Keeping track: An intra-UK comparison of orthodontic commissioning and treatment outcome assessments

Abstract

Introduction:

Across the United Kingdom (UK), National Health Service (NHS) orthodontic treatment is commissioned differently across the devolved nations. There is a relative paucity in the literature describing the way in which the orthodontic services in each country are commissioned and treatment outcomes measured.

Objective:

To highlight the differences in the following: commissioning of primary care orthodontic services across the UK; assessment of treatment outcomes; and the potential impacts these differences have on contractors, performers and patient care.

Materials and methods:

Data were collected using an online mixed-methods approach. Systematic content analysis was used to extract the required information from the websites and guidance documents of orthodontic service providers, which was then catalogued and verified electronically by senior dental advisors in the four devolved UK nations.

Results:

The Index of Orthodontic Treatment Need (IOTN) is a mandatory needs assessment tool used across all four nations, with an agreed minimum threshold of a dental health component (DHC) score of 3 and an aesthetic component (AC) score of 6 for NHS treatment. While the peer assessment rating (PAR) is the most utilised method of assessing post-treatment outcomes, it is applied differently by each country.

Conclusion:

While NHS orthodontic services across the UK share mutual elements of service delivery, there are significant differences in the prior approval process and assessment of treatment outcomes. More research is required to assess the economic feasibility of orthodontic treatment from the associated treatment outcomes.

Keywords

orthodontics commissioning treatment outcomes Index of Orthodontic Treatment Need peer-assessment rating primary care

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Baker

Mat

Robinson

(2010) What psychosocial factors influence adolescents’ oral health? Journal of Dental Research 89: 1230–1235.

Birkeland

Furevik

Bee

Wisth

(1997) Evaluation of treatment and post-treatment changes by the PAR Index. European Journal of Orthodontics 19: 279–288.

British Dental Association (BDA) (2021) Orthodontic tendering: hints and tips. Available at: https://www.bda.org/advice/Pages/Orthodontic-tendering-hints-and-tips.aspx (accessed January 2021).

British Dental Journal (BDJ) in Practice (2020) NHS Commissioning ‘very concerning’. BDJ In Practice 33: 7.

British Orthodontic Society (BOS) (2022) The Peer Assessment Rating (PAR) index. Available at: https://www.sdmag.co.uk/2012/07/13/pursuing_an_opportunity/ (accessed January 2021).

Brook

Shaw

(1989) The development of an index of orthodontic treatment priority. European Journal of Orthodontics 11: 300–320.

Community Health Council (2020) Orthodontic services in Wales: Hearing about the experiences of young people. Available at: https://cwmtafmorgannwgchc.nhs.wales/files/reports/orthodontic-services-in-wales-chc-national-report/ (accessed February 2022).

Curry

Nembhard

Bradley

(2009) Qualitative and mixed methods provide unique contributions to outcomes research. Circulation 119: 1442–1452.

Deans

Playle

Durning

Richmond

(2009) An exploratory study of the cost-effectiveness of orthodontic care in seven European countries. European Journal of Orthodontics 31: 90–94.

10.

Deeming

Cobourne

(2021) Making sense in a complex world of orthodontic commissioning. Journal of Orthodontics 48: 455–457.

11.

De Oliveira

(2003) The planning, contracting and monitoring of orthodontic services, and the use of the ION index: a survey of consultants in dental public health in the United Kingdom. British Dental Journal 195: 704–706.

12.

Department of Health (2013) Strategic Commissioning of Primary Care Orthodontic Services. Available at:https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukgwa/20130123210414/http://www.dh.gov.uk/en/Publicationsandstatistics/Publications/PublicationsPolicyAndGuidance/DH_4139176 (accessed February 2022).

13.

Department of Health, Social Services and Public Safety (DHSSPS) (2014) The Health & Personal Social Services General Dental Services (Amendment) Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2014. Available at:https://www.legislation.gov.uk/nisr/2014/3/pdfs/nisrod_20140003_en.pdf (accessed March 2022).

14.

Donaldson

(2014) Devolution and dentistry in Northern Ireland. Faculty Dental Journal 5: 108–109.

15.

Fox

Daniels

Gilgrass

(2002) A comparison of the Index of Complexity Outcome and Need (ICON) with the Peer Assessment Rating (PAR) and the Index of Orthodontic Treatment Need (IOTN). British Dental Journal 193: 225–230.

16.

Giles

Rizvi

Gray

Barker

Spencer

(2019) To accept, or not to accept? A service evaluation to appraise complexity assessment of orthodontic patients referred into a secondary care setting. British Dental Journal 226: 963–966.

17.

Green

(2016) An Overview of the Peer Assessment Rating (PAR) Index for Primary Dental Care Practitioners. Primary Dental Journal 5: 28–37.

18.

Health and Social Care (Northern Ireland) (HSCNI) (2016). General Dental Services Regulations (Northern Ireland) 1993. Available at: https://hscbusiness.hscni.net/pdf/2016%20GDS%20Regulations%20(NI)%201993.pdf (accessed January 2021).

19.

Health and Social Care (Northern Ireland) (HSCNI) (2018a) General Dental Services Regulations (Northern Ireland). Available at:http://www.hscbusiness.hscni.net/pdf/2018%20GDS%20Regulations%20(NI)%6201993.pdf (accessed January 2021).

20.

Health and Social care (Northern Ireland) (HSCNI) (2018b) Statement of Dental Remuneration (Northern Ireland). Available at: https://hscbusiness.hscni.net/pdf/Corrected%20-%20Statement%20of%20Dental%20Remuneration%202018-19.pdf (accessed January 2021).

21.

Jawad

Bates

Hodge

(2015) Who needs orthodontic treatment? Who gets it? And who wants it? British Dental Journal 218: 99–103.

22.

Kelly

(2018) NHS contractual obligations and communicating with the NHSBSA. NHSBSA. Available at: https://www.bos.org.uk/Portals/0/Public/docs/Events/Brian%20Kelly%20NHSBSA%20TGG%202018.pdf (accessed January 2021).

23.

Krippendorff

(2012) Content Analysis: An introduction to its methodology. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.

24.

Lewis

BRK

Plunkett

Hickman

Sandham

(2017) Re-shaping NHS orthodontic provision–the North Wales experience. British Dental Journal 222: 803–808.

25.

Mclntyre

(2012) Pursuing an Opportunity. Available at: https://www.sdmag.co.uk/2012/07/13/pursuing_an_opportunity/ (accessed October 2021).

26.

McMillan

(2000) The Microscope and the Moving Target: The Challenge of Applying Content Analysis to the World Wide Web. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 77: 80–98.

27.

Meade

Millett

(2013) An audit of orthodontic treatment eligibility among new patients referred to a Health Service Executive orthodontic referral centre. Journal of the Irish Dental Association 58: 246–251.

28.

NHSBSA (2018) NHS Dental Services Clinical Orthodontic Monitoring. Available at: https://www.nhsbsa.nhs.uk/sites/default/files/2018-10/Example%20Provider%20Report.pdf (accessed March 2022).

29.

NHS Dental Services (2017) Completion of form guidance–FP17O. Available at: https://www.nhsbsa.nhs.uk/sites/default/files/2017-02/Completion_of_form_guidance_-_FP170_-_England_%28V2%29_-_04.2016.pdf (accessed February 2022).

30.

NHS Digital (2022) NHS Dental Statistics: Annex 4 - Publication Guidance. Available at: https://digital.nhs.uk/data-and-information/publications/statistical/nhs-dental-statistics/nhs-dental-statistics-annex-4-guidance#orthodontics (accessed February 2022).

31.

NHS England (2013) Transitional commissioning of primary care orthodontic services. Available at: https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/orth-som-nov.pdf (accessed January 2021).

32.

NHS England (2015a) Introductory Guide to Commissioning Dental Specialties. Available at https://www.england.nhs.uk/commissioning/wp-content/uploads/sites/12/2015/09/intro-guide-comms-dent-specl.pdf (accessed January 2021)

33.

NHS England (2015b) Guides for commissioning dental specialties: orthodontics. Available at: https://www.england.nhs.uk/commissioning/wp-content/uploads/sites/12/2015/09/guid-comms-orthodontics.pdf (accessed January 2021).

34.

NHS England (2018a) Assessment of Orthodontic treatment need and level of service provision for the resident population of Cheshire and Merseyside 2018. Available at: https://www.england.nhs.uk/north/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2018/07/CM-Orthodontic-Needs-Assessment-April-2018.pdf (accessed February 2022).

35.

NHS England (2018b) Invitation to Tender Document. Available at: https://www.england.nhs.uk/south-east/wp-content/uploads/sites/45/2018/04/Invitation-to-Tender-for-Orthodontic-Services-in-the-south.pdf (accessed February 2022).

36.

NHS England (2018c) Personal Dental Services Orthodontic Service Specification. Available at: https://www.england.nhs.uk/south/wp-content/uploads/sites/6/2019/10/nhs-orthodontic-services-specification.pdf (accessed January 2021).

37.

NHS England (2019a) Essex Orthodontic Needs Assessment 2013. Available at: https://www.england.nhs.uk/mids-east/wp-content/uploads/sites/7/2019/04/Essex-Orthodontic-Needs-Assessment-2013-verson-6-1.pdf (accessed February 2022).

38.

NHS England (2019b) Personal Dental Services Orthodontic Service Specification. Available at: https://www.england.nhs.uk/south/wp-content/uploads/sites/6/2019/10/nhs-orthodontic-services-specification.pdf (accessed February 2022).

39.

NHS England (2019c) Personal Dental Services – Orthodontic Service. Available at: https://www.sehd.scot.nhs.uk/pca/PCA2011%28D%2906.pdf (accessed January 2021).

40.

NHS England (2021) Data Submission to the Review Body on Doctors’ and Dentists’ Remuneration – March 2021. Available at: https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/B0298-data-submission-to-the-review-body-on-doctors-and-dentists-remuneration.pdf (accessed February 2022).

41.

NHS Scotland (2010) General Dental Services. Regulations. Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ssi/2010/208/regulation/29/made (accessed January 2021).

42.

NHS Scotland (2021) National Service Scotland – Prior Approval. Available at: https://www.nss.nhs.scot/dental-services/allowances-claims-and-payments/get-prior-approval-for-treatments/ (accessed January 2021).

43.

Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency (NISRA) (2020) General Dental Statistics for Northern Ireland Annual Statistics 2019/20. Available at: https://hscbusiness.hscni.net/pdf/General%20Dental%20Statistics%20Publication%20201920%20-%20Revised.pdf (accessed March 2022).

44.

Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency (NISRA) (2021) General Dental Statistics for Northern Ireland Annual Statistics 2020/21. Available at: https://hscbusiness.hscni.net/pdf/General%20Dental%20Statistics%20Publication%202020-21.pdf (accessed March 2022).

45.

Office for National Statistics (2011) Sub-national populations for England. Available at: www.ons.gov.uk/ons/rel/snpp/sub-national-population-projections/Interim-2011-based/index.html (accessed February 2022).

46.

Padilla

(2014) Devolution and dentistry in Scotland. Faculty Dental Journal 5: 114–117.

47.

Phillips

Thompson

(1997) What is cost-effectiveness? London, England: Hayward Medical Communications.

48.

Price

(2016) Socioeconomic position and the National Health Service orthodontic service. PhD Thesis, University of Manchester. Available at:https://www.research.manchester.ac.uk/portal/files/54581425/FULLTEXT.PDF (accessed October 2021).

49.

Price

Whittaker

Birch

Brocklehurst

Tickle

(2017) Socioeconomic disparities in orthodontic treatment outcomes and expenditure on orthodontics in England’s state-funded National Health Service: a retrospective observational study. BMC Oral Health 17: 123.

50.

Quach

Popat

Karki

Playle

Richmond

(2019) Factors influencing orthodontic treatment outcome in South East Wales and implications for service commissioning. Journal of Orthodontics 48: 311–322.

51.

Richmond

(1993) Personal Audit in Orthodontics. British Journal of Orthodontics 20: 135–144.

52.

Scarborough

(2020) Orthodontic contract procurement: NHS orthodontic practice is not sustainable in die long-term. Dentistry 2020. Available at: https://www.dentistry.co.uk/2020/02/24/orthodontic-contract-procurement-nhs-orthodontic-practice-not-sustainable-long-term/ (accessed January 2021).

53.

Schanschieff

Shovelton

Toulmin

(1986) Report of the committee of enquiry into unnecessary dental treatment. London: Department of Health and Social Security.

54.

Scottish Dental (2011) Orthodontic treatment - Introduction of Index of Orthodontic Treatment Need. Health and Social Care Integration Directorate. Available at: https://www.sehd.scot.nhs.uk/pca/PCA2011%28D%2906.pdf (accessed January 2021).

55.

Scottish Dental Needs Assessment Programme (SNAP) (2015) Orthodontic Needs Assessment Report. Available at: https://www.scotphn.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/SDNAP_-_Orthodontic_Needs_Assessment_Report_Apr_2015.pdf (accessed January 2021).

56.

Sfondrini

Zampetti

Luscher

Gandini

Gandía-Franco

Scribante

(2020) Orthodontic Treatment and Healthcare Goals: Evaluation of Multibrackets Treatment Results Using PAR Index (Peer Assessment Rating). Healthcare 8: 473.

57.

Sollenius

Petrén

Björnsson

Norlund

Bondemark

(2016) Health economic evaluations in orthodontics: a systematic review. European Journal of Orthodontics 38: 259–265.

58.

Tickle

(1997) Clinical effectiveness and primary dental care. 2. The influence of health economics. Primary Dental Care 4: 85–87.

59.

Welsh Government (2015) Updated guidance: delivery of orthodontics in primary care. Available at: http://gov.wales/docs/phhs/publications/151214orthodonticsguidanceen.pdf (accessed February 2022).

60.

Wise

(2015) Personal Correspondence on 2008-2012 Unit of Orthodontic Activity values in England. Eastbourne: NH Business Services Authority Information Service.

61.

Zhou

Wang

Volière

(2014) The impact of orthodontic treatment on the quality of life a systematic review. BMC Oral Health 14: 66.