 May):
A1, A11
.
40.
The New York Times (1993c)
‘Gun Crazy’
(25 May):
A22
.
41.
Tucher, Andie
(1994) Froth & Scum: Truth, Beauty, Goodness, and the
Ax Murder in America’s First Mass Medium.
Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press
.
42.
Tucker, Cynthia
(1993)
‘A Tragedy Shoots Down Gun Lobby’s Myths’
, Atlanta Journal and Atlanta Constitution (30 May):
D5
.
43.
Turner, Victor
(1984) ‘Liminality and the Performance
Genres’, in
John J. MacAloon
(ed.) Rite, Drama Festival, Spectacle, pp.
19-41.
Philadelphia: Institute for the Study of Human Issues
.
44.
Vincent, Richard C.
,
Bryan K. Crow
and
Dennis K. Davis
(1989)
‘When Technology Fails: The Drama of Airline Crashes in Network
Television News’
, Journalism Monographs117
.
45.
Watanabe, Teresa
(1993)
‘Japanese Angered by U.S. Acquittal of Student’s Killer’
, Los Angeles Times (25 May):
A4
.
46.
White, Hayden
(1973) Metahistory: The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth
Century Europe.
Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press
.
47.
Williams, Rhys H.
and
Timothy J. Kubal
(1999)
‘Movement Frames and the Cultural Environment: Resonance,
Failure, and the Boundaries of the Legitimate’
, Research in Social Movements, Conflict and Change21:
225-248
.
